[Game] Naruto Mafia Game [Game Thread]

[Apriori]

Do you think Sagebee could be Mafia?

Dont ask other question to me, just answer my question first. After you answered it we can move to the next question. And this has something to do with your 'test'.

Yes, I believe Sage could be Mafia.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Yes, I believe Sage could be Mafia.

Ok, and what is your opinion when he votes Odd if you think Odd is also a mafia? Yes he has stated his reason before. He voted Odd not out of suspicion but just to tie the vote. But still I want to hear your opinion on that.

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

I meant this one,

Ehh is there alot of scum or just dumb players

Right now dragomir is most suspicious to me because he doesnt even reply back

Vote lynch: odd

Reason just to make the vote even

 

[Apriori]

Ok, and what is your opinion when he votes Odd if you think Odd is also a mafia? Yes he has stated his reason before. He voted Odd not out of suspicion but just to tie the vote. But still I want to hear your opinion on that.

Sage voting Odd, as means to tie, can very well be an attempt to stalemate the lynch. In my history of playing the game, tie lynch votes results in no death for the day.

Sage isn't trying to save his life, but save Odd's life. Why do I suspect both despite Sage voting or Odd, if both turn out to be Mafia? The order of events went from suspecting Odd with a fast train towards his death to an immediate hard shift on wanting to lynch Sage.

Sage "panicked" too quick over practically nothing and has spent most of day phase repeating explanations that do nothing to justify his behavior. His explanations shed light to his behavior, but does not convince me at least why his behavior should be excusable.

If you ask me, it was a poor attempt to justify and perhaps too poor. So poor that Odd's abilities surpass Sage, thus Sage is tributing his life to keep Odd around.

Not much information is solid considering its the first day phase.

 

[JojocIaw]

Sage voting Odd, as means to tie, can very well be an attempt to stalemate the lynch. In my history of playing the game, tie lynch votes results in no death for the day.

Sage isn't trying to save his life, but save Odd's life. Why do I suspect both despite Sage voting or Odd, if both turn out to be Mafia? The order of events went from suspecting Odd with a fast train towards his death to an immediate hard shift on wanting to lynch Sage.

Sage "panicked" too quick over practically nothing and has spent most of day phase repeating explanations that do nothing to justify his behavior. His explanations shed light to his behavior, but does not convince me at least why his behavior should be excusable.

If you ask me, it was a poor attempt to justify and perhaps too poor. So poor that Odd's abilities surpass Sage, thus Sage is tributing his life to keep Odd around.

Not much information is solid considering its the first day phase.

I too believe he was merely distancing himself. I suspected odd in a earlier post. (I'll have to go and read everything because i forgot why lmao)

 

[Finalbeta]

Is it just me or I noticed Sagebee and Gister do have quite similar playstyles in this game?

Both didn't read the most basic stuffs and acted OMGUS in several situations and also they don't seem to be in adversion one each other.

However they are voting different players, it would have been different if they didn't.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Sage voting Odd, as means to tie, can very well be an attempt to stalemate the lynch. In my history of playing the game, tie lynch votes results in no death for the day.

Sage isn't trying to save his life, but save Odd's life. Why do I suspect both despite Sage voting or Odd, if both turn out to be Mafia? The order of events went from suspecting Odd with a fast train towards his death to an immediate hard shift on wanting to lynch Sage.

Sage "panicked" too quick over practically nothing and has spent most of day phase repeating explanations that do nothing to justify his behavior. His explanations shed light to his behavior, but does not convince me at least why his behavior should be excusable.

If you ask me, it was a poor attempt to justify and perhaps too poor. So poor that Odd's abilities surpass Sage, thus Sage is tributing his life to keep Odd around.

Not much information is solid considering its the first day phase.

Ok that theory is reasonable.

I can understand the working mechanism behind it. Its possible because I've seen something similar in many games before. Its called as distancing or trace killing, I like to called it as diversion play. Just a very sharp players can see that move.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Is it just me or I noticed Sagebee and Gister do have quite similar playstyles in this game?

Both didn't read the most basic stuffs and acted OMGUS in several situations and also they don't seem to be in adversion one each other.

However they are voting different players, it would have been different if they didn't.

So it could be Sagebee saw how poor Gister's playing style in this game, his playing style could get him into a problem if not now, it can be later on. That poor playing style has affected Sagebee the most amongst all Mafia mates. He then saw Ansatsuken put him inside his suspicious list which Sagebee think that is not a good prospect. Anytime he could get caught. He panicked and started voting Ansatsuken and not engaged in discussion first. With hope he can convinced players to look into Ansatsuken's actions. But from all the players in this game he only alerted Ansatsuken's other suspicious candidates in Gutsy and Starboy. I think one of the two could be a scum. Why he's not calling for Gister? It because its too risky for them(mafia). Better kept the distance since people doesn't aware yet.

That is my simple theory.

 

[MadieV]

First off calm down, you are making yourself an easy target for some quality players

Secondly spotting Dragomir in a conversation is angleshooting, don't do it. It's using out of game knowledge to effect in game flow. I've seen it backfire everytime and it's generally considered a bad move

And thirdly don't vote me, vote for who you find suspicious. I could vote you up to save my own skin if I wanted but I think you are town so I'm not going to do that

Vote Lynch MadieV
Reason: I just have a really bad feeling that she is Mafia, going with my gut here

Interesting developments

You must be registered for see images

Looks like I found the lynch I want to commit to.

Vote Lynch: Junegirl_19

This vote stays until she can provide a convincing reason on why she was suspicious of sagebee. If she flips mafia, Odd, my friend, I'm coming after you ~

 

[Alubama]

Is it just me or I noticed Sagebee and Gister do have quite similar playstyles in this game?

Both didn't read the most basic stuffs and acted OMGUS in several situations and also they don't seem to be in adversion one each other.

However they are voting different players, it would have been different if they didn't.

I'm feeling the same way about this, whats suprising tho is that gister hasn't replied or showed his opinion about anything since the heat is off his back, which makes him more scummy to me.
I guess he feels safe now that everyone is focusing on sage.

I feel like Apriori is telling the true because a lot of thing that he stated made sense and i agree on.

Sage isn't trying to save his life, but save Odd's life. Why do I suspect both despite Sage voting or Odd, if both turn out to be Mafia? The order of events went from suspecting Odd with a fast train towards his death to an immediate hard shift on wanting to lynch Sage

. And for Ansa I don't know, hard to read. I'm a bit suspicious of you as well, you seem like you are helping the townies, but to be fair the only thing you are doing is keep the heat on one or two suspects whilst trying to manipulate the game your way with fast and elaborate answers that make logical sense. you have a good way around words and defending yourself.

I'm having a hard time keeping up with everything as this is my first game ever, but i'm doing my best.

And do we really want a tie lynch don't forget;

• Plurality Lynch - The player with the most votes at the end of the Day phase will get lynched. If there's a tie, either both the players will be lynched or a player who got the maximum votes first would be lynched.

This makes me suspect some people who are going for a tie, its a long stretched theory but could result in one good lynch for the mafia or a double if played like a pro.

 

[Sagebee]

Gister appears very scummy to me. His aggressive behavior at the beginning of D1, repetition of why he is not part of mafia this game (why would you keep explaining that when you have to focus on scum hunting and not repeating yourself that you are not the bad guy) seem too much and very suspicious to me. His suspicion and putting Koto (a confirmed townie) in the scum list is another evidence that screams 'scum.'
It is interesting to see what other players are saying about certain people's behaviors from previous games they played together. The play style changes and roles are given randomly, however, it is not a bad idea to keep an eye for the difference in behavior. I haven't played with Odd before, but players say he seems different this game. It is something to consider.
And the more I read into it, I see Odd defending Gister, what a lovely coincidence, he is trying to save his mafia buddy. Wow, it is all right in front of us, just see it and act on it. It is so obvious.
And Gister was asking about role revealing earlier in the game even though it is prohibited. Is he trying to get somebody who hasn't read the rules to role claim and get role blocked because of it?
His overall behavior does not sit right with me.


I am still on page 10 and giving my thoughts up until then, so keep that in mind guys, please

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

Madie mentioned the day actions. I think they are presented to get players talking and into more discussions, that's my guess.

I am not liking people who choose to do 'No vote', it isn't a good sign and makes me question you because after so much discussion you can find the suspect based on posts and lynch that suspect. This way we have a better idea for the next dayphase who to look for and start creating chains of who is who. It gives results and it is necessary.

Ansatsuken and Sagebee's interaction is quite interesting. He mentioned Sagebee was a mafia in another game and hasn't posted much, and seeing how defensive Sagebee became once he got a vote for him tells me to keep an eye on Sagebee. And I see that after the vote, Sagebee quickly voted for Ansatsuken which is odd since he didn't state the reason other than 'Ansatsuken finds me suspicious after I only posted a few things and votes me out of nowhere'
Sagebee is another one who hasn't even noticed Koto be a confirmed townie. How do you guys play the game if you don't pay attention or read other players' posts!? His reaction to accusations are not making him look good, not at all.He then proceeds into argumanets with Drago with weak reasoning, or better yet, lack of reasoning, and makes himself appear even scummier. Moreover, he goes further and puts his suspicion only on people who voted for him, like really! Wow, what a ...play.

Vote lynch: Sagebee
Reason: Described above

Apriori mentioning Koto as his top 3 suspects, hmmm.And then he says he missed it and has never seen it in a mafia game. @Apriori seems you have played mafia before, haven't you? If you have, you would have seen actions as player reveals throughout, it is very common in a game. It is odd that you said you played before but you weren't familiar with that. All that applies if you played the game before. Hence my question.


This is only the beginning, and this game is really exciting, I am enjoying it. The hosts are doing a great job!

Why voting for Madie all of a sudden? Only because you have a feeling she is scum? That is not the valid reason, maybe you can give evidence to make your reasoning stronger, otherwise it looks very odd

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

I am all caught up, finally

Again voted for ansta because found his move putting strong suspicion suss

And no I didnt put suspicion on people for just putting suspicion on me I explained alot

But if you want me to repeat reply

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

And people reacting to such accusation differs between each other. Not many players went straight voting the player who said that player is very suspicious to him. Most players tried to engage in conversation first. It applies into any type of situation, be it 2/3 posts or more than 20 posts. I based my suspicion not on the number of post you have but my hunch. This is a random role distribution game and not based on players experience, so anything is possible.

Yes I dont think its an overreaction but just a feeling of insecure within yourself. The insecurity must be because of something. I never pushed any read or observation or any case on you even after I put you inside my most suspicious list. I'm focusing on other matters altogether at that times. You're not the only Mafia(if you're really a Mafia) that exist in this game in the sense. As you're not yet made any big move in this game after your three posts I need to focus on the active one.

If you're mafia all these heeds mean nothing but if you're really a townie we will take your suggestion. But how could we know that you're not bluffing around with all these heeds? The thing I like about mafia game is reading player's no hope/last hope post such as that. It can be genuine or it can be nothing. But look at the stage of this game right now its still early in the game so I think it could be a genuine claim/statement. But one way to test Sagebee and his statement is by asking him to vote his most suspicious one. If he hesitate means he is afraid of getting caught wrong. It because if he made a wrong move(lynching a townie) people will put their focus on him in the next round. His most suspicious one right now is Dragomir. He voted Odd just to tie the tally. Waiting for your response Sagebee

Ft.

And people reacting to such accusation differs between each other. Not many players went straight voting the player who said that player is very suspicious to him. Most players tried to engage in conversation first. It applies into any type of situation, be it 2/3 posts or more than 20 posts. I based my suspicion not on the number of post you have but my hunch. This is a random role distribution game and not based on players experience, so anything is possible.

Yes I dont think its an overreaction but just a feeling of insecure within yourself. The insecurity must be because of something. I never pushed any read or observation or any case on you even after I put you inside my most suspicious list. I'm focusing on other matters altogether at that times. You're not the only Mafia(if you're really a Mafia) that exist in this game in the sense. As you're not yet made any big move in this game after your three posts I need to focus on the active one.

Well thanks for understanding the reason which I stick by only difference is I wouldn't do it again because I've given mafia an excuse to swarm.

As for your post below reason I say I dont fit mafia logic for one I've given my self exercise to put a target on my back even if I get past day one this target will still be there. And maybe my potential mafia teammates might not come to help fight for me but absolutely no one defended.

But main reason I wouldnt put attention on myself in first day phase even if suspicion was put on me.

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

@Odd I'm going to change the vote to dragomir so you flip the vote to him to tie to someone else

Vote lynch: dragomir

Reasons I find him most suspicious explanation given earlier

And if I get lynched at least pay attention to what I said before

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

Current votes 4 sagebee
1 final beta
1 odd
1 June
1 dragomir
1 madiev

 

[Odd]

Interesting developments

You must be registered for see images

Looks like I found the lynch I want to commit to.

Vote Lynch: Junegirl_19

This vote stays until she can provide a convincing reason on why she was suspicious of sagebee. If she flips mafia, Odd, my friend, I'm coming after you ~

This scares me

 

[Shanks]

OK sorry to be late...
Vote lynch : odd

OH SHIT SAGEBEE LOOKING SUS



This feels like a mafia panic


So instead if being suspected, you want to be the MOST suspicious?
:hmm:



He's answered your question. It's literally a hunch. This a OMGUS vote. You finding Nemo fishy rn IMO. Let's apply pressure.

Vote Lynch : Sagebee

Not really. I just find it odd that his post odd as he played a game where a confirmed role was basically unconfirmed after a day action.

Oh, forgot to put this in my previous post

Vote lynch Sagebee


Lul, he officially reached meme status.

That was a lot o read. People are drawing references from the previous game. I think Gister is not a scum. He has clinged to 'Naruto' I think I am gonna believe him. Butt he might be in trouble, even though he said scums can't do anything, he revealed his abilities if the hosts roleblocks him , he might even get killed.
I am not liking Sagebee. I can't quote down all his posts . but I have a feeling he is not a town. I think Ansatlun is Town.

Vote Lynch: Sagebee
Reason: She is scummy

First off calm down, you are making yourself an easy target for some quality players

Secondly spotting Dragomir in a conversation is angleshooting, don't do it. It's using out of game knowledge to effect in game flow. I've seen it backfire everytime and it's generally considered a bad move

And thirdly don't vote me, vote for who you find suspicious. I could vote you up to save my own skin if I wanted but I think you are town so I'm not going to do that

Vote Lynch MadieV
Reason: I just have a really bad feeling that she is Mafia, going with my gut here

I personally think Gister's way of playing is rather boring and lame. Revealing that much info (and it be true) is damaging to the game on many levels and I feel deserves punishment on principle. You are not a good player if you have to resort to damn near copy/paste your given character.

Either way. I request one thing. Do not allow the votes to accumulate on "Odd". You may ask why and I completely understand if this post seems scummy. I am currently testing something. My test will be ruin if he is killed and revealed to be town. I am also betting on the write up to reveal some information. If my hunches check out, town we are off to a great start.

As to ensure my test is actually taken. I shall place my vote on the leading name.

Vote Lynch: Sagebee

Interesting developments

You must be registered for see images

Looks like I found the lynch I want to commit to.

Vote Lynch: Junegirl_19

This vote stays until she can provide a convincing reason on why she was suspicious of sagebee. If she flips mafia, Odd, my friend, I'm coming after you ~

I will be considering these votes has it has been formatted correctly according to rules

Votes so far :​

@Junegirl_19 - 1 vote
@Sagebee -4 votes
@Odd -1 vote
@MadieV 1 vote

 

[Sagebee]

I personally think Gister's way of playing is rather boring and lame. Revealing that much info (and it be true) is damaging to the game on many levels and I feel deserves punishment on principle. You are not a good player if you have to resort to damn near copy/paste your given character.

Either way. I request one thing. Do not allow the votes to accumulate on "Odd". You may ask why and I completely understand if this post seems scummy. I am currently testing something. My test will be ruin if he is killed and revealed to be town. I am also betting on the write up to reveal some information. If my hunches check out, town we are off to a great start.

As to ensure my test is actually taken. I shall place my vote on the leading name.

Vote Lynch: Sagebee

What does odd not dying have to do with you lynching me

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

I will be considering these votes has it has been formatted correctly according to rules

Votes so far :​

@Junegirl_19 - 1 vote
@Sagebee -4 votes
@Odd -1 vote
@MadieV 1 vote

So votes not formatted correctly dont count?

 

[Ansatsuken]

I'm feeling the same way about this, whats suprising tho is that gister hasn't replied or showed his opinion about anything since the heat is off his back, which makes him more scummy to me.
I guess he feels safe now that everyone is focusing on sage.

I feel like Apriori is telling the true because a lot of thing that he stated made sense and i agree on.

Sage isn't trying to save his life, but save Odd's life. Why do I suspect both despite Sage voting or Odd, if both turn out to be Mafia? The order of events went from suspecting Odd with a fast train towards his death to an immediate hard shift on wanting to lynch Sage

. And for Ansa I don't know, hard to read. I'm a bit suspicious of you as well, you seem like you are helping the townies, but to be fair the only thing you are doing is keep the heat on one or two suspects whilst trying to manipulate the game your way with fast and elaborate answers that make logical sense. you have a good way around words and defending yourself.

I'm having a hard time keeping up with everything as this is my first game ever, but i'm doing my best.

And do we really want a tie lynch don't forget;

• Plurality Lynch - The player with the most votes at the end of the Day phase will get lynched. If there's a tie, either both the players will be lynched or a player who got the maximum votes first would be lynched.

This makes me suspect some people who are going for a tie, its a long stretched theory but could result in one good lynch for the mafia or a double if played like a pro.

Actually its not keeping the heat on one or two suspects. And I'm not manipulating anything here. But what I do most of the times are gathering an informations or opinions. Some players here already made up their mind and vote. In the previous game I didn't take too long to cast my vote. And the result was my town member(Gister) get lynched. So in this game I took a time before I cast my vote.

 

[Shanks]

Latest vote update

@Sagebee - 3 votes
@Junegirl_19 - 1 vote
@Dragomir - 1 vote
@Odd - 1 vote

PS: Dragomir's , odd , Gisters vote format is incorrect so not counted.

 

[Sagebee]

Is no one going to comment

 

[Ansatsuken]

Again voted for ansta because found his move putting strong suspicion suss

And no I didnt put suspicion on people for just putting suspicion on me I explained alot

But if you want me to repeat reply

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

Ft.
Well thanks for understanding the reason which I stick by only difference is I wouldn't do it again because I've given mafia an excuse to swarm.

As for your post below reason I say I dont fit mafia logic for one I've given my self exercise to put a target on my back even if I get past day one this target will still be there. And maybe my potential mafia teammates might not come to help bite for me but absolutely no one defended.

But main reason I wouldnt put attention on myself in first day phase even if suspicion was put on me.

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

@Odd I'm going to change the vote to dragomir so you flip the vote to him to tie to someone else

Vote lynch: dragomir

Reasons I find him most suspicious explanation given earlier

And if I get lynched at least pay attention to what I said before

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

Current votes 4 sagebee
1 final beta
1 odd
1 June
1 dragomir
1 madiev

@bold, I'm not sure if I understand that part but can you elaborate it further?

 

[Sagebee]

@bold, I'm not sure if I understand that part but can you elaborate it further?

You mean my lynch for dragomir?

I initially just suspected him with what I see as weak reasoning and being uncooperative to discuss. He became a strong mafia target for me when it seemed like he was colluding and out of everyone the strongest in wanting to push lynch.

 

[Ansatsuken]

You mean my lynch for dragomir?

I initially just suspected him with what I see as weak reasoning and being uncooperative to discuss. He became a strong mafia target for me when it seemed like he was colluding and out of everyone the strongest in wanting to push lynch.

Umm...not that part but this one

"And maybe my potential mafia teammates might not come to help bite for me but absolutely no one defended."

 

[Junegirl_19]

This is day 1. And I don't know exactly whom to suspect the most. In this chaos, Sagebee has been doubting Koto. Bu Koto is role revealed. Why bother then? He might be trying to Lynch a townie. I found him strange and aggressive. That is what sounded in my head. That is why I voted him.

Post automatically merged: Jan 29, 2019

I think Ansatsuken, Gister and odd are town.