[Game] A Certain Mafia Game #30
- Thread starter Toujo
- Start date
fluffy_rabbit
Member
eh i kinda liked these responses in real time but they arent actually that good
he's probably still a fine vote
fluffy_rabbit
Member
isnt the official story now that she just got a failed action notice and all of her changed stories were different guesses for what couldve caused the failed action?
fluffy_rabbit
Member
see idk when im scum and one of my actions fail my first instinct is never to out it in the thread
it could only lead to more questioning which could out my role (which i dont wanna insta-out as scum) or just get me sussed like this
why claim anything at all as scum
thats part of what makes me think alice is unlikely scum
it could only lead to more questioning which could out my role (which i dont wanna insta-out as scum) or just get me sussed like this
why claim anything at all as scum
thats part of what makes me think alice is unlikely scum
fluffy_rabbit
Member
"silly claims are townie" is a general adage that tends to get me correct reads in role madnessy setups
would still be somewhat surprised if alice was an exception
would still be somewhat surprised if alice was an exception
fluffy_rabbit
Member
fluffy_rabbit
Member
i mean bruh alice is probably never endgaming in this game there's no rush to d1 her either way still
fluffy_rabbit
Member
reiterating that i prefer voting demon over ansa but if people dont show up and start voting demon by the time i sleep tonight (likely 3 hours from now) ill give up and vote ansa
For me D1 lynch should also give info.
What info so you think to get if Demon Flips scum, but also what if he flips Town?
Ansa in my opinion too many jump in him early on and I didn't get why.
Then we have also Shanks directly calling me out focusing on inactives, I told him to eloberate he never bother to respond.
One can also use the whole last pages centered around me. Anyone almost Just commenting Nessos Case on Alice is Shit instead of pushing other stuff.
Why do I need to be convincedd that my read on Alice "could" be wrong. (Noonne said have to be, it was only a could)
By observing one Figures Out stuff like
XMTF the selfproclaimed pro who did nothing so far, His first hunch leeads to nothing. now jumping on the only one who called him out.
SirSalt did nothing but coasting. Are still have a strong townread in him, Fluffy?
fluffy_rabbit
Member
i dont think town flips almost ever give clear info. people like to talk up info from townflips, but i rarely see people have actually strong associations from them, even when they're highposters with lots of associations. sometimes they give false associations, because people assume there had to be at least 1 scum pushing them, when it was just a bunch of town sussing a town. i don't really believe in thinking about levels of info for the d1 lynch, i just want to vote my strongest scumreads.
on top of that, end of day is in less than 6 hours from now, if im not mistaken? i can see why you might want xtmf, salt, or shanks voted, but i still have more feeling of some of each of their posts being towny than demon/ansa. and with majority lynch, there's just... i don't see them on the table. ask me again tomorrow if we're both alive. today has to be demon or ansa, who are ultimately both still scummy and probably need to be flipped sooner or later without massive improvement.
my salt townread isn't that strong, but it still exists. no such townread exists for demon/ansa. and as somebody who susses them both, i don't think too many people jumped on them: i think they're just obviously scummy and plenty of the other town players in this game correctly recognized that, while you're the odd one out wanting to vote for fancier reasons and harder-to-sell votes. that probably makes you towny, but you being loud and stubborn as the only person who wants to vote xtmf/shanks/salt isn't really followable in this gamestate. its either demon/ansa, or we're probably getting a nolynch, which multiple people have said they don't want (personally it wouldnt be the worst thing for me, but i still prefer flipping one of those 2)
on top of that, end of day is in less than 6 hours from now, if im not mistaken? i can see why you might want xtmf, salt, or shanks voted, but i still have more feeling of some of each of their posts being towny than demon/ansa. and with majority lynch, there's just... i don't see them on the table. ask me again tomorrow if we're both alive. today has to be demon or ansa, who are ultimately both still scummy and probably need to be flipped sooner or later without massive improvement.
my salt townread isn't that strong, but it still exists. no such townread exists for demon/ansa. and as somebody who susses them both, i don't think too many people jumped on them: i think they're just obviously scummy and plenty of the other town players in this game correctly recognized that, while you're the odd one out wanting to vote for fancier reasons and harder-to-sell votes. that probably makes you towny, but you being loud and stubborn as the only person who wants to vote xtmf/shanks/salt isn't really followable in this gamestate. its either demon/ansa, or we're probably getting a nolynch, which multiple people have said they don't want (personally it wouldnt be the worst thing for me, but i still prefer flipping one of those 2)
fluffy_rabbit
Member
also i dont see salt being tired of your alice tunnel as inherently scummy lol
you call it coasting? i mean, town can coast too if they don't think theres any actual new info.
maybe he's scummy for not having more thoughts on other stuff though, you could have a point there.
you call it coasting? i mean, town can coast too if they don't think theres any actual new info.
maybe he's scummy for not having more thoughts on other stuff though, you could have a point there.
fluffy_rabbit
Member
anyway nessos reminding me he susses xtmf/salt lessens my indie suspicions
think nessos is very likely just town here
think nessos is very likely just town here
Haze_with_a_Z
Member
Gonna just go in list order at this point instead of isoing the new people I see from a random page.
I have no clue how to read rej(Im also putting him null). He gives a lot of reactions to people, but idk if that is AI in any way. Like half of his iso is reactions. It def seems like more when I look through their iso. Without their iso, all I remember is their answers to the questions I asked and so I can't really make a read on that, but nothing really stands out in their iso to me. One thing I did notice was how their reactions are always "haha" or "like" except for two of them. They have one "wow"(post 698) and one "sad"(post 108). What if those two posts had some sort of hidden significance?
I can't see their profile so I can't iso them(idk another way). Uh I don't think I've been on the thread at the same time as them so I don't remember their posts as much as I do for some other people. People have given him suspicion I think.
On page 42(I kinda went from page 698 and went forward to find some posts by them), they ask xtmfare what their reads were and why they thought they were wolf. They then stated what they thought of them(came in with fluff and no progress) though which I like. Questions(well most questions) are good and so are thoughts.
idk if I like their following posts as much though. I like how they made a reads list though and acknowledged a bunch of people, even if they just had a null read on them. I'm gonna call them null town.
On page 42(I kinda went from page 698 and went forward to find some posts by them), they ask xtmfare what their reads were and why they thought they were wolf. They then stated what they thought of them(came in with fluff and no progress) though which I like. Questions(well most questions) are good and so are thoughts.
idk if I like their following posts as much though. I like how they made a reads list though and acknowledged a bunch of people, even if they just had a null read on them. I'm gonna call them null town.
His name is hard to spell. I remember almost none of their posts besides when they decided to claim wolf. He was pretty active d1(irl), d2 slowed down, d3(today- I call it a day until I go to sleep but technically it'd be yesterday) didn't post. I kinda don't like that activity pattern, but they coulda also just gotten busy or something irl, idk.
They claim scum in their second post and idk if many of their posts are much better(such as post 191 or 207). I've never played with them, so idk if they usually act like this, but seeing as they are kinda consensus scum, I'd assume not.
They claim scum in their second post and idk if many of their posts are much better(such as post 191 or 207). I've never played with them, so idk if they usually act like this, but seeing as they are kinda consensus scum, I'd assume not.
idk why they wanna think a town vig shot d1 after stating that it is foolish to do so. Seems kinda contradictory. Idk if they really seem like town, but I haven't heard any suspicion on them. Does everyone think they are town and if so, why?
Also no profile viewing so I guess I'll go to their posts from where ever I am in my random window from looking at shanks.
On pg 46, I like their first post, they reflect on someone else's posts and gives an opinion about it. On the next page, their first comment feels kinda random. Next comment I kinda like, but it kinda feels NAI instead. Idk what that post would be. I kinda like their next post, and the following one is NAI to me. They are a town lean for me atm.
On pg 46, I like their first post, they reflect on someone else's posts and gives an opinion about it. On the next page, their first comment feels kinda random. Next comment I kinda like, but it kinda feels NAI instead. Idk what that post would be. I kinda like their next post, and the following one is NAI to me. They are a town lean for me atm.
It kinda seems weird to not be online but have reads on everyone. Like it seems more weird to me to be missing the 7 people, but I feel like if someone is offline, they are prob thinking of things other than the game. They are still behind in the game though, and I didn't realize they had been on the day before so it makes slightly more sense. Idk, I think they are just null to me.
I kinda like how this spot was defending Alice because if they were scum, they mighta just tried for a miskill instead to get rid of a townsperson. I kinda saw more of his posts today while I was in the thread, and I liked how they had their own opinions on stuff and wrote them out.
Literally haven't seen a single one of their posts in the thread. I don't have to hit the "show older items" button once. Are they usually a low poster? 8 posts feels kinda low, but then again, we only need 6 posts so I guess it follows the rules. Apparently they aren't following their normal activity standards but idk what those are. Like half of their posts feel pointless, so it feels like they are posting like half the number of times in a relevant way.
Notorious has 0-posted, so I don't have any thoughts on them besides "they should post"
There are so many people. I hate isoing. I think I'm finally done now though.
I'm a little offended, at least I'm more active and posting thoughts and reads vs half these other players.
And surprisingly this is the most active and involved I've been in a game a looooong time. It's literally why haze said I was doing wall posts. This isnt usually how I play on MU.
Aside from my coasting, its literally the same dead horse being beat.
You, Nessos are creating this huge focus on 4ish players that its a black hole. No one can focus on anything else. Literally if you stepped away, let others post other things and reads. It would allow for different content to be examine and discussed. But as anything is brought up. You crush it and bring it back to Alice.
So yes, I am annoyed, I am irritated and I dislike your play and I fear that you and Alice will be alive dp2 and repeat of dp1. Where its you tunneling. It's anti town. Ive stated it and its why i would policy lynch you.
You, Nessos are creating this huge focus on 4ish players that its a black hole. No one can focus on anything else. Literally if you stepped away, let others post other things and reads. It would allow for different content to be examine and discussed. But as anything is brought up. You crush it and bring it back to Alice.
So yes, I am annoyed, I am irritated and I dislike your play and I fear that you and Alice will be alive dp2 and repeat of dp1. Where its you tunneling. It's anti town. Ive stated it and its why i would policy lynch you.
fluffy_rabbit
Member
haze ive read your conclusions from your isos, but they're mostly pretty inconclusive lol.
did you read demon at any point? he's my top scumread and i dont see his iso in your list.
also what did you mean by "It kinda seems weird to not be online but have reads on everyone. " for nikamara?
did you read demon at any point? he's my top scumread and i dont see his iso in your list.
also what did you mean by "It kinda seems weird to not be online but have reads on everyone. " for nikamara?
fluffy_rabbit
Member
Haze_with_a_Z
Member
I managed to somehow skip over demon on the playerlist. I guess I have one more.
Well they had kinda a presence at sod, even if it was kinda a weird presence. Better than being gone all day. They were absent for yesterday, and the day before, they posted 6 times or so and none of the posts really did anything in my opinion. Like they stated that they were reading and didn't have scum reads, but they didn't post anything from after they read. Commented on the pace, but that was basically it, save for a few random posts.
Haze_with_a_Z
Member
no, I managed to miss him on the playerlist and commented on him afterwards.