I think less experienced players tend to do OMGUS early as town, because they think they are in the right and wrongly attackedThats called OMGUS , thats why i asked was this your first mafia game ?
just a hunch
I still think Powerlevels play a role here.I just don't see a scenario where vigi blind fires unless its safe attack
And if scum has 3 kill power per night we fucked
or we have killers with high power and killers with low power, nothing inbetween, so the killers with low power can scout the roles with higher powernah from hosting point of view thats shooting yourself in the leg
If you oversatuate town with defensive roles it breaks the game. And with 3 possible night kills you would need in general 2 to 3 protects. Anything more is just no no.
That being said. If 3 NK is a thing then its either one of these 3 options
1) 3 NK per night wrecks town
2) Fake attack
3) Odd/Even night NK action
I agree with this thought process, they are atleast mid tier.Kyte and Alice could be a high ranking role compares to their killers
I think I started with it, they are just likelier to be town, and it's more likely that the killers had less powers.You stated they are town but how are you able to determine alice and kyte role were high ?