Dark Knight Rises Overrated?

HiddenSound

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 27, 2012
Messages
20,009
Kin
-3💸
Kumi
-3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Does Bane have a Mexican accent?
I would have liked to see a realistic Killer Croc, Penguin, or Poison Ivy though. We've already had the Lizard in ASM, but seeing Killer Croc in the Christopher Nolan's Batman world would be awesome. Of course, I don't think Killer Croc would be able to destroy Gotham by himself, so maybe the Penguin or Riddler would be the side antagonists, much like how Two-Face and Scarecrow were. I would like to see the mind-blowing riddles they come up with. As for Poison Ivy, she could destroy the buildings with her plants. Again, I can't see her destroying both Gotham and Batman, so Killer Croc could be another villain.
I would've loved to see Penguin and/or Riddler. I don't really like Killer Croc, not really a fan of brute strength and unintelligent villains.
This is what I loved about Bane. He sounded like a mix between Patrick Stewart and Sean Connery. He sounded extremely intelligent, and he was. He sounded like a professor while being physically stronger than most people in the world. He is Batman's equal imo. He's just f*cking crazy though.
 

SashaUchiha

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
2,229
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Ok... why do we have to Rate/Underrate/Overrate anything???

I saw the movies with my friends, we loved the movie we had a lot of fun...

Dark Knight Rises was an AWESOME movie... I don't care about giving it any stars... come on guys! :shrugs:
 

Riku..

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Nov 24, 2008
Messages
10,427
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I'll just put this all in a spoiler so no one complains about it.

I can agree with saying that it wasn't as good as the Dark Knight, but I can't agree with your statement (in one of those posts) that it wasn't as good as the Avengers at all. The Avengers was EXTREMELY overrated and completely dependent on fight scenes and occasional comedy. My major problem with the Avengers was that Loki really didn't do much of anything in the movie; he was getting slapped around constantly and never really gave off that awesome feel like he did in Thor (in which he was the only outstanding part of that movie to me personally). And I didn't feel like anyone's acting was actually all that intense.

Now as far as this movie, again, I'm not sure if I liked it better than the Dark Knight, but it was truly an amazing movie. Bane's voice in my opinion was perfect and the actor that played him was great. Bane's voice shouldn't have been completely clear anyway, they had to insinuate how drugged up he was while also giving him a booming, commanding voice with an amount of sophistication in it, which is what they did perfectly.

The Talia Al Gul thing had to happen simply because it was part of the comics. That was more of a matter of all of the comic book fans who saw the movie that would be angry about the trilogy ending and them revealing Talia without them showing that she was a villain. As far as her acting... meh, the movie had enough great actors for me to get over that.

The Batman dying thing I can agree with you. Honestly... with that set-up I would have liked if Bruce died, it just kind of killed the moment seeing him return.

But a 5 out of 10!? That's insane. Bane's performance was brilliant, so was Catwoman's. Christian Bale was good (not great, but good), and personally, some people may not agree with me on this, I believe that the guy who played Alfred was great as well. Oh and Morgan Freeman is always awesome of course just because he's Morgan Freeman. :p And I believed that the plot was excellent. And there were so many great scenes. The football scene (Steelers ftw!) Batman's "death," the scene at the bank (when Bruce first returned to being Batman), and of course the airplane scene in the beginning. I personally liked the climb scene mainly because of the prisoners' chant. But 5 out of 10 is such a low rating, you said that it was a good movie and worth paying for, so surely you must mean at least a 7, right? I can even accept that low rating but I can't possibly agree with the Avengers being better than this; I liked the Avengers, but it very over-hyped; nothing about it really stood out aside from the action.

Not being as good as the Dark Knight though, I can agree with only because Heath Ledger was just unbelievably awesome. But in a way I don't really care which one was better; the Dark Knight Rises still had great things in it that the Dark Knight didn't, namely Bane and Catwoman. But I really, really hoped that Riddler would make a cameo somewhere in these movies. Throughout the trilogy the only think that I didn't feel like we got enough of from Batman was his ability as an ingenious detective. I mean we did get it, but I didn't feel like it was ever really emphasized.
 

Riku..

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Nov 24, 2008
Messages
10,427
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Why? For the benefit of others? If you just went with the movie without looking out for places to give/take points wouldn't it have been more fun? I don't get this... :|
I don't think that anyone really goes to theaters wanting to take points away from a movie (at least I don't), just kinda happens when you reflect on a movie after you watch it as opposed to watching it and never thinking about it again lol. And why not? Discussing a movie is a good way to have a nice conversation.
 

HiddenSound

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 27, 2012
Messages
20,009
Kin
-3💸
Kumi
-3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I'll just put this all in a spoiler so no one complains about it.

I can agree with saying that it wasn't as good as the Dark Knight, but I can't agree with your statement (in one of those posts) that it wasn't as good as the Avengers at all. The Avengers was EXTREMELY overrated and completely dependent on fight scenes and occasional comedy. My major problem with the Avengers was that Loki really didn't do much of anything in the movie; he was getting slapped around constantly and never really gave off that awesome feel like he did in Thor (in which he was the only outstanding part of that movie to me personally). And I didn't feel like anyone's acting was actually all that intense.

Now as far as this movie, again, I'm not sure if I liked it better than the Dark Knight, but it was truly an amazing movie. Bane's voice in my opinion was perfect and the actor that played him was great. Bane's voice shouldn't have been completely clear anyway, they had to insinuate how drugged up he was while also giving him a booming, commanding voice with an amount of sophistication in it, which is what they did perfectly.

The Talia Al Gul thing had to happen simply because it was part of the comics. That was more of a matter of all of the comic book fans who saw the movie that would be angry about the trilogy ending and them revealing Talia without them showing that she was a villain. As far as her acting... meh, the movie had enough great actors for me to get over that.

The Batman dying thing I can agree with you. Honestly... with that set-up I would have liked if Bruce died, it just kind of killed the moment seeing him return.

But a 5 out of 10!? That's insane. Bane's performance was brilliant, so was Catwoman's. Christian Bale was good (not great, but good), and personally, some people may not agree with me on this, I believe that the guy who played Alfred was great as well. Oh and Morgan Freeman is always awesome of course just because he's Morgan Freeman. :p And I believed that the plot was excellent. And there were so many great scenes. The football scene (Steelers ftw!) Batman's "death," the scene at the bank (when Bruce first returned to being Batman), and of course the airplane scene in the beginning. I personally liked the climb scene mainly because of the prisoners' chant. But 5 out of 10 is such a low rating, you said that it was a good movie and worth paying for, so surely you must mean at least a 7, right? I can even accept that low rating but I can't possibly agree with the Avengers being better than this; I liked the Avengers, but it very over-hyped; nothing about it really stood out aside from the action.

Not being as good as the Dark Knight though, I can agree with only because Heath Ledger was just unbelievably awesome. But in a way I don't really care which one was better; the Dark Knight Rises still had great things in it that the Dark Knight didn't, namely Bane and Catwoman. But I really, really hoped that Riddler would make a cameo somewhere in these movies. Throughout the trilogy the only think that I didn't feel like we got enough of from Batman was his ability as an ingenious detective. I mean we did get it, but I didn't feel like it was ever really emphasized.
Hmm... I agree with most of that actually, even my rating of it. Maybe I did rate it too low, a 7 sounds good. However I still believe it is overrated.

We completely agree on Bane and n the foot ball scene. That part was my favorite. The kid finishing his song, "Let the games begin.", and the events that shortly followed. Especially when Bane killed Dr. Pavel. "Who can deactivate this bomb?" "Only me." "Only you. . ." *snap*. Purely epic.
Bane's voice was just wonderful. Just. Wonderful. But I don't agree on the impression that we should understand he was really drugged because of his voice. I missed some possibly important dialogue. Like when he killed Taggart, I had no idea what was going on.

However, I, obviously, don't agree with the Avengers and Catwoman. I was never, ever interested in her and the kiss scene was rushed. And I just loved the Avengers, I really liked the blend of comedy and action. But yeah, my only complaint with that was Loki got messed up too many times.
 
Last edited:

SashaUchiha

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
2,229
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I don't think that anyone really goes to theaters wanting to take points away from a movie (at least I don't), just kinda happens when you reflect on a movie after you watch it as opposed to watching it and never thinking about it again lol. And why not? Discussing a movie is a good way to have a nice conversation.
hmmm... I guess you're right... but when we discuss it it's more about what we liked and didn't like... I still wouldn't rate it... I guess it's just different for everyone...

Hmm... I agree with most of that actually, even my rating of it. Maybe I did rate it too low, a 7 sounds good. However I still believe it is overrated.

We completely agree on Bane and n the foot ball scene. That part was my favorite. The kid finishing his song, "Let the games begin.", and the events that shortly followed. Especially when Bane killed Dr. Pavel. "Who can deactivate this bomb?" "Only me." "Only you. . ." *snap*. Purely epic.
Bane's voice was just wonderful. Just. Wonderful. But I don't agree on the impression that we should understand he was really drugged because of his voice. I missed some possibly important dialogue. Like when he killed Taggart, I had no idea what was going on.

However, I, obviously, don't agree with the Avengers and Catwoman. I was never, ever interested in her and the kiss scene was rushed. And I just loved the Avengers, I really liked the blend of comedy and action. But yeah, my only complaint with that was Loki got messed up too many times.
:y that was awesome!
 
Last edited:

Riku..

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Nov 24, 2008
Messages
10,427
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Hmm... I agree with most of that, even my rating of it. Maybe I did rate it too low, a 7 sounds good. However I still believe it is overrated.

We completely agree on Bane and n the foot ball scene. That part was my favorite. The kid finishing his song, "Let the games begin.", and the events that shortly followed. Especially when Bane killed Dr. Pavel. "Who can deactivate this bomb?" "Only me." "Only you. . ." *snap*. Purely epic.
Bane's voice was just wonderful. Just. Wonderful. But I don't agree on the impression that we should understand he was really drugged because of his voice. I missed some possibly important dialogue. Like when he killed Taggart, I had no idea what was going on.

However, I, obviously, don't agree with the Avengers and Catwoman. I was never, ever interested in her and the kiss scene was rushed. And I just loved the Avengers, I really liked the blend of comedy and action. But yeah, my only complaint with that was Loki got messed up too many times.
I really didn't have much trouble understanding Bane's voice to be honest. It was distorted of course, but as you said, it was a great voice to give him. But I really never had any moments where I really couldn't understand him. There was the occasional moment where I'd miss a word or two but that was usually because of someone else in the theater talking.

The kiss scene isn't what I was talking about with my point on Catwoman. The kiss scene was unimportant to me really, as was her marrying Bruce. The moments that she impressed me were scenes like the one in the bar and in the airport when she was taken for a short interrogation. And of course the ballroom scene. It was a short one, but I liked it.

As for the Avengers. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the movie and had a lot of fun seeing it, but when I heard about it from my friends before watching I was expecting awesome villains (yeah that was the other thing, the fact that there was only one named villain was a bit of a let down to), intense scenes, and amazing action scenes. When really I only saw the amazing action scenes. The comedy was good and there were plenty of laughable moments, but it took away from how intense the movie could have been. The entire Christopher Nolan Batman trilogy was just one incredibly intense movie after another. And the villains were consistently great and always took the movie to the next level (Scarecrow, Ra's, Joker, Bane--all great performances with Joker a cut, or a few cuts, above the rest). Both of which (intense scenes and awesome villains) I didn't really get in the Avengers, even when everything was blowing up the movie still felt lighthearted, probably because of all of the comedy. And of course it was always predictable. But that's just me, and I can certainly see why people liked it, I had fun watching it myself. But I don't thin that we'll be seeing eye-to-eye on this and I'd hate to ruin your view of the movie with all of my pessimistic views on it so I'll leave it at that. :p

Oh, and the one thing that I forgot to say, as always, Hans Zimmer made an awesome score.
 

HiddenSound

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 27, 2012
Messages
20,009
Kin
-3💸
Kumi
-3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
:y that was awesome!
Hehe, ikr

I really didn't have much trouble understanding Bane's voice to be honest. It was distorted of course, but as you said, it was a great voice to give him. But I really never had any moments where I really couldn't understand him. There was the occasional moment where I'd miss a word or two but that was usually because of someone else in the theater talking.

The kiss scene isn't what I was talking about with my point on Catwoman. The kiss scene was unimportant to me really, as was her marrying Bruce. The moments that she impressed me were scenes like the one in the bar and in the airport when she was taken for a short interrogation. And of course the ballroom scene. It was a short one, but I liked it.

As for the Avengers. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the movie and had a lot of fun seeing it, but when I heard about it from my friends before watching I was expecting awesome villains (yeah that was the other thing, the fact that there was only one named villain was a bit of a let down to), intense scenes, and amazing action scenes. When really I only saw the amazing action scenes. The comedy was good and there were plenty of laughable moments, but it took away from how intense the movie could have been. The entire Christopher Nolan Batman trilogy was just one incredibly intense movie after another. And the villains were consistently great and always took the movie to the next level (Scarecrow, Ra's, Joker, Bane--all great performances with Joker a cut, or a few cuts, above the rest). Both of which (intense scenes and awesome villains) I didn't really get in the Avengers, even when everything was blowing up the movie still felt lighthearted, probably because of all of the comedy. And of course it was always predictable. But that's just me, and I can certainly see why people liked it, I had fun watching it myself. But I don't thin that we'll be seeing eye-to-eye on this and I'd hate to ruin your view of the movie with all of my pessimistic views on it so I'll leave it at that. :p

Oh, and the one thing that I forgot to say, as always, Hans Zimmer made an awesome score.
Yes, Hans Zimmer is just so, so good. He was the one who conducted/created Pirates of the Caribbean's music, if I'm not mistaken.
But yeah, I can totally understand where you're coming from and I can see why you liked it so much. Thanks for not flaming me like others lol.
 
Last edited:

Riku..

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Nov 24, 2008
Messages
10,427
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Hehe, ikr



Yes, Hans Zimmer is just so, so good. He was the one who conducted/created Pirates of the Caribbean's music, if I'm not mistaken.
I don't think that he did all of them but I do believe that he did the first one, including that main theme that everyone instantly recognizes. He's conducted plenty of things, all of them great (at least as far as the soundtrack). This entire trilogy (maybe not Batman Begins, not sure), Lion King, Inception, the list goes on for that guy. Truly a genius.
 

NLee

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 27, 2010
Messages
7,056
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It was a fine movie I suppose. But I strongly disliked how Bane turned out to be a tool in the last 10-15 minutes and especially how he gets killed. Screw Talia, Bane was the main antagonist. He deserved a worth death and defeat at the hands of Batman. Not from Selina on Batman's bike -_-
 

Rookie27

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2012
Messages
14
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I signed up to this forum just to reply to you.

You're not the only one who feels the Dark Knight is overrated.

First off, there too many plot holes/unbelievable moments in this movie. (I wanted to link you to IGN where they list TDKR's plot holes, but I can't cause I don't have 10 posts yet) The realism Nolan so tediously built in the previous 2 films just goes downhill here. I had a really tough time suspending belief.

But let's say you could suspend belief, this film still suffers a lot of the same things Spider-Man 3 suffered. Mainly, they chewed off more than they could swallow. The problem - everything had to be BIGGER.

The things that bugged me the most were:

1) How did Bruce magically go from frail middle-aged man to kicking Bane's ass? At first I thought the X-Rays the doctor had were fake. That Bruce was just pretending to be a cripple to avoid suspicion. But no, turns out he really has no cartilage left in his joints. So how does he do all those push ups to beat Bane? Magic. And how did that leg brace he used fit into his tight suit? Why didn't Bane take it off when he captured Bruce? And to think he was shocked to see Batman return. IMPOSSIBLE!

2) Blake just walks up to Bruce's door and says, "Look, I know you're the Batman." WTF? Some people are defending this by saying he saw himself in Bruce. That means he had a guess, he called Bruce's bluff and Bruce didn't do anything to deny it. Wtf?

3) And I'm supposed to belief Bruce runs away to Paris with a girl he just met for a few days? There was an 8 year gap between TDK and TDKR, couldn't they have used that time to explain Bruce and Selina's romance? Maybe Bruce is desperate, and I know Selina is attracted to him, but she loves him? Really? And Mirinda Tate loves Bruce without even meeting him. Isn't that suspicious? World's greatest detective, loses all foresight at pretty women.

4) Bane's quest is hypocritical. In Batman Begins, Ra's Al Ghul wanted to destroy Gotham because it was shit. Bane however, needs to play mind games with the citizens of Gotham to destroy them psychologically before destroying the city for good. That sort of tells you that Batman did sort of save Gotham. Exacting Ra's Al Ghul's wish? Bullshit, it's just revenge.

5) Bane turns into a puppy at the end. Oh God... *facepalm. And he gets epicly friendzoned. Don't believe me? Would you not rage if your one true love calls you 'friend'? And she ****ed Bruce. But no ***** for you Bane.

6) Too many Hollywood cliches. i) Faceless people of different race? A plague? Come on. If it was a real prison, they would've raped Talia and her mom. But I guess this is a PG movie. ii) The old defuse the time bomb really really quick. Yeah, I can't even brush my teeth in less than 10 minutes when I wake up. But of course, he's the Batman. He can save Gotham, buy groceries, **** your mom, and be back for JLA on Cartoon Network all in 10 minutes. iii) And I think Bruce should have died for good. It would've felt better. A hero's sacrifice. But nope, can't have that. Not in Hollywood. iv) And why does Batman's weapons turn useless in the hands of the enemy? They could've easily shot down the Bat. It has a huge exposed rotor. Another Hollywood cliche.

There are many other things I find fault with in this movie. But overall I think, this doesn't feel like a Nolan film at all. I used to praise him like a God. I thought he was different. But he didn't "inceptioned" us this time. He used Hollywood cliches, he played with themes too big for him to handle and he recycled plots and themes from the previous two films. For all it's praise, many critics agree TDKR is the weakest in the trilogy. And that's saying something. Personally, I think all his other movies are either better or on par with Batman Begins. So when you say TDKR is the weakest of the trilogy, it might just be Nolan's first bad film.

(God, it's like seeing Federer lose his No 1 spot after.... what? 2 years being No 1?)

The irony of it all is, most of the people calling TDKR the best movie ever, either has not seen TDK (and Batman Begins), or doesn't know how to appreciate TDK. They're just buying into the hype. They can't have a superhero movie without big explosions. They can't have a superhero movie where the hero works in the shadows, being the Dark Knight. (Don't you think Batman is a little out of place fighting a war? It's like Qui-Gon telling Queen Amidala, "We can protect you, but we can't fight a war for you.")

Ironically, they are like the citizens of Gotham, they can't go on without a lie (Dent Act).
 

Rookie27

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2012
Messages
14
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The Dark Knight Rises currently has a slightly better rating than TDK on IMDB. Because of that, TDKR is automatically on IMDB's list of Top 250 films of all time (#9). Unbelievable.
 

HiddenSound

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 27, 2012
Messages
20,009
Kin
-3💸
Kumi
-3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It was a fine movie I suppose. But I strongly disliked how Bane turned out to be a tool in the last 10-15 minutes and especially how he gets killed. Screw Talia, Bane was the main antagonist. He deserved a worth death and defeat at the hands of Batman. Not from Selina on Batman's bike -_-
I KNOW U_U
I signed up to this forum just to reply to you.
You're not the only one who feels the Dark Knight is overrated.

First off, there too many plot holes/unbelievable moments in this movie. (I wanted to link you to IGN where they list TDKR's plot holes, but I can't cause I don't have 10 posts yet) The realism Nolan so tediously built in the previous 2 films just goes downhill here. I had a really tough time suspending belief.

But let's say you could suspend belief, this film still suffers a lot of the same things Spider-Man 3 suffered. Mainly, they chewed off more than they could swallow. The problem - everything had to be BIGGER.

The things that bugged me the most were:

1) How did Bruce magically go from frail middle-aged man to kicking Bane's ass? At first I thought the X-Rays the doctor had were fake. That Bruce was just pretending to be a cripple to avoid suspicion. But no, turns out he really has no cartilage left in his joints. So how does he do all those push ups to beat Bane? Magic. And how did that leg brace he used fit into his tight suit? Why didn't Bane take it off when he captured Bruce? And to think he was shocked to see Batman return. IMPOSSIBLE!

2) Blake just walks up to Bruce's door and says, "Look, I know you're the Batman." WTF? Some people are defending this by saying he saw himself in Bruce. That means he had a guess, he called Bruce's bluff and Bruce didn't do anything to deny it. Wtf?

3) And I'm supposed to belief Bruce runs away to Paris with a girl he just met for a few days? There was an 8 year gap between TDK and TDKR, couldn't they have used that time to explain Bruce and Selina's romance? Maybe Bruce is desperate, and I know Selina is attracted to him, but she loves him? Really? And Mirinda Tate loves Bruce without even meeting him. Isn't that suspicious? World's greatest detective, loses all foresight at pretty women.

4) Bane's quest is hypocritical. In Batman Begins, Ra's Al Ghul wanted to destroy Gotham because it was shit. Bane however, needs to play mind games with the citizens of Gotham to destroy them psychologically before destroying the city for good. That sort of tells you that Batman did sort of save Gotham. Exacting Ra's Al Ghul's wish? Bullshit, it's just revenge.

5) Bane turns into a puppy at the end. Oh God... *facepalm. And he gets epicly friendzoned. Don't believe me? Would you not rage if your one true love calls you 'friend'? And she ****ed Bruce. But no ***** for you Bane.

6) Too many Hollywood cliches. i) Faceless people of different race? A plague? Come on. If it was a real prison, they would've raped Talia and her mom. But I guess this is a PG movie. ii) The old defuse the time bomb really really quick. Yeah, I can't even brush my teeth in less than 10 minutes when I wake up. But of course, he's the Batman. He can save Gotham, buy groceries, **** your mom, and be back for JLA on Cartoon Network all in 10 minutes. iii) And I think Bruce should have died for good. It would've felt better. A hero's sacrifice. But nope, can't have that. Not in Hollywood. iv) And why does Batman's weapons turn useless in the hands of the enemy? They could've easily shot down the Bat. It has a huge exposed rotor. Another Hollywood cliche.

There are many other things I find fault with in this movie. But overall I think, this doesn't feel like a Nolan film at all. I used to praise him like a God. I thought he was different. But he didn't "inceptioned" us this time. He used Hollywood cliches, he played with themes too big for him to handle and he recycled plots and themes from the previous two films. For all it's praise, many critics agree TDKR is the weakest in the trilogy. And that's saying something. Personally, I think all his other movies are either better or on par with Batman Begins. So when you say TDKR is the weakest of the trilogy, it might just be Nolan's first bad film.

(God, it's like seeing Federer lose his No 1 spot after.... what? 2 years being No 1?)

The irony of it all is, most of the people calling TDKR the best movie ever, either has not seen TDK (and Batman Begins), or doesn't know how to appreciate TDK. They're just buying into the hype. They can't have a superhero movie without big explosions. They can't have a superhero movie where the hero works in the shadows, being the Dark Knight. (Don't you think Batman is a little out of place fighting a war? It's like Qui-Gon telling Queen Amidala, "We can protect you, but we can't fight a war for you.")

Ironically, they are like the citizens of Gotham, they can't go on without a lie (Dent Act).
The Dark Knight Rises currently has a slightly better rating than TDK on IMDB. Because of that, TDKR is automatically on IMDB's list of Top 250 films of all time (#9). Unbelievable.
I agree with you to a certain extent. I agree with 1, 2, 3, and 5, I was okay with the other points. I enjoyed it, but it being over Dark Knight is just wrong. Dark Knight really was one of the best movies I've ever seen.
 

NLee

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 27, 2010
Messages
7,056
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I signed up to this forum just to reply to you.

You're not the only one who feels the Dark Knight is overrated.

First off, there too many plot holes/unbelievable moments in this movie. (I wanted to link you to IGN where they list TDKR's plot holes, but I can't cause I don't have 10 posts yet) The realism Nolan so tediously built in the previous 2 films just goes downhill here. I had a really tough time suspending belief.

But let's say you could suspend belief, this film still suffers a lot of the same things Spider-Man 3 suffered. Mainly, they chewed off more than they could swallow. The problem - everything had to be BIGGER.

The things that bugged me the most were:

1) How did Bruce magically go from frail middle-aged man to kicking Bane's ass? At first I thought the X-Rays the doctor had were fake. That Bruce was just pretending to be a cripple to avoid suspicion. But no, turns out he really has no cartilage left in his joints. So how does he do all those push ups to beat Bane? Magic. And how did that leg brace he used fit into his tight suit? Why didn't Bane take it off when he captured Bruce? And to think he was shocked to see Batman return. IMPOSSIBLE!

2) Blake just walks up to Bruce's door and says, "Look, I know you're the Batman." WTF? Some people are defending this by saying he saw himself in Bruce. That means he had a guess, he called Bruce's bluff and Bruce didn't do anything to deny it. Wtf?

3) And I'm supposed to belief Bruce runs away to Paris with a girl he just met for a few days? There was an 8 year gap between TDK and TDKR, couldn't they have used that time to explain Bruce and Selina's romance? Maybe Bruce is desperate, and I know Selina is attracted to him, but she loves him? Really? And Mirinda Tate loves Bruce without even meeting him. Isn't that suspicious? World's greatest detective, loses all foresight at pretty women.

4) Bane's quest is hypocritical. In Batman Begins, Ra's Al Ghul wanted to destroy Gotham because it was shit. Bane however, needs to play mind games with the citizens of Gotham to destroy them psychologically before destroying the city for good. That sort of tells you that Batman did sort of save Gotham. Exacting Ra's Al Ghul's wish? Bullshit, it's just revenge.

5) Bane turns into a puppy at the end. Oh God... *facepalm. And he gets epicly friendzoned. Don't believe me? Would you not rage if your one true love calls you 'friend'? And she ****ed Bruce. But no ***** for you Bane.

6) Too many Hollywood cliches. i) Faceless people of different race? A plague? Come on. If it was a real prison, they would've raped Talia and her mom. But I guess this is a PG movie. ii) The old defuse the time bomb really really quick. Yeah, I can't even brush my teeth in less than 10 minutes when I wake up. But of course, he's the Batman. He can save Gotham, buy groceries, **** your mom, and be back for JLA on Cartoon Network all in 10 minutes. iii) And I think Bruce should have died for good. It would've felt better. A hero's sacrifice. But nope, can't have that. Not in Hollywood. iv) And why does Batman's weapons turn useless in the hands of the enemy? They could've easily shot down the Bat. It has a huge exposed rotor. Another Hollywood cliche.

There are many other things I find fault with in this movie. But overall I think, this doesn't feel like a Nolan film at all. I used to praise him like a God. I thought he was different. But he didn't "inceptioned" us this time. He used Hollywood cliches, he played with themes too big for him to handle and he recycled plots and themes from the previous two films. For all it's praise, many critics agree TDKR is the weakest in the trilogy. And that's saying something. Personally, I think all his other movies are either better or on par with Batman Begins. So when you say TDKR is the weakest of the trilogy, it might just be Nolan's first bad film.

(God, it's like seeing Federer lose his No 1 spot after.... what? 2 years being No 1?)

The irony of it all is, most of the people calling TDKR the best movie ever, either has not seen TDK (and Batman Begins), or doesn't know how to appreciate TDK. They're just buying into the hype. They can't have a superhero movie without big explosions. They can't have a superhero movie where the hero works in the shadows, being the Dark Knight. (Don't you think Batman is a little out of place fighting a war? It's like Qui-Gon telling Queen Amidala, "We can protect you, but we can't fight a war for you.")

Ironically, they are like the citizens of Gotham, they can't go on without a lie (Dent Act).
My fcuking god. THANK YOU for giving this film the critique it deserves. I can't agree with you more.
 

Rookie27

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2012
Messages
14
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I really wanted to like this movie, but with the hype and everything, people saying it's way better (than it should be), just couldn't stand it man. Ridiculous.
 

Hexuze

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
20,359
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Just a quick questions guys please reply to those who watched it.

Do you have to watch any of the previous batman movies to watch it?
 
Top