Do people really believe their in another dimension?

[Floydical]

No she teleported them somewhere, where they're at is sunny, while on the battlefield is still night time. Also the mangapanda translation is wrong becos tobirama repeats the same thing he said twice in that panel.

If that were really the case, what would be the point of showing all the kages? All four were shown and each now has a drive to join the battle. What would be the point if there was no way they could do so? Like I said above, she could have reformed the area to be sunny while she changed the rest of the landscape. Again, I am not relying on the mangapanda translation in my argument. I simply used it to help prove my point because the *********** version will disappear at the end of the week.

Actually no, I'm not. Instead of blindly responding, please at least try to read what I typed. My entire point revolves around the idea that the Kages' statements were meant to serve as a timeline depicting what was going on between Madara's end and the summoning of the new dimension. Clearly, you can see in the page that Madara's rods did not instantly disappear, so no I'm not under that assumption. I even said that Madara's rods are disappearing, meaning they were in a process of doing so. Had you read my comment with an open mind, you would've caught that the first time. My point was in fact that the statements as a whole took place over time. They didn't make their statements at once, rather they were made at different intervals in relation to the sequence of events on the battlefield. The fact that it took time for the rods to begin to disperse adds to what I'm saying. Indeed my analysis could still be flawed, but not for the reason you tried to convey.

As far as the rest goes, it really doesn't make much sense. My belief is that she "summoned" a new dimension by remodeling the surrounding land after the land in another world. Not that she literally took a piece out of a new dimension and brought it there. Even still, if she has the power to alter the surrounding land in the real world, I don't see why it's so hard for to believe that she could also alter another one to remain in tact at the same time. Whether she just made a "copy" of sorts of the other dimension, she swapped them out or just did a simple remodel, I highly doubt Kishi would just throw in the idea of it being a new dimension for nothing. That to me is a really absurd thing to believe but to each his/her own

As for reading what you typed, I suggest you do the same with my post. I never questioned your idea regarding the dissolving of the rods, rather when the rods began to dissolve. Your post implied that as soon as Madara was defeated, the rods in Hashi's back began to dissolve. Clearly the rods took a short time to dissolve once the process started, but that wasn't my point. My point was that it could have been several minutes between Madara being defeated and when the rods started to dissolve. Your points about the 3 kage's panels occurring at different intervals of time throughout the fight makes sense, but right there you are contradicting yourself.

You claim you believe she summoned a dimension rather than teleporting them to a new one, yet you defend the point that Hiruzen claims they disappeared and thus, went to a new dimension. So which is it that you believe? Also, after the third's panel, we see a panel of Minato stating he needs to get back to Naruto. This panel completely goes against the flow of time that you depicted above. In Minato's case, the crew is in the same spot they were before. Lastly, there is still the matter of the 4 kages being shown in the first place. If they have no means of making their way to the battlefield, what would be the point of showing them?

 

[Angelic.]

hokage could still deal with spiral or the ninja tools. if narutos group really is gone or not..

 

[Bad Touch Yakushi]

Sorry your points weren't really strong enough.

I'm not saying you're wrong but t seems too unlikely.

 

[Angelic.]

heres the viz of what tobirama and hiruzen said

Tobirama: (...To the spot where I sensed that mighty chakra...
...I might learn something!)

Hiruzen: (But... That mighty chakra suddenly vanished...)


(lol posted at the same time below)

 

[rollin]

This is what the viz translation said

Tobirama: (...To the spot where I sensed that mighty chakra...
...I might learn something!)

Hiruzen: (But... That mighty chakra suddenly vanished...)

 

[Floydical]

heres the viz of what tobirama and hiruzen said

Tobirama: (...To the spot where I sensed that mighty chakra...
...I might learn something!)

Hiruzen: (But... That mighty chakra suddenly vanished...)


(lol posted at the same time below)

This is what the viz translation said

Tobirama: (...To the spot where I sensed that mighty chakra...
...I might learn something!)

Hiruzen: (But... That mighty chakra suddenly vanished...)

Then what purpose does Minato's statement play on the very next page? Certainly the bit about Minato returning to Naruto still applies. If so, they are certainly not in a different dimension, but perhaps were in fact moved to a new location.

 

[Angelic.]

bc minato obvously wants to return to his son... the whole hokage dialogue was a continous statement. minatos a sensor as well so he also has lost the large chakra

 

[T0bidara]

what if the missing large chakra isnt Madara......
what if it's Naruto or Sauske or T0bidara.......

 

[DoubleKamui]

VIZ says "She summoned an alternate dimension?", which suggests they are in a different dimension.

 

[Angelic.]

what if the missing large chakra isnt Madara......
what if it's Naruto or Sauske or T0bidara.......

he hasth arived...

even viz was confusing for me imo

 

[flyboyissac]

you could be right but at the same time wrong she teleported them

quantum tunneling....

she teleported them to a new location
as you see her she has the power of teleporting

You must be registered for see images

 

[KRZYNASTY]

Basically it all comes down to two things:

1. One of the members (Naruto, Sasuke, Sakura, Kakashi or Kaguya) states that they're in a different dimension.
2. The Kage are not able to go to the location because it is in a place they cannot reach.

Those are the only defining characteristics that will help solve if they're a) in another dimension or b) if she simply changed the landscape. At the moment I lean more towards the dimension theory, but until someone or something confirms where they're at, it's really just theories and speculations.

 

[ThousandLegs]

give it a few more chapters

 

[BerryDerange]

Then what purpose does Minato's statement play on the very next page? Certainly the bit about Minato returning to Naruto still applies. If so, they are certainly not in a different dimension, but perhaps were in fact moved to a new location.

They are on mars, catchra from there can still be felt on earth because of madara's death creating a gravitational pull. Its geography looks like the mars I use to know

 

[AaaaNinja]

No they're faraway in the middle of a buncha mountains near inside an Active Volcano where kaguyas Palace is.

I would hope none still thinks they're in another dimension..

You must be registered for see links

They were able to feel Naruto's chakra from Konoha. So if they were moved to another physical location, I think Kaguya should have chakra that can be felt from far away too. Tobirama is running toward where he felt a huge amount of chakra. If the battle was moved to a faraway location where there are volcanoes, I think Tobirama would have sensed a new source of chakra somewhere else, and also realized he can't just get there by running. I think they're in another dimension. Maybe it's something that's sorta like Obito's other dimension.

Kakashi thinks it's another dimension. It's why he was surprised that Sasuke was able to call a summon there. There could be some kind of trick to the lava area, or Sasuke simply has some kind of dimension-crossing ability.

 

[Draxus]

I agree. I think it's a super advanced version of the sage technique Kabuto used to change the cave.

 

[Honord Sage]

Some believe so, I need a little more evidence. If the Second Hokage and Minato can teleport to Naruto and Sasuke then their still in our dimension some ware on Earth sines they do not have dimensional capabilities. If they can't then you know their not on our earth. So let see what happens next.