1st hokage vs 2nd hokage

[l3m0npl3dg3]

Now open. Sorry for the interruption^^

???

 

[Josh]

???

=_= Please use words when replying. "???" is like a one-word reply which is against the rules. I temporarily closed your thread to remove the posts/conversation with that Hashirama guy. I was apologizing for any incovenience the closing of it may have caused, but now your thread is clear of the spam and discussion that is relevant may continue.^^

 

[narutownsyouall]

=_= Please use words when replying. "???" is like a one-word reply which is against the rules. I temporarily closed your thread to remove the posts/conversation with that Hashirama guy. I was apologizing for any incovenience the closing of it may have caused, but now your thread is clear of the spam and discussion that is relevant may continue.^^

How have you posted 11000 times?

 

[l3m0npl3dg3]

=_= Please use words when replying. "???" is like a one-word reply which is against the rules. I temporarily closed your thread to remove the posts/conversation with that Hashirama guy. I was apologizing for any incovenience the closing of it may have caused, but now your thread is clear of the spam and discussion that is relevant may continue.^^

Thats not spamming i was wondering what the hell you were talking about

 

[TiddlySkydiver]

Manga facts>your opinions

Manga states Hashi is more powerful or Tobirama would have been the 1st, and it would have been him that fought Madara. Tobirama was defeated by Gold and Silver Bros and was killed by a group of 20 unnamed ninja. We don't know enough about Tobirama or the extent of his s/t and edo, which if it was as powerful as many are claiming, he wouldn't have been killed. They hype and feats from the manga both point to Hashirama as being superior, stop speculating and making Tobirama out to be better than he is when the manga clearly shows otherwise.

 

[-Madara Uchiha-]

1st Hokage wins

 

[USSJ Future Trunks]

Manga states Hashi is more powerful or Tobirama would have been the 1st

so by your logic, tsunade > jiraiya because he was not hokage and she was. maybe tobi just refused the job.

Tobirama was defeated by Gold and Silver Bros

not embarrassing since it was an ambush and kin/gin are rikudo descendants

which if it was as powerful as many are claiming, he wouldn't have been killed.

yes he would have if the 20 kumo ninjas had a counter for his jutsus

You have not seen his S/T ninjutsu in action, so you can't decide whether it's OP or not.

you havent seen hashirama in action period

Hashirama could controll tailed beasts too, something I've not heard Tobirama can do.

doesnt mean hes weaker. hashirama just had a special bloodline technique. kimimaro can spam bones out of his skin and naruto cant. so by your logic kimimaro > naruto

Hashirama was considered the best by Madara, Dan, everyone in his era, Kabuto

none of them called him the best. hes known as strongest of his time and can stop madara. madaras not representative of every ninja with a hax technique

He never mentioned Tobirama, only Hashirama as having powers similar to the Sage of Six paths.

he never mentioned ANYONE having similar power to sage of six paths besides HIMSELF and madara who was a fraction of that god's power.

but
hashi is said to be best shinobi ever by kabuto...

kabuto never said that. not even once, ever.

Because nothing in the manga says that the 1st is weaker than the 2nd

doesnt matter. everyone probably thought naruto stood no chance vs neji but it turns out he hid a power from everyone and did it alone. everyone thought hiruzen was the most monstrous hokage but oro took him down. everyone thought kyubi was weak, even oro and nagato, who both stated they underestimated it.

The 1st's power has been compared to the SO6P by Kabuto. I never saw him say anything about Tobirama

kabuto didnt compare shit. he said both were considered legends. he didnt say hashirama was anywhere near as strong as rikudo. tobirama is shrouded in secrecy. who knows what he showed in his crazy battle with 20 elite kumo ninjas? no one was watching that. and we know he had some decidedly dark kinjutsus like ET. which he used often enough to be known by chiyo muu and kin/gin

Why does Madara only talk about Hashirama

hashirama was his rival and the one who ended up taking him out.

If Tobirama was greater than Hashirama, then why does no one say that Tobirama was the strongest of his time?

we know for a fact who was REALLY the strongest ninja in the world during third shinobi great war (it was tobi) but no one besides himself was aware of that. who knows what kinds of crazy kinjutsu tobirama hid from everyone? ET was used often enough to be famous among the ninjas of that era.
kabuto stated its the greatest strongest jutsu in narutoverse.
so if hashirama is the greatest ninja then tobirama is the strongest ninja/most hax due to the fact he has a jutsu superior to anything in hashiramas arsenal. otherwise kabuto would respect mokuton as the strongest jutsu.

The 9 tails would lose to Hashirama. He already beat Madara and 9 tails on his own

no he didnt. mito helped and so did probably an army of fodder senjus since tobi said madara fought the whole village by himself. if nine tails was under his control yet madara was still by himself then hashirama probs used his own bijuus to fight madara with.

We do know Hashirama was made Hokage over Tobirama. Can you tell me why Hashirama was made Hokage over Tobirama, and this time, don't avoid the question

.
why was tsunade hokage? why was orochimaru hiruzen's first choice over jiraiya/white fang? why was hiruzen hokage when surely there were other better stronger people than some kid?
unlike other villages, the hokage is not always the strongest person in the village.

But with Tobirama, you have zero evidence to suggest that Tobirama > Hashirama

tobirama created what kabuto respects as the strongest jutsu thats ever been created.

Orochimaru using edo is not the same as Kabuto using edo. Kabuto could control way more edos than Orochimaru can. Orochimaru only controlled like two and he hardly used them to their true potential. Tobirama's edo technique is even worst, and who exactly would Tobirama use as an edo?

orochimaru controlled two 3 years before his death. who knows how much he completed it after that point? tobirama is a good guy so he didnt finish it to its true potential.

First off, Tobirama's edo was not as advanced as Orochimaru's one and it was incomplete.

doesnt make it weak by any stretch. minatos rasengan isnt as strong as naruto's but i bet minato would rape pre SM naruto and beat SM naruto high diff

Madara only ever talks about Hashirama, he never talks about Tobirama. All the hype goes towards Hashirama from the manga and never to Tobirama.

minato, kabuto, chiyo, muu (he wondered why 2nd hokage wasnt there among the edos, instead of say, hashi or hiruzen, meaning he thought 2nd deserved to be there even though he recognised third raikage), kin and gin (knew of edo tensei and didnt think the jutsu itself was any more advanced than it was in their time since they thought it was indeed him who resurrected them), and oro all expressed amazement at 2nd hokages power. it was said by anbu that it was unprecedented to see high level suitons without a water source, and it was said by many ninjas that hokages in general are all incredibly strong. not JUST hashirama or minato.

Also, there is a reason he was chosen as Hokage first over his brother

ok. tell us.

 

[narutownsyouall]

First wins. Hard difficulty though.