Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
Poison Chan, my most trusted fellow in the previous game, hope you're still in the same side as me in this game.
And as for everyone, just like Poison Chan I'm from the similar time zonr as her(SEA), not too far from India so not much I can post plus bad signel in my place is not helping.
@SoulKiller as far as this game goes my reading still limited and I'm aware of Dr. Strange very active nature in this game. Besides fluff posts he tried to emphasize on the "key" and helping in clearing a situation. If I'm going to extrapolate his action so far he might could be both(mafia or townie) but lean to town 55%, mafia 45% as of right now. I can feel an attempt to be more active or showing a contribution for a distancing from him also. Just time will tell.
As for killthestory, I can see two patterns from him, the pattern when he is a townie and thevpattern when he is a scum/wolf/mafia. When he was a townie he didn't "shy" from writing his write up or his reading on every players and result of every DP to look for evidence or making a reason, can be seen in Dr. Strange's mafia game. But stark contrast happened when he was a mafia in SoulKiller's game. He's not posting much until the first DP's time ran out. Little to no reading and contribution from him. He said something like this as a townie,
now, for town, there was a bit of a learning curve for pretty much everyone. i think the main problem was that nobody really knew what the right balance of passive and aggressive was. day 1 everyone was way too passive in solving the game. mafia is a game where even if you have no information, you create information and create reads off of this. by taking a long time to get serious and by not pressuring anyone, even if you didn't believe in a scumread on them, you allowed an atmosphere that generated no information for you guys to make a lynch that would give you further information down the road and would also clear up a lot of questions you wouldn't have to answer later. then, the next couple of days, people started tunneling others and getting so focused on a read that their information generation also resulted in a net negative. by focusing primarily on one person, you're ignoring all the reactions that other people are making to yours and your opponents interaction which is arguably the most important part of pressuring someone. you should constantly be aware of how people are reacting to what's going on and who's laying low and who isn't. scum got away with laying low a lot because town was going after the wrong members in a case that lead town to hurt themselves a lot early on. disregarding that, i think the rest of what i saw will be fixed with experience, so i'm excited to see how further games pan out.
I highlighted the important part. He never generated any read on any player in the SoulKiller's game. But that's is not a surprise because he is mafia afterall in that game.
Quoting his post about how mafia play,
you're doing well for your first game of mafia especially considering you are the mafia 
however, i'd like to point out a few inconsistencies in this post (more for future reference on how to scumread rather than in an attempt to lynch you as town has already lost parity) mafia struggles to form independent and cohesive thoughts when formulating scumreads. this is because they already understand the gamestate, and most new mafia players tend to shy away from actively lying and pushing someone for what they know is false reasoning. as you can see, q is struggling to fake scumreads and goes with the flow because that's just what every new mafia player does.
however, i'd like to point out a few inconsistencies in this post (more for future reference on how to scumread rather than in an attempt to lynch you as town has already lost parity) mafia struggles to form independent and cohesive thoughts when formulating scumreads. this is because they already understand the gamestate, and most new mafia players tend to shy away from actively lying and pushing someone for what they know is false reasoning. as you can see, q is struggling to fake scumreads and goes with the flow because that's just what every new mafia player does.I don't know the clear reason he posted less in Soulkiller's game. He get substituted by Dr. Strange the minutes before DP 1 ended. Maybe he is busy but everyone is busy including me when playing that game. But one thing for sure from his experienced itself is that good Mafia will avoid making a thorough scumread because they have no good reason if not a good point to make one. If they get caught making a wrong read and wrong decision they're totally screwed. They preferred to cooperate, blend in and listen instead. Make less suspicious action. I've experienced with one wolf in the previous game.
But I'm not saying he is mafia but the possibility is there. People can try judging his action here. 4 hours left in this game but where is he?
Another player who picked my attention is Gister. He posted something like a measurement to player's experience but not in this game thread but in the Sign up thread. I feel it like a scum move to recognize the most dangerous players to scum team. And the post appeared after all players have received their role. I based this on my hunch and not my read in this game.
As for SoulKiller he seems like a townie that trying to contribute and solve thing so no scum feeling on him yet.
And for the players that discussing about my role revealed(Dupa, Michelle, Dragomir and Odd) one of them could be mafia.
Finalbeta seems like a townie.
Post automatically merged:
As for the door I choose the center door.
Last edited:
