Amaterasu is NOT fire

[obito uchiha the wraith]

Techniquely Amaterasu is not fire. Flames require gases to continue burning. We have seen Amaterasu burn underwater completely cut off from any gases what so ever. Not only that but flames emit light Amaterasu does not. When sasuke accidentally amaterasued tobi, tobi fell back in the shadows we couldn't even see a faint glimmer. Not only that but flames spread and grow. In every instance Amaterasu was used it NEVER spread infact it stayed the same size unless it was put out by the user. So in conclusion it is not a fire only fire like.

 

[Joker]

Of course it's not fire, it's just your hot-ass breath in a unique form.

 

[iNotorious]

Read this thread, you will learn a lot.

You must be registered for see links

 

[Punk Hazard]

Ametarasu is black, how is it supposed to glow and give off light?

 

[Hemsey]

They're the black flames from hell. And regular flames still burn they don't extinguish. Well the big amounts of fire.

 

[Aya San]

It's not fire, it's black oil

 

[oShux]

Techniquely Amaterasu is not fire. Flames require gases to continue burning. We have seen Amaterasu burn underwater completely cut off from any gases what so ever. Not only that but flames emit light Amaterasu does not. When sasuke accidentally amaterasued tobi, tobi fell back in the shadows we couldn't even see a faint glimmer. Not only that but flames spread and grow. In every instance Amaterasu was used it NEVER spread infact it stayed the same size unless it was put out by the user. So in conclusion it is not a fire only fire like.

Never apply logic in a anime that's where you f*cked up with this thread dumb ass. And how does BLACK flames glow? And Amaterasu never spreaded? I guess when they spreaded to the tress after Sasuke and Itachi's fight doesn't count huh

 

[Corgi]

The hell did I just read...

Water, by the way, is H20. The H2 stands for two Hydrogen molecules. If you didn't know, Hydrogen is a gas. This is simple chemistry...

---

Author's Note: Not saying that fire can burn underwater, just saying there is Hydrogen in water, and maybe Amaterasu can burn off that, from a scientific point of view.

---

And, like my boy rikerslade said, a black flame won't give off light.

 

[-Punk-]

It's a summoning from the depths of hell , it uses your inner spirits .

 

[Gatsuuga]

Real world logic doesn't apply to naruto. It got sealed with a fire elemen sealing Jutsu.....it's fire.

 

[Sapiens Sequax Sex Semita]

fire can burn underwater it just needs combustible material and an oxidizer and it can burn anywhere outerspace underwater on top of mt Everest where ever

 

[Shadow Phantasm]

Of course Amaterasu is fire since it's based of the japanese goddess of fire who goes by the same name.

 

[obito uchiha the wraith]

Never apply logic in a anime that's where you f*cked up with this thread dumb ass. And how does BLACK flames glow? And Amaterasu never spreaded? I guess when they spreaded to the tress after Sasuke and Itachi's fight doesn't count huh

Fire emits light even if black flames existed which they can't they would emit light. They never spreaded in the itachi fight you jerk itachi shot it in a complete circle around the building ofcourse the trees got hit.

 

[Cfighter]

You must be registered for see images

"-an unholy black flame-"
/thread

 

[Silent Phantom]

fire can burn underwater it just needs combustible material and an oxidizer and it can burn anywhere outerspace underwater on top of mt Everest where ever

Thank you. I didn't want to be the one to rain on their parade.

 

[Joon]

Manga says you are wrong. Databook definitely says you are wrong.

 

[Sapiens Sequax Sex Semita]

Fire emits light even if black flames existed which they can't they would emit light. They never spreaded in the itachi fight you jerk itachi shot it in a complete circle around the building ofcourse the trees got hit.

if there were indeed black flames they would not emit light more then what light they emit to show that they are black and since there black they would absorb and emit all colors in the form of black "light", light sources don't have to illuminate things it can be quite the opposite really

 

[Corgi]

fire can burn underwater it just needs combustible material and an oxidizer and it can burn anywhere outerspace underwater on top of mt Everest where ever

OP, listen to the guy with America's greatest Gothic poet as their avatar u_u

 

[obito uchiha the wraith]

Manga says you are wrong. Databook definitely says you are wrong.

Science says I'm right and science is always right.

 

[Sapiens Sequax Sex Semita]

OP, listen to the guy with America's greatest Gothic poet as their avatar u_u

notice itachi/shusui eyes / the cat its full of uchiha refrences XD