Does Sasuke deserve punishment for his crimes?

[darkprince]

I never thought of Sasuke in terms of the punishment he should or might get. I've only ever considered how it might be possible for him to redeem himself.

yeah same goes for me.

 

[Micho22]

He deserves a p very bad punishment
He is a criminal village betrayer burn in naruto hell

 

[darkprince]

lolololololololololololololololol.

i see truth is bitter to you.so wait and watch the manga.

 

[Wind Squid]

thats the shinobi way.you have to kill sometimes to complete your tasks.even ninja belonging to villages does that.
despite all that,he warned them,although there was no need too.its not his fault.

There's so much...stupid in that one post...i ...i don't think i can ever come back from reading that. To think that such a braindead person is currently sharing my plane of existence is simply...bogus.

 

[SimonHawk]

In a way, she should be, but remember what Onoki said?

You must be registered for see links

"They're a hero who protected the Shinobi World." But with Itachis help of course.
And now Sasuke is heading to the battle field, so if he does end up helping win the war, they may end up forgetting about all his crimes. May be a high possibility. :eww:

 

[Aki Kimura99]

Noooo he doesn't deserve it at all! Omg...I can believe you actually posted this question... Of course he deserves but when you think about why he did it...I mean if someneone does what's did to Itachi to my brother I'll probably try to kill him like Sasuke did.

 

[Twisted007]

First, Your a Sasuke/Uchiha hater and your poll proofs that, there is not even a decent option for people who disagree with you.

Second, your logic doesn't make sense. Your saying that a hitman is not a murder because he gets paid for his kills. But somebody who kills for personal reasons is a murder. It makes no sense at all.

We have Raikage who attempted to kidnap Hinata, and than got Neji father killed. And he is a respected Kage.

We have Gaara, Danzo who killed how many people, and they respected.

We have Tsuchikage who hired Akatsuki to their biddings, and he is respected.

But Sasuke should be punished? Thats mad funny!!!!


p.s. Sasuke left a village that would have killed him if it wasn't for Itachi, they would have killed a kid just because of his clan, lets not forget that.

 

[Exaar]

at the very least, A should get One free punch on sasuke, Anywhere and as hard as he wants.

Just to make them even.

 

[Wind Squid]

First, Your a Sasuke/Uchiha hater and your poll proofs that, there is not even a decent option for people who disagree with you.

Second, your logic doesn't make sense. Your saying that a hitman is not a murder because he gets paid for his kills. But somebody who kills for personal reasons is a murder. It makes no sense at all.

We have Raikage who attempted to kidnap Hinata, and than got Neji father killed. And he is a respected Kage.

We have Gaara, Danzo who killed how many people, and they respected.

We have Tsuchikage who hired Akatsuki to their biddings, and he is respected.

But Sasuke should be punished? Thats mad funny!!!!


p.s. Sasuke left a village that would have killed him if it wasn't for Itachi, they would have killed a kid just because of his clan, lets not forget that.

Ughhh, here we go agaaaain, Don't mix war crime actions and state criminal law. Sasuke is a missing-nin, there's a huge difference.
Gaara is special case, i already answered it in the thread

They're both murderers, the diffence being, one is a gun and holds no responsibility for the kill and other is a criminal that went apeshit

 

[nakumaru]

I think he liked that :| and besides Naruto wouldnt allow anyone to hurt his lov...erm...his friend.

You stole that sig from someone on Mangafox

 

[Marka of the Six Paths]

he must pay for his crimes....

 

[Sot viing hun]

The bolded thing happened because Uchiha hate curse makes all them untrustworthy, overemotional and maglo-maniacal as it has been shown in the past. Are you going to trust a lunatic that's behaving like Sarah Palin on period 24/7 to take part in politics of your state, no i don't think so. (ba-duum-tss!)
You don't see this shit happening with the Hyuuga, un!


The needs of the many outweight the needs of the few

I understand your position, the Uchiha are apparently not trustworthy because of their curse and to leave them in charge of your politics seems a bit risky, but not all the Uchiha were megalomaniacs or just plain crazy, Tobirama had a prejudice because he saw with his own eyes how Madara ended, but like I say not all the Uchiha end up as crazy assholes. Tobirama was afraid that another Madara would be ''born'' some day.


lol the Hyuuga just don't give a fuck or they are just more collected and discrete.


_________________________________
My Internet is being a dick, that's why I couldn't reply earlier.

 

[Twisted007]

Ughhh, here we go agaaaain, Don't mix war crime actions and state criminal law. Sasuke is a missing-nin, there's a huge difference.
Gaara is special case, i already answered it in the thread

They're both murderers, the diffence being, one is a gun and holds no responsibility for the kill and other is a criminal that went apeshit

What are you talking about war crime and state criminal law?

And you failed with your weak arguments to condone Gaara's crimes. Hell you even put in your poll ''yes, a crime is a crime''

 

[Wind Squid]

I understand your position, the Uchiha are apparently not trustworthy because of their curse and to leave them in charge of your politics seems a bit risky, but not all the Uchiha were megalomaniacs or just plain crazy, Tobirama had a prejudice because he saw with his own eyes how Madara ended, but like I say not all the Uchiha end up as crazy assholes. Tobirama was afraid that another Madara would be ''born'' some day.


lol the Hyuugas just don't give a fuck or they are just more collected and discrete.


_________________________________
My Internet is being a dick, that's why I couldn't reply earlier.

Yeah, a total of ONE during Hashirama-Tobirama period
Two during Hiruzen-Minato period
and Zero during Tsunade rule

I WONDER WHY THEY WEREN'T TRUSTED BY THE VILLAGE

You must be registered for see images

----------------------------------------------------------------

Don't worry man, i still manlove you :flirty1:

 

[Sot viing hun]

Yeah, a total of ONE during Hashirama-Tobirama period
Two during Hiruzen-Minato period
and Zero during Tsunade rule

I WONDER WHY THEY WEREN'T TRUSTED BY THE VILLAGE

You must be registered for see images

----------------------------------------------------------------

Don't worry man, i still manlove you :flirty1:

It is somehow justified that they were not trusted, I admit that.

Don't worry man, i still manlove you

i still manlove you

love you

You must be registered for see images

 

[KevinPJH]

So you give no reasonable option to be against your own opinion?

Why make a pole if you can not put away your extreme bias side.

 

[Wind Squid]

It is somehow justified that they were not trusted, I admit that.

You must be registered for see images

S'all justified, s'all m' sayin' :snick:

Do you believe in Love at the first sight or do i have to walk by again?​

​

You must be registered for see images

 

[TenthHokagexRamen]

Yes but ofcourse naruto going to go straight homo and won't let it happen.

 

[SadSasuke]

In real life or a realist anime, yes. But in Naruto, because of the plot, no.

 

[darkprince]

There's so much...stupid in that one post...i ...i don't think i can ever come back from reading that. To think that such a braindead person is currently sharing my plane of existence is simply...bogus.

Looks like someone got emotional here.