Who has the better BATTLE INTELLECT? Itachi or Minato?

[Rikudou Tobi]

Itachi no contest.

You must be registered for see images

 

[shelke]

About as valid as your excuse for Sasuke talking while 4ft away from obito.

He's lucky he didn't get grabbed mid-sentence.

That is the databook's statement, not mine.

So, a shitty Kunai user it is. None of your made-up excuses mean much.

 

[To Whatever]

That is the databook's statement, not mine.

So, a shitty Kunai user it is. None of your made-up excuses mean much.

Wait, you admit Sasuke is a dumbass for that?

Well shit. I don't even like Minato like that so i'll take that as a win ha ha.

 

[shelke]

Wait, you admit Sasuke is a dumbass for that?

Well shit. I don't even like Minato like that so i'll take that as a win ha ha.

You admit Minato can't throw for shit? As you seemed to have presented nothing other than whine, man.

 

[JKakano]

Took him few seconds to figure out Obito's ability. While it took others hours.

few seconds? rubbish! He still don't know some of it. Itachi is same thou battle and pick up quickly. Minato couldn't figure out of obito enter itachi could.

 

[gerizzyYMcrew]

minato's plans for naruto worked...itachi's plans for sasuke failed more times than not

 

[Omar19992010]

I don't know why people are trying to downplay Minato.

He figured out Kamui on the spot and managed to beat Obito something that took everybody else 600 chapters and he came up with a battle strategy in order for Guy to land a hit on Madara.

 

[To Whatever]

You admit Minato can't throw for shit? As you seemed to have presented nothing other than whine, man.

I'll answer if you answer. :|

Be honest. That shit he did in vote 2 and against obito was borderline retardation

 

[JKakano]

minato's plans for naruto worked...itachi's plans for sasuke failed more times than not

What are you talking about? Minato failed too. Its just their saying. Its their path not itachi or minato. Itachi did too come ip quickly with nagato. My view itachi is better. Minato failed with obito lol

 

[shelke]

I'll answer if you answer. :|

Be honest. That shit he did in vote 2 and against obito was borderline retardation

Still lights years better than not being able to throw a few Kunais close to a target. And that too, from a ****ing Hokage. Who even made him a Chunin, let alone a Jounin ... and then that Hokage seat? Hiruzen was desperate, it seems.

 

[Waltz]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

Not the most intelligent way to engage a Kage level Uchiha wielding the Sharingan knowing that eye contact subjects you to being affected by Genjutsu. ​

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

In General? They were both prodigy's in their own right. Comparing Itachi solving the Edo Tensei was not simple due to his analytic ability but it was as equally due to him having the right tools to counter the Jutsu after understanding it's workings. There's nothing to say that Minato would have been unable to do the same if he had the said tool; Izanami, However the Manga portrays Minato having to invest a lot more thought process and time into analyzing and countering presented situations as opposed to Itachi and not only that, the Manga made it very clear that Itachi's knowledge overall greatly succeeds Minato's and adding that to his greater ability to apply this knowledge as well as his skills in presented combat scenarios indicates that he should be much more battle intelligent. Based on what is shown in the Manga we can easily say that Minato would fall for Itachi's Genjutsu because despite being cognizant of the Sharingan's abilities he faces Sharingan wielding opponents by continuously maintaining eye contact with them, which in context is more so a sloppy fighting style but on the other hand there's no way his FTG tactic's would not work on Itachi, or at least not easily or with moderate diffcultiy----with Itachi being cognizant of the Jutsu as his fighting style in every single scenario in the Manga minimizes the most obvious risk's to the greatest extent. ​

 

[gerizzyYMcrew]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

Not the most intelligent way to engage a Kage level Uchiha wielding the Sharingan knowing that eye contact subjects you to being affected by Genjutsu. ​

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

In General? They were both prodigy's in their own right. Comparing Itachi solving the Edo Tensei was not simple due to his analytic ability but it was as equally due to him having the right tools to counter the Jutsu after understanding it's workings. There's nothing to say that Minato would have been unable to do the same if he had the said tool; Izanami, However the Manga portrays Minato having to invest a lot more thought process and time into analyzing and countering presented situations as opposed to Itachi and not only that, the Manga made it very clear that Itachi's knowledge overall greatly succeeds Minato's and adding that to his greater ability to apply this knowledge as well as his skills in presented combat scenarios indicates that he should be much more battle intelligent. Based on what is shown in the Manga we can easily say that Minato would fall for Itachi's Genjutsu because despite being cognizant of the Sharingan's abilities he faces Sharingan wielding opponents by continuously maintaining eye contact with them, which in context is more so a sloppy fighting style but on the other hand there's no way his FTG tactic's would not work on Itachi, or at least not easily or with moderate diffcultiy----with Itachi being cognizant of the Jutsu as his fighting style in every single scenario in the Manga minimizes the most obvious risk's to the greatest extent. ​

bullshit

 

[gerizzyYMcrew]

What are you talking about? Minato failed too. Its just their saying. Its their path not itachi or minato. Itachi did too come ip quickly with nagato. My view itachi is better. Minato failed with obito lol

how did minato's plans for naruto failed?

 

[Tyris]

Minato easily.

not even if there was a fire x'D

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

not even if there was a fire x'D

Itachi's only intelligent feat is mind ****ing his brother.

 

[Prince Badman]

To be honest its very difficult to compare the two.....both were intellectual, smart and often were able to foresee things that were beyond others......I would place Minato over Itachi because Minato's judgement was much closer in actual than Itachi. Minato predicted Obito's plans and he adamantly sealed Kyubi inside his own son believing that its power would be requisite for defeating the masked man which actually proved true. Itachi's action on the other hand many times seem debatable and often we will find it questionable whether the actions he took were actually worth it. I will say Itachi sacrificed a lot for the village but his decisions regarding Sasuke turned out to be crap whose protection was his main motive. Minato on the other hand, call it the plot armour, had his actions justified at crucial points. Sealing his own chakra into nine tail seal, sealing Kushina's chakra into it too so Naruto could be helped in controlling Kyubi's power, those actually turned out to be master strokes. They both are almost equal but due to more sensible decision making and i say it relatively i will put Minato ahead.

 

[Tyris]

Itachi's only intelligent feat is mind ****ing NV.

fixed

 

[LoZelda101]

minato's plans for naruto worked...itachi's plans for sasuke failed more times than not

Lmao wow. Give your son a freebee powerup. Such a difficult genius plan that only elite shinobis would thought of. Kappa

 

[lndra]

Itachiiiiiii sempaiiiiiiiiiaiaiiaiaiaia

 

[gerizzyYMcrew]

Lmao wow. Give your son a freebee powerup. Such a difficult genius plan that only elite shinobis would thought of. Kappa

funny how a simple plan such as that beat out anything itachi had in mind for sasuke