Does Sasuke deserve punishment for his crimes?

[Hebi Sasuke]

The point is, they kill people that they were only ordered to kill and Sasuke went apeshit and boycotted the village, durr


Ucihas were planning a revolt, and it was the decision of Village elders, the only real crime Danzou did was not helping the village and even that would probably just get him mild jail sentence. Fodder samurai were people, not bugs, and they were protecting the kage summit wich was off limits



Gaara was the victim in that situation. And his father was at fault for making him a heartless monster

And that makes it perfectly fine. Gaara was a victim,but Sasuke wasn't? He was lied his whole life and Konoha murdered his clan without even thinking except for Hiruzen to try to peacefully resolve the issue. And to mention Itachi etc. Yeah,he definitely isn't a victim. You are just hating and you clearly can't think objectively if you justify Gaara but not Sasuke.

 

[mikeeozua]

Sasuke being accepted into the village would be unrealistic to me.
Also all the people who say he was justified in killing Danzo, no he's not. Danzo's plans and ideals meant nothing he was still a HOKAGE Candidate. Joining the Akatsuki can be considered a crime in itself. I like Sasuke and all, but betraying the village to go to Orochimaru, Then following the Akatsuki are not crimes that should go unpunished.

 

[mikeeozua]

1St : Imagine north korea attacks US and the defence secretary tells the army to stand down, will that get him a mild jail sentence... or a beheading in the city centre?

Sasuke was made like that because of Itachi killing his whole family and friends and showing it to him in a genjustu twice! and you want to blame Sasuke but not Gaara. Just admit Sasuke will not be punished because he wasn't all that bad.

Sasuke joined Akatsuki, Gaara didn't.

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

Sure, but did he betray his village? did he kill a candidate to hokage like Sasuke did?, did he join a criminal organisation like Sasuke? was he considered a S rank criminal?, no because he opened his eyes before it was too late, unlike Sasuke, that has only opened his eyes recently, after all he's done, and some people try to just ignore that and claim that he'll be forgiven and freed of sins because of that, I really hate that idea, but it's probably going to happen as I said in my previous comments.

Well I disagree with you. Danzo was an awful person who murdered and toyed with people. Yeah,he was thinking the best for Konoha,but he did deserve what he got. Sasuke was never evil just confused because of all the lies he was told over the years, and because he lost everyone he loved . He came to his senses and is now protecting a village who killed his clan ,his family and Itachi. That alone is enough for him to be forgiven.

 

[Sot viing hun]

Sasuke being accepted into the village would be unrealistic to me.
Also all the people who say he was justified in killing Danzo, no he's not. Danzo's plans and ideals meant nothing he was still a HOKAGE Candidate. Joining the Akatsuki can be considered a crime in itself. I like Sasuke and all, but betraying the village to go to Orochimaru, Then following the Akatsuki are not crimes that should go unpunished.

My thoughts exactly, If I get labeled as a Sasuke hater because I want him to face the consequences of his crimes, then I totally accept that label without objection.

Well I disagree with you. Danzo was an awful person who murdered and toyed with people. Yeah,he was thinking the best for Konoha,but he did deserve what he got. Sasuke was never evil just confused because of all the lies he was told over the years, and because he lost everyone he loved . He came to his senses and is now protecting a village who killed his clan ,his family and Itachi. That alone is enough for him to be forgiven.

Don't be mistaken, I think Danzō　was a total asshole too, but you can't justify Sasuke killing him by any means, it's the assasination of a Hokage candidate, and before that he broke through the Kage Summit looking for him, it matters not if Sasuke was confused, he was aware of his crimes and has to receive the consequent punishment, I know he's suffered alot but that doesn't justify his crimes.

 

[6thpathsage]

Sasuke joined Akatsuki, Gaara didn't.

Gaara killed more people in his childhood years than in sasuke's entire life.

 

[Wind Squid]

1St : Imagine north korea attacks US and the defence secretary tells the army to stand down, will that get him a mild jail sentence... or a beheading in the city centre?

Sasuke was made like that because of Itachi killing his whole family and friends and showing it to him in a genjustu twice! and you want to blame Sasuke but not Gaara. Just admit Sasuke will not be punished because he wasn't all that bad.

I would be very pleased if USAsha got wiped away from the map of the world xd but srsly, that wasn't a declaration of war, it was a terrorist surprise attack, and in fact, Danzou might have done the right thing by preserving the military force. A cruel, but reasonable tactic in order to be able to fend off future attackers (if only Nagato hadn't ressurected everyone that is)

And that makes it perfectly fine. Gaara was a victim,but Sasuke wasn't? He was lied his whole life and Konoha murdered his clan without even thinking except for Hiruzen to try to peacefully resolve the issue. And to mention Itachi etc. Yeah,he definitely isn't a victim. You are just hating and you clearly can't think objectively if you justify Gaara but not Sasuke.

Gaara was a jinchuriki. A village asset and its weapon. The fate of jinchurikis lies in the hands of the Kage. The Kazekage had basically driven him insane with all the mental torture and hardships he had him be put through his entire childhood. I bet you're the one that blames the gun and not it's user.

On the other Hand, Sasuke just suffered ONE traumatic experience and it was all done for his future benefit. You're the one that's ignorant and has no objective thinking

 

[Targaryen]

No. This is not the real world, this is a manga called Naruto. You're not a fan boy if you want a character to be in it not in jail / dead. Fail. :eww:

 

[Wind Squid]

My thoughts exactly, If I get labeled as a Sasuke hater because I want him to face the consequences of his crimes, then I totally accept that label without objection.

Yeah i suppose i should also add
" - joined a terroristic organisation"

 

[Sot viing hun]

Yeah i suppose i should also add
" - joined a terroristic organisation"

He joined the biggest criminal organisation in the narutoverse, it should be added.

 

[Targaryen]

You must be registered for see images

Lol, it was an accident. But you can see what I'm trying to say.

Besides Kishimoto isn't going to make him answer for his crimes, deal with it. He's gonna get off scot-free for helping in the war.

Naruto will never let people harm Sasuke.

Unless the plot changes he's gonna be just fine, deal with it. *_* *_* *_* *_* *_* *_*

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

I would be very pleased if USAsha got wiped away from the map of the world xd but srsly, that wasn't a declaration of war, it was a terrorist surprise attack, and in fact, Danzou might have done the right thing by preserving the military force. A cruel, but reasonable tactic in order to be able to fend off future attackers (if only Nagato hadn't ressurected everyone that is)


Gaara was a jinchuriki. A village asset and its weapon. The fate of jinchurikis lies in the hands of the Kage. The Kazekage had basically driven him insane with all the mental torture and hardships he had him be put through his entire childhood. I bet you're the one that blames the gun and not it's user.

On the other Hand, Sasuke just suffered ONE traumatic experience and it was all done for his future benefit. You're the one that's ignorant and has no objective thinking

For God's sake,one traumatic experience. You are now going measure sadness ? Your hate is so big and obvious you could cut it with a knife. You shouldn't hate so much,he is just a fictional character. Let him be

 

[Wind Squid]

He joined the biggest criminal organisation in the narutoverse, it should be added.

Welp it wasn't always that way, Yahiko started it as a peace-keeping organisation and all of the villages had employed Akatsuki at one point so....i dunno lol

 

[RasenUchihaChaos]

i guess its time for an Itachi quote lol


"People live their lives bound by what they accept as correct and true. That's how they define "reality". But what does it mean to be "correct" or "true"? Merely vague concepts ... their "reality" may all be a mirage. Can we consider them to simply be living in their own world, shaped by their beliefs?"


and then Pain "...Do you understand pain a little now? If you don't share someone's pain, you can never understand them. But just because you understand them doesn't mean you can come to an agreement. That's the truth."

You must be registered for see images

 

[Sot viing hun]

Lol, it was an accident. But you can see what I'm trying to say.

Besides Kishimoto isn't going to make him answer for his crimes, deal with it. He's gonna get off scot-free for helping in the war.

Naruto will never let people harm Sasuke.

Unless the plot changes he's gonna be just fine, deal with it. *_* *_* *_* *_* *_* *_*

So all you got to say is ''Kishimoto won't do it'' and the infamous ''deal with it'', I guess we should deal with it and shut up even if it's completely retarded, it's not like our opinions matter one bit, why the hell discuss right?, we are not in a Naruto discussion forum after all...

 

[Klad]

Yup he deserves a punishment,but not death.

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

My thoughts exactly, If I get labeled as a Sasuke hater because I want him to face the consequences of his crimes, then I totally accept that label without objection.



Don't be mistaken, I think Danzō　was a total asshole too, but you can't justify Sasuke killing him by any means, it's the assasination of a Hokage candidate, and before that he broke through the Kage Summit looking for him, it matters not if Sasuke was confused, he was aware of his crimes and has to receive the consequent punishment, I know he's suffered alot but that doesn't justify his crimes.

I would agree with you if all people in this manga who did crimes and that is pretty much everybody,got a deserving punishment. But that isn't the case.

 

[6thpathsage]

I would be very pleased if USAsha got wiped away from the map of the world xd but srsly, that wasn't a declaration of war, it was a terrorist surprise attack, and in fact, Danzou might have done the right thing by preserving the military force. A cruel, but reasonable tactic in order to be able to fend off future attackers (if only Nagato hadn't ressurected everyone that is)


Gaara was a jinchuriki. A village asset and its weapon. The fate of jinchurikis lies in the hands of the Kage. The Kazekage had basically driven him insane with all the mental torture and hardships he had him be put through his entire childhood. I bet you're the one that blames the gun and not it's user.

On the other Hand, Sasuke just suffered ONE traumatic experience and it was all done for his future benefit. You're the one that's ignorant and has no objective thinking

Future attackers will attack what? He didn't know tsunade used slugs to save everybody meaning he was entirely ok for everbody to be wiped out from the village (scratch that... there was no village left) it was 100% selfish not a tactic and btw you are forgetting he cheated his way into being hokage candidate using kotoamatsukami.


Sasuke was the only uchiha left in the planet, is that not constant torture in it self (not to mention whatever nightmares he would have had of the event)... Quit being strong headed im tiring of arguing with you.

 

[Marceant]

damn ****ing hater

 

[Targaryen]

So all you got to say is ''Kishimoto won't do it'' and the infamous ''deal with it'', I guess we should deal with it and shut up even if it's completely retarded, it's not like our opinions matter right?, we are not in a naruto discussion forum after all...

It's not retarded. If you really care that much why don't you make a thread for EVERY single character who has a history of mass-murdering etc. who got off scot-free?

As you just said it's opinion.
So why do you act like your opinion is the only opinion? Other people have opinions too.
Just look at the poll.
You don't respect other peoples opinion yet you expect it?

You must be registered for see images