[Game] [FIN] Round 8- Dracula Castle Madness Game

[The Cow]

To make sure I understand correctly, you're trying to convey that Misa's main suspect was Ryu but instead he voted Odd under the impression that this was plurality lynch and Waindo was going to get lynched. So, Misa's last minute vote could've been an attempt to save Waindo, making it an indicator that they're wolf buddies. Right?

Post automatically merged: Mar 17, 2019

But unless I understood his role incorrectly, wasn't Odd the vigilante? or are we entertaining the possibility of more than one vig?

Feels like there's either too many or too few deaths, ya know?

 

[Just_Red]

I also mentioned the possibility of someone shading Misa which might be the case here.

Define shading please.

To make sure I understand correctly, you're trying to convey that Misa's main suspect was Ryu but instead he voted Odd under the impression that this was plurality lynch and Waindo was going to get lynched. So, Misa's last minute vote could've been an attempt to save Waindo, making it an indicator that they're wolf buddies. Right?

Post automatically merged: Mar 17, 2019

But unless I understood his role incorrectly, wasn't Odd the vigilante? or are we entertaining the possibility of more than one vig?

Odd was town. What's vigilante?

 

[Mr.Lonely]

Define shading please.


Odd was town. What's vigilante?

The vig is a town role with the ability to night kill someone they think it's mafia, sorry if like a super hero.

 

[MadieV]

Yes, that was what I was thinking

It does make sense. I didn't think too much about it at first considering this was majority lynch and regardless of where he placed his vote, the day would end in a no lynch but I think you could be right about this.

 

[Mr.Lonely]

Sort of* my phone is sure making me mad

Post automatically merged: Mar 17, 2019

It does make sense. I didn't think too much about it at first considering this was majority lynch and regardless of where he placed his vote, the day would end in a no lynch but I think you could be right about this.

Of course, I knew it was majority as well but I think he didn't realize that.

 

[Waindo]

Truly your intellect is dizzying.

Not as much as your demeanor.

 

[The Cow]

The vig is a town role with the ability to night kill someone they think it's mafia, sorry if like a super hero.

Wolf vigis are possible but less common.

So vigi, serial killer, multiball. Something different. Doesn't matter overmuch at this very moment but worth keeping in mind.

 

[Mr.Lonely]

Wolf vigis are possible but less common.

So vigi, serial killer, multiball. Something different. Doesn't matter overmuch at this very moment but worth keeping in mind.

Yeah I suppose so, I haven't played enough games to experience that. Of course Odd was town, so he would be a town vig.

 

[MadieV]

Feels like there's either too many or too few deaths, ya know?

My theory is that Odd shot someone. The Odd I know definitely would have with that role.

 

[Mr.Lonely]

What I'm also curious about is who Odd targeted that resulted in his kill bouncing to someone else.

 

[Just_Red]

Gtg, study for stuff, I wont be on till tmw bye!!

 

[Mr.Lonely]

My theory is that Odd shot someone. The Odd I know definitely would have with that role.

Agreed, and who did he suspect the most

 

[The Cow]

Agreed, and who did he suspect the most

who knows

 

[MadieV]

Agreed, and who did he suspect the most

 

[Ansatsuken]

So what I think about Odd is right. He is Town. But before his alignment is confirmed he could be Town/Serial Killer. But it leans toward town for me.

I think Odd is a town.

Nothing people here do would change his approach in Mafia game.

He didn't care whether he is a wolf or town, but that's how he plays.

But giving a list of players and then leave it just like that means two possibility:-

a)He is a Town

b)He is a Serial Killer.

Both give him a lot of room to make a maneuver/change in approach and giving out a list of players.

But when he played as a Mafia, he doesn't have a freedom to do all these.

^^^^^
How I read his Meta.
________________

And I think the killing of Odd had something to do with an attempt to frame/throwing a shade to people who were suspecting him in the last DP.

 

[Waindo]

Agreed, and who did he suspect the most

You.

 

[LanMisa]

Okay, I have read up on the posts this phase so far and there are some things I'd like to say:

1) I.... did not realise what kind of lynch system we were operating under. As some people might have expected I misunderstood the majority lynch at EOD for the more common plurality lynch. I was shocked to see SleepingTerror die, especially since she had a role that was basically doing exactly what just happened (change the lynch to something else) and was thinking all night phase about who did that and what kind of motivation that player had to swap Odd with Sleeping, of all the people, and who could have used that power.... until I read your guys posts about the lynch system, did some googling on the meaning of majority/plurality and now I feel pretty dumb.
2) With that being said I REALLY can't overstate how bad it is that nobody even showed up for EOD! As the flips show we deal with a LOT of non-town killing power, we just lost one of our own in Odd, it seems, and we didn't get a single one of the 4-5 scum yet. It's getting even HARDER to get any lynch done - but if we don't lynch at all, scum just kills us during the night and we lose the game without any fight! Please, if people can't be around EOD, they should say so before that we can try to get a proper wagon going in time. As was seen, starting shortly before EOD did... not lead us anywhere.
3) I don't remember Evan being scumread by anybody in the game, so I strongly assume that he was not killed by town. Because of that I think that at the very least one scum player is from outside this forum.
4) Since it was brought up: I didn't shoot at Odd, but I won't lie that I would have. Mostly because I completely misunderstood the rules and thought up until half an hour ago that he was "saved" from the lynch. I didn't fear Odd; all he did was claim my guilt without even trying to present arguments nor to convince others of his mysterious reads. Him dying town makes me suspect of the people who protected him the strongest though; there was not a single good reason to heavily read him town, he did nothing towny and as people said, every behaviour that he showed he had apparently also shown as non-town roles. Thus I still heavily suspect Ryu of knowing more than he should have and being a scum team member trying to pocket Odd.

Post automatically merged: Mar 17, 2019

What I'm also curious about is who Odd targeted that resulted in his kill bouncing to someone else.

Why do you think that Odd's kill was bounced?

 

[Waindo]

This is turning out to be pretty self-explanatory and right under our noses, If Odd targeted anyone last night, I think he targeted Mr. Lonely.

 

[Eliphas]

Okay, I have read up on the posts this phase so far and there are some things I'd like to say:

1) I.... did not realise what kind of lynch system we were operating under. As some people might have expected I misunderstood the majority lynch at EOD for the more common plurality lynch. I was shocked to see SleepingTerror die, especially since she had a role that was basically doing exactly what just happened (change the lynch to something else) and was thinking all night phase about who did that and what kind of motivation that player had to swap Odd with Sleeping, of all the people, and who could have used that power.... until I read your guys posts about the lynch system, did some googling on the meaning of majority/plurality and now I feel pretty dumb.
2) With that being said I REALLY can't overstate how bad it is that nobody even showed up for EOD! As the flips show we deal with a LOT of non-town killing power, we just lost one of our own in Odd, it seems, and we didn't get a single one of the 4-5 scum yet. It's getting even HARDER to get any lynch done - but if we don't lynch at all, scum just kills us during the night and we lose the game without any fight! Please, if people can't be around EOD, they should say so before that we can try to get a proper wagon going in time. As was seen, starting shortly before EOD did... not lead us anywhere.
3) I don't remember Evan being scumread by anybody in the game, so I strongly assume that he was not killed by town. Because of that I think that at the very least one scum player is from outside this forum.
4) Since it was brought up: I didn't shoot at Odd, but I won't lie that I would have. Mostly because I completely misunderstood the rules and thought up until half an hour ago that he was "saved" from the lynch. I didn't fear Odd; all he did was claim my guilt without even trying to present arguments nor to convince others of his mysterious reads. Him dying town makes me suspect of the people who protected him the strongest though; there was not a single good reason to heavily read him town, he did nothing towny and as people said, every behaviour that he showed he had apparently also shown as non-town roles. Thus I still heavily suspect Ryu of knowing more than he should have and being a scum team member trying to pocket Odd.

Post automatically merged: Mar 17, 2019

Why do you think that Odd's kill was bounced?

Not knowing him, and basing it strictly on his play, I would say it was one of the ones on his list.

 

[Mr.Lonely]

Okay, I have read up on the posts this phase so far and there are some things I'd like to say:

1) I.... did not realise what kind of lynch system we were operating under. As some people might have expected I misunderstood the majority lynch at EOD for the more common plurality lynch. I was shocked to see SleepingTerror die, especially since she had a role that was basically doing exactly what just happened (change the lynch to something else) and was thinking all night phase about who did that and what kind of motivation that player had to swap Odd with Sleeping, of all the people, and who could have used that power.... until I read your guys posts about the lynch system, did some googling on the meaning of majority/plurality and now I feel pretty dumb.
2) With that being said I REALLY can't overstate how bad it is that nobody even showed up for EOD! As the flips show we deal with a LOT of non-town killing power, we just lost one of our own in Odd, it seems, and we didn't get a single one of the 4-5 scum yet. It's getting even HARDER to get any lynch done - but if we don't lynch at all, scum just kills us during the night and we lose the game without any fight! Please, if people can't be around EOD, they should say so before that we can try to get a proper wagon going in time. As was seen, starting shortly before EOD did... not lead us anywhere.
3) I don't remember Evan being scumread by anybody in the game, so I strongly assume that he was not killed by town. Because of that I think that at the very least one scum player is from outside this forum.
4) Since it was brought up: I didn't shoot at Odd, but I won't lie that I would have. Mostly because I completely misunderstood the rules and thought up until half an hour ago that he was "saved" from the lynch. I didn't fear Odd; all he did was claim my guilt without even trying to present arguments nor to convince others of his mysterious reads. Him dying town makes me suspect of the people who protected him the strongest though; there was not a single good reason to heavily read him town, he did nothing towny and as people said, every behaviour that he showed he had apparently also shown as non-town roles. Thus I still heavily suspect Ryu of knowing more than he should have and being a scum team member trying to pocket Odd.

Post automatically merged: Mar 17, 2019

Why do you think that Odd's kill was bounced?

Because he targeted the person connected to Evan who dies when Vlad the Impaler is attempted to be killed.