- Joined
- Feb 21, 2009
- Messages
- 6,354
- Reaction score
- 429
dam that was long
You've hit the nail on the head.I think the Hyūga and Byakūgan were retcons.
But from an in-universe explanation: Kakashi was simply mistaken
Kakashi said "They say the Uchiha origin lies with the Hyūga Clan" Kakashi was not making a definitive statement based on his own knowledge but rather he was basing his statement on hearsay.
And if you look at OP's scan, Kakashi was making another erroneous statement: "The Rikūdo Sage? He's nothing but a myth, and the Rinnegan is just a mutation"
I am disappointed in the answer I got. I hope its not true.I think the Hyūga and Byakūgan were retcons.
But from an in-universe explanation: Kakashi was simply mistaken
Kakashi said "They say the Uchiha origin lies with the Hyūga Clan" Kakashi was not making a definitive statement based on his own knowledge but rather he was basing his statement on hearsay.
And if you look at OP's scan, Kakashi was making another erroneous statement: "The Rikūdo Sage? He's nothing but a myth, and the Rinnegan is just a mutation"
You've hit the nail on the head.
For me it's been obvious for a while now, but you'll still see people making elaborate threads about how the Hyuga can still be relevant.
I am disappointed in the answer I got. I hope its not true.
It is very very obvious that these two are related and my thread already contains information on this. If you and everyone else wants to disagree about the title of my thread and attack the non manga fact parts which are theory than you can take it elsewhere where creativity does not fluorish and idiots are evolved, I have no time to reply to sad individuals who want to disagree on such minor obvious points and I am tired of piecing together anything with intelligence if I am constantly met with such a dull response and later my words are used against me to fight or to steal my ideas.
... But it was just Hashirama though. Not the whole Senju Clan.
You mean the only Senju being Hashirama as he was the only Senju seen using Sage Mode. Also, it is because of their vitality or life fore and physical energy they have the body to sustain Sage Mode.
Bro, what? You won't me to say I like theory and leave it at that? I am pointing out key facts while deducing the theory to separate the non-factual information.
1. I understand how it all connects to the the "God Tree". However, your cutting through the ancestry line. Senju and Uchiha inherited their traits from the younger and older son of the Sage and their (younger and older) traits from the Sage himself. It is unknown, but you can say the Sage was born with the traits from his mother and she obtain the power from the God Tree (Juubi).
2. You have gone and talk about Yin/Yang. Yin/Yang can be said for anything quoted by Madara. It is balance. The Sage disrupt that balance separating the Juubi. However, he maintain the balance creating the Tailed Beast with the Creation of All Things Technique. Sp that does not matter.
3. You explain the Uchiha thing and I got lost, hence my recent post.....
It is because the Uchiha's traits known to be inherit from the Older Son of the Sage are they not able to access Sage Mode and because their are not an essential connection to the Juubi, but descendants of the Sage who posses Rinnegan.
Nice man, enjoyed the read+rep
Ok, so first I would like to apologize for taking so long to put my input in your thread as you asked me personally via message to do that.
Now about the thread itself. Of course I completly agree with tittle of the thread and I think that you perfectly or in very good way proved your points by presenting them clearly and in simple way.
The only problem I would have with you thread is that you said Sage of six paths is just Yang while Juubi is Yin, which would be wrong, well partially true but still partially wrong.
Juubi's body is shown being as made of wood release and Juubi's eye is shown mix of sharingan and Rinnegan.
I believe that Hagoromo was Precursor of Hyuuga and Uzumaki clans but he was netiher of them but still somehow possesed all of them powers. It would fits well into manga as Uzumaki were known of sealing techniques and Hyuuga clan possesing Byakugan is known to have the best vision among all three great doujutsu. It would be both ingredients to allow SOSP to discover chakra and seal Juubi. Most likely he also used Senjutsu to increase his sealing arts power and also make Hyuuga(taijutsu oriented moves much stronger).
The fact that also Hagoromo was stated by Black Zetsu to be one of the two who awake Rinnegan naturally. The most of people believed that Rinnegan came from Juubi or Juubi's influence but it was proved wrong when Obito become Juubi's host and still lacked Rinnegan in one of eye. It is also impossible for Rikudou to be born with Rinnegan as it was stated he awake these eyes later.
The only last remaining choice is Hagoromo had to awake Rinnegan before fight against Juubi but after his birth. Well as far as Manga goes it shows that it is impossible to awake Rinnegan from normal eyes... but what if Sage already possesed Byakugan then... maybe Juubi's influence or it's eye on Byakugan caused it to change/evolve into Rinnegan, for me it would make sense and hold some importance.
Keep in mind that Byakugan was forgotten and lack panel time as well as lack development. What would be better way then to show it as Hagoromo's original doujutsu before he became Juubi's Jinchurki.
Imagine:
(Byakugan+Sharigan+Rinnegan)ULTIMATE EYE + (Senjuu, Uzumaki)ULTIMATE BODY = Juubi Jinchurki Sage of six paths
If he had also Senjutsu which I believe he had + possesed wood release then you have right there definiation of ultimate being worth for Kishimoto to be praised and put at the top of entire Narutoverse.
Sorry for such long reply... idk if you find time and will to read it but if you did then I hope you would enjoy that![]()