[Game] Our loved Mangakas and their masterpieces Mafia Game #19

Status
Not open for further replies.

Elmage G Ace

Elite
Joined
Mar 30, 2011
Messages
6,190
Reaction score
1,102
You must be registered for see images

We need evaluation, A simple townread ISO is the easiest, scum gutreads are always welcome and are harming noone, only yourself if done crappy.
I don't really do gut-reads in mafia game, statistically speaking, how effective is it? Just curious. I'm guessing it's more effective coming from an experienced player, but I'm not an experienced player, so you won't see me give reads, or vote anyone based on gut feeling. That being said, I will share if I find something interesting
 

Rej

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
1,280
I don't really do gut-reads in mafia game, statistically speaking, how effective is it? Just curious. I'm guessing it's more effective coming from an experienced player, but I'm not an experienced player, so you won't see me give reads, or vote anyone based on gut feeling. That being said, I will share if I find something interesting
You can always evolve and get out of your shell bro, I believe in it. :)
 

Rej

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
1,280
it is effective to read how out of place or calculating your behaviour is, how friendly or malcious you position a read, so another player can indeed say "that guy (speaking of you) is town"
 

Elmage G Ace

Elite
Joined
Mar 30, 2011
Messages
6,190
Reaction score
1,102
it is effective to read how out of place or calculating your behaviour is, how friendly or malcious you position a read, so another player can indeed say "that guy (speaking of you) is town"

I don't think I'll ever get to a point where I'm giving gut reads tbh, I'm a very calculative person, and I rely on that a lot, it's one of my defining traits (I'm a programmer irl) so yeah, while I acknowledge the importance of gut reads, don't expect me to give one, my style comes down to, "do his/her actions add up as town/mafia? Does it align with his/her personality?" no matter how we try to pretend, we can't really hide our personality, I've played with Michelle a lot for example, and despite her alignment, I know she's an empathetic person. Can't fake that. I also know that if I build a case and pressure AllRed long enough, I can tell her alignment, I know that LanMisa is a sensitive person, Alice seems carefree but she's quite observant when she's town, and so I'd naturally become suspicious of her if she didn't pick up things I'd expect her to, Ansa is usually direct in his approach, and moth seems more sarcastic when he flips mafia, and may try to draw attention to himself, and then focus this attention to whoever he sus(I'll need more data on him to conclude ._.) but below the humour, and sarcasm, he's a really smart player. So yeah, I slowly build a personality profile on every player I play for/against
 

Rej

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
1,280
I don't think I'll ever get to a point where I'm giving gut reads tbh, I'm a very calculative person, and I rely on that a lot, it's one of my defining traits (I'm a programmer irl) so yeah, while I acknowledge the importance of gut reads, don't expect me to give one, my style comes down to, "do his/her actions add up as town/mafia? Does it align with his/her personality?" no matter how we try to pretend, we can't really hide our personality, I've played with Michelle a lot for example, and despite her alignment, I know she's an empathetic person. Can't fake that. I also know that if I build a case and pressure AllRed long enough, I can tell her alignment, I know that LanMisa is a sensitive person, Alice seems carefree but she's quite observant when she's town, and so I'd naturally become suspicious of her if she didn't pick up things I'd expect her to, Ansa is usually direct in his approach, and moth seems more sarcastic when he flips mafia, and may try to draw attention to himself, and then focus this attention to whoever he sus(I'll need more data on him to conclude ._.) but below the humour, and sarcasm, he's a really smart player. So yeah, I slowly build a personality profile on every player I play for/against
You must be registered for see images

I see I got a better understanding now.

A pokerface player.
 

SoulKiller

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
12,320
Reaction score
2,375
You must be registered for see images
 

Ansatsuken

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Reaction score
3,810
I don't think I'll ever get to a point where I'm giving gut reads tbh, I'm a very calculative person, and I rely on that a lot, it's one of my defining traits (I'm a programmer irl) so yeah, while I acknowledge the importance of gut reads, don't expect me to give one, my style comes down to, "do his/her actions add up as town/mafia? Does it align with his/her personality?" no matter how we try to pretend, we can't really hide our personality, I've played with Michelle a lot for example, and despite her alignment, I know she's an empathetic person. Can't fake that. I also know that if I build a case and pressure AllRed long enough, I can tell her alignment, I know that LanMisa is a sensitive person, Alice seems carefree but she's quite observant when she's town, and so I'd naturally become suspicious of her if she didn't pick up things I'd expect her to, Ansa is usually direct in his approach, and moth seems more sarcastic when he flips mafia, and may try to draw attention to himself, and then focus this attention to whoever he sus(I'll need more data on him to conclude ._.) but below the humour, and sarcasm, he's a really smart player. So yeah, I slowly build a personality profile on every player I play for/against
I know you're calculative type of person. Even you still can be calculative when you're mafia before. I always see you as town. Like feel very safe when you're around. How you addressed player is very enjoyable to see.
 

Elmage G Ace

Elite
Joined
Mar 30, 2011
Messages
6,190
Reaction score
1,102
You must be registered for see images

I see I got a better understanding now.

A pokerface player.
lol! Yeah, way to sum it up xD
I know you're calculative type of person. Even you still can be calculative when you're mafia before. I always see you as town. Like feel very safe when you're around. How you addressed player is very enjoyable to see.
Thanks lol! Although, as a result of my style, I'm often seen as mafia by some
 

Ansatsuken

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Reaction score
3,810
@mothbomb

Why Noami looked suspicious to you? Any good reason you can share with us? What's your opinion on Alice and Sage?

Alice feels more quite than before.
 

Ansatsuken

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Reaction score
3,810
As for All_Red I can see her approach finally worked and payed off. She managed to get the best response from LanMisa that convinced her Misa is town. She then unvote. That's definitely town All_Red's playing.
 

Rej

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
1,280
:lok: will go to sleep, you guys can handle this will be around in 7 hours or so

I suggest doing some ISO posts on mid and low posters and force them to deliver a performance towards EoD. I will do so when I evaluate later on tomorrow (or today lol).

Night
 

Ansatsuken

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Reaction score
3,810
Damn sorry for being late will catch up and post soon

Okay


Skimmed through nothing too big has caught my eye yet but keeping an eye on those trying to keep a low radar especially ones havent said anything constructive yet.

Lol how Ironic. That bold-underline statement perfectly fit your situation.

You are trying to sound reasonable here but there's no follow up after that from you. That statement has turned into an empty statement. There's couple of big things have happened in this round(AR vs LanMisa and Ansatsuken vs Lukundo), what's your take on these issues?

Something hinder you from sharing your opinion?
 

Ansatsuken

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Reaction score
3,810
Town Sagebee is usually proactive but what actually happened? Busyness?
 

mothbomb

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 31, 2019
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
703
I wanna use the discord emojis here, the emojis here are rly...not fulfilling for mafia
You must be registered for see images
I still wonder why AR entered this way, maybe it was her own way to become comfortable.
Lukundo is quite agressive, got a town lean on him. I also dont have meta references to that guy.
Ansa is Ansa, townlean early on.

I know Poison Chan has a bad today, so I gonna wait before I put my reads on her, I got nullreads on her.

Just some gutty reads from my side.
I like this post by LanMisa for some reasons, it is inquisitive and gives off a civillian vibe.

:score:this was not a good answer, you should have just engaged the conversation with Misa and said you are town.
you could chose any answer, just not the suspicious ones :score:
I brought Naomi here, she will need some time but usually doesnt vote D1 since as new player she mostly participated in mislynches previously. She will come online later as she currently is asleep, I think she is from NA.
About Konan dunno. Also a new player for me, but we shouldn't create hectic in a 60 hours DP if they take their time to answer.
Nicely said, I agree it was some weird thought process. Tho making summary posts is always a good thing for fellow civillians aslong they are accurate.
:score: I am also a new player, I think I started with @Naomi_Rose last year in summer. But I took more games with me as I was partially a big addicto.

I dont want to go into details, I'd mostly say find out for yourself, if you play with someone new interact with them once they are up.
nope, I just played with you, Luku and Red on AB
I played 3 games on NF (subbed out twice and NKd N1 once) XD
Else you can find me on TS and ex TB
You must be registered for see images

weren't you early gamed most games before? I mean welcome to the club, I only truly finished one game here I think. lmao

but yeah, I already spoiled on discord about how determined I am about this game
Early gamed? I only die young as Mafia and tend to survive longer as town. Mafia never fears me, it seems.

I have only played twice here, that is true, but I have been playing for over a year now in total and consider myself experienced, albeit not a veteran by any stretch.
I dont know any other term for that one. Dunno there was a game once where I played scum and won, and I played quite innocent and since that happened (and such scenarios repeated, besides D1 Jester Win) people decided to hardfocus me early on and get me out.

I consider myself knowledgeable, beyond an amateur level, but my praxis experience is still not enough and I rly wanna do my first hostings soon. But enviromental changes and meeting new people indeed increased my mafia knowledge.
Still I feel like this year I have been the nr 1 mislynched towny on my ex home forum TB, where it almost became a running gag. :yay:



What do all these posts have in common?

Naomi rose reacted to all these posts

never quoted any of these posts

never talked about a single one of these posts

never gave a read on a single one of these players

and has produced more reactions than ACTUAL posts this game
 

mothbomb

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 31, 2019
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
703
Now she doesnt know anyone but rej very well
but this seems ultra sus. and im only up to p5 so far on my reread of naomi activity
 

Ansatsuken

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Reaction score
3,810
@Rej don't expect much, as i mention these type of games are not my thing.

Also from what i learn playing these type, people on first day putting votes.

are usually scum day invest.

Is this META always being practiced by her in every game @Rej?
 

Ansatsuken

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Reaction score
3,810
What do all these posts have in common?

Naomi rose reacted to all these posts

never quoted any of these posts

never talked about a single one of these posts

never gave a read on a single one of these players

and has produced more reactions than ACTUAL posts this game
Ok but what all those reactions mean to you?
 

mothbomb

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 31, 2019
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
703
quote messed up and merged my reply

--

I hardly participated in misslynches, nor day 1. I do recall you being town doing that with wai miss-lynching people. :lok: that everyone came on you your lynch for playing like that lol.

and yes was asleep, ^^
Vote Lynch: Naomi Rose

let us begin the ritualistic
dance with de mawth
I suspect red so far, poison, and naomi
60hrs.....



Naomi rose summary

psychotically obsessed with anything rej posts

lurking

complained that the phases are too long?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top