[Game] Toujo's Maid Wars Mafia #39

[Poison]

I'm trying to read the thread since morning but something keeps coming up. I guess I'll do it after lunch for sure.

 

[Ultraviolet]

I don’t really understand the purpose of this post.
Should I have made my mind up about her after what, 6 pages before she had even responded to my questions?

You should have had a snap judgement right away, did you not?

 

[Ultraviolet]

But I don’t care about you saying you don’t like a players post, my point about you was that you were giving overly generous stamps of approval to players for little or no reason.

Saying that you didn’t like a different post, or that ‘you just like it’ isn’t a rationale for liking X’s post. I want to know what you like about it so I can judge your thought process, which as of right now looks very suspect to me.

What is a thought process behind that post that wouldn't look suspect to you?

 

[Grammaton]

What is a thought process behind that post that wouldn't look suspect to you?

Posts that have a logic I can follow. Theres nothing to like about X saying he didnt know this was a kingmaker game, so the fact she liked it is suspect to me

 

[Grammaton]

You should have had a snap judgement right away, did you not?

Im assuming this is just trolling?

 

[Ultraviolet]

Posts that have a logic I can follow. Theres nothing to like about X saying he didnt know this was a kingmaker game, so the fact she liked it is suspect to me

Try again, I'm asking you to give me an example of what would be a follow up from her that would make you go "hmm ok that's reasonable"

 

[Ultraviolet]

Im assuming this is just trolling?

???

No.

 

[Grammaton]

Try again, I'm asking you to give me an example of what would be a follow up from her that would make you go "hmm ok that's reasonable"

I dont think such an answer exists, hence me bringing it up in the first place

 

[Ultraviolet]

I dont think such an answer exists, hence me bringing it up in the first place

Right, you asked her a loaded question:

Could you explain what you liked about XTMF seemingly not being aware this was a Kingmaker game, and why you think this is a good opening?

Which contradicts your post here:

I don’t really understand the purpose of this post.
Should I have made my mind up about her after what, 6 pages before she had even responded to my questions?

Stating that you didn't have your mind made up.

What I'm driving at here Gramma is that it's very obvious you took issue with that post of hers from the get go. You realize that by your own admission here the response Alice gave was inconsequential, and that your questioning of her looks rather performative.

 

[Grammaton]

Im assuming this is just trolling?

I mean the fact im asking her further questions should be indicative of my current position on her - if youre looking for a final judgment then what youre asking is entirely unreasonable

 

[Ultraviolet]

I mean the fact im asking her further questions should be indicative of my current position on her - if youre looking for a final judgment then what youre asking is entirely unreasonable

If you're asking further questions for no other reason than the explicit purpose of making them look worse, that is scummy dude.

 

[Grammaton]

Right, you asked her a loaded question:



Which contradicts your post here:



Stating that you didn't have your mind made up.

What I'm driving at here Gramma is that it's very obvious you took issue with that post of hers from the get go. You realize that by your own admission here the response Alice gave was inconsequential, and that your questioning of her looks rather performative.

What hell dimension is this? She makes a post that I dont think theres a satisfactory answer for, so I ask her about it - she might have an explanation that makes sense to her but doesnt to me, but I can at least join the dots and try to understand where she was coming from, which is how youre supposed to question people?

It is a loaded question, youre right, just as any question you ask to a suspect is. Youre trying to force a mistake out of them so you can put them away, or alternatively, you want them to answer you so convincingly that its obvious you made a mistake. Ive no idea what your objection to this is, and why you legitimately think this is a valid line of attack?

 

[Grammaton]

If you're asking further questions for no other reason than the explicit purpose of making them look worse, that is scummy dude.

?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

 

[Ultraviolet]

Can you direct me to anything of any consequence you have done in this game? Thx

Get back to me when you’re ready to actually play

This is more like what Im looking for.

So my next question is this - youve listed 5 players (me, Ultra, Ekko, that afk guy with sheep avatar, Kek) based on activity and contribution that you think could be mafia. I have literally nothing in common with any of those other players in that Im one of the few actually trying to play the game, so could you explain why youve grouped us together in that way?

Also all your assertions here that you're the only one "actually playing" (whatever that means) feels super disingenuous and icky

 

[Grammaton]

Thats seriously the dumbest thing ive ever read in a game.

 

[Grammaton]

Also all your assertions here that you're the only one "actually playing" (whatever that means) feels super disingenuous and icky

Who else is actually posting anything of substance?

 

[KekW]

both of you popoo

 

[Ultraviolet]

Thats seriously the dumbest thing ive ever read in a game.

lol, you're scum

 

[Grammaton]

lol, you're scum

2nd dumbest thing ive read in a game

 

[Ultraviolet]

Been there and done that man. You got caught scum tunneling on a weak player. I'll moved on since you're basically locked in.