Does Sasuke deserve punishment for his crimes?

[Sot viing hun]

I would agree with you if all people in this manga who did crimes and that is pretty much everybody,got a deserving punishment. But that isn't the case.

I'm totally aware of that, knowing the historial of this manga, he won't be punished at all, instead he'll be glorified as a hero(which he will be) and everyone will forget about his crimes.

It's not retarded. If you really care that much why don't you make a thread for EVERY single character who has a history of mass-murdering etc. who got off scot-free?

As you just said it's opinion.
So why do you act like your opinion is the only opinion? Other people have opinions too.
Just look at the poll.
You don't respect other peoples opinion yet you expect it?

You must be registered for see images

Where did I show a bit of disrespect towards someone's else opinion?, your comment wasn't worthy of respect as all you said was ''deal with it'' and ''Kishimoto won't allow it'', not everyone's going to be happy with that, we don't have to ''deal'' with anything If the execution of Sasuke's redemption totally sucks.

Where do I act as my opinion is the only opinion? You just pulled that out of your ass.

 

[Targaryen]

Fix'd :scorps:

Naruto doesn't have authority? Omg lolol. The Kages are on terms with Naruto.
THEY ARE THE AUTHORITY.

Naruto would protect Sasuke IF people didn't listen to him. Naruto would side with Sasuke.
If he had no authority, he'd go against the authority. Not gonna happen. Sorry. :dunno: hmm :erm: :eww:

 

[Wind Squid]

Future attackers will attack what? He didn't know tsunade used slugs to save everybody meaning he was entirely ok for everbody to be wiped out from the village (scratch that... there was no village left) it was 100% selfish not a tactic and btw you are forgetting he cheated his way into being hokage candidate using kotoamatsukami.


Sasuke was the only uchiha left in the planet, is that not constant torture in it self (not to mention whatever nightmares he would have had of the event)... Quit being strong headed im tiring of arguing with you.

There were still plenty of people left in the village and the other villages could easily attack them at any given time so they needed to have at least SOME forces left in order to protect them, and it was easily rebuilded in a short amount of time, durr. And what could Danzou's forces accomplish by throwing themselves at Pein? We have seen Anbus getting mashed around like weak leafs in the rain (ba-duum-tss!) And again, Danzou cheating his way was a minor crime, he would just get jail sentence for about a year or 5

Again, you could say the same for Gaara only suffering one traumatic experience but he didn't. It was constant, unlike Sasuke's. You're just a Sasuke apologist

 

[Xlad]

Oh, he deserves a certain punishment all right.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[Wind Squid]

Naruto doesn't have authority? Omg lolol. The Kages are on terms with Naruto.
THEY ARE THE AUTHORITY.

Naruto would protect Sasuke IF people didn't listen to him. Naruto would side with Sasuke.
If he had no authority, he'd go against the authority. Not gonna happen. Sorry. :dunno: hmm :erm: :eww:

He's a genin for ****'s sake. Doesn't matter if A acknowledges his resolve, his VILLAGE DOESN'T
And Naruto ain't gonna break the law any time soon, bud. Not gonna happen. Sorry

 

[darkprince]

well his actions are justified and he has done more good than harm.
by killing orochimaru,danzo and akatsuki members,he had helped the shinobi world.so there are more chances people would accept him.

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

I'm totally aware of that, knowing the historial of this manga, he won't be punished at all, instead he'll be glorified as a hero(which he will be) and everyone will forget about his crimes.

That definitely wouldn't be right if everyone was punished for their crimes,I would agree with you. But since is this way,his "crimes" are nothing compared to some other characters in this manga.

 

[Wind Squid]

I'm totally aware of that, knowing the historial of this manga, he won't be punished at all, instead he'll be glorified as a hero(which he will be) and everyone will forget about his crimes.



Where did I show a bit of disrespect towards someone's else opinion?, your comment wasn't worthy of respect as all you said was ''deal with it'' and ''Kishimoto won't allow it'', not everyone's going to be happy with that, we don't have to ''deal'' with anything If the execution of Sasuke's redemption totally sucks.

Well..there aren't many actual glorified criminals that come to mind....lol...who are they?

 

[Targaryen]

He's a genin for ****'s sake. Doesn't matter if A acknowledges his resolve, his VILLAGE DOESN'T
And Naruto ain't gonna break the law any time soon, bud. Not gonna happen. Sorry

Ha! Ok, you think Naruto would watch Sasuke die?

If it wasn't for Kakashi and Yamato, Naruto would have duked it out with Raikage at that one point, let alone if Sasuke has come back.

Naruto really wouldn't care, Naruto's emotions > His logic.
He's always been like that. Especially over bonds and his friends etc.

Gotta see the truth. *_*

 

[Wind Squid]

It's not retarded. If you really care that much why don't you make a thread for EVERY single character who has a history of mass-murdering etc. who got off scot-free?

As you just said it's opinion.
So why do you act like your opinion is the only opinion? Other people have opinions too.
Just look at the poll.
You don't respect other peoples opinion yet you expect it?

You must be registered for see images

Well, actually there's only one mass-murdering phsycho that got scot-free but his case was completely justified.
Oh and only like 6 people disagree, and thats's like, the minority, so...yeah. What most people deem to be actual reality has to be so

Ha! Ok, you think Naruto would watch Sasuke die?

If it wasn't for Kakashi and Yamato, Naruto would have duked it out with Raikage at that one point, let alone if Sasuke has come back.

Naruto really wouldn't care, Naruto's emotions > His logic.
He's always been like that. Especially over bonds and his friends etc.

Gotta see the truth. *_*

Uh, no, Naruto wouldn't have ducked it out with A, cause Raikage wouldn't pick on tiny, baby man
He wouldn't let Sasuke die and he wouldn't go against the decision of all the ninja villages so he would probably go into a coma but that's not what gonna happen

 

[Sot viing hun]

Well..there aren't many actual glorified criminals that come to mind....lol...who are they?

Itachi is a clear example of it in my opinion, he sure was a hero, but comitted crimes against Konoha and killed his own kinsmen, but at least he died a criminal and he felt guilty about it, I hope Sasuke feels that same guilt and doesn't die a saint.

Maybe my comment was a bit unfortunate, I just meant that I don't want Sasuke to be a saint clear of all sins just because he recently has opened his eyes and is willing to understand.

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

There were still plenty of people left in the village and the other villages could easily attack them at any given time so they needed to have at least SOME forces left in order to protect them, and it was easily rebuilded in a short amount of time, durr. And what could Danzou's forces accomplish by throwing themselves at Pein? We have seen Anbus getting mashed around like weak leafs in the rain (ba-duum-tss!) And again, Danzou cheating his way was a minor crime, he would just get jail sentence for about a year or 5

Again, you could say the same for Gaara only suffering one traumatic experience but he didn't. It was constant, unlike Sasuke's. You're just a Sasuke apologist

You know we are talking about a made up world of fiction? I don't think you do.

 

[Wind Squid]

Itachi is a clear example of it in my opinion, he sure was a hero, but comitted crimes against Konoha and killed his own kinsmen, but at least he died a criminal and he felt guilty about it, I hope Sasuke feels that same guilt and doesn't die a saint.

Um, excuse me, but, wasn't that the decision of Konoha elders? That was a mission, y'know. They were conspirators and were making a coup'de tat against the village, thus starting the 4th shinobi war. Itachi actually went out of his way as to avoid physcial violence in his future as Akatsuki spy, lol

 

[Wind Squid]

You know we are talking about a made up world of fiction? I don't think you do.

your point being...?

 

[Targaryen]

Well, actually there's only one mass-murdering phsycho that got scot-free but his case was completely justified.
Oh and only like 6 people disagree, and thats's like, the minority, so...yeah. What most people deem to be actual reality has to be so

Uh, no, Naruto wouldn't have ducked it out with A, cause Raikage wouldn't pick on tiny, baby man
He wouldn't let Sasuke die and he wouldn't go against the decision of all the ninja villages so he would probably go into a coma but that's not what gonna happen

Only 6 people.. I didn't pick any option because you're just being a **** to other people opinions~ and I'm sure MANY others don't wanna pick an idiotic option in the poll, so the poll in inaccurate. Sorry bub. :eww:

And yes, yes he would. He's gone against authority for various reasons before, MANY for Sasuke. E.g. Going against Kakashi, Yamato etc.

Starting to think you are a troll, bub. =D

 

[Sot viing hun]

Um, excuse me, but, wasn't that the decision of Konoha elders? That was a mission, y'know. They were conspirators and were making a coup'de tat against the village, thus starting the 4th shinobi war. Itachi actually went out of his way as to avoid physcial violence in his future as Akatsuki spy, lol

I'm totally aware of that, but he still accepted the mission, ironically for the sake of the village I know, that's why Itachi is a tragic hero.

Maybe my comment was a bit unfortunate, I just meant that I don't want Sasuke to be a saint clear of all sins just because he recently has opened his eyes and is willing to understand.

 

[Wind Squid]

You must be registered for see images

Only 6 people.. I didn't pick any option because you're just being a **** to other people opinions~ and I'm sure MANY others don't wanna pick an idiotic option in the poll, so the poll in inaccurate. Sorry bub. :eww:

And yes, yes he would. He's gone against authority for various reasons before, MANY for Sasuke. E.g. Going against Kakashi, Yamato etc.

Starting to think you are a troll, bub. =D

Because there are subjective truths, like personal opinions on musical preferences or favourite genres of cinematic entertainment, and then, there are objective, ahem, "universal" truths, like:
-charging a murderer for the crimes that he had committed.
And anyones opinion that such person shouldn't suffer the consequences of his past sins, is, quite frankly, foolish, and thus, doesn't have the privilege of having his pathetic opinion being respected.

And no, Naruto had only Orally expressed his stance on the subject at hand, he's not going to fight his superiors

Oh also,

You must be registered for see images

 

[Bad Touch Yakushi]

The thing is, the elders and Hiruzen must fundamentally know that they were entirely in the wrong. They created Sasuke and Sasuke had every right to go astray. He was bound to go rogue and they must've known that.

Konoha has enough guilt to know that Sasuke isn't totally at fault. That said, Sasuke also could've done MUCH worse. Joining Akatsuki, killing Danzo & attacking the 5 Kage are pretty big deals but I feel that what he is about to do now will more than redeem him.

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

The thing is, the elders and Hiruzen must fundamentally know that they were entirely in the wrong. They created Sasuke and Sasuke had every right to go astray. He was bound to go rogue and they must've known that.

Konoha has enough guilt to know that Sasuke isn't totally at fault. That said, Sasuke also could've done MUCH worse. Joining Akatsuki, killing Danzo & attacking the 5 Kage are pretty big deals but I feel that what he is about to do now will more than redeem him.

This. Finally someone reasonable .

 

[Wind Squid]

I'm totally aware of that, but he still accepted the mission, ironically for the sake of the village I know, that's why Itachi is a tragic hero.

Maybe my comment was a bit unfortunate, I just meant that I don't want Sasuke to be a saint clear of all sins just because he recently has opened his eyes and is willing to understand.

Welp, actually, if he HADN'T accepted the mission, then he'd be trialed for the defiance against the orders of his superiors, lol. Once again, blame the user and not the gun. Itachi is not just a tragic hero. He is ninja Jesus. I doubt theee... Ninjasus

You must be registered for see images

I totally agree with your stance