If Hinata and Sakura fought in the chuunin exams

Keimil

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
1,851
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Anime always depicted the chakra as blue, yet now her chakra is purple.




Yes, it does. As it could very easily be said he's infusing his attacks w/ bijuu chakra for the orange one's and not doing so for the blue ones.



Already told you the diffrence, one is blue, other is purple. Why is the latter purple, unlike blue as the former is? Diffrent chakra.



And yet you're okay w/ presuming Sakura can unblock chakra points despite it never being shown or said.

At least w/ Hinata's case, there are hints, such as her chakra changing colour from blue to purple, her attack having a different name despite looking the exact same as TLF other than colour, and her actually meeting Hamura.



This isn't even an argument Lol



The Jesus man already did that, try again. What was the point of Hamura showing up if the other dude already explained everything?



Her chakra was blue before this. So yes, it did change.



I dare you to find a single scan that states that Sakura can unblock chakra points.

See what I did there? :rolleyes: Hypocrite

I don't need to give a scan anyways, as it as already shown her lion fists attack went from blue to purple, what's the answer for this? Only obvious answer is that she recieved a diffrent kind of chakra.




It means his descendants, those that have his DNA can damage it.




He didn't, he simply powered up Hinata's attack.



That's like saying all Uzumakis have Hagoromo's chakra, when we all know it's not the same as what happened to NAruto in particular.



You tend to do that a lot w/ your Yin seal theory, y'know?



Chakra was still shown to be the same as the anime [blue] as shown by Naruto's rasengan being blue. Therefore, this would mean Hinata's chakra is still blue, like in the anime, and turned purple after meeting Hamura.

Moreover, it's clear more than anything else that the movie follows the coloration of the anime and not the manga, so that only further shows that Hinata's TLF being purple is not some mere design choice.



One is blue, other is purple. Yet they have the same function> Why's one blue and the other purple ? It's because of Hamura's chakra being infused into it.



It's funny how when you want, Hinata's feats are "only for romantic purposes" yet when you want, her feats are "nothing but fact"

If her flying is for romantic purposes, than her being saved by Naruto and being caught by Naruto are also done for nothing but romance and should not be


Actions speak louder than words, we saw her fly, so there's no need to say she can.



Kishi didn't have full control over the movie Lol





Oh, just like how it's fact Hinata was shown flying? yet here you are denying it, yelling about it being for romance and atmosphere, yet going on to say every other romantic scene is completely valid in feats. Make up your mind.



Gonna leave this here, because I already explained this

All which happened before she got the chakra. And even if she did, this still doesn't disprove that she wasn't flying at the end of the movie when they kissed. Who's to say she didn't figure it out at that exact moment? Naruto was initially falling into Kaguya's lava pit and had to get saved by Sasuke, didn't he?

Yet a few seconds later, he was flying, because he grasped it at that exact moment. Same could be said for Hinata's case; She gained the chakra, but learned to fly later




Always depending on that slow-mo argument, eh?

Let me repeat myself, because you seem to like avoiding questions.

If it was slow motion, the snow wouldn't be falling as it was, and if it was slow motion, Hinata would still have her hair flowing upwards due to the wind. If it was slow motion, they would not have been in the exact same place for 30 seconds without even a shred of hint that they have moved even one inch downwards.

Again, What kind of indication do you have for me to believe they were 'falling very slowly' ? Why are they falling very slowly to begin with? Why should I believe this when everything I pointed out goes against it and that we know they're back on earth.



In the same context as how all the Uzumaki have Hagoromo's chakra, yet the chakra Naruto got from Hagoromo is not the same.



Yeah



chakra went from blue to purple. Explain this.



30 seconds of footage w/ absolutely no indication of down ward movement [yet rather, there was sideways movement] disagree w/ this.



Yes

no

look at her abilities section on her page, just above the Dojutsu part.



Still Hinata's, because she has Byakugan [it wasn't activated in that scene] and 64 palms shows her reflexes are better and more precise





Just showing how it was on par in abilities to Kuaram, who is 1/9th the Juubi's. And we already saw how many times inferior Kurama was to the Juubi. So it's not hard to belive the Juubi is superiro to the golem [no shit Lol] .



Except the one Sakura reacted to was an unstable form of the Juubi, while the one hinata reacted to was the V2 Juubi, and it was stable.

Stable form > Unstable form, naturally.



You must be registered for see images





Sakura also had a surprise bubble, that just means the two noticed the enemy. Not to mention, as I said before, she was in a battle pose, getting ready to take them on, and she fell on her knees because Naruto knocked her down.



Again, Naruto knocked Hinata down, it wouldn't have happened if he hadn't showed up.


i wasn't refering to her way of dealing w/ the zetsus, as the manga and anime depict her reaction, expression, and pose diffrentl. I was only refering to the fact that naruto is the reason she was on her knees, not because she couldn't handle the zetsus.




I guess I just found a better one



No, I didn't, here's a link to the full page

You must be registered for see images




how do you know they're more experienced? Hinata probably depends on Air Palm more than those two, since they have other techs. Then again, I already said how Byakugan isn't needed if it's not a human opponent.






When did this happen?



Good job ignoring context. She made it over to the other side just fine, the reason she stumbled was becasue the edge of the building crumbled. Something like that bares no weight in a battle scenario.



K, still doesn't prove Sakura's reflexes are better, since Hinata didn't have Byakugan on.



Nah, Sakura showed surprise at seeing the spike [hence the scream] meaning she didn't see it coming, not the same as Hinata's case. Not to mention that whole scene is darker than black, so it's not clear what even happened.




Because Naruto didn't knock her down as he did to Hinata.



So I guess Sakura was gonna be injured badly too because she also had the surprise bubble on her panel ? Lol That's nothing more than to show they've noticed the enemy.

Naruto knocked her down, not the enemies, get that through your head.



it's almost like she didn't want Toneri to know what she's doing.

Then again, Naruto never went into BSM against the puppets. It's nothing more than plot. Unless you're gonna tell me BSM loses to TOneri's puppets.



Hinata never had Hamura's chakra when the TOneri puppet confronted her. Also, Toneri is at god tier, above even EMS Madara and Hashirama, so even w/ Hamura's chakra, Hinata wouldn't be as strong.



My conclusion says that Kakashi's intellect was off the mark by a long shot, as not only was Hinata the one who found hints regarding Hanabi's location [the Kunai], she was also the one who found the portal to the moon, as well as the one who stopped the moon from falling, twice, along side Naruto.

I've said this before, so here it is again: Kakashi is a bad hokage. Him becoming Hokage was nothing more than fanservice for his fans due to getting rid of the sharingan.
Ok, here we go...

I took the liberty to organize our debate for topic in discussion, I am just feeling too tired to properly reply to each fragment.



Hinata's Chakra Trasnfer

  • Your premises are:
    • Different chakra color
    • New name for the same technique
    Your conclusion is that Hinata received chakra from Hamura, while she was having a conversation with his gost and other descendants from him.
  • Regarding to the new name of the technique, It's kind of crazy that a new techniques makes your conclusion more convincing, from what I know, she could have learned that technique in the 2 years that have passed since the war ended, and she could have performed it using the Hamura chakra she just receive, so I fail to understand how a new technique, very similar to one she has used in the manga, imply she has received chakra from a superior being.
  • Now, the new color chakra is good enough to determine she had chakra transferred to her?

    Let's analyse this, Naruto and Sasuke were the ones that had received chakra from Hagoromo, and they didn't have their chakra color changed, Naruto's chakra was always different due to he is a Jinchuriki, and no one noticed that Sasuke had the color of his chakra changed. Disregarding what the anime will show, cause it's not canon...
    Kishi cover wth Naruto in God mode, and his chakra is still yellow just like his previews cloaks:
    You must be registered for see images

    Said this, If Naruto and Sasuke didn't have the color of their chakra changed after Hagoromo gave them his chakra, why do you assume Hinata had chakra transferred in The Last?
    And most importantly, why are you assuming Hamura's chakra is violet/purple? With the color argument it's more likely that Sasuke transferred her chakra than Hamura... Toneri was Hamura's descendant, he has more pure blood bonds with Hamura, and his chakra was Green...
  • Besides, you are dennying the fact Hinata stated "Hamura chakra flows within her TOO"
    You must be registered for see images
    Maaning she is not the only one, all her family does along with Toneri too.
  • And finally, I have found a translation a Hinata fan made of Hinata's profile in the Retsu no Sho/The Last Databook:
    Hinata Hyuuga

    The Sunflower Who Hid Love and Admiration for Naruto in Her Heart, and Bloomed Beautifully
    Hinata was born as the eldest daughter of the Hyuuga clan’s main house. Having struggled since childhood with the pressure of being “the next leader of a noble clan,” as well as with her own withdrawn nature, she admired Naruto’s “strength,” and decided to adhere to his nindou. Now, having matured as a shinobi and as a woman, Hinata’s feelings for Naruto cause her to shake…

    Before:
    Caption of panel of near-beaten Hinata from chuunin exams: I never go back on my word. Hinata resolves to adhere to the same nindou as Naruto…!!
    Caption of panel where Hinata uses hakke kuushou against the Juubi: She uses her juuken palm to release air pressure. This is taijutsu handed down by the Hyuuga clan.
    Caption of panel where Hinata uses hakke rokujuuyon shou: The secret juuken technique “hakke rokujuuyon shou.” She masters it with the courage to step out beyond her limits.

    “Byakugan”
    The rare “kekkei genkai” inherited only by the Hyuuga clan. It boasts a 360-degree range of vision and the ability to see clearly for hundreds of meters, and is able to see through opponents’ chakra networks.
    Caption for sketch of Hinata with activated byakugan: When her byakugan is activated, Hinata’s facial expression becomes sharper.
    Before:
    Hinata shows her byakugan in her death match with Neji.

    Feelings Towards Naruto
    Since her days at the academy, Hinata has been attracted to the “strength” that Naruto possesses. That admiration eventually changed into the desire to be by Naruto’s side, and also became the source of Hinata’s growing confidence.
    Before:
    Caption for panel from chapter 98: He unintentionally leaves her dazed with his impulsive “I like you.”
    Before:
    Caption for panel from 615: During the ninja war, Hinata grew into someone who could support Naruto in a predicament and stand as his equal.

    Art of Hinata
    Wedding clothes
    Caption at lower right: Headdress. Her hair is rolled up in a turban-like structure.
    Middle caption: An Ootsutsuki wedding dress, complete with a veil on her head.
    Left caption: Hinata wears a skirt while not on a mission.
    Just search for Retsu-no-sho on Tumblr and you will find it.
    As you see there is no mention of Hamura's chakra or her flying skills either.
    Sorry, but there is no way Kishi leaves that behind, you delusion came to an end.


    I really can't understand the way you think, and the how you conveniently interpreted the movie in your favorite character benefit without noticing, but If you still want to think that way, go ahead... I am not debating any longer with an irrational person.

Sakura and Hinata - Speed Feats​
  • OMG! Please don't play with me that way, am I crazy or we just agreed on something?

    Of course Hinata has better reflexes with Byakugan active, I never claimed that.
    Databooks only assign the Base Stats of a character, so Sakura has better reflexes than Hinata when her Byakugan is off (3 vs 2.5), but this changed when the Hyuuga turn on the veins on her face.
    Byakugan provides a better reading in CQC combats, similar to Sharingan, but better, oh... you know all that so I don't have to say it.
    But Sakura movement speed is still faster, Byakugan, as much great advantages it provides, It doesn't make you move faster or any smarter either.
  • Thanks for the scan, I didn't remember that, the thing is we don't know how Hinata get to save Neji, was neji fighting others? Was Hinata get advantage of the surprise factor?
    Many many options and scenarios that would make your hypothetical example fail.
    Neji has always been praised to be stronger, faster, better than Hinata in every single aspect, Databooks support it and so does his feats and hype.
    I believe you are not biased enough to think Neji is slower than Hinata War arc, right?
    All we know, is that the protected him from a Zetsu, but that don't necessarily means she outspeeded him... we just don't know.
  • Hinata had to be saved by Naruto and Sakura was the one who jumped first, yes, I am comparing how they reacted to the same very attack that was aimed to hit them equally, with the same preparation, exhaustion, time, etc.

    Hinata didn't move, Sakura did, as simple as that.
  • The fact that you think that you can compare Manga attacks with Anime ones, is kind of stupid.
    There is no time between one panel an other, so no, your comparison is not valid.
    With that logic, I could say Sakura is way faster than Hinata by comparing the speed of their attacks when they were ambushed by some puppets in the movie... Not to mention she get hit once, and the puppets weren't trying to kill her.
    If you think she was trying to discretely destroy the Tenseigan, which is a valid point, well every discretion should have ended when she got discovered. It's stupid for her to think than Toneri, the one who controlled the puppets with the Tenseigan don't know that they are being attacked... So the fact that she only used Gentle Fist an other melee attacks to beat them can't be justified for her discretion.
  • Considering now the scenarios where Hinata and Sakura were struggling with White Zetsus, Hinata was going to get mutilated, and Sakura was going to get..... grabbed?
    You must be registered for see images
    The first Zetsu had no weapons, and Sakura was in a fghting stance even if she get grabbed she would counter easily like she countered before, when the enemy was much closer, armed and behind her:
    You must be registered for see images
    You must be registered for see images
    The manga doesn't suggest Naruto pushed her back to save her, that is the anime and yours interpretation, which also imply she was going to be badly mutilated as well as the manga. Anyway, Anime = Filler.
    So no.
  • Yes, Sakura reacted to an unstable juubi, what's with it? It was already proven in the manga that some times power without control can be superior in power and speed, and again, the one that attacked Sakura had full Hatchibi and half Kyuubi, and that makes it more powerful than the one Hinata countered.
  • Hinata falling three times on canon has no weigh on a Battle scenario?
    The first time she tripped in the middle of a war, the second one she almost fell off the edge of high building but Naruto saved her, and the other one the floor broke under her feet and she tripped again, and Naruto saved her, again.
    What has anything to do that she tripped on the edge? That is a valid justification?
    She has horrible balance...
  • Can't be said whether if she was using Byakugan or not when she reflected the spike, the pages of the actual manga are way too smaller than that, the fragment you provided was zoomed in, It's not noticeable in the real size.
    Pretty weird you didn't call the anime version on this matter :rolleyes: Only when it supports your point, right?
    Anyway, she had Byakugan before and after she used Air palm and there is no reason for her to turn it off.

Hinata Flying Skills


I can't believe I am debating this.

Your entire argument depends on a single scene which was forced in order to be romantic and beautiful.

  • If we consider the whole anime canon, and we used the stupid logic your using, all of the characters that were shown jumping from tree to tree have the ability to fly.
    In most cases, they make one jump in the middle of a conversation and last for several minutes in the air (check minute 32:15):
    [video=youtube;ZzVfcbopHmI]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZzVfcbopHmI[/video]
    It's like Captain Tsubaza, they run and run and run and they never get to the other side of the field.
    Trying to prove Hinata can fly is like trying to prove the field size was superior to the one stated in the official rules.
    It's idiotic...
  • Even if any fapper agrees with you on this "feat", you don't get to say she can fly, I don't know what you are watching, I only saw her standing in the same place and moving only by holding Naruto.
    So this scene shows Hinata floating in the air, not moving at all, only with the help of Naruto and the great impulse that sent them there.
    Great power up!
  • Flying skills are missing on Retsu no sho, already provided above. If that skill was true, It had been included, but there is nothing on her profile.

    How odd, right?
Byakugou counters Gentle Fist


I don't repeat my whole argument again about this issue, only a quick summary with the premises and the conclusion:

These are the facts
  • Naruto received the 64 palms directly, hitting all his body and sealing Naruto's chakra network for a while.
  • Naruto channeled Kyuubi chakra through his body and got a sh*tty that didn't proide Naruto with long chakra arms/claws or high level defense, the cloak didn't change Naruto's personality and it didn't have the shape of the fox.
The two conclusions:
  • Sealed chakra is safe from Gentle Fist
  • By releasing sealed chakra to the user's network, one's chakra flow stop being "sealed" by Gentle Fist and the user can use chakra again.
There is no property, element or superiority of Kyuubi's chakra hyped to be the one that let Naruto use chakra again.
Not in that time, or any other.

The most idiotic and frustrating thing about debating this again is that you already agreed with me about this issue several times. And every chance you have to throw it again you do, ending in the same way as always.

I conclude with premises I took from facts of the manga, you are concluding about Hamura's Chakra with premises such as the color of her chakra and the new name of the technique.
 

V h o

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jan 27, 2013
Messages
16,796
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Ok, here we go...

I took the liberty to organize our debate for topic in discussion, I am just feeling too tired to properly reply to each fragment.



Hinata's Chakra Trasnfer

  • Your premises are:
    • Different chakra color
    • New name for the same technique
    Your conclusion is that Hinata received chakra from Hamura, while she was having a conversation with his gost and other descendants from him.
  • Regarding to the new name of the technique, It's kind of crazy that a new techniques makes your conclusion more convincing, from what I know, she could have learned that technique in the 2 years that have passed since the war ended, and she could have performed it using the Hamura chakra she just receive, so I fail to understand how a new technique, very similar to one she has used in the manga, imply she has received chakra from a superior being.
  • Now, the new color chakra is good enough to determine she had chakra transferred to her?

    Let's analyse this, Naruto and Sasuke were the ones that had received chakra from Hagoromo, and they didn't have their chakra color changed, Naruto's chakra was always different due to he is a Jinchuriki, and no one noticed that Sasuke had the color of his chakra changed. Disregarding what the anime will show, cause it's not canon...
    Kishi cover wth Naruto in God mode, and his chakra is still yellow just like his previews cloaks:
    You must be registered for see images

    Said this, If Naruto and Sasuke didn't have the color of their chakra changed after Hagoromo gave them his chakra, why do you assume Hinata had chakra transferred in The Last?
    And most importantly, why are you assuming Hamura's chakra is violet/purple? With the color argument it's more likely that Sasuke transferred her chakra than Hamura... Toneri was Hamura's descendant, he has more pure blood bonds with Hamura, and his chakra was Green...
  • Besides, you are dennying the fact Hinata stated "Hamura chakra flows within her TOO"
    You must be registered for see images
    Maaning she is not the only one, all her family does along with Toneri too.
  • And finally, I have found a translation a Hinata fan made of Hinata's profile in the Retsu no Sho/The Last Databook:
    Just search for Retsu-no-sho on Tumblr and you will find it.
    As you see there is no mention of Hamura's chakra or her flying skills either.
    Sorry, but there is no way Kishi leaves that behind, you delusion came to an end.


    I really can't understand the way you think, and the how you conveniently interpreted the movie in your favorite character benefit without noticing, but If you still want to think that way, go ahead... I am not debating any longer with an irrational person.

Sakura and Hinata - Speed Feats​
  • OMG! Please don't play with me that way, am I crazy or we just agreed on something?

    Of course Hinata has better reflexes with Byakugan active, I never claimed that.
    Databooks only assign the Base Stats of a character, so Sakura has better reflexes than Hinata when her Byakugan is off (3 vs 2.5), but this changed when the Hyuuga turn on the veins on her face.
    Byakugan provides a better reading in CQC combats, similar to Sharingan, but better, oh... you know all that so I don't have to say it.
    But Sakura movement speed is still faster, Byakugan, as much great advantages it provides, It doesn't make you move faster or any smarter either.
  • Thanks for the scan, I didn't remember that, the thing is we don't know how Hinata get to save Neji, was neji fighting others? Was Hinata get advantage of the surprise factor?
    Many many options and scenarios that would make your hypothetical example fail.
    Neji has always been praised to be stronger, faster, better than Hinata in every single aspect, Databooks support it and so does his feats and hype.
    I believe you are not biased enough to think Neji is slower than Hinata War arc, right?
    All we know, is that the protected him from a Zetsu, but that don't necessarily means she outspeeded him... we just don't know.
  • Hinata had to be saved by Naruto and Sakura was the one who jumped first, yes, I am comparing how they reacted to the same very attack that was aimed to hit them equally, with the same preparation, exhaustion, time, etc.

    Hinata didn't move, Sakura did, as simple as that.
  • The fact that you think that you can compare Manga attacks with Anime ones, is kind of stupid.
    There is no time between one panel an other, so no, your comparison is not valid.
    With that logic, I could say Sakura is way faster than Hinata by comparing the speed of their attacks when they were ambushed by some puppets in the movie... Not to mention she get hit once, and the puppets weren't trying to kill her.
    If you think she was trying to discretely destroy the Tenseigan, which is a valid point, well every discretion should have ended when she got discovered. It's stupid for her to think than Toneri, the one who controlled the puppets with the Tenseigan don't know that they are being attacked... So the fact that she only used Gentle Fist an other melee attacks to beat them can't be justified for her discretion.
  • Considering now the scenarios where Hinata and Sakura were struggling with White Zetsus, Hinata was going to get mutilated, and Sakura was going to get..... grabbed?
    You must be registered for see images
    The first Zetsu had no weapons, and Sakura was in a fghting stance even if she get grabbed she would counter easily like she countered before, when the enemy was much closer, armed and behind her:
    You must be registered for see images
    You must be registered for see images
    The manga doesn't suggest Naruto pushed her back to save her, that is the anime and yours interpretation, which also imply she was going to be badly mutilated as well as the manga. Anyway, Anime = Filler.
    So no.
  • Yes, Sakura reacted to an unstable juubi, what's with it? It was already proven in the manga that some times power without control can be superior in power and speed, and again, the one that attacked Sakura had full Hatchibi and half Kyuubi, and that makes it more powerful than the one Hinata countered.
  • Hinata falling three times on canon has no weigh on a Battle scenario?
    The first time she tripped in the middle of a war, the second one she almost fell off the edge of high building but Naruto saved her, and the other one the floor broke under her feet and she tripped again, and Naruto saved her, again.
    What has anything to do that she tripped on the edge? That is a valid justification?
    She has horrible balance...
  • Can't be said whether if she was using Byakugan or not when she reflected the spike, the pages of the actual manga are way too smaller than that, the fragment you provided was zoomed in, It's not noticeable in the real size.
    Pretty weird you didn't call the anime version on this matter :rolleyes: Only when it supports your point, right?
    Anyway, she had Byakugan before and after she used Air palm and there is no reason for her to turn it off.

Hinata Flying Skills


I can't believe I am debating this.

Your entire argument depends on a single scene which was forced in order to be romantic and beautiful.

  • If we consider the whole anime canon, and we used the stupid logic your using, all of the characters that were shown jumping from tree to tree have the ability to fly.
    In most cases, they make one jump in the middle of a conversation and last for several minutes in the air (check minute 32:15):
    [video=youtube;ZzVfcbopHmI]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZzVfcbopHmI[/video]
    It's like Captain Tsubaza, they run and run and run and they never get to the other side of the field.
    Trying to prove Hinata can fly is like trying to prove the field size was superior to the one stated in the official rules.
    It's idiotic...
  • Even if any fapper agrees with you on this "feat", you don't get to say she can fly, I don't know what you are watching, I only saw her standing in the same place and moving only by holding Naruto.
    So this scene shows Hinata floating in the air, not moving at all, only with the help of Naruto and the great impulse that sent them there.
    Great power up!
  • Flying skills are missing on Retsu no sho, already provided above. If that skill was true, It had been included, but there is nothing on her profile.

    How odd, right?
Byakugou counters Gentle Fist


I don't repeat my whole argument again about this issue, only a quick summary with the premises and the conclusion:

These are the facts
  • Naruto received the 64 palms directly, hitting all his body and sealing Naruto's chakra network for a while.
  • Naruto channeled Kyuubi chakra through his body and got a sh*tty that didn't proide Naruto with long chakra arms/claws or high level defense, the cloak didn't change Naruto's personality and it didn't have the shape of the fox.
The two conclusions:
  • Sealed chakra is safe from Gentle Fist
  • By releasing sealed chakra to the user's network, one's chakra flow stop being "sealed" by Gentle Fist and the user can use chakra again.
There is no property, element or superiority of Kyuubi's chakra hyped to be the one that let Naruto use chakra again.
Not in that time, or any other.

The most idiotic and frustrating thing about debating this again is that you already agreed with me about this issue several times. And every chance you have to throw it again you do, ending in the same way as always.

I conclude with premises I took from facts of the manga, you are concluding about Hamura's Chakra with premises such as the color of her chakra and the new name of the technique.
Just to add, Yin seal (in theory) can work like what naruto did in part 1, because yin seal releases a huge amount of chakra to push the chakra that's blocking the passage/opening points out. Imagine the chakra pathway as a river, enemy chakra is blocking that river and then a large amount of chakra (could be quantity or quality) expels that blocking chakra from the river/pathway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keimil

Keimil

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
1,851
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Just to add, Yin seal (in theory) can work like what naruto did in part 1, because yin seal releases a huge amount of chakra to push the chakra that's blocking the passage/opening points out. Imagine the chakra pathway as a river, enemy chakra is blocking that river and then a large amount of chakra (could be quantity or quality) expels that blocking chakra from the river/pathway.
Exactly.
 

Made in Heaven

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
31,444
Kin
5💸
Kumi
-6💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
[*]Regarding to the new name of the technique, It's kind of crazy that a new techniques makes your conclusion more convincing, from what I know, she could have learned that technique in the 2 years that have passed since the war ended, and she could have performed it using the Hamura chakra she just receive, so I fail to understand how a new technique, very similar to one she has used in the manga, imply she has received chakra from a superior being.
Because everything aside from the colour appears to be the exact same, so why isn't it referred to as Gentlt Step: Twin Lion fists?

[*]Now, the new color chakra is good enough to determine she had chakra transferred to her?

Let's analyse this, Naruto and Sasuke were the ones that had received chakra from Hagoromo, and they didn't have their chakra color changed, Naruto's chakra was always different due to he is a Jinchuriki, and no one noticed that Sasuke had the color of his chakra changed. Disregarding what the anime will show, cause it's not canon...
Kishi cover wth Naruto in God mode, and his chakra is still yellow just like his previews cloaks:
You must be registered for see images

Said this, If Naruto and Sasuke didn't have the color of their chakra changed after Hagoromo gave them his chakra, why do you assume Hinata had chakra transferred in The Last?
No, the colour of the chakra only changes if they choose to do so.



Here, Sasuke INFUSES his chidori with 6 path chakra, in turn, changing it into a darker colour. Had he not infused it w/ 6 path chakra, it would have remained it's normal colour [blue]


And most importantly, why are you assuming Hamura's chakra is violet/purple?
Why can't I ? Hinata's was shown to be blue. after all, so it's clearly not hers

Toneri was Hamura's descendant, he has more pure blood bonds with Hamura, and his chakra was Green...
Toneri is a branch member. Toneri having green chakra doesn't hold any weight here, since 1000 years have passed since Hamura's time

[*]Besides, you are dennying the fact Hinata stated "Hamura chakra flows within her TOO"
You must be registered for see images
Maaning she is not the only one, all her family does along with Toneri too.
The Hyuga don't have Hamura's chakra, it was never stated to be as so or even implied.

The "too" is referring to Toneri, as he gained Hamura's chakra through reemerging the bloodlines of Hamura, Hyuga+Ootsutsuki.

So only Toneri and Hinata have Hamura's chakra, one by combining both families, the other by receiving it directly.

[*]And finally, I have found a translation a Hinata fan made of Hinata's profile in the Retsu no Sho/The Last Databook:
Just search for Retsu-no-sho on Tumblr and you will find it.
As you see there is no mention of Hamura's chakra or her flying skills either.
Sorry, but there is no way Kishi leaves that behind, you delusion came to an end.
That book doesn't speak of abilities in THE LAST


OMG! Please don't play with me that way, am I crazy or we just agreed on something?

Of course Hinata has better reflexes with Byakugan active, I never claimed that.
Databooks only assign the Base Stats of a character, so Sakura has better reflexes than Hinata when her Byakugan is off (3 vs 2.5), but this changed when the Hyuuga turn on the veins on her face.
Byakugan provides a better reading in CQC combats, similar to Sharingan, but better, oh... you know all that so I don't have to say it.
That's all I was ever arguing .

But Sakura movement speed is still faster, Byakugan, as much great advantages it provides, It doesn't make you move faster or any smarter either.
How so? Hinata knows 64 palms, meaning she would naturally need high-speed and fast movements to use. I'm not arguing that Hinata is faster on foot than Sakura, I'm just arguing her CqC is faster.

Thanks for the scan, I didn't remember that, the thing is we don't know how Hinata get to save Neji, was neji fighting others? Was Hinata get advantage of the surprise factor?
Many many options and scenarios that would make your hypothetical example fail.
Neji has always been praised to be stronger, faster, better than Hinata in every single aspect, Databooks support it and so does his feats and hype.
We can see that there were no enemies engaging Neji, as he was even able to turn around and talk w/ Hinata.

Exactly, Neji has been said to be better in all those categories than Hinata, yet Hinata has been shown to be better in taijutsu than Sakura, even before learning 64 palms [the pinnacle of Hyuga taijutsu], but here you are claiming Sakura would have fought of the 2 zetsus but Hinata needed saving from 3 ?
I believe you are not biased enough to think Neji is slower than Hinata War arc, right?
No

All we know, is that the protected him from a Zetsu, but that don't necessarily means she outspeeded him... we just don't know.
Same goes to Naruto defending Hinata, just because someone was saved, that doesn't mean they needed to be saved. They could have defended themselves [Neji could have used Rotation, Hinata could have used TLF/64 palms], but were instead saved by someone else.

Hinata had to be saved by Naruto and Sakura was the one who jumped first, yes, I am comparing how they reacted to the same very attack that was aimed to hit them equally, with the same preparation, exhaustion, time, etc.

Hinata didn't move, Sakura did, as simple as that.
That's fine, as you yourself said Hinata's reflexes are not as good w/o Byakugan, which she didn't have on.


If you think she was trying to discretely destroy the Tenseigan, which is a valid point, well every discretion should have ended when she got discovered. It's stupid for her to think than Toneri, the one who controlled the puppets with the Tenseigan don't know that they are being attacked... So the fact that she only used Gentle Fist an other melee attacks to beat them can't be justified for her discretion.
Actually, the puppets are automatically controlled by the power of the Tenseigan machine. So it would still stand that she wasn't trying to have Toneri know what she was doing.

It is an altar used to collect and amplify natural energy, with the clan using it as an energy source to power everything on the moon, including the countless autonomous puppets that served them.


Hence why the puppets stopped functioning when the Tenseigan was destroyed, as that is what controls them, not Toneri. I mean, what power could eye-less Toneri have even used to control all those hundreds of puppets all on his lonesome?

[*]Considering now the scenarios where Hinata and Sakura were struggling with White Zetsus, Hinata was going to get mutilated, and Sakura was going to get..... grabbed?
You must be registered for see images
The first Zetsu had no weapons, and Sakura was in a fghting stance even if she get grabbed she would counter easily like she countered before, when the enemy was much closer, armed and behind her:
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
Actually, the 2nd Zetsu was going at her as well, w/ a Kunai in hand.

If you're using Sakura's previous feat of taking down a Zetsu [who was unaware she knew who he really was] to justify why she'd be able to take out 3 Zetsu's that caught her off guard, shouldn't I be able to say the same thing for Hinata? That her countering one Zetsu that was attacking Neji proves she'd be able to take down those other three?

The manga doesn't suggest Naruto pushed her back to save her, that is the anime and yours interpretation, which also imply she was going to be badly mutilated as well as the manga.

Anyway, Anime = Filler.So no.
Then what caused her to go from a fighting pose to on her bum in a split second ? It's easy to infer that it was because of Naruto.

You used an anime clip down below to justify why Hinata can't fly... so ...

Yes, Sakura reacted to an unstable juubi, what's with it? It was already proven in the manga that some times power without control can be superior in power and speed, and again, the one that attacked Sakura had full Hatchibi and half Kyuubi, and that makes it more powerful than the one Hinata countered.
Possibly, yes, but the fact that the bijuus were trying to separate, so much so to the point that you could even see their individual faces trying to tare away, should have had some sort of hindrance on the Juubi's speed, isn't it logical to think that ?

Hinata falling three times on canon has no weigh on a Battle scenario?
Yes, it doesn't, because as I said, you're simply ignoring context in all of these situations.

The first time she tripped in the middle of a war,
The context you're ignoring: She was exhausted.... already went over this w/ you here



Yet you stopped replying

the second one she almost fell off the edge of high building but Naruto saved her,
The context you're ignoring here is that she did in fact make it across to the other building just fine, but due to the building being so old, it crumbled underneath her weight, which causes her to fall. Unless she'd be fighting in this exact same location, or another ruined ciity w/ old building, this would not factor into a fight scenario.

and the other one the floor broke under her feet and she tripped again, and Naruto saved her, again.
So if something you're standing on breaks, it means you have poor balance ???

She has horrible balance...
And yet, she knows 64 palms. Lol

Can't be said whether if she was using Byakugan or not when she reflected the spike, the pages of the actual manga are way too smaller than that, the fragment you provided was zoomed in, It's not noticeable in the real size.
I disagree. Look back at the scene where Hinata saves Neji

You must be registered for see images


You can easily see lines on her face indicating her Byakugan is activated.

Yet, in 614, there's not a single line here. An no, the picture is not edited or zoomed in.

You must be registered for see images


and even more so, in 616, where we get a BIG, clear picture of her using air palm, she AGAIN doesn't have her Byakugan activated.

You must be registered for see images


Pretty weird you didn't call the anime version on this matter :rolleyes: Only when it supports your point, right?
Only reason I referred to the anime was to show that the anime associated Hinata falling to Naruto's arrival, nothing more.

Anyway, she had Byakugan before and after she used Air palm and there is no reason for her to turn it off.
Unless she wants to save chakra, which would make sense, considering Byakugan eats up more chakra than Sharingan or Rennigan, as it took up Neji's chakra in half a night, while Hinata replaced him for the second half of the night as watch-out.

I can't believe I am debating this.

Your entire argument depends on a single scene which was forced in order to be romantic and beautiful.

If we consider the whole anime canon, and we used the stupid logic your using, all of the characters that were shown jumping from tree to tree have the ability to fly.
In most cases, they make one jump in the middle of a conversation and last for several minutes in the air (check minute 32:15):
[video=youtube;ZzVfcbopHmI]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZzVfcbopHmI[/video]
It's like Captain Tsubaza, they run and run and run and they never get to the other side of the field.
Trying to prove Hinata can fly is like trying to prove the field size was superior to the one stated in the official rules.
It's idiotic...

Even if any fapper agrees with you on this "feat", you don't get to say she can fly, I don't know what you are watching, I only saw her standing in the same place and moving only by holding Naruto.
So this scene shows Hinata floating in the air, not moving at all, only with the help of Naruto and the great impulse that sent them there.
Great power up!

Flying skills are missing on Retsu no sho, already provided above. If that skill was true, It had been included, but there is nothing on her profile.

How odd, right?
Agree, I admit she can't fly, but using the anime for your argument isn't valid.

I don't repeat my whole argument again about this issue, only a quick summary with the premises and the conclusion:

These are the facts
  • Naruto received the 64 palms directly, hitting all his body and sealing Naruto's chakra network for a while.
  • Naruto channeled Kyuubi chakra through his body and got a sh*tty that didn't proide Naruto with long chakra arms/claws or high level defense, the cloak didn't change Naruto's personality and it didn't have the shape of the fox.
The two conclusions:
  • Sealed chakra is safe from Gentle Fist
  • By releasing sealed chakra to the user's network, one's chakra flow stop being "sealed" by Gentle Fist and the user can use chakra again.
There is no property, element or superiority of Kyuubi's chakra hyped to be the one that let Naruto use chakra again.
Not in that time, or any other.

The most idiotic and frustrating thing about debating this again is that you already agreed with me about this issue several times. And every chance you have to throw it again you do, ending in the same way as always.

I conclude with premises I took from facts of the manga, you are concluding about Hamura's Chakra with premises such as the color of her chakra and the new name of the technique.
I never said I disagreed w/ this, I was just pointing out you were using logical inferences based off of previous facts to support a theory of yours about Sakura's abilities, yet when I do the same for Hinata's case of getting chakra from Hamura, you called me bias and pathetic.

I'll reiterate my point on this issue again:

If Yin seal is closed > Gentle Fist closes chakra points > Yin seal can open them.

If Yin seal is open > Gentle Fist closes chakra points > Yin seal can't open them.

EDIT: Sealed Chakra isn't safe from Gentle Fist 100% of the time.

 
Last edited:

Keimil

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
1,851
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Because everything aside from the colour appears to be the exact same, so why isn't it referred to as Gentlt Step: Twin Lion fists?
There is no logical connection between a new name for the same technique and a God transferring you chakra.

No, the colour of the chakra only changes if they choose to do so.
But the colour of her chakra has never been confirmed canonly, you said it yourself, anime content is not a valid argument, well...
In your case, anime is only valid when it supports Hinata's feats....




Here, Sasuke INFUSES his chidori with 6 path chakra, in turn, changing it into a darker colour. Had he not infused it w/ 6 path chakra, it would have remained it's normal colour [blue]
That is a new technique, not a new color of chakra.

Plus, Sasuke already has shown that he can use Enton, dark flames, and before he was using red flames, the color is still the same, black. It's a technique, It doesn't change the color of his chakra.

Why can't I ? Hinata's was shown to be blue. after all, so it's clearly not hers
First, Hinta's chakra has only been stated to be blue in Anime, you said it in this very post that is not valid.
Secondly, why would you assume Hamura's chakra is purple when Hinata used purple chakra? How are you linking this 2?
No where has been stated Hamura's chakra color nor that he transferred chakra to Hinata, so I really can't understand how you came up with that conclusion.

Toneri is a branch member. Toneri having green chakra doesn't hold any weight here, since 1000 years have passed since Hamura's time
Toneri, an Otsutsuki, still has closer and purer blood bonds with Hamura than a Hyuuga,

The Hyuga don't have Hamura's chakra, it was never stated to be as so or even implied.
They are his linage, they have their blood and chakra.

Plus, I have already said it:

Hamura didn't give Hinata his chakra in order to destroy the Tenseigan, she explicitly said that only one with Hamura's blood was able to touch it. Given the fact that Hinata and Naruto were able to successfully attack the Tenseigan together, only with Hinata's chakra, it means that having his blood or chakra means the same thing, since Naruto didn't have Hinata's blood but her chakra.
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

The "too" is referring to Toneri, as he gained Hamura's chakra through reemerging the bloodlines of Hamura, Hyuga+Ootsutsuki.
No, Naruto was able to attack the Tenseigan with her chakra, not her blood, proving that her chakra is the one that have the right properties to destroy the Tenseigan.

So only Toneri and Hinata have Hamura's chakra, one by combining both families, the other by receiving it directly.
No, Hinata never received any chakra from no one in the movie. It should have been stated.


That book doesn't speak of abilities in THE LAST
The booklet shows the most updated version of our characters.
There is nothing about Hamura chakra, not even one scan about her ancestor Hamura.

That's all I was ever arguing .
Oh come on.... Byakugan makes your visual field way bigger, she can notice long ranged attacks before the common eye does, and it does provide better reading to the user.

How could Sakura's reflexes be better than that?

How so? Hinata knows 64 palms, meaning she would naturally need high-speed and fast movements to use. I'm not arguing that Hinata is faster on foot than Sakura, I'm just arguing her CqC is faster.
Her CQC is better by Databook, yes, it does imply faster hand speed, if you were debating that.

Sakura has faster movements on foot, she has better evasion maneuvers and longer reach with her jumps.


We can see that there were no enemies engaging Neji, as he was even able to turn around and talk w/ Hinata.
We only saw the post saing scene. There is no way to say she outspeeded him, at all.

Exactly, Neji has been said to be better in all those categories than Hinata, yet Hinata has been shown to be better in taijutsu than Sakura, even before learning 64 palms [the pinnacle of Hyuga taijutsu], but here you are claiming Sakura would have fought of the 2 zetsus but Hinata needed saving from 3 ?
There is a difference, Hinata was attacked with blades the blades were approaching to her and Naruto saved her. Called it whatever you want, if he pushed her, the blades were cutting her, if he countered before they get her, the blades were cutting her since she paralyzed herself, on her knees, in the floor.
You called the anime version, she even get to open her mouth in fear and surprise, and even stand back a little, before getting pushed/saved by Naruto.
You say Hinata, with superior Taijutsu could counter everything Sakura can. In both occasions, the girls noticed their attackers at the very same time and distance, but is Sakura the one who has has better speed movement, and evasion skills. Plus, the one that was closer to Sakura wasn't armed, her 2 Zetsu's attackers meant less danger than Hinata's attackers, in number and offensive power.

Good, that saves time.


Same goes to Naruto defending Hinata, just because someone was saved, that doesn't mean they needed to be saved. They could have defended themselves [Neji could have used Rotation, Hinata could have used TLF/64 palms], but were instead saved by someone else.
No, that is different cause we know the whole situation.
Hinata saving Neji scene was omitted, we don't know for sure how it happened.


That's fine, as you yourself said Hinata's reflexes are not as good w/o Byakugan, which she didn't have on.
Yeah... we are making progress here...



Actually, the puppets are automatically controlled by the power of the Tenseigan machine. So it would still stand that she wasn't trying to have Toneri know what she was doing

.
The power of the Tenseigan was making the puppets move, but the puppets were moving by Toneri's will, they were doing whatever he wanted, like Black Zetsu to Madara, It's stupid to think they were not going to alert their master in case of an intruder.
Still, not a excuse for using just melee attacks.




Hence why the puppets stopped functioning when the Tenseigan was destroyed, as that is what controls them, not Toneri. I mean, what power could eye-less Toneri have even used to control all those hundreds of puppets all on his lonesome?
The Tenseigan was not evil, that was just power that kept the puppets on, It doesn't make any sense that the Tenseigan commanded the puppets to kidnap Hinata or Hanabi, that was Toneri.



Actually, the 2nd Zetsu was going at her as well, w/ a Kunai in hand.
Yes, but the first didn't, she could have countered the Zetsu that attacked her from her back, she could have soloed both by punching the first away, or maybe the second one could injured her, we don't know. The threat was greater in Hinata's case anyway.

If you're using Sakura's previous feat of taking down a Zetsu [who was unaware she knew who he really was] to justify why she'd be able to take out 3 Zetsu's that caught her off guard, shouldn't I be able to say the same thing for Hinata? That her countering one Zetsu that was attacking Neji proves she'd be able to take down those other three?
The Zetsu's Kunai was practically on her neck, and she still was able to counter it.
Sakura was already in fighting/guarding stance, and the Zetsu had no weapons, he was no threat to Sakura, since she had already countered an armed one from her back who was at the same distance or closer, I guess the second one could have damaged her, maybe, still he was further.

Another important thing is that Sakura couldn't just blow the floor with CES because she had allies next to her.

Again, we don't know how is Neji's case, the distance, the threat, the attack she used to defeat him, the time she noticed him, everything. But we know Sakura's case.

Besides, at the end of the manga (ch 699), we know for a fact that the second Zetsu stop being a threat to Sakura, but I can't say the same about Hinata.



Then what caused her to go from a fighting pose to on her bum in a split second ? It's easy to infer that it was because of Naruto.
She was on fighting pose, but she was fighting another disguised Zetsu, look above her in the panel.
She was facing in other direction, the is a movement effect on her hand, and also a hitbox.
She had just defeated a Zetsu when these 3 ambushed her:
You must be registered for see images

You used an anime clip down below to justify why Hinata can't fly... so ...
I beleive I said "if anime was canon". Plus, I provided other arguments, and you agreed, so....



Possibly, yes, but the fact that the bijuus were trying to separate, so much so to the point that you could even see their individual faces trying to tare away, should have had some sort of hindrance on the Juubi's speed, isn't it logical to think that ?
Not at all, Naruto stated they were moving "too damn fast".

Yes, it doesn't, because as I said, you're simply ignoring context in all of these situations.
There is nothing to ignore... Falling three times in canon is pretty hard to counter.

The context you're ignoring: She was exhausted.... already went over this w/ you here



Yet you stopped replying
Yup, just like everybody else.



The context you're ignoring here is that she did in fact make it across to the other building just fine,
but due to the building being so old, it crumbled underneath her weight,
which causes her to fall. Unless she'd be fighting in this exact same location, or another ruined ciity w/ old building, this would not factor into a fight scenario.
Don't you think she should have thought of it? Naruto made it just fine...


So if something you're standing on breaks, it means you have poor balance ???
No, but some realizes what is going on before falling.



And yet, she knows 64 palms. Lol
Yeah, she does, she learned it at least 3 years after his cousin, and Kaiten at 699 is still missing.



I disagree. Look back at the scene where Hinata saves Neji

You must be registered for see images


You can easily see lines on her face indicating her Byakugan is activated.

Yet, in 614, there's not a single line here. An no, the picture is not edited or zoomed in.

You must be registered for see images
Not the same, Hinata's drawing is bigger and from a clearer angle.
Although I can't notice if she has or not Byakugan in that scan, you know as well as I do, that the manga pages nline are way bigger than in the original tome.


and even more so, in 616, where we get a BIG, clear picture of her using air palm, she AGAIN doesn't have her Byakugan activated.

You must be registered for see images
Yes, that one is far clearer, she doesn't have Byakugan.



Only reason I referred to the anime was to show that the anime associated Hinata falling to Naruto's arrival, nothing more.
No, you used it when you tried to prove Hinata's chakra is blue too.



Unless she wants to save chakra, which would make sense, considering Byakugan eats up more chakra than Sharingan or Rennigan, as it took up Neji's chakra in half a night, while Hinata replaced him for the second half of the night as watch-out.
Why would she save chakra when the spikes were still raining?


Agree, I admit she can't fly, but using the anime for your argument isn't valid.
Finally, we are making progress here, 2 are down, 1 to go.

You used anime on the Naruto saving Hinata issue and to support your theory of Hinata's chakra color.

Again, I provided other arguments too. It's not like I depend on that, the manga pages show it too:
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
I couldn't find one scan when they are actually leaning on the trees to jump... But it's obvious they did.
Kishi just didn't draw it...


I never said I disagreed w/ this, I was just pointing out you were using logical inferences based off of previous facts to support a theory of yours about Sakura's abilities, yet when I do the same for Hinata's case of getting chakra from Hamura, you called me bias and pathetic.

I'll reiterate my point on this issue again:

If Yin seal is closed > Gentle Fist closes chakra points > Yin seal can open them.

If Yin seal is open > Gentle Fist closes chakra points > Yin seal can't open them.

EDIT: Sealed Chakra isn't safe from Gentle Fist 100% of the time.

First thing, you did disagreed at the beginning, I have PMs of you claiming me to stop considering my conclusion of Byakugou countering Gentle Fist as canon when you found the Kidoumaru scan.

Secondly, I agree 100% completely, I told you all that to begin with... all about the seal and how would it work, and also when it wouldn't.

But I can't accept that you are comparing the Gentle Fist weakness I found with your theory about Hamura transferring his chakra to Hinata.

In the reasoning I made the conclusion can be deducted easily by just applying all premises.

  • Premise 1: Naruto's Kyuubi chakra was safe from Gentle Fit as long as the chakra it stayed in the seal. (no particular property of its chakra was stated to be the one that made it possible)
  • Premise 2: Naruto could unblock his coils by releasing chakra from the seal.
  • Premise 3: Kidoumaru after using the seal, received at least 3 strikes of Gentle Fist, which disrupted his chakra from the seal as well, preventing him fro using it anymore.
  • Conclusion: Sealed chakra can counter Gentle Fist as long as it stays on the seal, and be used after having one's chakra disrupted.
Your reasoning:
  • Premise 1: Hinata had a very short conversation with Hamura
  • Premise 2: Hinata's chakra color is purple on the movie
  • Premise 3: Hinata has a "new" technique on the movie
  • Conclusion: Hinata received Hamura's chakra
I can not connect the dots here.
Hinata chakra color was never stated to be blue on the manga, only the anime suggest that, which you already said, "it's not valid". They probably just give her that color in order to prevent her feats in the movie from looking too random, everyone has blue chakra in the anime, so blue chakra has already been used like a cloak before, in filler and others....
Hamura's chakra was never stated to be purple either, you are just guessing that, It can't be one of your premises, It's just a guess from your part.
Naruto and Sasuke didn't have their chakra color changed, they only got new techniques, god level techniques.
If Hinata had received the power from Hamura, don't you think she should have been able to destroy the Tenseigan on her own?
Finally, the booklet that they give with the movie tickets shows the ultimate canon version of our characters, If there is no Hamura chakra for her, It's because she did't get it.

PD: There is a rumor, so just take it as a rumor this time, that the Booklet says Sakura and Shikamaru are Jounin in The Last.
 
Last edited:
Top