A poll comes down to a popularity contest. People who have no idea on what's being discussed or just overly biased could vote. That's not really too good of a way to judge a debate. NF, isn't their vs section was different from ours as the day and night? It'd be like pulling out a member who hasn't read the manga since the beginning of the war arc, they'd have an entirely different impression of the manga. And then we run the risk of, "Are they really qualified". Maybe I'm just not in the loop and everyone else is on NF too, but who's to say who would be a good judge over there?