Kishi's horrible writing - Sakura

Status
Not open for further replies.

Natsu Shazneel

Banned
Supreme
Joined
Jan 21, 2012
Messages
37,690
Reaction score
1,999
It matters cause to me Sakura is not special because of that. She is special for being the main character and cause her ability fit Tsunade's training. Anyone could train with a Sannin and still not be able to be special like Shizune or even Anko.

I already stated that she has no special clan. She just has plot on her side, because she is part of the main squad. Lol Honestly you are basically agreeing with me here while thinking you are disagreeing with me. Key word here, she is special.

I brought the shonnen aspect cause males are always more important than females in those type of mangas usually.

So by your logic other shonen females need to be more important than males in order to be better than Sakura? *rolls his eyes* Just wtf?
 
Last edited:

Edenia

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
16,723
Reaction score
1,275
I already stated that she has no special clan. She just has plot on her side, because she is part of the main squad. Lol Honestly you are basically agreeing with me here while thinking you are disagreeing with me. Key word she is special.



So by your logic other shonen females need to be more important than males in order to be better than Sakura? *rolls his eyes* Just wtf?

No, you said that Sakura was a special girl because she trained under Tsunade so I don't agree there. I agre she's special than others because she's main character and her ability fits for the plot, she's still a normal ninja from no specific clan in the manga and if you already stated that well then sorry for misinterpretation

No, the shonnen aspect is just because people make high expectations of females even if main characters not that females need to be stronger than males in other shonnens in order to be better than Sakura
 
Last edited:

Natsu Shazneel

Banned
Supreme
Joined
Jan 21, 2012
Messages
37,690
Reaction score
1,999
No, you said that Sakura was a special girl because she trained under Tsunade so I don't agree there. I agre she's special than others because she's main character and her ability fits for the plot, she's still a normal ninja from no specific clan in the manga.

Ok so Tsunade was just a ordinary ninja right? And no she is not a normal ninja. Lol Show me others like her in the manga.

No, the shonnen aspect is just becuse people make high expectation of females even if main characters not that females need to be stronger than males in other shonnens in order to be better than Sakura

I am sorry its either your poor grammar or spelling that put me off from this. I don't understand it at all.
 

Edenia

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
16,723
Reaction score
1,275
Ok so Tsunade was just a ordinary ninja right? And no she is not a normal ninja. Lol Show me others like her in the manga.



I am sorry its either your poor grammar or spelling that put me off from this. I don't understand it at all.

This won't lead anywhere. Let's leave it at that.
 

1Told

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Oct 17, 2014
Messages
2,935
Reaction score
316
Instead he made sakura the laughing stock of team 7 by neglecting her(the dude outright said her forgot about her). In the end she never caught up to Naruto and Sasuke she stated she would, at least SP are hinata fanboys so we can expect more of her in the anime later on(not to mention the last)

Kishi never gave a crap about Sakura, he changed her face only (and her clothes? wow) many time for 15 years instead of making that character interesting, appealing for the audience and valuable for the story...
he's such a troll, maybe he hate her even more than every single one of us because he clearly never had any intention to save her and you don't forget a character if you care about it, come on let's be honest here XD
 

Made in Heaven

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
31,444
Reaction score
2,201
More like you completely failed to understand how the character is written. She definitely could be written better but she is not that bad as you claim repeatedly. Plus she is the most developed female in the manga.

Sakura's goal was to be nin. She is. Then her next goal was to be a medic and she became an excellent one. She was able to create antidote for Sasori's poison after extracting and analyzing it (none in the Sand village could do it) and then heal people on the field using her seal and summon. That shows how skilled she became at it.

One of her other goals is to be able to keep up with two of the most overpowered people in the verse who managed to defeat the ultimate villain. What's wrong with that goal?

Both her team mates had a head start since the day they were born-- One had sharingan and another Uzumaki chakra+ kyuubi to fall back on. They only need to learn to harness those powers. Sakura on the other hand has to rely on her normal self.

Kakashi trained Sasuke personally and told her to sit on the side line for his sake in middle of the chunin exams. He found a teacher for Naruto- because he knew he won't shut up that easily but not Sakura why? That's exploiting her sympathy for Sasuke's situation against her personal interest.

By the end despite her being an ordinary girl from an ordinary back ground without any inheritance or gifted powers she was one of the top shinobies on the field. Only Kabuto and Tsunade can challenge her and both are her senior. One an experienced Sannin and the other had stolen add ons. And none of the others could have helped Obito in rescuing Sasuke from that desert.

Not a bad performance for a book smart girl on the field. She could be written in a better way but she is not one dimensional nor her goal was bad seeing the level of competition in team 7. She was the only person in the team without a personal baggage but I don't see why I should hold it against her. Having a troublesome dark past is too main stream anyway. :p

And she definitely seems too believable and realistically turned out to generate this much of passion and interest in her that some of you guys cannot seem to have enough of her.

She also had the goal of catching up to Naruto and Sasuke, which .... to no one's surprise, never happened. That goal is wrong because it makes her come off as arrogant as a person for actually thinking she can do that despite clearly being tiers lower than even Sage Naruto & Hebi Sasuke, and badly written as a charcater because she never accomplished it.

Sakura is hardly the most developed female, there are for sure a handful that are above her. Rest assured, Karin is not one of them.

Kakashi not finding a teacher for her shouldn't matter, as she later ended up having Tsunade as her mentor.

She isn't ordinary, she has near perfect Chakra control. That could have been exploited in many ways aside from the Yin seal, but wasn't. And really, being ordinary isn't an excuse for her failure to keep up w/ her own goal.

No one's necessarily asking for a dark past for Sakura, but FFS, at least give us some sort of proper, complex past to begin with.

Choji and Hinata don't have dark pasts, still have nice backgrounds.
 
Last edited:

Keimil

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
1,851
Reaction score
191
She also had the goal of catching up to Naruto and Sasuke, which .... to no one's surprise, never happened. That goal is wrong because it makes her come off as arrogant as a person for actually thinking she can do that despite clearly being tiers lower than even Sage Naruto & Hebi Sasuke, and badly written as a charcater because she never accomplished it.

Sakura is hardly the most developed female, there are for sure a handful that are above her. Rest assured, Karin is not one of them.

Kakashi not finding a teacher for her shouldn't matter, as she later ended up having Tsunade as her mentor.

She isn't ordinary, she has near perfect Chakra control. That could have been exploited in many ways aside from the Yin seal, but wasn't. And really, being ordinary isn't an excuse for her failure to keep up w/ her own goal.

No one's necessarily asking for a dark past for Sakura, but FFS, at least give us some sort of proper, complex past to begin with.

Choji and Hinata don't have dark pasts, still have nice backgrounds.

Sakura's background is Part 1.
To sum up, Sakura was useless until Tunade trained her, the one she loved called her annoying, left her unconscious in a bench and set out in the seek of power, Naruto and her made a promise to bring Sasuke back.

After all what happened in Part 2, I think she had a pretty good development to be Heroine of a Shounen... And yes, I consider her the most developed female in Naruto.
 

MAN OF SIN

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
8,281
Reaction score
430
Sakura's background is Part 1.
To sum up, Sakura was useless until Tunade trained her, the one she loved called her annoying, left her unconscious in a bench and set out in the seek of power, Naruto and her made a promise to bring Sasuke back.

After all what happened in Part 2, I think she had a pretty good development to be Heroine of a Shounen... And yes, I consider her the most developed female in Naruto.

That's not a background at all. The closest thing to a background was the bullying thing, which only explained the rivalry with Ino.

Kishi should have explained why had that view about parents and why she wore that symbol all the time.
 
Last edited:

To Whatever

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 27, 2013
Messages
18,010
Reaction score
1,512
Sakura's background is Part 1.
To sum up, Sakura was useless until Tunade trained her, the one she loved called her annoying, left her unconscious in a bench and set out in the seek of power, Naruto and her made a promise to bring Sasuke back.

After all what happened in Part 2, I think she had a pretty good development to be Heroine of a Shounen... And yes, I consider her the most developed female in Naruto.

She's the main Heroine so by default she's going to be more developed.

Just because she's more developed doesn't make her a better character.
 

Keimil

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
1,851
Reaction score
191
That's not a background at all. The closest thing to a background was the bullying thing, which only explained the rivalry with Ino.

Kishi should have explained why had that view about parents and why she wore that symbol all the time.

In part 2, that's her back story and/or her background.


She's the main Heroine so by default she's going to be more developed.

Just because she's more developed doesn't make her a better character.
No, It doesn't, but what is good or bad is up to each one to decide.

IMO, I think she is a great character.
 

MAN OF SIN

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
8,281
Reaction score
430
She also had the goal of catching up to Naruto and Sasuke, which .... to no one's surprise, never happened. That goal is wrong because it makes her come off as arrogant as a person for actually thinking she can do that despite clearly being tiers lower than even Sage Naruto & Hebi Sasuke, and badly written as a charcater because she never accomplished it.

Kishi should have at least had her admit inferiority like Vegeta did. Then she wouldn't have came off as arrogant.
 

Shruikan

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
18,476
Reaction score
1,102
Which female did Kishinev even care about in the series if not Sakura?hinata is like in a handful of panels.Ino is non existent.Her Dad was more developed than she was in P2.Temari is just there.The only ones is Tsunade who in my opinion is a sucky character based on what I saw of her in both the Pain fights and the Kabuto one.

The only argument I am seeing here is a lack of backstory which thankfully Kishi didnt listen to his fans for
 
Last edited:

Made in Heaven

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
31,444
Reaction score
2,201
Sakura's background is Part 1.
To sum up, Sakura was useless until Tunade trained her, the one she loved called her annoying, left her unconscious in a bench and set out in the seek of power, Naruto and her made a promise to bring Sasuke back.

After all what happened in Part 2, I think she had a pretty good development to be Heroine of a Shounen... And yes, I consider her the most developed female in Naruto.

That's not a background. Background is shit that happens prior to the beginning of the story.

If you think her development is on par w/ a typical, average Shonen heroine's than I suggest reading other mangas.

Except she isn't . Not even top 5

Which female did Kishinev even care about in the series if not Sakura?hinata is like in a handful of panels.Ino is non existent.Her Dad was more developed than she was in P2.Temari is just there.The only ones is Tsunade who in my opinion is a sucky character based on what I saw of her in both the Pain fights and the Kabuto one.

The only argument I am seeing here is a lack of backstory which thankfully Kishi didnt listen to his fans for

Oooooh myyy goood Lol

your post is full of dumb from start to finish, but that one statement is unbearable.
 
Last edited:

Shruikan

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
18,476
Reaction score
1,102
That's not a background. Background is shit that happens prior to the beginning of the story.

If you think her development is on par w/ a typical, average Shonen heroine's than I suggest reading other mangas.

Except she isn't . Not even top 5



Oooooh myyy goood Lol

your post is full of dumb from start to finish, but that one statement is unbearable.

Looking at your quote in my sig I should be honoured.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top