[Game] Death Note Mafia Game #34

[Guillotina]

Yah that's selfish. At least i know you can be anti-town while being town now.

 

[TheLukundo]

I'm not saying that Osie is Town, nor am I saying that Guillo is Town.
I'm saying that Osie and Guillo are not scum together.

 

[Guillotina]

because soul didn't even know how to vote until 30 minutes before the day's end. I also asked the host and she didn't confirm one way or another so as not o affect game play. Good host.

Ok.

 

[Guillotina]

I'm keeping it on Osie, i hope we hit scum!

Off to work. Cheers

 

[osieorb18]

And also framed it as Osie trying to sew confusion when really Osie's trying desperately to save his ass.

Nah, I'd be posting a lot more and trying a lot harder if I was focused on saving my ass.

 

[osieorb18]

Osie's post are entertaining and I liked his reads but I've made a PoE and Ace/Osie is at the top of it and I'm sticking to my guns. And as good as Osie's post are, doesn't make up for the fact that Ace never explained why Soul wasn't scummy. There are only 3 ppl who weren't on the Soul Train (still funny) and since yah know it's not me, It's Osie/Guillotina. We clear those up, then if necessary look into a possible bussing scenario (which is insane to me. you don't buss your role cop when with one pendulum shift you can push a mislynch)

If you think the team is Osie/Guillotina, well, I think the team is Rej/Guillotina, so I'm down to eliminate either of those two. So we can meet in the middle on Guillotina.

@TheLukundo If you're down.

 

[TheLukundo]

No, Osie. You can be scum with Rej. You can't be scum with Guillo. I'm only going Rej.

 

[Nikamara]

Walk me through how Osie is teamed up with Guillo

Walk you through what now no. That's not what I or anyone said.

 

[Nikamara]

I'm not saying that Osie is Town, nor am I saying that Guillo is Town.
I'm saying that Osie and Guillo are not scum together.

I'm saying Osie is scum and that if the game doesn't end there is a 3rd party involved and it's Guillotina. Never said they were scummates. Keep up.

 

[Nikamara]

If you think the team is Osie/Guillotina, well, I think the team is Rej/Guillotina, so I'm down to eliminate either of those two. So we can meet in the middle on Guillotina.

@TheLukundo If you're down.

That's not what I said love. Again, I think you're mafia and that if the game doesn't end when you die, there is an Indie and my guess for possible Indie is Guillotina.

 

[Nikamara]

If you think the team is Osie/Guillotina, well, I think the team is Rej/Guillotina, so I'm down to eliminate either of those two. So we can meet in the middle on Guillotina.

@TheLukundo If you're down.

No dice. You're dying. Pack your bags. Wavering on the person who should have been lynched from Day 2 is what cost us Alice's life in the first place.

 

[osieorb18]

@TheLukundo @Nikamara Holy crap this might actually be an 8/2 setup; I'm coming around to the idea of Guillotina possibly being town with this one post. Kinda makes me want to eliminate Rej even more, but...

In case we're in LyLO and Michelle didn't inform us of it, Rej is always the elimination here; Guillotina just isn't nearly as scummy.

1) You being a nosy parker answering questions asked directly to others is one.
2) I dont mind the pressure, no need to apologize for it, but i've caught scum multiple times when they begin answering questions that were asked yo others. If you do this as town, you need to stop doing that.
3) I never sais it would.

1) Ehh, I know it's a bit of a faux pas (I've been playing for plenty of years to know that), but it really depends on the context as to how much it actually affects things. People take it as a hard and fast rule when they shouldn't.
2) It really depends on the context.
3) The actual only reason people have an issue with someone else answering the question interrupting is if it leads on the following person. So that is the implication if you're being indignant about it.

I mean, it could be and we are at lylo now but 3 scum in a 10 player set up is scum sided and totally unbalanced! If there are 3 scum then we never had a chance and Michelle will need some game set up lessons.

Out of character: I'm not a mod here, but having designed/hosted/reviewed/moderated/etc dozens of games, this is incredibly poor sportsmanship and I'm rather disgusted by it.

Because the entire players have suspected your slot and somehow you've managed to survive while townies keep falling, your slot needs to get sorted but if we only have today to solve this then, bussing in the only other possibility.

Like i've bussed as scum on Day 1 in difficult games that were townsided by design because it was the only way to win as a deepwolf, Lukundo was in one by the way he can confirm this (High Noon), but if there are three scum like you believe, scum don't need to bus here, they just need 3 mischops. Piece of cake!

But now that i think about it, It would make sense that Rej or Lukundowould have bussed SK if Rej read the game state and deduced that SK was gonna get the axe.

Is this why you think there gotta be 3 scum?

Hmm. Hmm. I have thoughts here. But hmm.

No it was, like i said, i found it odd how Lukundo engaged with Fait, but it reminded me of the way he pushes and tunnels people as town.

Interesting. I'd agree that Luk's pushes feel natural.

It's true, it is anti-town but I subbed in to this game to help Michelle because she's been there to play my games when i was a host noob and didnt have clout to convince players to play my games. I dont have time to case everyone, i got like an hour to post something here, two if i force myself after work. I believe i'm contributed a lot for what I can give to this game and my ISO is proof of it.

Hmm again. While I don't agree on the previous posts being hugely townie, this actually feels kinda on point. Maybe I'm almost down to believe that the game is 8/2 SK+Rej.

I can't speak for the thousands of people that play this game, but thunderdoming is one of my main tactics. I solve based on how the opponent engages with me in those thunderdomes and reacts and NGL, the more i engage with you the more townie you sound and that is perplexing.

I get that sometimes.

That's the problem i cannot provide detail reads! Im off to work in 15 minutes and then i'll comeback to a game that's its already on night phase if we didnt lose it already!

*Sigh*

 

[Nikamara]

You are very persuasive but Nikas are more stubborn than they appear If were simply judging today I think You're less scummy than Guillotina, but I'm judging the whole game.

 

[TheLukundo]

Ooooooooooooooooooooooo

I'm with you Nika.

 

[osieorb18]

No, Osie. You can be scum with Rej. You can't be scum with Guillo. I'm only going Rej.

Hmm.

 

[TheLukundo]

Nggggggggn...

 

[TheLukundo]

7/2/1 makes sense.

More sense than 7/3 and more sense than 8/2

 

[TheLukundo]

Which is why you're thinking the way you are

 

[osieorb18]

No dice. You're dying. Pack your bags. Wavering on the person who should have been lynched from Day 2 is what cost us Alice's life in the first place.

I haven't read Elmage's posts (or really SK's for that matter), but I'm down to do so and interaction case them to see if I get where you're coming from, if you'd like. If you have something better for me to do, let me know. If I'm dying no matter what, might as well help out.

 

[Nikamara]

just read your new post about why you are townleaning on Guillotina some fair points in there. I'm waiting for the case on why Rej is scum though. Explain how rej busses his role cop day 1 over the newb who no one one knew and then didn't use it to paint himself in a townie light. explain.