[VS] 7G Gai vs Base Minato

HNIC

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 24, 2012
Messages
2,503
Reaction score
96
why would it be a draw? 7th gate isn't permanent. It greatly strains and exhausts the user. Once guy can no longer maintain it, which isn't too long. Then he becomes physically worn out, fatigued and slower. That's when it is time to strike. While in 7 gates, all you can do is not attack him and ftg away.

We've witness Minato exhausted in a battle before as well. The fact is, Gai's power will overwhelm Minato, he'll be forced to use ftg consistently, while trying to deliver an offensive strategy in the process. Within this period of time, he'd use more chakra than his fight against Obito/Kyuubi. Therefore, trying to stall until Gai tires out is losers argument. The fatigue would hit both parties.
 

Worm

Banned
Veteran
Joined
Jan 3, 2013
Messages
4,092
Reaction score
311
Lol AC i like my girl too much to be homo U_U It's not about winning or losing, but enjoying a debate between fictional characters :p

I myself enjoy rape and mutilation. However, seeing as neither of characters are female, I am sad to say I cannot go into detail on how this battle would go. But kk, I get it.
 

Bogard

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Reaction score
2,378
Minato's reaction speed.
You must be registered for see images

Got demolished by an opponent far slower than Madara, and failed to Hirashin away until he lost his kunai, his hand and got stuck by a Gudo Dama. Meanwhile, Gai is fighting on par with Madara forcing him on the defensive. Do note, 1 Rinnegan non-Jin Madara was casually reacting to an FTG user whose striking speed is superior to Minato's [ ], whereas Juubi Jin 1 Rinnegan Madara who is 100's of times faster in every aspect needed to parry Gai's attacks since he couldn't dodge them.
Against Obito Jin, Minato was mentally unstable, but before you talk about excuses, i'll add this

7th gated Gai attack speed = Jubi Jins attack speed(roughly) > Minato's attack speed

However, Jubi jins reactions > Minato's reactions > 7th Gated Gai's reactions and this is what i'm debating here. Why? Because during his fastest move in 7th gate(Hirudora), Jubi Jin Madara cut it in half, sending him relying before he could even react. Because during his fastest step in 8 gate, Minato could complete 2 teleportations before he could move an inch. Inconsistent to you? I don't care. It's my conclusion
 

Rιver

Banned
Veteran
Joined
May 17, 2014
Messages
3,025
Reaction score
202
I am AC of the house of worms, first of my name, rightful king of worm's landing. For me, it is only natural to have a worm slithering around somewhere, be it the one in my pants or the one on this site. We, worms, are not merciful and seek to destroy every last fish that opposes us, be they the Starks or Baratheons. However, do not fear, Bogard of the House of Minatard, I swear on my only true god, Syura-oniisama, that I shall free you of the curse of yellow homosexual sunflowers, and of course, your unpleasant smell. And so, I ask thee, Bogard, to pledge your loyalty to the House of Worms, and answer the holy question


Stop with the fahking GoT shiet.
 

Worm

Banned
Veteran
Joined
Jan 3, 2013
Messages
4,092
Reaction score
311
I swear to Syura-oniisama, I shall not stop.
 

TheAncientCenturion

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Oct 30, 2012
Messages
7,020
Reaction score
632
I'll try to reply during my break, I've got a few questions regarding the topic.
 
Last edited:

Gold Lightning

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jun 16, 2012
Messages
6,823
Reaction score
448
We've witness Minato exhausted in a battle before as well. The fact is, Gai's power will overwhelm Minato, he'll be forced to use ftg consistently, while trying to deliver an offensive strategy in the process. Within this period of time, he'd use more chakra than his fight against Obito/Kyuubi. Therefore, trying to stall until Gai tires out is losers argument. The fatigue would hit both parties.

No, if minato has intel on the gates, then he wouldn't bother with an offensive counter until guy is worn out, because gates causes heavy drawbacks to the user and minato knows this. Even if minato gets tired, that's just a stamina issue. Guy on the other hand will feel the full backlash of the gates straining his body and will also feel fatigue to a much greater degree than minato spamming ftg.

Minato utilising only ftg is never gonna tire him out unless he uses it like 50 times, which won't be the case. Fatigue isn't going to hit minato when all h'es doing is the most basic ftg. Only time minato was exhausted was in his first fight with obito, and that was due to giant summonings, teleporting giant attacks and objects (tbb and kurama). summoning aren't needed here, and only time space time barrier will be used is probably against hirudora (which causes great fatigue on Guy, one of those and guy won't be moving so smoothly anymore).

Once 7 gates is down, Guy is done. You think Guy can continuously chase Minato in 7 gates when he has markings all over the place? And I didn't even mention shadow clones. What will guy do if minato makes like 20 clones and they all run off into different directions Lol (will guy chase them all?)All Minato has to do is time waste, then strike when Guy wears himself out. Minato will lose if he goes for a direct approach, waiting the gates out however ensures a minato win.
 
Last edited:

HNIC

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 24, 2012
Messages
2,503
Reaction score
96
No, if minato has intel on the gates, then he wouldn't bother with an offensive counter until guy is worn out, because gates causes heavy drawbacks to the user and minato knows this. Even if minato gets tired, that's just a stamina issue. Guy on the other hand will feel the full backlash of the gates straining his body and will also feel fatigue to a much greater degree than minato spamming ftg.

Minato utilising only ftg is never gonna tire him out unless he uses it like 50 times, which won't be the case. Fatigue isn't going to hit minato when all h'es doing is the most basic ftg. Only time minato was exhausted was in his first fight with obito, and that was due to giant summonings, teleporting giant attacks and objects (tbb and kurama). summoning aren't needed here, and only time space time barrier will be used is probably against hirudora (which causes great fatigue on Guy, one of those and guy won't be moving so smoothly anymore).

Once 7 gates is down, Guy is done. You think Guy can continuously chase Minato in 7 gates when he has markings all over the place? And I didn't even mention shadow clones. What will guy do if minato makes like 20 clones and they all run off into different directions Lol (will guy chase them all?)All Minato has to do is time waste, then strike when Guy wears himself out. Minato will lose if he goes for a direct approach, waiting the gates out however ensures a minato win.

Generally, your claim is Gai will be exhausted because Minato, having intel, would use ftg the entire time until Gai is worn out. Gai would attack foolishly and set his own fate.

You're ignoring the fact that Gai too has intel and has the ability to transition between gates as the fight lingers on. Base Gai arguably has the hand speed to counter Minato's striking speed to begin. So the fact that you believe Gai would knowingly waste his energy on Minato, is ridiculous.

You're looking for Minato to win so badly, you're not thinking the fight through.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
I already admitted that 7 gated Gai had better striking speed than Minato on my first post. What i don't agree with however is that he has better reactions than him. Pay in mind that during the start of his offensive against Madara Jin, Madara never striked back. To notice the reaction speed of someone is when he is actually attacked. Madara on the other side was only dodging from the back. When he actually attacked(to cut down Gai's Hirudora), he did it so fast Gai didn't even have time to complete the Hirudora and was sent relying before he even noticed

You don't still get it.

Madara never struck back because of his striking speed. However when he blocked Gai the first time, he wasn't given the chance to react because Gai could move fast enough to react and land another strike.

Let me give you an example here:

Minato stikes Juubito and Juubito reacts by blocking the attack: . Shortly after, Minato is unable to react during that period and only reacts after Obito strikes him .

Gai strikes Madara, Madara blocks him but Madara is unable to strike back like he did to Minato because Gai reacts fast enough to deliver another strike keeping Madara on the defensive and unable to counter back. Madara did strike Gai's attack when Gai landed to use the hand seal and if you look well in the middle of this scan , you'll see Gai's last movement where he physically landed down before Madara could and uses the hand seal for the technique. That's when Madara could use his staff to strike back after Gai paused which shows before he couldn't at all. That alone should convince you considering he could pause right in from of the Jin and use the hand seal for the attack before the Jin could land.


Many times in the Manga it has been shown: Kisame tries to hit Gai, Gai reacts and then strikes back in the 6G. Ay tries to hit Minato, Minato reacts and then nearly strikes back(B intervened). Minato tried to hit Juubito, Juubito reacts and then strikes back. Gai tries to hit Madara, Madara reacts but is unable to strike back. Minato tries to hit Madara, Madara reacts by striking back with Minato not being able to react.

Gai's case is different because he's fast enough to move and react with a strike avoiding a counterattack.



Gai couldn't react to Naruto's shunshin, something Kakashi compared to Minato's [ ]

I hope you know that's Base Gai. Not to mention that's Naruto coming right from his back which he had no idea on.

You said it yourself. It increases his physical capacities only. Nowhere is it stated that Gates upgrade his reactions. With this in mind, there is no reason for me to assume he can react to Minato's shunshin or Hiraishin if he couldn't to Naruto's that was compared to Minato's speed

That's Base Gai that you're talking about int that scan.

- Naruto came from his back to deflect something in front of him

- That scan is not a legit reaction fail since Gai isn't the one Naruto's coming for.

If I go by what you're saying, I'll be here saying Base Gai has better reactions than KCM Naruto in a CQC since Gai prevented Obito from touching him after swinging his Sohsuga while Naruto couldn't react to Obito to touching him after using his chakra arms. That sounds better than what you said but instead, I can't use that as a legit feat since it's not really a consistent comparison.

The Gates increase your physical capabilities meaning naturally he's better in every single physical department than his Base form and that includes reaction speed. Unless you want to say something like Base Gai can react to Amaterasu or can replicate what 7G Gai did against Madara.


Him being able to physically keep up and a Jin being unable to strike him at that point due to his striking and reaction speed should tell you Minato's only chance is catching him off guard when he has no idea of his position or something like that. If Minato come head on, he dies as he's no match in a CQC.


And this is where i disagree. All what i concede is on the part his attack speed is fast enough to surpass Madara jin's precognition. However, i disagree with him having faster reactions than Minato. Gai's reactions are roughly on par with Sharingan Kakashi [ ]

You're using the 6G. That's vastly inferior to the 7G..Not to mention you're wrong with your 6G comparison.

- There were 3 Bijuus against Gai and Kakashi.

- Kakashi missed against that very Bijuu that hit them both in the bottom of this scan

- Next scan that same Bijuu uses its tail to hit both Gai and Kakashi despite Gai not being its opponent . How's that a fair comparison?

- Both of them reacted but got pushed back by the force of the attack, how does that show that they're equal in terms of reactions because they both reacted? Just like saying Kurama uses its tail to smack Hashirama and Tobirama but because they both react, their reaction speed equal to each other.

You think 6G Gai is equal to Kakashi in terms of reaction(I'm ignoring you're implying in the 7G). Clearly false.
 
Last edited:

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Honestly if one says outlasting, That's farr better than someone saying 6G Gai reaction = Kakashi' reactions. I've never slapped my head harder ahaha.

Minato could definitely win this but my point is it's a high diff either way since Minato would struggle to tag Gai as he has to engage him in a CQC. Bogard is trying to imply it's a stomp. Never have I heard someone comparing Gai's Base/other versions of the Gates to the 7th and saying they somehow have equal reaction speed. I can't believe this is you Bogard. Now I know why you think we overrate Gai.
 

Gold Lightning

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jun 16, 2012
Messages
6,823
Reaction score
448
Generally, your claim is Gai will be exhausted because Minato, having intel, would use ftg the entire time until Gai is worn out. Gai would attack foolishly and set his own fate.

You're ignoring the fact that Gai too has intel and has the ability to transition between gates as the fight lingers on. Base Gai arguably has the hand speed to counter Minato's striking speed to begin. So the fact that you believe Gai would knowingly waste his energy on Minato, is ridiculous.

You're looking for Minato to win so badly, you're not thinking the fight through.

Dunno what the heck you are talking about, Guy starts in 7 gates, thats kind of the matchup of this thread. Nor am I saying guy will attack foolishly, the question is how can he attack when you have a shadow clone using teleporter?

Guy is not transitioning between base and 7 gates. You're ignoring the drawback of it, the side effects of opening the 7th gate are that the user's muscle fibres are ripped to shreds, causing intense pain, especially if anything or anyone touches them.

Guy would be retarded to deactivate 7 gates after opening it. Its all or nothing, if he deactivates it, he's just wasting it. Just opening it causes serious damage. If he turns it off, he'll be feeling the drawbacks almost immediately and that will handicap him against minato. This isn't the 6th gate, Guy can't flick it on and off without worrying too much about the drawbacks. Turning off 7 gates to try and conserve himself won't work, it just makes it harder for him to re enter.

You're the one not thinking now. I'm not ignoring anything, it's just that intel benifits Minato more. Minato also has large chakra reserves, he can play defence for as long as he needs to. You didn't even address the shadow clone situation, which is probably minatos safest method for winning this.
 
Last edited:

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
FTG is instant teleportation so if Minato already marks a position especially a long distance one, he can get there faster than Gai would since Gai physically moves. However, within a short point, Minato is definitely not faster as he himself is naturally not faster.

In a 1v1 fight, 8G Gai would blitz him on foot considering his speed. Especially when Ay could pin point every single one of his Kunais in the battlefield and after seeing Minato speed was pretty confident of hitting him when he reappears
 

LuckyMan

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
7,768
Reaction score
464
Don't forget, you can't compare a character who is alive to an Edo character because the Edos are weaker across the board.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Don't forget, you can't compare a character who is alive to an Edo character because the Edos are weaker across the board.

Irrelevant since you can't prove to me his capabilities being alive.

-When he was an Edo, he had BM to physically enhance him. Alive form doesn't have that.

-This is Base Minato and his SM made up everything since they were almost at full power.

Basically EDO Minato>> Alive Minato in every category since he had BM.
 

HNIC

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 24, 2012
Messages
2,503
Reaction score
96
Dunno what the heck you are talking about, Guy starts in 7 gates, thats kind of the matchup of this thread. Nor am I saying guy will attack foolishly, the question is how can he attack when you have a shadow clone using teleporter?

Guy is not transitioning between base and 7 gates. You're ignoring the drawback of it, the side effects of opening the 7th gate are that the user's muscle fibres are ripped to shreds, causing intense pain, especially if anything or anyone touches them.

Guy would be retarded to deactivate 7 gates after opening it. Its all or nothing, if he deactivates it, he's just wasting it. Just opening it causes serious damage. If he turns it off, he'll be feeling the drawbacks almost immediately and that will handicap him against minato. This isn't the 6th gate, Guy can't flick it on and off without worrying too much about the drawbacks. Turning off 7 gates to try and conserve himself won't work, it just makes it harder for him to re enter.

You're the one not thinking now. I'm not ignoring anything, it's just that intel benifits Minato more. Minato also has large chakra reserves, he can play defence for as long as he needs to. You didn't even address the shadow clone situation, which is probably minatos safest method for winning this.

Again, you're exaggerating this exhaustion argument in favor of Minato. Let's not confuse Gai using and transitioning between gates consistently throughout the entire war and eventually becoming exhausted to a FRESH Gai.

After Gai activated 7th Gate and used his most powerful technique against Kisame, he displayed no exhaustion. In fact, he was ready to continue fighting the moment Kisame released himself

Therefore, Gai being able to active and deactivate gates, while being mobile and capable to perform is in fact possible. Of course it's a matter of how frequently he can do this, but as stated, base Gai'a hand strikes counters Minato's attempt to land a direct blow.

The clones aren't much of threat, especially as they'll only disperse from the gates chakra being released. Unless they're there to play backup for ftg purposes, they'll be unless.
 

LuckyMan

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
7,768
Reaction score
464
Irrelevant since you can't prove to me his capabilities being alive.

-When he was an Edo, he had BM to physically enhance him. Alive form doesn't have that.

-This is Base Minato and his SM made up everything since they were almost at full power.

Basically EDO Minato>> Alive Minato in every category since he had BM.

I don't need to prove his capabilities because the clues make it blatantly clear in the Edos; all of them were severely weakened compared to their live counterparts, from Madara all the way to Haku.
 
Top