I created this thread cause minato defeated him, and I want to see if u guys think itachi can
It does he forced tobi to retreat so he won, and u didn't answer who u think will winHe didn't defeat him Tobi retreated, if that counts as winning I guess he did
It does count as a win because if Tobi had stayed all that would have happened is he would have been killed. He knew it and so he left.He didn't defeat him Tobi retreated, if that counts as winning I guess he did
No it s itachi before he diedIt does count as a win because if Tobi had stayed all that would have happened is he would have been killed. He knew it and so he left.
On thread, probably Itachi. As long as it isn't the 7 year old Itachi during the same time period.
Well minato delt with both y cant itachiIf you mean that Itachi also has to fight the Kyuubi as well then I'd say Tobi, if it was just their quick 1v1 then Itachi.
Minato made him retreat so he wontobi won because he is still alive and minato not so much he may have stopped the nine tails attack but beat tobi ...no he didnt sorry and as for your vs match tobi was affraid of itachi so i will say itachi
edit: unless you mean tobi is controling kurama then no tobi wins
He died saving the village from the nine tails, but he beat tobi and made him retreatno minato died so he lost
Well minato delt with both y cant itachi
U r so in itachi fanboyTobi had his intentions for coming to konoha and he completed it. There was no reason to stick around. If tobi had actually decided to fight and go all out, he wouldve stuck around and possibly use izanagi.
Anyway who do i think would win against pre ms rennigan tobi and sick itachi?.
Firstly both had great respect for each other. Tobi decided to honour his agreement with itachi. What people fail to get is that, if tobi deemed itachi as a pushover he wouldve dishonoured the agreement after all, what can itachi do to him.
Similarly itachi somewhat agreed that with his current state, he couldnt possible defeat tobi, therefore left it to sasuke. Firstly by implanting amaterasu, but also by letting him awaken the ms and eventually taking his eyes to stop the blindness process but also to acquire a new power.
Back to the fight. How tobi's technique works isnt hard to figure out. Team kakashi figured it out during their chase for sasuke. Fu and torune figured it out. Itachi ive no doubt would figure it out. The difference between team kakashi, fu and torune and minato is that unlike minato they didnt have the speed to make their strategy work and that was their downfall. Itachi might be fast, but unless he can come up with a great strategy with requires the use of limited speed on his part he cannot defeat tobi. Similarly tobi cannot defeat him
Minato dies because of the fight with the nine-tails and the demon seal, he DID win in the fight with tobi... basically you're saying if I got in a fight with someone in the middle of the treat and that person ran away, then I got hit by a car... so he wins? your logic is flawedno minato died so he lost
this isnt rocket surgery here lol if two people fight one dies the other doesnt then the one who is alive wins its pretty simple