Well Kishi is making easier to figure out who Tobi is not

[The God of Wind]

Wow just WoW!

 

[UKCmasterkeybladeninja]

You can say that but if you read my post on page 9 you would see that the time frames don't make sense for it to be Obito plus awakening MS the same day you awaken Sharingan is just ridonculous don't you need 3 tomeo sharingan to get there anyway?

Tobi is using time and space with 3 tomeo so maybe and doesnt it happen in times of danger the third kicked in. lol this is far fetched dont take me srsly with this one though loll remember 2 tomeo can copy jutsus lol what if obito saw minato do FTG lvl 1 and it just happened like that lol

 

[lilshell43]

I still believe it's Uchiha Kagami. It makes sense that it would be him.

 

[jdilla]

Tobi is using time and space with 3 tomeo so maybe and doesnt it happen in times of danger the third kicked in. lol this is far fetched dont take me srsly with this one though loll remember 2 tomeo can copy jutsus lol what if obito saw minato do FTG lvl 1 and it just happened like that lol

Jiraiya meets Nagato with rinnegan during the 2nd world war and obito dies as a child during the 3rd we know that Tobi gave Nagato the rinnegan so how would Obito do this even though it's highly likely that he was born after the 2nd world war?

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

Ok I left this thread for abit but I have returned Tobi can be obito!

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

"Here's my theory obito's near death experience enabled him to unlock his ability to become intangible and pass through solid objects and barely makes it out alive from the underground cave with the right side of his body half crushed. Right after this he encountered Zetsu who meets this young boy with special eye powers and saves him. (also zetsu could of saved this boy, or he could of used space time, but I think turning intangible is more likely)

I belive Zetsu is some sort of creation by madara “The way I see it is that, when madara was dying he activated the rinnegan, and let’s zetsu take the rinnengan from him, along with the harashima cells, and also some of madara's own DNA. He then tells zetsu implant all of these things into a piece of zetsu body, like a big enough chunk to make a body, hence developing a second madara. That had all his memories (or possibly he could of extracted his entire brain?) and shit.

And later infused this body with obito who he found because he needed the body of an uchiha and this was he’s perfect chance because the uchiha’s were all still alive and he didn’t want to engage into combat.
Now what if zetsu before meeting obito implanted the rinnegan into an uzumaki child (nagato). So he could get the Sage Body |Sage Eyes sort of thing in order to study it abilities and then later when this uzumaki child was powerful enough revive madara in his prime.

But as this uzumaki got older and stronger zetsu knows he wouldn’t be able to guide and control this child anymore, which is why he needed an uchiha body to put madara’s dna, memories and harashima cells into. Which he later did when he lucky found this defenceless boy with special eye power.. Obito."

My theory

 

[MickNerks]

So ya Kishi is slowly eliminating them so far we know its not izuna madara shusui madara fugaku anyone who isn't an uchiha

now lets see which uchihas would have a reason not to like the clan um i really don't know I would say Obito but why wouldn't he like the village and be dumb enough to fight is killer sensei oh well what do you think he could be now that its narrowed down

He didnt eliminate Izuna.. Izuna is one of the most obvious choices of who he could be and this chp 590 just proves it.. Izuna would be mad at Uchiha clan because what they did to madara and mad at senju same reason as madara.. Tobi is theone who says izuna is dead, but if he wanted to keep his identity a secret it would make since for him to say that.

Did you see my picture? ''After my brother died'' - That means he is dead, why would he lie? Make no sense again

Hes not lying.. What if izuna did die and madara brought him back to life...

 

[synkross]

ok this is very interesting ....but all the possible contenders for Tobi have some flaws.

1)Obito/Tobi Theory:

well this is very old and believe me no matter how hard you try, the time line just doesn't add up...no motive....no nothing.

2)Izuna/Tobi Theory:

again a very popular theory but no....in the in ch:577 Madara was kinda grieving Izuna's death .....and i don't think he is lieing here....Naruto/577/7

so he really is dead.

3)Elder Son/Tobi Theory:

Elder Son would be too OP....and wouldn't require any team(Akatsuki) to accomplish his plan....and i don't think he could live so long (considering ...no Zetsu technology at that time lolz)....as zetsu is made of hasi and madara's cells.

4)Future Sasuke/Tobi Theory:

i'm simply amazed by the sh*t ppl can pull out of their a**es. End of Story

5)Advanced Zetsu Madara clone/Tobi Theory:

highly unlikely....cuz it would just ruin his character if the main villain turns out to be an experiment moreover Tobi is far more ambitious to turn out to be just a clone lolz.

6)Kagami/Tobi Theory:

As much as i lean towards this one, it still has flaws...ok now ppl claim that kagami could be tobi cuz the 2nd hokage created space/time jutsu and kagami might have mastered it and so on...but they seem to forget that 2nd hokage was also the one to create Edo Tensei , of which Tobi seemed to have very little knowledge of since he asked kabuto to tell him how the technique works. Naruto/520/9
If tobi was kagami then for sure he would've known about it(i can't imagine him letting such high technique slip right through his jaws)...hell even naruto knows kakashi's raikari is a lightening style attack.
so i don't think so....

anyways this is just what i observed and i can be wrong but i just thought i'd say it anyways xd .

(Note:i'm unable to link cuz of my post count but i have given ch and page numbers)

 

[jdilla]

Yes the Izuna and Kagami theories all make a lot more sense than the Obito ones. Personally I think it would be sweet if he was Izuna and as I said before it's one of the more likely options I would just be sad if it was Obito his speech in Kakashi gaiden is prbs still my favourite out of everyone's and it would break my heart if he went back on his word like that.

 

[nataku]

"Here's my theory obito's near death experience enabled him to unlock his ability to become intangible and pass through solid objects and barely makes it out alive from the underground cave with the right side of his body half crushed. Right after this he encountered Zetsu who meets this young boy with special eye powers and saves him. (also zetsu could of saved this boy, or he could of used space time, but I think turning intangible is more likely)

I belive Zetsu is some sort of creation by madara “The way I see it is that, when madara was dying he activated the rinnegan, and let’s zetsu take the rinnengan from him, along with the harashima cells, and also some of madara's own DNA. He then tells zetsu implant all of these things into a piece of zetsu body, like a big enough chunk to make a body, hence developing a second madara. That had all his memories (or possibly he could of extracted his entire brain?) and shit.

And later infused this body with obito who he found because he needed the body of an uchiha and this was he’s perfect chance because the uchiha’s were all still alive and he didn’t want to engage into combat.
Now what if zetsu before meeting obito implanted the rinnegan into an uzumaki child (nagato). So he could get the Sage Body |Sage Eyes sort of thing in order to study it abilities and then later when this uzumaki child was powerful enough revive madara in his prime.

But as this uzumaki got older and stronger zetsu knows he wouldn’t be able to guide and control this child anymore, which is why he needed an uchiha body to put madara’s dna, memories and harashima cells into. Which he later did when he lucky found this defenceless boy with special eye power.. Obito."

My theory

Interesting theory you got there :scorps:

 

[TobisPawn]

*Elder Son*

 

[Uzumaki king]

And hair is the justification? The Uchiha's have similar hair. Sasuke's hair resembles Madara/Izuna. Is he them? I hope u dont say yes.

no hair is just a factor but i understand were you'er coming from

 

[NarutoFactoid]

Yet, people still think it's Obito, because that's the most logical choice...

theres NOTHING logical about it. they have the same hair is what it seems like. big whoop.

 

[Uzumaki king]

Interesting theory you got there :scorps:

That theory makes a whole lot of sense wen you put it that way good job

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

theres NOTHING logical about it. they have the same hair is what it seems like. big whoop.

I have about 10 more points then just same hair

 

[Sage6paths]

yes i believe Tobi is Izuna.

1. Before Madara dies, he revives Izuna and passed his Rinnegan to Izuna.
2. Then madara told Izuna his plans for his own revival.
3. But he knew if Izuna revive him, Izuna will die too. (he dont want it to happen)
4. So he instructed Izuna to give his Rinnegan to Nagato.
5. The idea is to use a 3rd party Rinnegan user to revive Madara himself.
6. Thus, Nagato was picked.
6. Their plan was to have 2 brothers alively human in present time.
7. Izuna acted on the will of his brother, thus he calls himself Madara.
8. Their love as brothers is as deep at the brotherly love between Sasuke and Itachi.

Hope it helps.
Not official, but i hope i guessed it right.

 

[JasonSamuel]

ok this is very interesting ....but all the possible contenders for Tobi have some flaws.

1)Obito/Tobi Theory:

well this is very old and believe me no matter how hard you try, the time line just doesn't add up...no motive....no nothing.

2)Izuna/Tobi Theory:

again a very popular theory but no....in the in ch:577 Madara was kinda grieving Izuna's death .....and i don't think he is lieing here....Naruto/577/7

so he really is dead.

3)Elder Son/Tobi Theory:

Elder Son would be too OP....and wouldn't require any team(Akatsuki) to accomplish his plan....and i don't think he could live so long (considering ...no Zetsu technology at that time lolz)....as zetsu is made of hasi and madara's cells.

4)Future Sasuke/Tobi Theory:

i'm simply amazed by the sh*t ppl can pull out of their a**es. End of Story

5)Advanced Zetsu Madara clone/Tobi Theory:

highly unlikely....cuz it would just ruin his character if the main villain turns out to be an experiment moreover Tobi is far more ambitious to turn out to be just a clone lolz.

6)Kagami/Tobi Theory:

As much as i lean towards this one, it still has flaws...ok now ppl claim that kagami could be tobi cuz the 2nd hokage created space/time jutsu and kagami might have mastered it and so on...but they seem to forget that 2nd hokage was also the one to create Edo Tensei , of which Tobi seemed to have very little knowledge of since he asked kabuto to tell him how the technique works. Naruto/520/9
If tobi was kagami then for sure he would've known about it(i can't imagine him letting such high technique slip right through his jaws)...hell even naruto knows kakashi's raikari is a lightening style attack.
so i don't think so....

anyways this is just what i observed and i can be wrong but i just thought i'd say it anyways xd .

(Note:i'm unable to link cuz of my post count but i have given ch and page numbers)

someone finally uses his brain...theres been too much garbage on this thread

I have about 10 more points then just same hair

If you think its obito u clearly dont understand this manga. tobi looks really old. he fought minato when kakashi was still a kid. he was way too short to be tobi in just a year

 

[GenZer0]

does anyone realize that the right side of tobi had a sharigan and the right side of obito's body was crushed? so the sharigan on tobi's right side shouldve been crushed to if hes obito.... also how can it be izuna....how can he live that long? Its probaly just going to be a character we never heard of and kishi is going to create a whole back story on toby.

 

[Uzumaki king]

someone finally uses his brain...theres been too much garbage on this thread

its not garbage there just theories

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

If you think its obito u clearly dont understand this manga. tobi looks really old. he fought minato when kakashi was still a kid. he was way too short to be tobi in just a year

We have only seen the left side of tobi's face never the right it is always hidden. If your has got crushed by a rock it would look squashed, also the right side of your body would be ****ed up. We have seen tobi ripping of his arm as if he cannot even feel this side of his body.

Kakashi was about 15-16 at the time, please tell me how strong naurto and sasuke is right now and tell me how old they are.. go on..

It was about 3-4 years after the war enough time for minato to become hokage and be hokage for abit also enough time for kakashi to become old enough for kakashi to gain a new outfit. So as we can see it was a time skip. also obito was taller then kakashi.

Hit me with more points with why not and I will prove them wrong.