Kakashi having MS is illogical

[ANBU BlackOpps]

As both sharingan are from one Uchiha im guessing the eyes are always going to be linked somehow so when Obito awakened his MS Kakshi's did too. It was just a matter of Kakshi knowing he awakened it.

 

[Meowazziel]

Tobirama says that when a Uchiha suffers after experiencing the lost of a love one or despair, special chakra sprouts inside their brains, which affects their optic nerve producing a change in their eyes

You must be registered for see images

But problem is that Kakashi isn't Uchiha, so normally the special chakra couldn't even be formed since it only happens on Uchihas

It explains however why the strain on his body is greater than Uchihas since he lacks that special chakra in the head, plus the fact that he also lacks Uchiha DNA

Maybe it happens to anyone, only uchiha have special eyes who turn into sharingan when that stuff gets released into the brain.

Maybe it somehow turns both eyes into MS if it happens in one eye, even though the other is in someone else his socket.

I dont know though.

Anyway good find.
I have overlooked it.

Rep and thanks for you man.

 

[BEASTLY NARUTO]

What if kakashi killed rin only to gain ms....i think it ll be more logical cause that what most did except sasuke,obito....

 

[Austin Uchiha]

Tobirama says that when a Uchiha suffers after experiencing the lost of a love one or despair, special chakra sprouts inside their brains, which affects their optic nerve producing a change in their eyes

You must be registered for see images

But problem is that Kakashi isn't Uchiha, so normally the special chakra couldn't even be formed since it only happens on Uchihas

It explains however why the strain on his body is greater than Uchihas since he lacks that special chakra in the head, plus the fact that he also lacks Uchiha DNA

dont you remember? kakashi's sharingan is at a constant. its not like he can deactivate it. since he is non uchiha it has to stay the way the original uchiha had it. BUT kakashi only got MS because obito was there to witness Rin's death. since the owner of the eye saw the death. both eyes awakened MS

 

[Adebayo]

well, kakashi did kill/lose rin. whereas he promised obito that he would protect her with his life. that's enough emotional trauma to awaken the ms, afterall the condition is lose someone close. the other possibility is that both eyes are connected, so maybe obito awakening the ms automatically awakens kakashis' own. And tobirama wasn't explaining the ms, when he meant symptom. he was referring to the sharingan with 3 tomoes

 

[Voltron]

well, his ms developed because he was close enough to obito.... when one evolves, the other evolves....
it would kinda suck to have a ms in one eye and a three tome sharingan in the other.....

 

[Booker]

The EYE was of Uchiha blood, so when Kakashi experienced grief the Uchiha DNA in the eye reacted.

 

[Kages]

Well it was Obito's eye :shrug:

 

[Trollasaur]

LOL thinking back why didn't Obito just kill Kakashi there and take his eye back? Anyways Kakashi might of had the hots for Rin too lol

 

[Great Sage of Uchiha]

But his optic nerve isn't connected to Obito's brain so how would it send the signal to his eye?

Wait are you using reality logic on naruto -__- stop it.

 

[sukyyb]

It's still Obito's eye. And they're clearly connected as seen with their techniques. Obito can warp himself while Kakashi can warp objects. What are the odds of that? They're linked.n

 

[FizzyDrink]

I'm going to say this even though I have no idea whether it makes sense scientifically or not, but then again, this is manga...

Anyways, my two cents are this. Obito had his special Uchiha chakra imbued into his eye, and considering that it was still in Sharingan form when he transferred it to Kakashi, is it possible that that chakra remained in the eye, and then spread through Kakashi himself? This would be substantiated when we see Obito seeing what Kakashi sees, seeing as a bit of the Obito UCHIHA chakra remains. So when Obito unlocked the Mangekyou, it wasn't coincidence that Kakashi did, it was a result of the connection, as many have already said.

Basically I'm trying to scientifically explain the connection, and I personally believe that seen this way, this is no plot hole.

 

[The Work]

That's why you don't use logic in animated series

 

[DaAnswer]

It seems that Kakashi could be a far decentant of an Uchiha.

 

[Dark Enemy]

the point is Kakashi could adapt to the eye and in time making him resistance to the effects, about that little special chakra probably will occur only a uchiha clan

 

[ARandomBlackKid]

Kakashi has plot on his back.

 

[Thee Beyonder]

Whats this going to solve?