Does ITACHI deserve a brother like SASUKE?

[Thegreatflash]

Well he obviously is. Tell me who's possibly smarter than him? Itachi is smart all around.
Tobi- Uchiha/sharingan/bijuu intelligence
Kabuto- Ninjutsu/medical-related intelligence
Shikamaru- Tactics
Kakashi- Tactics
Orochimaru- Ninjutsu intelligence
Minato- Tactics and developing jutsus
Itachi- Planning the future, tactics, jutsus, solving mysteries, philosophy etc

Itachi
Planning the future- True (and admittedly some pretty darn impressive fore-sight for a 13 year old)
Tactics - most def
Jutsu - lol, i'm guessing you mean mostly genjutsu with this, then yea Solving mysteries - I think this falls under tactics

Minato
Tactics - Yea ( pretty high level too )
Planning and fore-sight - (He gets this also, due to naruto)
Invented a jutsu - That's true
Jutsu - yea (i mean, he did learn all the uzumaki seals, so he gets that too)

x factors for both

Minato : while we have seen itachi in action since part one, and have wayyy more quotes and examples of his skill's abilities, and battle prowls you could say that we only saw minato fight seriously once, one "play-fight" and a few foderizations, were-as itachi has had far more screen-time comparatively.

Itachi : What's pretty crazy about itachi is that.... he was 13 when he killed his clan, around 20 at his oldest, and that's a major factor. I mean, were comparing a full grown man (we saw minato mostly as a man) v.s someone who, for a large portion of the series, was just a teen. Not to mention he was terminally il as well

Conclusion : tbh idk for sure, i mean, i'm a huge minato fan, but minato v.s. itachi is just a really close bout in most cases. We have barely seen any of minato's arsenal, and itachi, died really young and sick.

But i would assume minato was smarter just by a hair, and largely because i am a fan of his, i will concede though, that if itachi had lived to minato's ago he would likley be smarter ( more intelligent)

 

[Hipster Madara]

Guys, stop wanking Itachi for a moment and be open minded. He is telling the truth of the matter, if you think about it. I think Itachi was a great brother nonetheless, but what he said is kinda true.
Itachi did a lot of mistakes with Sasuke, he even admitted it, so why can't you guys just accept it?

 

[Wolfang714]

I personally think that Sasuke needs to get his ass whooped, he doesn't deserve a brother like Itachi. But I think Itachi would say differently. I think Itachi would say he doesn't deserve a brother like Sasuke.

 

[Tartarus]

Guys, stop wanking Itachi for a moment and be open minded. He is telling the truth of the matter, if you think about it. I think Itachi was a great brother nonetheless, but what he said is kinda true.
Itachi did a lot of mistakes with Sasuke, he even admitted it, so why can't you guys just accept it?

exactly, even Itachi admits he made of alot of bad mistakes. Fanboys won't even listen to Itachi himself.

 

[Ryuu..]

Lol this is a serious thread.

 

[Prince of Persia TTT]

Sasuke def needs a brother like Itachi bcoz he is the one who can spank sasukes ass
but Itachi def dont deserve an emo like Sasuke

 

[Redd]

So you guys think Itachi is the good bro after all this???

You must be registered for see images

First I will kill your family and make it your life goal to hate and kill me. Then I will come back and Genjutsu you to watch it over and over again. Thats right after I beat you to a bloody pulp.

Then I will neglect to tell you the truth even when I come back into the after life until you beg the crap outta me.

This is what Itachi pretty much did

You must be registered for see images

Then at the end.

You must be registered for see images

What I would do

You must be registered for see images

xd You get Reps for that man.

 

[MacMiller]

Nope.

 

[Redd]

Oh yeah it Itachi is so smart that he also know about the curse of hatred. Just throwing that out there.

Guys, stop wanking Itachi for a moment and be open minded. He is telling the truth of the matter, if you think about it. I think Itachi was a great brother nonetheless, but what he said is kinda true.
Itachi did a lot of mistakes with Sasuke, he even admitted it, so why can't you guys just accept it?

This +Rep

 

[TheItachiUchiha]

Thats a joke right, other way around.

 

[theoneturk]

Wow lame threat.. Itachi chose to murder his clan, even his parrents, to make sure Sasuke would stay safe.. And when Itachi & Sasuke clashed in the Uchiha hideout itachi deugged himself so he would die against Sasuke and show him as the savior of the Uchihas. And no matter how strong Sasuke became, Itachi always saw him as someone he needed to protect wich is a good thing.. "Do Sasuke deserve better than itachi?) answer to that is: Impossible, he already had the best :')

 

[theoneturk]

Drugged'

 

[Dubbuoo]

Itachi is responsible for Sasuke's pain. He should've killed Sasuke when he had the chance on the night of the massacre. At least then Sasuke would be at peace. But Itachi's selfishness got in the way if you ask me. This begs the question; does Sasuke deserve BETTER than Itachi? I'd say so.

oh so is saving konoha and continuing to untill death, possibly preventing a war, saving his stupid ass brothers life( who needs to be dead!!), allowing sasuke to unlock mangekyo sharingan and stopping edo tensei for naruto to take the weight off his shoulders. yup Itachi is selfish:flaw:

 

[immortal sage]

itachi is to good for saskue and your dumb you say by killing saskue he would be a better brother

 

[Stark]

Ask Kishi

 

[shogun973]

Itachi is responsible for Sasuke's pain. He should've killed Sasuke when he had the chance on the night of the massacre. At least then Sasuke would be at peace. But Itachi's selfishness got in the way if you ask me. This begs the question; does Sasuke deserve BETTER than Itachi? I'd say so.

tachi should have told the uchiha what danzo was planning had some of them kill friends to get MS and take over the government by killing the elders and hokage by surprise. With all those MS users intruders wouldn't have had a chance imagine 50 amateretsu's lol

 

[HiddenSound]

Itachi deserves a better brother than Sasuke. He gave up his family for peace and the village, and Sasuke is there only to screw up his wishes.

 

[Champ]

Nop Itachi ruined Sasuke's life

 

[Vendaku]

seriously this is crazy. what itachi did didn't just effect sasuke. It effected everyone. If sasuke wasn't such a screwed up kid trying so hard to avenge his family. Who would be Naruto's rival. Who would kick his butt and make him want to be better and better. Naruto would have remained the way he was. Jiraya wouldn't of taken notice of a Naruto that didn't try so hard. Naruto would have become a weakling jinchuriki and tobi would of taken the 9 tails long ago. What Itachi did was one of the most pivotal things in the series. like TheoneTurk said Itachi saved Sasuke. He made sure his brother survived and got stronger and eventually he died by his brothers hand. In the end the only reason Allied Shinobi Forces are winning is because of Itachi. He is a key piece and player in the story. Without him doing what he did all would be lost.

 

[Mercury Uzumaki]

Itachi's actions created Sasuke's personality.So I think he does.Maybe before then end of the anime we will see Sasuke be more forgiving(hopefully).