Could Uchiha use Gentle fist?

[EdoItachi]

I know people are going to read the title and call me an idiot or a troll but I'm being 100% serious. I want to see if other people agree with me that a experienced fully developed sharingan user could copy the Hyuga clan's gentle fist techniques.

There are 2 factors that I believe would make it possible:
1.) The sharingan allows the user to perceive and predict there opponent's physical actions mainly taijutsu. It also allows them of course the ability to mimic their opponent's technique as long as the person is physically able to perform it. Using the sharingan an experienced user with good chakra control should be able to memorize and copy the movements implemented in the gentle fist fighting style.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Seeing as Sasuke was able to copy Lee's Taijutsu after one brief fight.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

And he only had 2 tomoe Sharingan at the time which he had only recently awakened.

I think that's enough evidence to support that an Uchiha could copy the physical movements of the Hyuga at least.

2.) The second factor is that the sharingan allows the user to perceive the flow of chakra. This ability would allow the user to see the way the chakra is used in the gentle fist and would allow them to copy it the same way it would be used to copy ninjutsu.

Combining these two factors I don't think it is unbelievable that with the Sharingan a person could effectively use the gentle fist using both the sharingan's ability to perceive and mimic both the physical movements and flow of the chakra.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Thoughts?

 

[BK 201]

Hmm, I'm not sure. They probably can learn it to some degree, probably not to the extent of the Hyuga but both of the eyes possess similar eye abilities in some cases. They probably can learn it with the help of the Sharingan and some training but I doubt as well as the Hyuga. I say not as well as Hyuga mainly because their level of insight isn't as deep as the Byakugan's.

 

[God Of Destruction]

Why not gentle fist is taijutsu move.

 

[yondaime4]

I dont see why not but its kinda useless if you got a ms because at that point who really needs taijutsu amiright?

 

[Calpal]

It doesnt sound too far fetched.
Seems possible.

 

[EdoItachi]

I dont see why not but its kinda useless if you got a ms because at that point who really needs taijutsu amiright?

Very true lol. I was just curious on what other people thought.

 

[BLAZE]

i m curious now
nice thread btw

 

[llxFLaMe]

Yea I believe so

 

[EdoItachi]

i m curious now
nice thread btw

Thanks man! I was curious too so I did some investigating haha.

 

[Moe22]

Well i'm not sure if the sharingan can see the chakra pathway system as clear as the Byakugan can. Byakugan sees the whole chakra path system, and gentle fist is based off of shutting down these chakra "pressure points". However, we've seen on numerous occasions that the Uchiha see chakra as different colors as opposed to all the nerves. That's why I think the Uchiha can't use gentle fist, however I could be wrong.

 

[XxLapizxLazulixX]

anyone who is skilled enough can learn it. But since Byakugan can see internally, it is practically made for byakugan users.

 

[Vkdude]

Gentle fist is performed by releasing chakra from chakra points and striking the opponents chakra points. I think if an uchiha can do that then y not !

 

[Mari Makinami]

I'm pretty sure they can. Nice thread, +rep

 

[EdoItachi]

Well i'm not sure if the sharingan can see the chakra pathway system as clear as the Byakugan can. Byakugan sees the whole chakra path system, and gentle fist is based off of shutting down these chakra "pressure points". However, we've seen on numerous occasions that the Uchiha see chakra as different colors as opposed to all the nerves. That's why I think the Uchiha can't use gentle fist, however I could be wrong.

I understand that the Byakugan does have deeper perception than the sharingan. I was thinking that by memorizing the fighting style by watching a natural user in combat they could merely mimic the movements and copy the chakra used to perform it so by striking the right spots on the outside of the body they wouldn't need to see them clearly they would just merely know it was the right place to strike based on the user's taijutsu which was copied.

 

[ᖇ α z m α η]

Nice thread dude.
Adding my opinions to it, to identify the chakra points and use the correct amount of pressure according to it to stop the flow Byakugan is the effective way. That is why only the Hyuugas can only use Gentle Fist.

There is a possibility for the Uchihas to copy the techniques but the effectiveness and results wont be the same.

 

[Moe22]

I understand that the Byakugan does have deeper perception than the sharingan. I was thinking that by memorizing the fighting style by watching a natural user in combat they could merely mimic the movements and copy the chakra used to perform it so by striking the right spots on the outside of the body they wouldn't need to see them clearly they would just merely know it was the right place to strike based on the user's taijutsu which was copied.

Interesting, I hadn't thought of it that way.

 

[Moe22]

But why memorize all 64 chakra points when you can just spam amaterasu? LOL

 

[ᖇ α z m α η]

But why memorize all 64 chakra points when you can just spam amaterasu? LOL

Not every Uchiha is able to use Amaterasu

Gentle Fist can become handy when used closed combat

 

[EdoItachi]

Nice thread dude.
Adding my opinions to it, to identify the chakra points and use the correct amount of pressure according to it to stop the flow Byakugan is the effective way. That is why only the Hyuugas can only use Gentle Fist.

There is a possibility for the Uchihas to copy the techniques but the effectiveness and results wont be the same.

I see what you're saying but I think that with the sharingan a person would have good enough perception to do damage to an opponents internal organs with the gentle fist effectively.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

As seen in these pages the gentle fist is mainly utilized to attack a persons internal organs using chakra flowing through their palms while pressing the chakra points is more advanced. I think with the sharingan the user would be able to mimic a gentle fist users taijutsu and the flow of chakra from their palm allowing them to effectively hurt their opponent internally without needing the deep perception of the byakugan. Probably wouldn't be able to accurately press chakra points in combat.

 

[UchihaGee]

well, i think it can be copied, even kakashi who is not an Uchiha... The Hatake are well known for their jutsu copying skills... And Kakashi also has the sharingan and i think it wouldn't take him that much time to master it!