Forbidden Jutsu but Forbidden by who?

IIB7252

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
1,494
Reaction score
209
This page we have Madara Saying (scolding) Naruto on his use of a forbidden jutsu.

Why does Madara classify it as a forbidden jutsu?

Back in part I we were told the jutsus in that scroll were declared forbidden by the Hokages.

But Madara was never in the village and so how.....

Please share your thoughts...
 

Jordanofthecloud

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Aug 19, 2011
Messages
1,980
Reaction score
182
Madara knows HELLA jutsus. And Shadowclone Jutsu is a forbidden technique.

It's common sense to Madara
 

Ciao

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 11, 2012
Messages
6,568
Reaction score
760

IIB7252

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
1,494
Reaction score
209
Madara knows HELLA jutsus. And Shadowclone Jutsu is a forbidden technique.

It's common sense to Madara

A little bit of recap about Madara:

He grew up and learned the ninja trade in the period before the villages , where there were no Kages just clans duking it out.
He was there when Kohona was founded, without him and his clan Kohona wouldn't have been founded.
He tried to oppose Hashirama on the leadership front and become the first Hokage.
Having failed at that he left the village and has attacked it at least once.
Then he went into a cave and became a bitter old man.

Who was the Hokage who declared KB forbidden?
 

LolaxXx

Banned
Veteran
Joined
Oct 22, 2011
Messages
4,424
Reaction score
273
By the land its from. Shadow clones are pretty OP. Especially if you have high chakra levels.
 

IIB7252

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
1,494
Reaction score
209
By the land its from. Shadow clones are pretty OP. Especially if you have high chakra levels.
Yes true....
Kishi made an error,
Yes dear thats what even I think because...
My guess is Hashirama as Madara was associated with Kohona just at the beginning of his reign.

Madara and Hashirama is complicated but it doesn't sit well with me that Madara would follow Hashi's edict and consider TKB "forbidden" especialyy after all this time.

Was it another Kage?

I sincerely doubt Madara gave a damn any other Kage's edicts, again even if it was Hashirama I don't see Mads taking it lightly that a jutsu was now of limits to him, and how would he know them was he still on the newsletter list?
 

Noobastank

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Feb 28, 2012
Messages
1,364
Reaction score
112
Shadow clones have been forbidden since its introduction. we can assume that shadow clones have been around since before the hidden village system. Shadowclones were probally already known to be a double edged sword back then so when the village system was introduced it was deemed forbidden to low level ninja with low chakra levels who would use the technique un wisely. thats my opinion atleast
 

SpiderRider89

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Nov 9, 2011
Messages
3,037
Reaction score
218
My question is if the edo is forbidden and the shadow clone is forbidden then why wasn't Naruto and Kakashi outcast for using it? Also, why hasn't Sasuke copied that ability yet, he could greatly benefit from it! :cool:
 
Last edited:

frbro82

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
989
Reaction score
54
Hashirama made the scroll of the forbidden justsu.. Hashirama may have used it when he fought Madara
 
Last edited:

Noobastank

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Feb 28, 2012
Messages
1,364
Reaction score
112
Hashirama made the scroll of the forbidden justsu.. Hashirama may have used it when he fought Madara

This may be true aswell. if hashi carried it with him then madara would know about it because someone of madaras level would have alot of intel on his opponent
 

IIB7252

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
1,494
Reaction score
209
Good question lol
Thanks mate...
Shadow clones have been forbidden since its introduction. we can assume that shadow clones have been around since before the hidden village system. Shadowclones were probally already known to be a double edged sword back then so when the village system was introduced it was deemed forbidden to low level ninja with low chakra levels who would use the technique un wisely. thats my opinion atleast

But million dollar question is...
Is the "forbidden" classification older than Kohona and comes from the time Madara himself was still training, thus more open to other's rules, the clan wars period ?

I personally don't see warring clans coming together and reaching a consensus that "these jutsus are just too dangerous and we'll never ever use them" somebody would inevitably disregard the rules to get a edge.

My question is if the edo is forbidden and the shadow clone is forbidden then why wasn't Naruto and Kakashi outcast for using it? Also, why hasn't Sasuke copied that ability yet, he could greatly benefit from it! :cool:
Excatly...+ rep dear...
Hashirama made the scroll of the forbidden justsu.. Hashirama may have used it when he fought Madara
Hmmm..Then how will Madara know...
This may be true aswell. if hashi carried it with him then madara would know about it because someone of madaras level would have alot of intel on his opponent
hmm...
 

LolaxXx

Banned
Veteran
Joined
Oct 22, 2011
Messages
4,424
Reaction score
273
Well, it was forbidden in Madara's era. So maybe thats when it became fobidden. But who created it?

(off topic but Madara must've been really mad when Hashi used 1000 shadowcones, lol)
 

Paintry4

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Aug 1, 2012
Messages
2,768
Reaction score
88
Kagebunshin is not a forbidden jutsu.generally forbidden jutsus are those jutsus which affect the user highly who uses it.like rashenshuriken in normal mode wen hit hand to hand is considered as forbidden coz it affect its user too.
Madara is the person from the past,these all forbidden jutsus were made from the time of so6p.they are not made during konoha regime,so a person having such experiences can tell which jutsu is forbidden or not.edo tensei is a forbidden jutsu coz it needs extense diversion of mind unlike kabuto who mastered it
 

IIB7252

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
1,494
Reaction score
209
Well, it was forbidden in Madara's era. So maybe thats when it became fobidden. But who created it?

(off topic but Madara must've been really mad when Hashi used 1000 shadowcones, lol)
Ya but what made it???
Lol Nice 1...Cant stop laughing....

Kagebunshin is not a forbidden jutsu.generally forbidden jutsus are those jutsus which affect the user highly who uses it.like rashenshuriken in normal mode wen hit hand to hand is considered as forbidden coz it affect its user too.
Madara is the person from the past,these all forbidden jutsus were made from the time of so6p.they are not made during konoha regime,so a person having such experiences can tell which jutsu is forbidden or not.edo tensei is a forbidden jutsu coz it needs extense diversion of mind unlike kabuto who mastered it

Kinjutsu (Literally meaning "Forbidden Techniques") are techniques that have been banned from being taught or used.
This ban could have been put in place for any number of reasons, but kinjutsu can generally be put in either of two categories:

-Techniques that do extreme harm to oneself (e.g. the Multiple Shadow Clone Technique, which will bring almost any user to the brink of death by mere use).
-Techniques that violate the laws of nature (e.g. the Summoning: Impure World Reincarnation, which resurrects the dead with a human sacrifice).

Despite being banned, the use of these techniques generally does not carry any legal consequences in respects to the village they're used in, except those brought on by the techniques themselves. However, their use is heavily frowned upon, especially those techniques that violate nature.
The question is who banned them...
If they were banned at the first place was it banned in full NINJA WORLD???
Than y doesnt the all the village come toghether put a hardcore sentence/punisment like death,etc...
If Justus were banned then why to keep the scroll!!!Isnt it better to destroy the scroll...Does it make sense to save them
 

garas56

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Aug 4, 2012
Messages
2,706
Reaction score
77
This page we have Madara Saying (scolding) Naruto on his use of a forbidden jutsu.

Why does Madara classify it as a forbidden jutsu?

Back in part I we were told the jutsus in that scroll were declared forbidden by the Hokages.

But Madara was never in the village and so how.....

Please share your thoughts...

He fought Hashirama who Known all thous Jutsus And Hashirama Had the scrol with him in that fight so........
All jutsus are created by SO6P
 
Last edited:

Paintry4

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Aug 1, 2012
Messages
2,768
Reaction score
88
Ya but what made it???
Lol Nice 1...Cant stop laughing....



Kinjutsu (Literally meaning "Forbidden Techniques") are techniques that have been banned from being taught or used.
This ban could have been put in place for any number of reasons, but kinjutsu can generally be put in either of two categories:

-Techniques that do extreme harm to oneself (e.g. the Multiple Shadow Clone Technique, which will bring almost any user to the brink of death by mere use).
-Techniques that violate the laws of nature (e.g. the Summoning: Impure World Reincarnation, which resurrects the dead with a human sacrifice).

Despite being banned, the use of these techniques generally does not carry any legal consequences in respects to the village they're used in, except those brought on by the techniques themselves. However, their use is heavily frowned upon, especially those techniques that violate nature.
The question is who banned them...
If they were banned at the first place was it banned in full NINJA WORLD???
Than y doesnt the all the village come toghether put a hardcore sentence/punisment like death,etc...
If Justus were banned then why to keep the scroll!!!Isnt it better to destroy the scroll...Does it make sense to save them

well actually i'm now thinking are you abnormal man? U just told your ans and u askin the same thing again n again...the techniques are forbidden for some reasons..and u know it and who did banned it? It's the same creater of jutsu who ban it after knowing all its side affects.and who write the laws? The user of that jutsu confront to elders like kages for approving it to be forbidden and they made the laws abt them that they are forbidden from now.well after being approved it's used by several shinobi and y aren't they punished! All are punished even oro was going to be punished but he fled away.
 

xnakelx

Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2012
Messages
55
Reaction score
2
shadow clone jutsu isnt forbidden rather Multi shadow clone jutsu is forbidden because of the toll it takes on the user. Just maintaing one shadow clone isnt easy not to talk of 10-100 that is why it is only naruto that is shown to use the technique on such scales as it is only him(and some other people) who can use the technique without feeling side effects
 
Top