- Joined
- Jul 7, 2012
- Messages
- 4,285
- Reaction score
- 641
Beginning with Ryuusa Bakuryuu is a futile attempt given the objective of the combatants as it is only a technique used to give him a geographical advantage and even if further enforced withYou must be registered for see linksit is still futile given the defense capabilities of Doton: Domu.
Hardly. Ryūsa Bakuryū will allow Gaara to dominate proceedings given the territorial advantage that the technique creates. It'll not only increase the volume of sand at the Kazekage's disposal, but also allow Gaara to more freely make use of his other abilities, such as Suna no Kanchi [
You must be registered for see links
]. Controlling the environment takes away Kakuzu's element of surprise (which is lessened further by the more plane landscape, as Ryūsa Bakuryū does indeed displace standing structures like trees [
You must be registered for see links
]) as anything which comes into contact with the sand can constantly be tracked. Doton: Domu restricts Kakuzu's movements greatly, so using it doesn't give him a means of overcoming his problem in the long term. Sure, he'll survive being crushed in the short term, but given his inability to properly move when in this state, he'll still remain trapped in the Kazekage's sand. He won't be able to engage Gaara, nor will he be able to ambush the latter as Gaara is aware of whether or not a target has been crushed [
You must be registered for see links
].Gaara continually using shock waves through the sand would amount to nothing but a waste of chakra and once over, Kakauzu can easily resurface given his bodily construction. Ryuusa Bakuryuu projects from Gaara's standing point meaning that there will also be trees and solid earth directly behind [given the location] and the claim that the technique 'clears forestry from the area' is actuallyYou must be registered for see linksas the trees were fractured for the most part; leaving an opening for hidden surprises such as attacking from underground as Kimimaro.
Gaara won't need to continually send pulses through his sand if he's alerted to the fact that Sabaku Taisō was unsuccessful at the first attempt. His fighting style doesn't consist of irrational plays [
You must be registered for see links
]. If Kakuzu chooses to resurface, he must deactivate Doton: Domu, which, of course, makes him vulnerable to Gaara's assaults. It doesn't seem like he's able to release his threads when in a hardened state either, as his skin seems to seal itself shut, preventing anything from escaping from the inside [
You must be registered for see links
][
You must be registered for see links
]. Even in part I, Gaara was able to level the majority of the battlefield, and most of the obstructions, such as trees, were indeed displaced. If you consider the increase in scale of Gaara's Jutsu as he's progressed from part I to part II [
You must be registered for see links
], then it becomes apparent that Ryūsa Bakuryū only serves in aiding Gaara's cause and limiting how effectively Kakuzu can make use of guerrilla tactics. Being able to tell whether Kakauzu is alive of not through sand sensory and being 'intellectual' aren't counters for Kakuzu defensebut rather qualities of both Gaara and his sand.
But they do help prevent Gaara from putting himself at risk - which makes Kakuzu's efforts all the more futile.
Sand, as stated prior are simply earthed elements manipulated by chakra and is weak against Raiton based offences. Rikiri hailed as the lightening cutter [technique which once easily breached Gaara's defenses], was almost over powered by Kakuzu's raiton as Kakashi suffered injury [indicating the superior of the two] and will no doubt do justice to Gaara's sand shield.
The face-off between Raikiri and Raiton: Gian doesn't give any indication of the latter being able to breach the best of Gaara's defences, particularly if one is looking for some sort of idea regarding piercing power. Gian simply doesn't have the feats which suggest that it can penetrate quantities of sand reaching these scales [
You must be registered for see links
][
You must be registered for see links
].The melting point of sand [quartz] is some 1710ºC and even if entirely composed of other soil aggregates; it's melting point is still vastly inferior to the high temperatures of lightening being some 30,000ºC and highlights the reasoning behind Raiton being the perfect opposition for Doton; leaving high possibilities for Raiton: Gian to easily breach Gaara's immediate defenses, frying him in the process. The intent of this match is to kill the opponent and as such is a great disadvantage to Gaara as his methods of execution revolve solely around crushing the opponent with sand; something Kakuzu's defenses, specifically a varied yet distinct form of diamond completely negates.
I could give you many examples of instances in this manga where real life physics have been contradicted, because Raiton techniques for example (which you claim to hit such high temperatures), have been shown to not burn or cause an eruption of flames when in contact with burnable materials such as wood or human flesh [
You must be registered for see links
][
You must be registered for see links
]. There was no real indication that Sasuke's Chidori caused any sort of noticeable melting when it came into contact with Gaara's sand [
You must be registered for see links
]. Furthermore, the black flames which, although clear hyperbole, are supposedly 'as hot as the sun', didn't ruin Gaara's sand [
You must be registered for see links
]. This, in addition to Gian's less than impressive piercing feats, suggests that Gaara's more meaty defences will not be bested by such a technique. The sand has already been easily anticipated and avoided on foot [You must be registered for see links->You must be registered for see links->You must be registered for see links] By two persons having a 4.5 for speed and given Kakuzu's feats inYou must be registered for see linksYou must be registered for see linksas well as a 4.0 for speed; would be able to do similarly as well as react to any possible attacks Gaara may bring forth which includes the first move whether it be Suna Shigure or Ryuusa Bakuryuu.
And yet, we can clearly see Gaara's sand being successful in its attempts at seizing the opponent [
You must be registered for see links
] or preventing a team mate from sustaining a serious injury [
You must be registered for see links
][
You must be registered for see links
]. And in all the examples given, each combatant had a speed equal to or greater than 4.0 (except Ē, although we know where he stands with regards movement speed) - pretty much all of them were seemingly 'quicker' than Kakuzu, and were still caught or intercepted by the Godaime Kazekage's sand. We can also see him grabbing the Sandaime Raikage (who was known for his speed) [
You must be registered for see links
] and defending against Sasuke's Enton [
You must be registered for see links
], which of course, isn't slow by any means.Kakuzu cannot be caught from below via similar means as not only does the jutsu not prevent Kakuzu from moving [only the hardened portion] but may provide a full bodily defense on contact with any sand as:
You must be registered for see images
Meaning the claims that Kakuzu will be completely incapacitated at any use of the technique are untrue.
If Kakuzu wishes to protect himself from any of Gaara's omnidirectional attacks, he will need to harden his entire body. It will, essentially, incapacitate him. Given the environmental advantage the Kazekage is sure to possess, Kakuzu will find it more and more difficult to impose his preferred fighting style, since he is far more likely to spend the majority of his time on the defensive. Whilst Gaara's sand allows him to attack and defend simultaneously, Kakuzu doesn't benefit from such versatility. If he chooses to bring out his most famed defensive technique, he severely limits how well he can put Gaara on the back foot. The Kazekage has more options. He can play the waiting game if needs be.
Fresco, It is more than likely also given his age and experience through the years that Kakazu would be knowledgeable of the fact that Sunagakure is the village of the Land of Wind and with an intelligent mind as his, would be forming the stated premises; that Gaara has a wind-based affinity which may possibly manipulate the material situated inside the gourd. If Gaara takes to the skies he will only be met with assaults from the other hearts.
Such a deduction may not prove wholly useful, as the techniques Kakuzu has at his disposal can still be dealt with by Gaara's defences. The Kazekage will surely identify the abilities of each individual mask, at which point he can act accordingly - such as rapidly subduing them with large quantities of sand (and then crushing them) or isolating the ones he feels pose the biggest threats.
Gaara'll be able to quite comfortably fight from an aerial standpoint. Even in the air, the hearts can still be crushed if they are caught by the Godaime's sand [
You must be registered for see links
]. He could also resort to Suna Arare [
You must be registered for see links
] in an attempt to knock the hearts from the skies.Kakashi's feats against Futon: Atsugai were solely due to theYou must be registered for see linksto anticipate attacks; as for a Gaara not wielding any doujutsu and a stationary fighter the same cannot be said. The destructive force of this fuuton would no doubt cause Gaara to play defense, leaving him open for alternate or combined assaults.
Kakashi doesn't possess an absolute defence, so his means of avoiding or overcoming Futon: Atsugai isn't the same as the one which Gaara must adopt. Gaara doesn't need to benefit from the Sharingan's ocular powers when he can quite quickly encase himself in a defence consisting of layers upon layers of solid, hard sand. Playing defensive isn't an issue for Gaara, because with the versatile nature of his sand, he can switch to an offensive state near instantly. The same cannot be said for Kakuzu, unfortunately.
As regards part 1 Gaara, he could have suffered a fatal wound if Chidori wasYou must be registered for see links. Bringing the Raiton no Yoroi argument is a rather weak attempt to say that Gaara's sand would defend against Raiton: Gian as the voltage carried by the Raiton no Yoroi is is harmless as those who have come in direct contact with it suffered no damage from the raiton itself, Onooki mounting Ay is the greatest example. If you had some rudimentary understanding of the chakra flow you would know that it is only the user shrouding their body in a layer of lightning chakra that, not to be used as an offence or def but to electrically stimulate the nervous system; thus amplifying taijutsu.
Even if what has been said about the Raikage is dismissed, the fact remains that Raiton Gian doesn't have piercing feats which will enable Kakuzu to land a critical blow on Gaara.
On the other hand, the same obviously cannot be said for Chidori, Raikiri or Raiton: Gian as they are used as concentrated offences of Raiton chakra and are at a much higher voltage. Sasuke scratching Ay with chidori and Raiton: Gian injuring Kakashi through the lightening cutter testify to that fact. Earth [which sand is apart of] is weak against lightening, that is a canonical, yet critical fact that cannot be ignored or underestimated as it has been highlighted on more than one occasion.
Even with a reference to data highlighted in canon, the fact remains that the technique must still be strong enough to breach or best the element or force which it is up against. That is to say, there is no certainty in a small D-Rank Suiton defeating a large, A-Rank Katon. Gian simply isn't backed by feats in this case. Suggesting that the technique will be able to tear through the Crème de la Crème of Gaara's defences indicates a major underestimation of his abilities [
You must be registered for see links
], or a frightening overestimation of Kakuzu's.TheYou must be registered for see linksat which Kakuzu can protect himself with Domu is evidently quicker than it would take Gaara to completely cover and crush Kakuzu with sand. You still haven't stated how Gaara kills Kakauzu, which actually is an impossibility as not only does Kakuzu have higher chakra reserves but the perfect counter to Gaara's sand, being Raiton.
Gaara defeats Kakuzu by crushing each and every heart; that much is apparent. The only thing in question here is; how long will it take? Because Doton: Domu is Kakuzu's only real solution to being totally squished, and in this state, Kakuzu poses practically no threat to the Godaime. If Kakuzu wants to win, he'll need to make himself vulnerable. And unlike his foe, he can't drive on the offensive and protect himself in the same instance. Gaara can also resort to Suna Bunshin feints in an attempt to deceive or mislead Kakuzu into leaving himself susceptible to a damaging blow. This is also another way of overcoming Raiton: Gian, if standard tanking isn't already an obvious counter.
Rolling forward: After Kakuzu easily evades Garra's attempts through defenses and strategical thinking he uses Jiongu and releases the lightning, fire, and wind masks; beginning a barrage of assaults on Gaara, yet timed correctly to fill voided intermissions yet occasionally attack simultaneously to increase its power and flexibility of attacks.
We've already discussed how Jiongu won't prove to be useful in this scenario when Gaara's Sand Sensing abilities are considered. It really does put him in a poor position, because he won't be able to effectively defend against Gaara's techniques. He could choose to concentrate his efforts on laying siege to the Kazekage's defences, but a lack of self awareness will only put him at risk of being seized by Gaara's sand, which will more than likely be occupying the majority of the landscape (after Ryūsa Bakuryū is used).
Gaara would be solely focused defending against assaults, in which he will ultimately fail given Raiton. As he control's his hearts with mere thought it still leaves options for Kakuzu to travel beneath ground enforcing Doton: Domu assaults on Garra from either behind the scope of Ryuusa Bakuryuu or directly beneath, resulting in critical injury as Gaara's only defenses would be occupied.
Feats are simply not on Kakuzu's side. His techniques will never be able to breach Gaara's sand, given what he's be shown to defend against [
You must be registered for see links
][
You must be registered for see links
][
You must be registered for see links
]. Kakuzu's Domu prevents him from being a threat to Gaara, and his threads cannot bypass his Sand Sensing ability. In fact, there seems to be some contradictions in your team's strategy. If Domu, as Varrah claims, is to be used to tank & observe aerial attacks such as Suna Arare or Suna Shigure, how, in his immobile state, does Kakuzu plan on avoiding the sand arms which so easily captured the Edo Kage? Remembering, of course, that Mū only avoided it because of his sensing abilities [
You must be registered for see links
]. Your initial argument emphasised the approach Kakuzu would take, but then went on to describe another - I sense a lack of continuity here. Ultimately, it is Gaara who will benefit from the landscape. Gaara who can constantly follow Kakuzu's movements; Gaara who can easily swap between both attack and defence. He can control the land whilst patrolling the sky. The sheer scale and versatility of the Godaime's abilities are what will allow him overcome this particular foe.