I hardly see the difference considering the fact that Snack wasn’t able to do anything in return. Damaging him and then deciding to leave him in his condition is considered defeat. At the end of the day, he wounded Formal General Snack and sunk two of Big mom’s ships. What should that tell you?
The difference is you said beat and sorry but to me if you throw sand in someone's eyes and then run away and you're faster than them than you didn't win. If you break someone's leg but run away because you know when they get up and they will get up you won't be able to do it again, you didn't win. Kid vs Snack is the same thing and he even said so himself. It tells me he likes hit and run tactics and he's strong but Urogue who actually beat snack is stronger.
It’s not really an assumption. Running has nothing to do with physical striking/lifting strength and for Rogers to fight Whitebeard countless times to a standstill goes without saying.
Running is a feat attributed to physical strength what are you talking about? Someone physically stronger can run faster and longer.
It never said that their combat ability is equal, all it said is that they fought to a standstill and that they had countless battles. That’s it.
That's literally saying their combat ability is equal not their physical strength unless you're asserting they fought with their fists.
Given the fact that his cabin boy Shanks was able to match Old Whitebeard’s physical strength with just one arm, know that his masters utilize similar fighting style basically tells you.
For you to scar a Yonko that severely requires a great deal of physical strength. It’s only when they’re deprived or weakened that it becomes easy for a common new world pirate to damage a Yonko at all.
Now you're implying Roger was stronger. You're talking like Roger is a fighter like Zoro or Sanji or Shanks who use ther physical bodies and weapons but we don't know what weapons he used to match WB in combat. How do you know he didn't have some special weapon or special haki to help him in combat?
I don’t remember Shakky ever mentioning Blackbeard at all. Because if BB was included from the beginning then it would be called 12 super rookies and not 11.
You're confusing the 11 Supernova with the Worst Generation which is the 11 Supernova + Blackbeard.
Luffy, Zoro, Kid, Drake, Law, Drake, Apoo, Urogue, Bonnie, Bege, and Hawkins alone were never referred to as the Worst Generation as far as I remember only the 11 SuperNova. The term Worst Generation was coined to refer to them and Teach.