1) Ehh. I don't know many town players whose solving would be significantly sabotaged by anything I've said here.
2) That's fair. I can attempt to be more respectful. I apologize for the pressure I've placed on you. I know that when I believe I have a solution path, like most people, it can result in a degree of tunnel vision.
3) Oh, no, I welcome a Luk answer. My answer will have no impact on Luk's answer though.
1) You being a nosy parker answering questions asked directly to others is one.
2) I dont mind the pressure, no need to apologize for it, but i've caught scum multiple times when they begin answering questions that were asked yo others. If you do this as town, you need to stop doing that.
3) I never sais it would.
3 scum in a 10 player setup is not at all unusual, though. If anything, 2 is a little low without a bit of an awkward power ratio. Standard town:scum ratios are between 22% and 33%.
I mean, it could be and we are at lylo now but 3 scum in a 10 player set up is scum sided and totally unbalanced! If there are 3 scum then we never had a chance and Michelle will need some game set up lessons.
Then why are you so unwilling to consider Rej? You haven't talked about Rej all game. That action speaks quite loudly. Are you protecting Rej for some reason? If you're town, then you have no reason to do so here.
Because the entire players have suspected your slot and somehow you've managed to survive while townies keep falling, your slot needs to get sorted but if we only have today to solve this then, bussing in the only other possibility.
Like i've bussed as scum on Day 1 in difficult games that were townsided by design because it was the only way to win as a deepwolf, Lukundo was in one by the way he can confirm this (High Noon), but if there are three scum like you believe, scum don't need to bus here, they just need 3 mischops. Piece of cake!
But now that i think about it, It would make sense that Rej or Lukundowould have bussed SK if Rej read the game state and deduced that SK was gonna get the axe.
Is this why you think there gotta be 3 scum?
Also, you said you had collected info forming meta from multiple games. In context, I asked why you were so ready to townread Luk when you had never given a case. You were very certain about townreading Luk. Luk was not an option at all for your PoE.
No it was, like i said, i found it odd how Lukundo engaged with Fait, but it reminded me of the way he pushes and tunnels people as town.
It took multiple times of asking you for detail before you provided detail on one read. Even if you think I'm mafia, you cannot be 100% certain, so actively ignoring requests for detail implicitly states that you refuse to contribute to cooperation between players in the thread. That is anti-town behaviour.
It's true, it is anti-town but I subbed in to this game to help Michelle because she's been there to play my games when i was a host noob and didnt have clout to convince players to play my games. I dont have time to case everyone, i got like an hour to post something here, two if i force myself after work. I believe i'm contributed a lot for what I can give to this game and my ISO is proof of it.
Is it based on thunderdomes that everyone resolves slots? Is it based on thunderdomes that you resolve slots or based on reading the reactions given in those thunderdomes?
I can't speak for the thousands of people that play this game, but thunderdoming is one of my main tactics. I solve based on how the opponent engages with me in those thunderdomes and reacts and NGL, the more i engage with you the more townie you sound and that is perplexing.
I look forward to it, given that if you can provide detailed reads during this day phase, and if you are correct that there is only 2 mafia (which I doubt, but it's possible), then we can quickly eliminate Rej and conclude the game!
That's the problem i cannot provide detail reads! Im off to work in 15 minutes and then i'll comeback to a game that's its already on night phase if we didnt lose it already!
I made links to searches of each user's posts in order. I.e. exactly what one would use to read along. It doesn't take time to follow along post by post in the search. It takes a lot of time to make each post number into a link; this site doesn't have links by post position in the thread. Not to mention, you asked me specifically about the SK analysis. The SK analysis is literally just going post by post through SK's ISO and listing out the number of times each person's name comes up in SK's posts, including quoting people and excluding posts with 0 names, or every player's name. It's a very easy analysis to do on flipped mafia to see who they mention more or less often. When there's a disconnect, it means the players below the disconnect are more likely buddies than not.
There are only 3 ppl who weren't on the Soul Train (still funny) and since yah know it's not me, It's Osie/Guillotina. We clear those up, then if necessary look into a possible bussing scenario (which is insane to me. you don't buss your role cop when with one pendulum shift you can push a mislynch)
Hope town pulls this off and that my reads are right.
