Yeah basically and im not so sure you can classify Otsutsuki as yin or yang. It seems like have yin/yang by default. Byakugan/Sharingan, strength speed and tons of chakra.Hagoromo had a Rinnegan for practically most of his life.
Yeah basically and im not so sure you can classify Otsutsuki as yin or yang. It seems like have yin/yang by default. Byakugan/Sharingan, strength speed and tons of chakra.Hagoromo had a Rinnegan for practically most of his life.
God-tier Otsutsuki’s like Kaguya and Hagoromo are yin-yangYeah basically and im not so sure you can classify Otsutsuki as yin or yang. It seems like have yin/yang by default. Byakugan/Sharingan, strength speed and tons of chakra.
The separation of yin and yang didn't occur until Asura and Indra. For Madara to reach an Otsutsuki power level he needed to combine yin and yang.God-tier Otsutsuki’s like Kaguya and Hagoromo are yin-yang ☯. The lesser Otsutsuki like Hamura, Momoshiki, etc. are either yin or yang.
We are only shown that Momoshiki and Kaguya had the 3rd eye. Kinshiki is a Yang (he had no doujutsu). Kaguya is arguably a Yang as she did not have a Rinnegan (only the red one). Also on the shrine, both Kaguya and Kinshiki were on the bottom of the pair (possibly hinting that top is Yin and bottom is Yang).Yeah, I meant that Pure Otsutuski can never attain the Tenseigan after eating the Chakra fruit, which is why Kaguya, Momo, Kin, etc. never had it. Only their human-hybrid descendants can, which is why Hamura, Toneri had it, and why Hagoromo also ended up with a god-tier doujutsu.
I do not believe that Momoshiki cared for Boruto nor for his eye. Remember that he faced Sasuke and he had the Rinnegan. They never tried to get his. He simply gave his seal to him because he was the one that defeated him even in his final form.And finally, Momoshiki himself wasn’t able to obtain Boruto’s “new” doujutsu, so he made Boruto a vessel and will try to take over his body in order to utilize the latter’s eye power.
Are you talking about the filler episode? Sharingan is the diluted Yin chakra in the head. Hagoromo was far from diluted. As far as the seal goes, the most logical reason for that is he is Yin which means he needed some Yang so Hagoromo and Hamura probably stored their own chakra on the other so they can use them in case of emergency.I think Hagoromo had the yang seal because he embodied both. Although he had a Sharingan he was also a sage and jinchuriki two abilities that are considered high on the yang scale. Since Kaguya was basically the ten tails her sons may have inherited the yin and yang. She had plenty for everyone.
Kinshiki had a Rinnegan, the databook says that he is capable of chakra absorption and we know that Momoshiki gained a third eye after eating Kinshiki. Also, Kinshiki himself said that he’d eaten his previous “father-figure”, so he needed a Rinnegan to turn him into a fruit.We are only shown that Momoshiki and Kaguya had the 3rd eye. Kinshiki is a Yang (he had no doujutsu). Kaguya is arguably a Yang as she did not have a Rinnegan (only the red one). Also on the shrine, both Kaguya and Kinshiki were on the bottom of the pair (possibly hinting that top is Yin and bottom is Yang).
Kaguya never did use any Rinnegan technique as well (aside from the dimensional travel). So even if she was Yin, she never did anything with her Rinnegan. There is possibly a good reason why Kaguya did not have the Tenseigan and that is because of spoilers (The Last was about to be released/in the works).
But let's theorize that a Yang ate chakra fruit, they could unlock a 3rd eye. This would be backed up by the fact that Kaguya had one (if she was indeed a Yang).
I also believe that the Tenseigan would work like a Sharingan would. It would turn off if not in use and revert back into a Byakugan and the Rinnegan would just come out of the RinneSharingan. (At least that was what I believed after watching The Last then Boruto The Movie came out and Momoshiki had 2 in his hands)
I do not believe that Momoshiki cared for Boruto nor for his eye. Remember that he faced Sasuke and he had the Rinnegan. They never tried to get his. He simply gave his seal to him because he was the one that defeated him even in his final form.
Madara was capable of absorbing chakra without the Rinnegan as was Hashirama. We also don't know if a Rinnegan is a prerequisite in all forms of "eating" your comrade. Momoshiki already had a Rinnegan, hence his third eye can just as well be a mutation caused by the increase in chakra from eating Kinshiki.Kinshiki had a Rinnegan, the databook says that he is capable of chakra absorption and we know that Momoshiki gained a third eye after eating Kinshiki. Also, Kinshiki himself said that he’d eaten his previous “father-figure”, so he needed a Rinnegan to turn him into a fruit.
I like how you are willing to argue that something that we know is canon regardless of how little it was explained and how stupid it was isn't "real" while you also argue that the Databooks are unfailingly true despite the fact that they often contradict the manga and take it as a fact even if the manga never touched on the specific subject. We don't know if Kinshiki has Chakra Absorption and we don't even know how his version would function.Also, the Tenseigan is a fake doujutsu that was half baked; There was no real logic to it.
Except we’ve Kinshiki use t/s technique in the anime exactly like Kamui so yeah, and according the online episode filler lists, that episode was canon. Also Hashirama used the Wood Dragon to absorb chakra, not his body. They’re entirely different so don’t try and compare them, and until something else is shown to prove that a Rinnegan isn’t needed to turn someone into a chakra fruit, it’s pretty set in stone. But you’re still free to try and prove me wrong of course.Madara was capable of absorbing chakra without the Rinnegan as was Hashirama. We also don't know if a Rinnegan is a prerequisite in all forms of "eating" your comrade. Momoshiki already had a Rinnegan, hence his third eye can just as well be a mutation caused by the increase in chakra from eating Kinshiki.
Three things:I like how you are willing to argue that something that we know is canon regardless of how little it was explained and how stupid it was isn't "real" while you also argue that the Databooks are unfailingly true despite the fact that they often contradict the manga and take it as a fact even if the manga never touched on the specific subject. We don't know if Kinshiki has Chakra Absorption and we don't even know how his version would function.
Hashirama used Wood Style, Nagato used Rinnegan, Momoshiki used Rinnegan, Madara used his body. They are all Chakra Absorption in terms of application with different tools being used. Hence Chakra Absorption isn't a unique trait of the Otsutsuki Clan or the Rinnegan. Meaning for all we know, Kinshiki didn't have Chakra Absorption and even if he did he (likely) didn't get it from a Rinnegan as we never see him use it or possess it.Except we’ve Kinshiki use t/s technique in the anime exactly like Kamui so yeah, and according the online episode filler lists, that episode was canon. Also Hashirama used the Wood Dragon to absorb chakra, not his body. They’re entirely different so don’t try and compare them, and until something else is shown to prove that a Rinnegan isn’t needed to turn someone into a chakra fruit, it’s pretty set in stone. But you’re still free to try and prove me wrong of course.
And all Databooks to-date hold inaccurate information or things that cannot be confirmed because the manga never dwelled on it. Because of that if falls into the realm of subjectivity unless the specific excerpt you are taking is written by the current writer(s) of the manga themselves. Otherwise its a collection of subjective opinions and theories. If I read an officially licensed history book written by some dude who insisted that Hitler was a Alien from Pluto, is that true? No. Can it be true? Well technically yes. Is it likely to be true? That is up to you and your subjective opinion to decide.1. There is no “databooks (plural)” I used an excerpt from a databook, not several. And I even spoke on how ignorant the databook was for giving Kinshiki that attribute without him displaying it.
"Fake" implies that it doesn't exist. Which is clearly does as we've seen it within canon material. No matter how stupid, unexplained or inconsistent it is, it isn't fake and it (sadly) exists. It also doesn't contradict other known facts of the series, meaning it fits within the story. Sasuke not having his Rinnegan active for example is a inaccuracy because we know for a fact that its wrong. The Tenseigan however is not such an inaccuracy as we don't know why Hamura didn't have it, but we know it exists.2. The Tenseigan is a fake doujutsu, Hamura’s spirit didn’t even have the Tenseigan when appeared before Hinata.
In the realm of subjective opinions, sure.3. Kinshiki has a Rinnegan, get over it.
-*Casually ignores Kinshiki’s use of s/t technique*Hashirama used Wood Style, Nagato used Rinnegan, Momoshiki used Rinnegan, Madara used his body. They are all Chakra Absorption in terms of application with different tools being used. Hence Chakra Absorption isn't a unique trait of the Otsutsuki Clan or the Rinnegan. Meaning for all we know, Kinshiki didn't have Chakra Absorption and even if he did he (likely) didn't get it from a Rinnegan as we never see him use it or possess it.
You went off on a tangent, eh? Is sticking to Naruto too taxing for you?And all Databooks to-date hold inaccurate information or things that cannot be confirmed because the manga never dwelled on it. Because of that if falls into the realm of subjectivity unless the specific excerpt you are taking is written by the current writer(s) of the manga themselves. Otherwise its a collection of subjective opinions and theories. If I read an officially licensed history book written by some dude who insisted that Hitler was a Alien from Pluto, is that true? No. Can it be true? Well technically yes. Is it likely to be true? That is up to you and your subjective opinion to decide.
“Fake” doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist, fake means a counterfeit, a con, a ruse. At least that’s the way I used, which is also correct since it has multiple definitions. Try to keep up, though buddy."Fake" implies that it doesn't exist. Which is clearly does as we've seen it within canon material. No matter how stupid, unexplained or inconsistent it is, it isn't fake and it (sadly) exists. It also doesn't contradict other known facts of the series, meaning it fits within the story. Sasuke not having his Rinnegan active for example is a inaccuracy because we know for a fact that its wrong. The Tenseigan however is not such an inaccuracy as we don't know why Hamura didn't have it, but we know it exists.
Disprove Kinshiki’s s/t tech use then talk, until then. ShhhIn the realm of subjective opinions, sure.
LOL IDK why you're discussing that though..The Infinite Tskuyoumi is a Rinnegan technique, not a sharingan technique.
It's canon, half baked or not. It's logical. Tenseigan is the doujutsu that is developed if you're on Hamura's lineage whereas it becomes Rinnegan if you're on Hagoromo's.. There's nothing fake about it. That's like discussing why Hagoromo had redish hair and skin when Kaguya has white hair and skin and Hamura has bluish hair and skin. That's all Tenseigan is, just the light version and the Rinnegan is the dark version.Also, the Tenseigan is a fake doujutsu that was half baked; There was no real logic to it
Overreaching, Naruto, Hashirama, Toneri had chakra absorption. They never had Rinnegan. Hell, the Uzumaki chakra chain could act like one and that's not a Rinnegan tech. Absorption, yes. Rinnegan, no? S/T.. where and when? I honestly just watched it and I must have missed it.Kinshiki had a Rinnegan, the databook says that he is capable of chakra absorption
LOL, Toneri absorbed the sun's chakra when he absorbed all of the eyes and were caught in the sun's ray. He also just sucked Naruto's chakra even without his Tenseigan, although he has Byakugans all over his body and they also were a part of the Tenseigan Orb. Going by this fact, Kinshiki has the capability to sap chakra away. Especially for the fact that Kinshiki came after Toneri in terms of design. Which means whatever Toneri has, Kinshiki should have.Also Hashirama used the Wood Dragon to absorb chakra, not his body. They’re entirely different so don’t try and compare them, and until something else is shown to prove that a Rinnegan isn’t needed to turn someone into a chakra fruit
Where did you say this? I've gone over this comment thread and the closest thing you've said is:And I even spoke on how ignorant the databook was for giving Kinshiki that attribute without him displaying it.
Not really criticizing how ignorant the databook. You just stated a fact.He has a Rinnegan but it hasn’t been shown for whatever reason; almost like the non-canon Urashiki where they showed his last minute.
For a guy that's into "logic" and canon bible, you sure are dishing out a lot of illogical fanfic. Like I said, Momoshiki was never interested in doujutus. Just chakra. That's why he never saw Sasuke as a threat. Even Naruto for that matter. He simply wanted Kurama.And finally, Momoshiki himself wasn’t able to obtain Boruto’s “new” doujutsu, so he made Boruto a vessel and will try to take over his body in order to utilize the latter’s eye power.
With this logic, Hagoromo should never have had the Rinnegan as we all know that Momoshiki, a pure blooded celestial, had them. If Hagoromo was a hybrid, he should not have awaken them. If you are trying to argue that Hagoromo absorbed the Juubi and became its Jin, then he should have fought Kaguya without the Rinnegan. Ergo, they have Tenseigan.Only their human-hybrid descendants can, which is why Hamura, Toneri had it, and why Hagoromo also ended up with a god-tier doujutsu.
Tenseigan is canon, Kinshiki was never shown with Rinnegan, get over it.Kinshiki has a Rinnegan, get over it.
Hey, stay out of the conversation I’m having with that other guy. The things he and I were discussing expand beyond this thread. Focus on our conversation, otherwise you make an ass out of yourself.LOL IDK why you're discussing that though..
It's canon, half baked or not. It's logical. Tenseigan is the doujutsu that is developed if you're on Hamura's lineage whereas it becomes Rinnegan if you're on Hagoromo's.. There's nothing fake about it. That's like discussing why Hagoromo had redish hair and skin when Kaguya has white hair and skin and Hamura has bluish hair and skin. That's all Tenseigan is, just the light version and the Rinnegan is the dark version.
Overreaching, Naruto, Hashirama, Toneri had chakra absorption. They never had Rinnegan. Hell, the Uzumaki chakra chain could act like one and that's not a Rinnegan tech. Absorption, yes. Rinnegan, no? S/T.. where and when? I honestly just watched it and I must have missed it.
LOL, Toneri absorbed the sun's chakra when he absorbed all of the eyes and were caught in the sun's ray. He also just sucked Naruto's chakra even without his Tenseigan, although he has Byakugans all over his body and they also were a part of the Tenseigan Orb. Going by this fact, Kinshiki has the capability to sap chakra away. Especially for the fact that Kinshiki came after Toneri in terms of design. Which means whatever Toneri has, Kinshiki should have.
Where did you say this? I've gone over this comment thread and the closest thing you've said is:
Not really criticizing how ignorant the databook. You just stated a fact.
For a guy that's into "logic" and canon bible, you sure are dishing out a lot of illogical fanfic. Like I said, Momoshiki was never interested in doujutus. Just chakra. That's why he never saw Sasuke as a threat. Even Naruto for that matter. He simply wanted Kurama.
With this logic, Hagoromo should never have had the Rinnegan as we all know that Momoshiki, a pure blooded celestial, had them. If Hagoromo was a hybrid, he should not have awaken them. If you are trying to argue that Hagoromo absorbed the Juubi and became its Jin, then he should have fought Kaguya without the Rinnegan. Ergo, they have Tenseigan.
If you do not understand, replace Rinnegan with Sharingan. "Momoshiki has Sharingan" "Hagoromo has Sharingan" If Momoshiki has it, Hagoromo has the diluted version. Ipso facto, if Hamura has Tenseigan, it is natural that Kaguya, Momoshiki and Kishiki have them. Much like Rinnegan has the Sharingan techs.
Tenseigan is canon, Kinshiki was never shown with Rinnegan, get over it.
Also, you are willing to use anime episodes and databooks over manga and Kishimoto written movies?
Please, try not to discuss anything since you are putting your fanfics as facts. At least mine and the others SPECULATE through being logical about our approach. If ours is not proven, we back it up with events that reinforce our claim but we never state ours as facts, at least I have not yet. Yours have been half baked the entire time. Any farfetched ideas you have had so far was never backed up by evidence nor do they come from a reliable source.
Actually I will finish addressing your idiocy, give me a moment.-SNIP-
Yrah, I think the concept wad there early on(Bringer of darkness) but they fixed it up as they decided on yin yang.There is no such thing as a Hashirama with Yin path, he’s yang dominant and doesn’t have a mental energy capacity to be even considered yin.
He can use a genjutsu but it really doesn’t mean he’s a strong yin (mental energy user).Yrah, I think the concept wad there early on(Bringer of darkness) but they fixed it up as they decided on yin yang.
Post automatically merged:
@Animegoin damn boy
People are denying Kaguya's sharingan?
Well the SageMode marking in his face has nothing to do with “yin” and you’re assuming that Tsunade’s seal is anything relevant to Hashirama’s SageMode.LMAO you're no longer worth my time.
How the **** do you think I would misspell a direct quote? You and I both know that's your misspell, I'm too lazy too rewrite your shit. Why are you so stuck up on that in the first place? Like I said, it doesn't even matter if you spelled it to deaf. I carried on and saw it as defeat and never pointed it out... You TRY HARD. XD
As for Kaguya, again... missed the context. Countless times I have pointed out that TO US WE NEVER SAW HER USE THE RINNESHARINGAN. We only saw Madara use it. For the first and last time, that is all we know that the Rinnesharingan can do. Get over yourself with your grand delusion and overreaching theories. Keep up dumbass.
"A sharingan which served as Rinnegan"
The **** is this bullshit fanfic? DIDN'T KNOW THAT SHARINGAN CAN USE AMENO AND LIMBO
XD LMAO
You're filled with nonsensical fanfic!
Get that to your head. FFS. I'm speaking to a child.
The only time WE HAVE EVER SEEN the Rinnesharingan in action was from Madara and that was only to cast IT, a large scale Tsukuyomi, a Sharingan tech. Hence, no Rinnegan. If you are such a smart kid, you wouldn't have asked: "which part are you attributing the Infinite Tskuyomi to; The sharingan portion, or the Rinnegan portion?" because it's obvious. You're a dumbass that you've asked me that. This just proves it.
You keep bringing up S/T as a Rinnegan tech as well..
Obito's eyes have S/T and that isn't Rinnegan now is it?
Tsukuyomi and S/T tech have been shown to be used by Sharingan users.. So IDK why you keep implying it's a Rinnegan tech when Sharingan can do them.
"The Infinite Tskuyomi can ONLY be cancelled by those with both a Rinnegan and Six Paths Senjutsu"
LMAO! The former, yes. The latter, no. The fact that Sasuke protected and made Naruto not step out of his Susanoo means that he can't dispell the IT.. Overreaching.
"Again, you can’t even differentiate between those two doujutsu’s abilities but you’re saying definitively that Kaguya’s sharingan and the Rinnegan have different powers. The epitome of idiocy if I’d ever seen it"
IDK about you but we were never shown any Rinnesharingan techs outside of IT. Give me a panel where it was used and we will see if it's Rinnegan or Sharingan.
You are so nitpicking, even outside this thread and that you are so keen to point out people who do not point you "good" points and cry about it and there you go, beating about the bush. Insulting until you can come up with arguments that you think are good and they end up being trash.
Psst! It's simply because you're trash.
"That’s called “projecting”, dear boy. "
Says the guy that keep trying to put that misspelling as my fault on my DIRECT quote XD LMAO! Really topped Dreckerplayer on levels of delusions here, my boy. The mental gymnastics you perform man! It's commendable at this point.
Honestly you are such a poor sport that it's embarassing.
You know those people who insult on a debate? Sore losers who can't make up a good argument so they commit to personal attacks and that's your tactic.
Good for you to start replying things ON TOPIC after half a day... -_-
And you call me slow? "5 hours" XD You're half a day.
"EDIT: it has been a few mins now" - Like I'd lose sleep over you and your nonsense LMAO!
Post automatically merged:
Clearly, I have always said that Hagoromo was Yin path and his kids are (Yin-Yin) Indra, and (Yin-Yang) Asura
While Hamura is Yang path and his kids are (Yang-Yin) Hyugas, (Yang-Yang) Toneri
I don't believe that I've said that Hashirama can use Yin path. But hey, feel free to point it out. Maybe it was not communicated properly.
LOGIC: Hagoromo had Rinnegan while Hamura didn't have Tenseigan during their fight with Kaguya. In terms of parallels, Hagoromo would be Yin and Hamura is Yang.
Following this path, it would make Indra and Asura Yin lineage where Indra is Yin dominant while Asura is Yang dominant. All the way to their descendants, Uchiha and Senju.
Another reason why we also can say that Hashirama is Yin is because of his Sage Mode gives a forehead mark (typically associated with mental and spiritual energies much like the Hindu Bindi mark). This symbolism is even more prominent with Tsunade as she literally has the Yin Seal to store up her chakra. From what we can tell, Sage Modes have always given markings on the face, noticeably around the eyes. Rarely with the forehead.
The symbol of duality is always there and that is mainly the platform that Kishi always stresses out. If Hagoromo was BOTH, there would be no need for Hamura.
THEORY: Hagoromo having the Yang symbol and vice versa with Hamura could be another play where it is "Yang within Yin and Yin within Yang"
I feel the need to correct this, even if I have no belief that you will comprehend it. When reading a story, context is important as is the knowledge of characters. At the time Sasuke states that it is a Rinnegan Technique he doesn't know that the Rinne-Sharingan exists, let alone that Madara has obtained it. All he knows is that Madara has the Rinnegan and cast a Visual Illusion on the world. Hence based on his knowledge he assumes its a Rinnegan Technique because as far as he knows Madara doesn't have anything else and his Rinnegan is able to block it out.Sasuke himself stated that the IT is a Rinnegan technique.
LMFAO ”he doesn’t know that the rinnesharingan exists”I feel the need to correct this, even if I have no belief that you will comprehend it. When reading a story, context is important as is the knowledge of characters. At the time Sasuke states that it is a Rinnegan Technique he doesn't know that the Rinne-Sharingan exists, let alone that Madara has obtained it. All he knows is that Madara has the Rinnegan and cast a Visual Illusion on the world. Hence based on his knowledge he assumes its a Rinnegan Technique because as far as he knows Madara doesn't have anything else and his Rinnegan is able to block it out.
Too further elaborate on this, Madara explains that the Infinite Tsukuyomi can only be cast with the "fruit" or "eye" of the Shinju, which we see is the Rinne-Sharingan and not the Rinnegan.
Well he doesn't, arguing that he does is just invalid as you cannot know that something exists if you have never seen, heard or even imagined it before. This also falls back to a point I made to you in another thread, that being the context of a character's knowledge within the story. No one aside from Kaguya and Madara have ever unlocked the Rinne-Sharingan to our knowledge and it's name has never been said by either individual.LMFAO ”he doesn’t know that the rinnesharingan exists”
Of course he would refer to it as a Rinnegan, to his knowledge the Rinnegan is the highest form of Visual Prowess and there exists nothing above it as far as Sasuke knows. He does however know that the Rinnegan can take on different shapes and looks, as seen with himself and Momoshiki. He has therefore no reason or possibility to believe that its anything but that.You’re incredibly stupid. Sasuke literally refers to 2 different Bijuu’s third eyes as Rinnegan in both the Naruto and Boruto panels I posted.![]()
Looks don't really amount to anything in terms of Ninjutsu. Which is why people with the Sharingan are so praised because they can actually deduct what kind of technique it is based on what they see with their Sharingan. Normal people cannot do that, hence they cannot judge a technique by its appearance. That and as I said, he has no knowledge of the existence of the Rinne-Sharingan, nor how it looks. There is no logical reason, or even possible reason for him to know that it isn't a Rinnegan.Absolutely nothing backs up your argument, not character dialog or anything. Sasuke literally sees the design on the moon and everything.
This is for starters a single instance of when a Technique, without seeing it several times it can just as well have been a mistake or just how said technique appears on the target. As we see when Sasuke casts Genjutsu on the Bijuu with his Rinnegan, their eyes takes the shape of his own unique Rinnegan and not the standard Rinnegan like what the Rinne-Sharingan resulted in. Hence we have two Genjutsu cast by two different people with different results, visually speaking.The Purple Rinnegan design literally shows up in the eyes of the populace further signifying that it’s a Rinnegan technique.![]()
Lmfao you could’ve just told me to edit out the insults of my most recent reply, instead of deleting it.Please watch your language people. Keep the argument to the point and skip personal attacks. If it continues your post will be deleted and you will be banned from the thread.
Avani spared you from garnering more embarrassment from those who haven’t yet read this thread by deleting those comments, but I screen recorded everything, your ignorance is forever reserved and will again manifest at my leisure.Well he doesn't, arguing that he does is just invalid as you cannot know that something exists if you have never seen, heard or even imagined it before. This also falls back to a point I made to you in another thread, that being the context of a character's knowledge within the story. No one aside from Kaguya and Madara have ever unlocked the Rinne-Sharingan to our knowledge and it's name has never been said by either individual.
There isn't a known written down story of the eye that gives it a name either. We as readers know it's name because we have out-of-world mediums such as the author or collaboration pieces that give us said information. Which leads into your second point;
Of course he would refer to it as a Rinnegan, to his knowledge the Rinnegan is the highest form of Visual Prowess and there exists nothing above it as far as Sasuke knows. He does however know that the Rinnegan can take on different shapes and looks, as seen with himself and Momoshiki. He has therefore no reason or possibility to believe that its anything but that.
Looks don't really amount to anything in terms of Ninjutsu. Which is why people with the Sharingan are so praised because they can actually deduct what kind of technique it is based on what they see with their Sharingan. Normal people cannot do that, hence they cannot judge a technique by its appearance. That and as I said, he has no knowledge of the existence of the Rinne-Sharingan, nor how it looks. There is no logical reason, or even possible reason for him to know that it isn't a Rinnegan.
This is for starters a single instance of when a Technique, without seeing it several times it can just as well have been a mistake or just how said technique appears on the target. As we see when Sasuke casts Genjutsu on the Bijuu with his Rinnegan, their eyes takes the shape of his own unique Rinnegan and not the standard Rinnegan like what the Rinne-Sharingan resulted in. Hence we have two Genjutsu cast by two different people with different results, visually speaking.
Logically speaking here this would confirm either one of a few things;
(1) That Madara didn't use the Rinne-Sharingan to cast the Genjutsu, but his own Rinnegan. (Severely unlikely)
(2) That when the Genjutsu is cast by the Rinne-Sharingan, the victims are shown with the standard Rinnegan as its a devolution of the Rinne-Sharingan. (More likely)
(3) It just how the Technique looks when cast. (Also high possibility)
Nowhere in here does it even come close to referring to this eye as a "Rinnegan" and the outside information we are so lucky to have qualifies it as a Kekkai Mora named Rinne-Sharingan as opposed to a Kekkai Genkai like the Rinnegan is classified. There is nothing in the canon material to confirm or deny this, so as I mentioned earlier when you spouting about your beloved Databook: As long as nothing contradicts the outside knowledge and it fits within the context of the story then it could and likely should be taken as canon.
On a final note about just taking one source as "undeniable facts" is in regards to Sasuke referring to it as "Rinnegan". So far he is the only person in the world who has directly referred to it as such, and given his limited knowledge it does make sense that he would.