Search results

it's more that I see it bordering on twtbaw / open wolfing and I don't think that's how alice plays at all.

and i just said i'm not really sold anyway on you being a wolf, fwiw.

my reads nowadays are suited for each person because i know everything is personality related. i don't think i've generalised anything in my case for you and even said why I think you had a wolfy EoD based on my perception of how YOU usually village. whether i'm wrong or not it's a whole...

elmage, my immediate reaction was to town read alice for her EoD posts, but admittedly i know she played in one game and randed scum, idk how much she evolved / how she played it last time, and that could be of use. basically, i felt like her last post was a pretty good observation to make on...

sure, i'm asking why though.

alright, reading back on my post, i see some holes. he wasn't really planning to go over inactives, but he wanted to go for somebody else either way. it's fine though, because i'm not really sold on it being him. but he'll need to say why alice is a wolf.

elmage, why'd you vote for alice?

yeah, agreed. rarely remember elmage tunneling someone for an entire day. off my memory he has a much broader focus as a villager, especially on d1. he has something for each and everyone / has a lot more details to pick on than just to focus on one person for the ~entire day. also, his EoD...

sorry, i tend to think most things should be obvious from other's perspectives as well. but it's just iioa, again. he doesn't really have a read, he's kinda like "yeah you're null". maybe i'm expecting more from him in terms of having a read on me, but i feel like he should have a gth stance...

i read the denmon thing and it doesn't move the needle too much for me. i'm more interested why you voted him early on. iirc you even made a post saying that your votes were serious, so it sounds like you had a reason.

i don't really keep a "reads list" on D1, i have a few leans here and there. it's pretty tough too when people are making 2 posts per day. most of them are =rand. and yeah, i skimmed your post (meaning that I just read your part for me) and still didn't like it a lot, i'll probably keep it on...

sk, can you summarise why you voted for denmon the first time and why you still sat on him from ~page 2? like why is he scum pretty hard to follow your back and forths

also, idk if luk voted correctly (through PM). so it should be tied if everyone else voted correctly.

i can't read denmon's posts in 12 minutes, Elmage. gonna have to be next phase.

gonna be here in like 10 minutes

this whole post reads to me as if you're saying fait is scum but you aren't actually calling him ever a scum for it. and it's a bit iioa-y too. read like a partnery interaction in the sense that you aren't calling him scum for it but you wanna be seen like you are pushing him somehow...

as i said, i'm not saying you two are the team right now. but what made me point that out is because of your luk vs fait post where you seemed to imply fait was scummy for his actions (just because he talked about meta) but you never really made a big point about him being scum off of it...

it’s not really a needle in the hay though, i can’t understand why you’d have that read on Nika based on that one post. what are you even basing it on?

also, i don't think people realised just how hilarious / wolfy the line that i've quoted from rej's post is in a game where he claims he can't read anyone because of low content (among which are people that he's been playing with for YEARS), he gives a take on the one player WITH ONE POST that...

you already quoted it. some sort of reaction to my w/w post. as for your other remark, i guess that's fair and all, but i wasn't making the point of him defending himself, just wondering why he didn't prod into my head for why i had the read, since he didn't have a read on my slot (obviously -...