Konan v Sound 4

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
Wth did I just read? Lmfao can't believe you dared call my point BS. Tsukoyomi could be used and a Ribcage couldn't? Smh. The funny part of this is the fact that I remember you once supported the notation that Itachi's clone could use a ribcage(Can't remember but it seems you probably proved it) which would mean his clone can also use Tsukoyomi since according to you, a ribcage is more taxing than Tsukoyomi chakra wise hence Itachi being able to use Tsukoymi but not a Ribcage? Pitiful. Now we are reaching the conclusion that Itachi's clone can use Tsukoyomi? Correct? Even though it takes a ridiculous amount as stated by Kisame. Cut the excuses out.

Not to mention if it restricts them, it does completely. Not "Some bit of chakra could be used" "While some others could". The level of chakra of 2 is stronger than Konan's. So SM being required to halt their chakra according to you isn't proof that it would be needed for other individuals that have weaker forms of chakra.

Judging from the bold, it looks like someone's feelings are hurt just because I don't agree with you. The crossed out part is irrelevant unless you can give me a reason why Itachi's shadow clone can't use Tsukuyomi, because I'm seeing none.

I think manifesting Susanoo (not maintaining it) takes more chakra than Tsukuyomi or Amaterasu for several reasons. First off, Itachi is much more liberal with his use of Tsukuyomi than he is with his use of Susanoo. He used Tsukuyomi twice in one day (once on Kakashi and once on Sasuke) despite it being unnecessary for him to do so on either occasion. Then he chose to use Amaterasu instead of Susanoo to break out of Toad Mouth Bind. Then there's the fact that Susanoo requires chakra from both eyes while Tsukuyomi only uses chakra from one eye. When did Kisame state Tsukuyomi uses a ridiculous amount of chakra, and how does that prove it uses more chakra than Susanoo?

Not sure what you're trying to say in the next paragraph. Obviously some chakra can be used while under genjutsu if Shikamaru can use shadow posession. Put this into perspective. Itachi can use Tsukuyomi while being under the effects of a SM-boosted genjutsu, but Konan can't explode a paper tag? Let's get real.

I argued this with him and he ended up agreeing that Yang is involved...Not to mention it's speculation on both your parts. Read my post to Apex and you'll understand. If there's anything, tell me what's wrong and I also want to know why Amaterasu and Tsukoymi were given their element but Susano'o wasn't addressed to be any of this. Susan's is formed from chakra and has been stated to be chakra in a physical form. Not to mention the fact that PS is stabilized chakra which should rule out the fact that it's Yin considering Yin techniques are made up of almost mental energy all through making their chakra unstable. It won't make sense for PS to have stabilized chakra as stated making it different from Yin while it's other forms would be Yin? Not sensible.

Ok, let's say Yang is involved in Susanoo. Now show me where it says yang is involved in manipulating paper or exploding a paper bomb. Show me where it says shadow posession is just yin, and Sasuke/Itachi's genjutsu is just yin. If you do all that, then I might agree. Otherwise I don't see how yin and yang have crap to do with it, because that's just not a realistic conclusion to reach. Ay's shroud isn't yin or yang, but it was supressed when he got caught in genjutsu [ ]. There is no jutsu in the manga ever that specifically targets either yin or yang chakra. They are equal in every regard seeing how Yang Kurama=Yin Kurama, and Naruto's Avatar=Sasuke's Susanoo despite one receiving the yin half of Hagomoro's chakra and the other receiving the yang half.

Read the panels carefully and don't make your assumptions. Those aren't being controlled, they were most likely brought out or formed first but how would we know which it is? When we literally see hand movements not knowing how the others were formed. You have minimal proof that the were being controlled due to it being off paneled. Due to no indication that it was I'm not sure why the paper were scattered as soon those 2 where it thrown. So much for her manipulating them or being able to control it. Not to mention if you look above her head, you can see paper being moved recklessly out of her way so there's less to suggest it was being controlled. Otherwise, I'm not sure why she'll have to throw it if she could control them or manipulate them freely without movements. Not sure why she'll have to hold it to change the shape if she manipulates it at free will in her human form. No proof that she can manipulate it without movement while in this form. Makes Zero sense because even against Obito, she had to transform to fire paper Shuriken freely. She always had to transform to use paper freely. It could have been brought out from her pouch and held. Are we going to suggest Tobirama's paper tags were hovering because they were in mid air? Makes more sense since she was only a learner at that point. Otherwise having to shape by holding and throw it is off when she could manipulate it freely in this state.

Lol I really love the "Inb4" part. You saw she needed physical movements but you relate a technique to another without solid proof that she doesn't need physical movements for something smaller? Well, because it's not as large? Ridiculous and yet again, no proof suggesting she can control paper in her base state without hand movements.

Jesus. The papers are hovering in the air for more than two panels. The fact that they didn't fall to the ground because of gravity means Konan was controlling them in some sort of way, and there's no denying that. Then we have the fact that Nagato blew those papers towards Jiraiya with fuuton, so perhaps it was faster for Konan to throw the paper shurikens instead of manipulate them. Where are you going with the Tobirama example? He was clearly manipulating those paper tags, just like Konan was.

Konan sometimes moves her body to control paper, and sometimes she doesn't, regardless of being in paper form or not. Konan's in paper form, but she moves her hand anyway. Maybe her papers move faster when she moves physically? Gaara sometimes moves his body when he controls sand [ ], and sometimes he doesn't. Konan always fights in paper form when she can. Why are you asking for feats when clearly her being in paper form is unrelated to if she can actually manipulate paper without moving? Or explode a paper tag, something which requires no movement at all?
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
Isn't Tayuya's demon attack chakra without a physical form?

No, it's unstable chakra. The reason why it's unstable, but still chakra, is because it has more spiritual energy than it does physical energy.

I'm saying he's using Yin release to form and shape the Susano and then having his physical energy consumed by the Susano in return. That's what allows the Yin chakra to become stable (and get away from the ethereal state which it starts in which is the same state of the spirits), unlike Tayuya's spirits. He's not using Yang release.

@Haizaki, I'll get back to you when I have enough time

Well, I can't really see any holes in this post. So I'll agree. But to make it clear what you are saying:

1. Sasuke uses Yin Release.
2. Susanoo is formed, but in ethereal state due to the overwhelming difference between physical energy and spiritual energy in the chakra (Doki spirits)
3. Sasuke adds more physical energy to make it stable.

This is correct? Right?
 

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
No, it's unstable chakra. The reason why it's unstable, but still chakra, is because it has more spiritual energy than it does physical energy.



Well, I can't really see any holes in this post. So I'll agree. But to make it clear what you are saying:

1. Sasuke uses Yin Release.
2. Susanoo is formed, but in ethereal state due to the overwhelming difference between physical energy and spiritual energy in the chakra (Doki spirits)
3. Sasuke adds more physical energy to make it stable.

This is correct? Right?

Yes, exactly. Further fits into the Yin definition of shape and form from nothingness, whereas Yang is instilling life into a form, which would be BM avatar. Obvious Yin-Yang opposites with BM avatar and Sasuke's Susano.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Judging from the bold, it looks like someone's feelings are hurt just because I don't agree with you. The crossed out part is irrelevant unless you can give me a reason why Itachi's shadow clone can't use Tsukuyomi, because I'm seeing none.

I'm laughing so no it doesn't...Though I could tell from your first post that you were sitting on a hot stove after disagreeing with your nonsensical post. Anyways what you're trying to tell me now is Itachi's shadow clone can use Tsukoyomi? Right? Let's get to it.

I think manifesting Susanoo (not maintaining it) takes more chakra than Tsukuyomi or Amaterasu for several reasons. First off, Itachi is much more liberal with his use of Tsukuyomi than he is with his use of Susanoo. He used Tsukuyomi twice in one day (once on Kakashi and once on Sasuke) despite it being unnecessary for him to do so on either occasion. Then he chose to use Amaterasu instead of Susanoo to break out of Toad Mouth Bind. Then there's the fact that Susanoo requires chakra from both eyes while Tsukuyomi only uses chakra from one eye. When did Kisame state Tsukuyomi uses a ridiculous amount of chakra, and how does that prove it uses more chakra than Susanoo?

How about no? Using Amaterasu rather than Susano'o to break out doesn't mean a thing unless you then want to claim Itachi's clone can use Amaterasu as well. Then it gets dumber and dumber. Where does it state a Ribcage which is V1 takes a ridiculous amount though? I'll wait. 2 can play at this game.

Kakashi not Kisame stated it ..Viz Scan explains it better but I have no access to that now. Either way it takes a good amount of chakra so I suggest you quit this argument.

Where was it stated that a Ribcage uses more chakra and how does it mean that it requires more than Tsukoyomi? What proof? It's already been stated that Tsukoyomi takes a big amount and that's all I need considering you stated they couldn't use "chakra-heavy techniques". Exactly what you stated.

Not sure what you're trying to say in the next paragraph. Obviously some chakra can be used while under genjutsu if Shikamaru can use shadow posession. Put this into perspective. Itachi can use Tsukuyomi while being under the effects of a SM-boosted genjutsu, but Konan can't explode a paper tag? Let's get real.

Some chakra can be used...I love how you make it seem like Tsukoymi requires little or so amount of chakra. No because Konan has no real reasons for me to believe she can manipulate her chakra under this conditions due to her being a Yang user.



Ok, let's say Yang is involved in Susanoo. Now show me where it says yang is involved in manipulating paper or exploding a paper bomb. Show me where it says shadow posession is just yin, and Sasuke/Itachi's genjutsu is just yin. If you do all that, then I might agree. Otherwise I don't see how yin and yang have crap to do with it, because that's just not a realistic conclusion to reach. Ay's shroud isn't yin or yang, but it was supressed when he got caught in genjutsu [ ]. There is no jutsu in the manga ever that specifically targets either yin or yang chakra. They are equal in every regard seeing how Yang Kurama=Yin Kurama, and Naruto's Avatar=Sasuke's Susanoo despite one receiving the yin half of Hagomoro's chakra and the other receiving the yang half.

Lmao..Konan is solely a Yang user as stated by the DB. I'll show you the Shika bit.:

Ying Yang/Onmyouton page:

Inton (Yin/Dark), which creates form from nothing, and Youton (Yang/Light), which breathes life into form. Skillfully manipulating these two elements, the Sage of Six Paths, Ootsutsuki Hagoromo, developed the Banbutsu Souzou (Creation of All Things) Jutsu. Creating the nine Bijuu out of the Juubi's chakra was also the result of Onmyouton. Afterwards, Inton was inherited more predominately in the Uchiha clan, while Youton was inherited more predominately in the Senju clan.

Then, can only the Uchiha and Senju use this power? The answer is no. For example, even without using a Sharingan, the proportional amount of genjutsu that involves "creating form from nothing" is high. Furthermore, there are many "hiden ninjutsu" passed down among specific shinobi clans that are not affiliated with any of the five nature transformations but are instead grounded in Onmyouton. For example, the Akimichi clan uses Youton to expand their bodies' size, while the Nara clan uses Inton to expand, contract, and transform shadows. In the same vein, even without being Uchiha or Senju, shinobi manipulate chakra and use jutsu, and the basis of that is said to be rooted in Onmyouton.

I've showed you..Now go ahead and prove me wrong. Go ahead and show me where it states Susano'o is solely Yin.

- Ay's point is a weak point because it was deactivated after the Genjutsu. Not to mention, refer to B's Cloak still being active during Sasuke's restriction Genjutsu even though he fell down.


Jesus. The papers are hovering in the air for more than two panels. The fact that they didn't fall to the ground because of gravity means Konan was controlling them in some sort of way, and there's no denying that. Then we have the fact that Nagato blew those papers towards Jiraiya with fuuton, so perhaps it was faster for Konan to throw the paper shurikens instead of manipulate them. Where are you going with the Tobirama example? He was clearly manipulating those paper tags, just like Konan was.


What in the world? Are you blind? They were in Mid air and didn't have to fall on the ground due to the panel indicating they were most likely just brought out? Big assumption to say she was manipulating them at that point. Especially when there's one above her head while 3 are in different positions in front of her. Not to mention why did she manipulate the shape if she could just do so as she's shown in the Manga without touching it in her paper state? Why did she have to hold it to manipulate it when she has shown in her paper state that she can change the shape without holding it? When she has also fired shaped paper at others before without having to throw it indicating that this aspect is irrelevant. Why did the other papers scatter apart after those 2 were thrown? Boy you have no argument so don't call my points BS lmao.

Tobirama can manipulate paper now? Lmao. No...Use your eyes and see that he only just threw them out so they weren't hovering even though it was in mid air. Look at his hands.

Konan sometimes moves her body to control paper, and sometimes she doesn't, regardless of being in paper form or not. Konan's in paper form, but she moves her hand anyway. Maybe her papers move faster when she moves physically? Gaara sometimes moves his body when he controls sand [ ], and sometimes he doesn't. Konan always fights in paper form when she can. Why are you asking for feats when clearly her being in paper form is unrelated to if she can actually manipulate paper without moving? Or explode a paper tag, something which requires no movement at all?

Flawed post...Konan already moved her hand position from the very beginning so she never made movements to manipulate the position of paper in this state and she has shown she doesn't need to anyways. When Obito tried to use Kamui, her hands were already at him before that so it was her mentally controlling it. Zero proof suggesting she can manipulate paper without movements in this form and the manipulation doesn't fall under the Yin category.

No, it's unstable chakra. The reason why it's unstable, but still chakra, is because it has more spiritual energy than it does physical energy.



Well, I can't really see any holes in this post. So I'll agree. But to make it clear what you are saying:

1. Sasuke uses Yin Release.
2. Susanoo is formed, but in ethereal state due to the overwhelming difference between physical energy and spiritual energy in the chakra (Doki spirits)
3. Sasuke adds more physical energy to make it stable.

This is correct? Right?

How? Tayuya's spirits are entirely chakra...Unstable chakra due to having almost Metal energy alone. Susano'o is not like that...Datsbook states "Chakra takes a physical form". That's Susano'o so there's really no way it can work the same way as Tayuya's spirits which are already chakra in a spiritual state or so.

Apex is wrong because:

- For Susano'o to form, chakra would take a phsycal form because that's what it is. That's what the databook states it to be. How would Sasuke put physical form into chakra?

- Perfect Susano'o doesn't crave energy...However it's already in a stabilized form when made. It's stabilized chakra once formed.

- Where did Sasuke adding physical energy coming from? You know why that was stated? Because Apex said it consumes the user's life...There are other factors like ST which consumes the user's life...There's Gates as well. We can't suggest because Susano'o affects the user physically, then that means Sasuke is adding more physically energy to it to make it stable when it is and already consuming the user's life. This isn't correct.

It's a massive speculation given how the mechanics work...Tayuya's chakra spirits craving physical energy of others doesn't equate to it being the same as Susano'o because it consumes the user's life due to affecting him. There are other techniques that do that to the user. There's no way Apex comparison works.
 
Last edited:

Zexion~

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
17,100
Reaction score
862
Oh I see, her demons only contain spiritual energy which is why they crave a physical form to attack/devour for the energy. Man when Kishi actually gave jutsu cool and logically unique descriptions life was so good.

Not sure what the argument here is though.
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
How? Tayuya's spirits are entirely chakra...Unstable chakra due to having almost Metal energy alone. Susano'o is not like that...Datsbook states "Chakra takes a physical form". That's Susano'o so there's really no way it can work the same way as Tayuya's spirits which are already chakra in a spiritual state or so.

They are intangible because they are composed of mainly Spiritual Energy. Susanoo switches from ethereal state to solid state. It falls into the same category as Tayuya's spirits going by Apex's explanation. Databook says chakra takes a physical form, and that's after physical energy is added. So nothing in the DB contradicts what he's saying.

Apex is wrong because:

- For Susano'o to form, chakra would take a phsycal form because that's what it is. That's what the databook states it to be. How would Sasuke put physical form into chakra?

Explained above and by Apex's post. Susanoo starts off as ethereal and becomes physical when more physical energy is added. Not sure what the bold is talking about nor am I sure what the confusion here is.

- Perfect Susano'o doesn't crave energy...However it's already in a stabilized form when made. It's stabilized chakra once formed.

That's irrelevant.

- Where did Sasuke adding physical energy coming from? You know why that was stated? Because Apex said it consumes the user's life...There are other factors like ST which consumes the user's life...There's Gates as well. We can't suggest because Susano'o affects the user physically, then that means Sasuke is adding more physically energy to it to make it stable when it is and already consuming the user's life. This isn't correct.

Except unlike all those examples you listed, Susanoo starts off or can become an ethereal thing.

It's a massive speculation given how the mechanics work...Tayuya's chakra spirits craving physical energy of others doesn't equate to it being the same as Susano'o because it consumes the user's life due to affecting him. There are other techniques that do that to the user. There's no way Apex comparison works.

Is it speculation? Yes. Does it make sense? Yes. The only bit that's iffy is WHY physical energy is drained, but even that has an explanation of it's own. Most jutsu in the series that have been shown to have no elemental are usually Yin and Yang. Susanoo most likely falls into one of those categories, and it'd lean towards Yin more than it'd lean towards Yang.
 

Zexion~

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
17,100
Reaction score
862
If Susano'o had merely one state of energy wouldn't it be attracted to the other? As thats the definition of unstable chakra.....
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
If Susano'o had merely one state of energy wouldn't it be attracted to the other? As thats the definition of unstable chakra.....

Is that the definition of unstable chakra? Or is that just a property of Tayuya's Doki? Or is it just why the Doki search out physical energy, but not the thing that makes them like that? Not sure.
 

Zexion~

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
17,100
Reaction score
862
Is that the definition of unstable chakra? Or is that just a property of Tayuya's Doki? Or is it just why the Doki search out physical energy, but not the thing that makes them like that? Not sure.

Your second and third questions sort of go together :lol but I was assuming it was unstable chakra, I think you could find another example somewhere hidden in the manga.
 

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
Is that the definition of unstable chakra? Or is that just a property of Tayuya's Doki? Or is it just why the Doki search out physical energy, but not the thing that makes them like that? Not sure.

You must be registered for see images


Since it's mostly spiritual energy it craves physical energy in order to obtain stability. That's just like Sasuke's Susano. It's mostly spiritual energy in the ethereal state but as it consumes Sasuke's physical energy it obtains the craved stability. Thus it becomes a Yin based structure run on the user's physical energy.
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
Your second and third questions sort of go together :lol but I was assuming it was unstable chakra, I think you could find another example somewhere hidden in the manga.

Meh, kind of.

It is unstable chakra. The wiki says they are unstable, so they search for physical energy to become stable, but nothing directly states or implies that they search out physical energy automatically due to the lack of it.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Apex, KidGamer...Good arguments but I'll respond when I get home :p
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
They are intangible because they are composed of mainly Spiritual Energy. Susanoo switches from ethereal state to solid state. It falls into the same category as Tayuya's spirits going by Apex's explanation. Databook says chakra takes a physical form, and that's after physical energy is added. So nothing in the DB contradicts what he's saying.

No Susano'o doesn't have an ethereal state. That's the Aura and it's just like Zabuza who doesn't have Yin release but could still release the sort of Aura before he released his Hidden in the mist technique.Susano'o was never stated to have such a state...That's merely the Aura.

There's not way it can switch from Ethereal state to Solid state but still release the ethereal state from it's body That's Aura....Think of Gai releasing Aura from his body upon utilizing the gates.

Also if the DB states chakra takes a physical form but doesn't state anything about the previous form, it's speculating that it's previous form had to be changed to a physical form. It's not ethereal but merely an Aura from the technique.


Explained above and by Apex's post. Susanoo starts off as ethereal and becomes physical when more physical energy is added. Not sure what the bold is talking about nor am I sure what the confusion here is.

It's Aura...Zabuza releases Aura before he uses the Mist...He doesn't have Yin. It's not possible that Susano'o is an ethereal state but by adding more physical energy which according to Apex involves the energy coming by the user's life being consumed. That's wrong seeing how other techniques work. Plus the fact that it drains the user physically? Shouldn't be true.



That's irrelevant.

I'll factor that in considering how those spirits were released in an unstable state but PS being brought out in a stabilized form of chakra. If something craves physical energy to be in a stable state, how can it be in a stable state when formed? Tayuya's demons where in an unstable state once released but PS becomes stable as soon as it was released. It's special materialzed chakra and Tayuya doesn't get drained when she uses them.


Except unlike all those examples you listed, Susanoo starts off or can become an ethereal thing.

No it doesn't because it still releases Aura...Not it being in an unstable state. How can it be in both states at the same time? It's clearly the Aura from the technique unless it contains both maybe.

Is it speculation? Yes. Does it make sense? Yes. The only bit that's iffy is WHY physical energy is drained, but even that has an explanation of it's own. Most jutsu in the series that have been shown to have no elemental are usually Yin and Yang. Susanoo most likely falls into one of those categories, and it'd lean towards Yin more than it'd lean towards Yang.

Yes but I don't think it connects. Chakra takes a physical form but nothing stated about physical energy being given to an ethereal form for the chakra to become a physical form...If it was true and it wasn't just the Aura, it should have been mentioned that it was first in a spiritual state for it to become like this despite the word spiritual consistently used for the weapon it wields. Physical energy being drained is another thing that puts a dent on it as well...Tayuya demons don't put any physical strain on her and Susano'o doesn't put any physical strain on the user it attacks. Plus if Susano'o is in a solid state, why is Sasuke's physical energy still drained when that physical state had been attained?
 

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
Oh boy. I'm going to have to break this one down quote by quote :coffee:

I'm laughing so no it doesn't...Though I could tell from your first post that you were sitting on a hot stove after disagreeing with your nonsensical post. Anyways what you're trying to tell me now is Itachi's shadow clone can use Tsukoyomi? Right? Let's get to it.

Yes. That is exactly what I'm saying :lol. A shadow clone has half the original's chakra. Shadow clones can use any of the original's techniques given they have enough chakra. Unless you think Tsukuyomi takes more than half of Itachi's chakra, I don't see where you're going with this. Don't know why you're having trouble grasping a relatively simple concept.

How about no? Using Amaterasu rather than Susano'o to break out doesn't mean a thing unless you then want to claim Itachi's clone can use Amaterasu as well. Then it gets dumber and dumber. Where does it state a Ribcage which is V1 takes a ridiculous amount though? I'll wait. 2 can play at this game.

Itachi had just used Tsukuyomi and was trying to preserve chakra. He literally states that he was forced to use Amaterasu (Viz TV).

You must be registered for see images

The scan on this website says the same thing, but it's harder to understand due to bad translation [ ]. But he wasn't forced to use Susanoo. If ribcage Susanoo takes less chakra than Amaterasu like you are saying, then he wouldn't have used Amaterasu nor would he say he was forced to use it when there was an alternative. A ribcage could have ripped through the toad stomach more easily than Amaterasu.

And yes. Itachi's clone can use Amaterasu, because there's literally no reason for that not being possible. When we have feats of a crow clone (much weaker than shadow clone) using Susanoo, this much should be obvious. The bold makes no sense, because your only evidence for Tsukuyomi>Susanoo is an irrelevant statement.

Kakashi not Kisame stated it ..Viz Scan explains it better but I have no access to that now. Either way it takes a good amount of chakra so I suggest you quit this argument.

Kakashi said "it takes a considerable amount of chakra." Something he only knew secondhand because he was in genjutsu the moment he looked in Itachi's eye and therefore couldn't see the side effects. Once you can connect this statement to your argument that Tsukuyomi>Susanoo in terms of chakra use, then we can talk about this actually being a relevant point to make.

Where was it stated that a Ribcage uses more chakra and how does it mean that it requires more than Tsukoyomi? What proof? It's already been stated that Tsukoyomi takes a big amount and that's all I need considering you stated they couldn't use "chakra-heavy techniques". Exactly what you stated.

1. Itachi used Amaterasu instead of Susanoo to break free from Toad mouth bind. Something I've already explained.

2. Susanoo takes chakra from both eyes, whereas Tsukuyomi requires chakra from only one eye. A point I've already brought up.

3. If chakra use has anything to do with MS strain (I think it does), then further proof is that Itachi went blind in one eye after using that sharingan for one Tsukuyomi and also to hold up Susanoo for a second to block Kirin, against Sasuke. He didn't go blind in his other eye until he used it 5 times for Amaterasu.

Tayuya's genjutsu supressed Itachi's chakra enough to where he couldn't use Susanoo, but not enough to where he couldn't use Tsukuyomi. That's all there is to it.

Some chakra can be used...I love how you make it seem like Tsukoymi requires little or so amount of chakra. No because Konan has no real reasons for me to believe she can manipulate her chakra under this conditions due to her being a Yang user.

Lmao..Konan is solely a Yang user as stated by the DB. I'll show you the Shika bit.:

I doubt exploding a paper tag requires either yin or yang considering genin level ninja can do so and not every genin has yang. If you really need me to, I will look through DB descriptions of every character that has detonated a paper bomb ever. I'm sure I will find someone, who like Konan, is not listed as a yin user.

I've showed you..Now go ahead and prove me wrong. Go ahead and show me where it states Susano'o is solely Yin.

Apex and KidGamer explained pretty well why Susanoo is manifested through yin, then stabilized by feeding off Sasuke's physical energy (yang.)

- Ay's point is a weak point because it was deactivated after the Genjutsu. Not to mention, refer to B's Cloak still being active during Sasuke's restriction Genjutsu even though he fell down.

If Ay could have reactivated it after getting caught in genjutsu, he obviously would have done it :lol. Exact same situation as Susanoo. Genjutsu=suppresses chakra. Raiton armour=releasing large amounts of chakra, and V2 was stated to be Ay amping up his chakra levels to tailed beast levels. Bee's V1 cloak wasn't deactivated because that's Hachibi's chakra (not Bee) thus its chakra wasn't supressed, because Hachibi wasn't caught in the genjutsu.

What in the world? Are you blind? They were in Mid air and didn't have to fall on the ground due to the panel indicating they were most likely just brought out? Big assumption to say she was manipulating them at that point. Especially when there's one above her head while 3 are in different positions in front of her. Not to mention why did she manipulate the shape if she could just do so as she's shown in the Manga without touching it in her paper state? Why did she have to hold it to manipulate it when she has shown in her paper state that she can change the shape without holding it? When she has also fired shaped paper at others before without having to throw it indicating that this aspect is irrelevant. Why did the other papers scatter apart after those 2 were thrown? Boy you have no argument so don't call my points BS lmao.

Show me where in the panel it indicates them most likely being just brought out, because there's no indication of that. Why would she bring out more papers, when she already had formed shurikens in her hand ready to throw? When she was a kid, her paper movement speed is definitely slower than when she is an adult, so maybe she threw them because they would fly faster, and so Nagato could enhance them with fuuton with better timing. The same paper is hovering by her head in both panels, despite enough time having elapsed between panels for Konan to move her arms and throw the shuriken a good distance ahead of her.

Tobirama can manipulate paper now? Lmao. No...Use your eyes and see that he only just threw them out so they weren't hovering even though it was in mid air. Look at his hands.

Okay, Tobirama threw the paper tags. What was your point with that again?

Flawed post...Konan already moved her hand position from the very beginning so she never made movements to manipulate the position of paper in this state and she has shown she doesn't need to anyways. When Obito tried to use Kamui, her hands were already at him before that so it was her mentally controlling it. Zero proof suggesting she can manipulate paper without movements in this form and the manipulation doesn't fall under the Yin category.

Fine, I'll just link other instances in which she made movements to control her paper despite already being in paper form and not needing to.







Sometimes she uses physical movements, and sometimes she doesn't. Just the same way Gaara sometimes moves his hands to manipulate sand, and sometimes he doesn't (a point you didn't address). Konan spreads her chakra throughout her paper in a similar way that Gaara spreads his chakra throughout his sand so I don't see why a comparison can't be drawn here. She can probably do it on a larger and faster scale when she aids it with physical movement, but still lol....you are claiming she cannot move one paper, or detonate one paper bomb without movement? Come on now. Especially when she can make a boquet of flowers made from dozens of papers with a slight flick of her wrist [ ]. Not to mention intel is full here so when Konan sees Tayuya bring out her flute she can just detonate a bunch of paper bombs and drown out the noise of the flute with explosions so Konan wins no matter what you say.
 
Last edited:

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Yes. That is exactly what I'm saying :lol. A shadow clone has half the original's chakra. Shadow clones can use any of the original's techniques given they have enough chakra. Unless you think Tsukuyomi takes more than half of Itachi's chakra, I don't see where you're going with this. Don't know why you're having trouble grasping a relatively simple concept.

Itachi's crow clone which doesn't take up to half his chakra like the shadow clone could pull out a Ribcage but Itachi couldn't pull it out because it takes a considerable amount of chakra despite pulling Tsukoyomi which also does? Makes no sene.....Where's your proof that a Ribcage takes more than that? None. Susano'o has different forms and they take different amounts of chakra. Unless you think PS takes the same amount as a Ribcage which was never noted to take that much like Tsukoyomi. You're only making up the fact that it takes much.

Itachi had just used Tsukuyomi and was trying to preserve chakra. He literally states that he was forced to use Amaterasu (Viz TV).
The scan on this website says the same thing, but it's harder to understand due to bad translation [ ]. But he wasn't forced to use Susanoo. If ribcage Susanoo takes less chakra than Amaterasu like you are saying, then he wouldn't have used Amaterasu nor would he say he was forced to use it when there was an alternative. A ribcage could have ripped through the toad stomach more easily than Amaterasu.

This sickening logic you're employing simply because you have 0 proof that a Ribcage takes that much. Because he didn't use this doesn't mean he couldn't have employed it. That's crap. Not to mention there could be reasons why he didn't use Susano'o but it's unknown to us. Don't bring in "he didn't use a Ribcage" when you don't have valid enough reasons except well, anticipate he didn't use it because it takes more chakra. Plus the fact that there was a distance between them and that wall and the fact that it required enough speed to get rid of that due to the wall of flesh behind them being swift hence Itachi had no choice but to clear the one in front of him before he got there

And yes. Itachi's clone can use Amaterasu, because there's literally no reason for that not being possible. When we have feats of a crow clone (much weaker than shadow clone) using Susanoo, this much should be obvious. The bold makes no sense, because your only evidence for Tsukuyomi>Susanoo is an irrelevant statement.

Keep saying these things. Not to mention what makes this moronic is the fact that a crow clone contains less amount of chakra that the shadow clone as stated by the DB so it means a Ribcage definitely doesn't take that much.

How about no? My evidence is based on that fact that you BEANS have zero scans to prove the fact that a RIBCAGE takes a large amount of chakra....Your comparison is weak because different forms of Susano'o require different level of chakra.

Kakashi said "it takes a considerable amount of chakra." Something he only knew secondhand because he was in genjutsu the moment he looked in Itachi's eye and therefore couldn't see the side effects. Once you can connect this statement to your argument that Tsukuyomi>Susanoo in terms of chakra use, then we can talk about this actually being a relevant point to make.

Pretty sure you need to realize how you sound. Also, google the definition of considerable and I don't care because it's been stated either way that it does take a large amount. A crow clone was only shown to use a Ribcage and that's it. Sasuke's chakras were growing weaker to the point where he couldn't do much and yet he could still maintain a Ribcage eve though he couldn't use other forms...Upon his chakra being replenished, he could employ higher versions of Susano'o. Your arguments don't make sense because you can't even prove that a Ribcage takes as much chakra...You're only using "Susano'o" as an argument which is nonsensical..When a Ribcage doesn't take as much chakra in that contained crow clone which isn't close to the shadow in terms of chakra reserves? Yet I'm supposed to believe it taking a considerable amount like Tsukoyomi and Amaterasu?

Bring proof that a Ribcage takes a large amount like those 2 or don't bother.

1. Itachi used Amaterasu instead of Susanoo to break free from Toad mouth bind. Something I've already explained.

Something I've already addressed.

2. Susanoo takes chakra from both eyes, whereas Tsukuyomi requires chakra from only one eye. A point I've already brought up.

Susano'o has different forms, hence different levels of chakra.

3. If chakra use has anything to do with MS strain (I think it does), then further proof is that Itachi went blind in one eye after using that sharingan for one Tsukuyomi and also to hold up Susanoo for a second to block Kirin, against Sasuke. He didn't go blind in his other eye until he used it 5 times for Amaterasu.

Irrelevant

Tayuya's genjutsu supressed Itachi's chakra enough to where he couldn't use Susanoo, but not enough to where he couldn't use Tsukuyomi. That's all there is to it.

All there is to it is that you failed horribly to prove your point of why a large amount can which is more than or around a Ribcage.

- Itachi's crow clone doesn't take up to half but can use a Ribcage showing it doesn't taken that much..Yet Itachi couldn't pull it out? You're trying to serious? I'll give you sometime to rethink how silly you sound.



I doubt exploding a paper tag requires either yin or yang considering genin level ninja can do so and not every genin has yang. If you really need me to, I will look through DB descriptions of every character that has detonated a paper bomb ever. I'm sure I will find someone, who like Konan, is not listed as a yin user.

If it doesn't then it stands no chance. Nothing suggest Konan can control paper in these circumstances.


Apex and KidGamer explained pretty well why Susanoo is manifested through yin, then stabilized by feeding off Sasuke's physical energy (yang.)

No but notice none responded to my last post because of the points I raised.


If Ay could have reactivated it after getting caught in genjutsu, he obviously would have done it :lol. Exact same situation as Susanoo. Genjutsu=suppresses chakra. Raiton armour=releasing large amounts of chakra, and V2 was stated to be Ay amping up his chakra levels to tailed beast levels. Bee's V1 cloak wasn't deactivated because that's Hachibi's chakra (not Bee) thus its chakra wasn't supressed, because Hachibi wasn't caught in the genjutsu.

He obviously would have done it if it could isn't an argument you know? Not to mention the Genjutsu suppressing them are different. Genjutsu controls the chakra in your head and Killer B was filled with Hachibi's chakra . Hence that chakra should have been suppressed since that's the chakra being controlled. Plus the bottom right of this scan, B states his almost absorbed most of my chakra despite us knowing it was Hachibi's chakra given to him at that point . He couldn't because that was the Chakra given to him for him to control.

Hence that chakra should have been suppressed.


Show me where in the panel it indicates them most likely being just brought out, because there's no indication of that. Why would she bring out more papers, when she already had formed shurikens in her hand ready to throw? When she was a kid, her paper movement speed is definitely slower than when she is an adult, so maybe she threw them because they would fly faster, and so Nagato could enhance them with fuuton with better timing. The same paper is hovering by her head in both panels, despite enough time having elapsed between panels for Konan to move her arms and throw the shuriken a good distance ahead of her.

Show me where the panels indicate them hovering...Show me where got them from. I really wonder where...Explain to me why there's one above her head and 3 in from of her in different positions. She could have manipulated them while Nagato strengthened it or made it faster. Why are they not shown being manipulated? That's an assumption.

I've never been surprised before...Let's look at the 2 panels and you tell me if the position of the bottom right and bottom left are the same Hell no..They cleared as she threw it and in the Nagato panel, there's no paper there. They won't be scattering about if she could control them and the one above won't be that far from her head in the next panel. Minimal evidence that she did. Why didn't the fire the other ones? Why just 2? Maybe because she couldn't freely manipulate them because she fired 4-5 at a time in her paper state at Obito in this state.


Okay, Tobirama threw the paper tags. What was your point with that again?

That you have no point.







- Konan slaps to activate her God technique. That could just mean the paper bombs were way too much to be controlled at the same time..1 billion anyways which is why it was made into a technique.
- Konan creates paper into a sword to stab Jiraiya?
- Konan is manipulating her paper Lol..She's activating her Shikigami technique.
- How does that even show Konan using hand movements to manipulate her paper? She's releasing paper from her body and firing it at him.
- Not sure how that show her having to user hand movements to control them? Because she flies upwards and then her paper moves at the same time with her moving towards Obito.

Sometimes she uses physical movements, and sometimes she doesn't. Just the same way Gaara sometimes moves his hands to manipulate sand, and sometimes he doesn't (a point you didn't address).

Let's assume your point was made, it would never ever show that Base Konan can replicate the same. Not to mention the first time she tried firing paper at Obito, she had to transform first to throw that much at him? Why? Why not in her Base form and then when she wanted to attack him directly, she could have transformed then to save chakra.

Konan spreads her chakra throughout her paper in a similar way that Gaara spreads his chakra throughout his sand so I don't see why a comparison can't be drawn here. She can probably do it on a larger and faster scale when she aids it with physical movement, but still lol....you are claiming she cannot move one paper, or detonate one paper bomb without movement? Come on now. Especially when she can make a boquet of flowers made from dozens of papers with a slight flick of her wrist [ ].

Thanks, another proof that she requires physical movement in order to manipulate paper. There's a reason to why there are 2 forms...Paper form and Base form. Shows that her flexibility with the paper is much greater than her base form asides this assumption.

Not to mention intel is full here so when Konan sees Tayuya bring out her flute she can just detonate a bunch of paper bombs and drown out the noise of the flute with explosions so Konan wins no matter what you say.

While the remaining sound 5 do nothing...Not to mention this would mess up her view and Jirobo who can use hiding like a mole would take advantage of this trapping her. Plus if she's focused on Tayuya, webs can catch her off guard, Kimmi can shoot out Teshi Sendan. There just a lot of combos that can come after he once she's caught off guard. They all need to protect Tayuya and that's it.

I addressed the Yin argument.
 
Last edited:

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
Haizaki, that was by far the worst post you've made so far in this thread. I'm giving you until 3pm Central time to edit it.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Haizaki, that was by far the worst post you've made so far in this thread. I'm giving you until 3pm Central time to edit it.

Jackboy telling me he's giving me time to edit my post? FOH lil kid..Since when did you have the nerve and who the fk do you think you are to tell me what to change without addressing it? Btw, KidGamer agreed Yin isn't the necessary condition so don't bring that up..Hope to see your next reply soon about how crow clones can supposedly use Tsukoyomi.
 

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
Yes but I don't think it connects. Chakra takes a physical form but nothing stated about physical energy being given to an ethereal form for the chakra to become a physical form...If it was true and it wasn't just the Aura, it should have been mentioned that it was first in a spiritual state for it to become like this despite the word spiritual consistently used for the weapon it wields. Physical energy being drained is another thing that puts a dent on it as well...Tayuya demons don't put any physical strain on her and Susano'o doesn't put any physical strain on the user it attacks. Plus if Susano'o is in a solid state, why is Sasuke's physical energy still drained when that physical state had been attained?

Would just like to address this part since I think you are misinterpreting what I was saying. I am not saying the two ninjutsu are the same, I am saying the Yin is the same in any case of any jutsu. While Susano (or any jutsu) is ethereal (in a predominantly Yin state), it craves a balance like Kakashi mentioned once early on in the manga [ ]. To use jutsu the physical and spiritual energy must be in a balance as he states. So when Tayuya releases her jutsu the spirits search for physical energy in order to create that balance and become stable. It gets that physical energy from other sources, not the user. Susano takes physical energy from the user in order to obtain that balance. The same Susano can disappear once chakra is no longer expended by the user. In the same way, once physical energy is no longer expended by the user, it would go back to the ethereal state. So his body is constantly aching because he's constantly maintaining Susano. It's not a jutsu were you can form the chakra and then have it up eternally since it requires no maintenance, because it clearly does.
 

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
Jackboy telling me he's giving me time to edit my post? FOH lil kid..Since when did you have the nerve and who the fk do you think you are to tell me what to change without addressing it? Btw, KidGamer agreed Yin isn't the necessary condition so don't bring that up..Hope to see your next reply soon about how crow clones can supposedly use Tsukoyomi.

When NB is taken this serious...

You must be registered for see images
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
Would just like to address this part since I think you are misinterpreting what I was saying. I am not saying the two ninjutsu are the same, I am saying the Yin is the same in any case of any jutsu. While Susano (or any jutsu) is ethereal (in a predominantly Yin state), it craves a balance like Kakashi mentioned once early on in the manga [ ]. To use jutsu the physical and spiritual energy must be in a balance as he states. So when Tayuya releases her jutsu the spirits search for physical energy in order to create that balance and become stable. It gets that physical energy from other sources, not the user. Susano takes physical energy from the user in order to obtain that balance. The same Susano can disappear once chakra is no longer expended by the user. In the same way, once physical energy is no longer expended by the user, it would go back to the ethereal state. So his body is constantly aching because he's constantly maintaining Susano. It's not a jutsu were you can form the chakra and then have it up eternally since it requires no maintenance, because it clearly does.

Lol why the hell did I not take the bold into account?
 
Top