Does Sasuke deserve punishment for his crimes?

[Wind Squid]

Lets run through the accidental good he did:

Assisted in killing Haku, Assisted in konoha invasion, Killed Itachi = a mass murder, facilitated death of diedara = kidnapper of kazekage, Killed Danzo = Conspirator against hokage with orochimaru and he also assisted terrorist plots due to his neglect (Pain), He killed original zetsu and a couple more, He assisted in the release of Edo tensei = saving countless more lives, Facilitated revival of previous hokage= they might win this war for good. His character is more complex than you make it seem and in total hes done more good than bad in his life

> Killing haku was his mission. That's like ...if i got praise for going to university
> Don't you mean "assisted in defending the village"? Look above for answer ^
> He wanted to take Deidara for questioning for his own selfish reasons, he probably wouldn't have killed him either cause he had no intent of doing so
> Danzo was still a Vice-Hokage, killing him without a trial is a crime in itself
> Itachi was on spying mission, an agent of Konoha, that's a crimeception
> It was Itachi's idea and he did all of the work by himself (mostly)
> It took 4 greatest undead shinobi to convince Sasuke to march against Madara, and all of them are under Orochimaru's control fyi, whom he had also ressurected

 

[bittu1415]

i think sasuke will be a great reinforcement for them

 

[6thpathsage]

> Killing haku was his mission. That's like ...if i got praise for going to university
> Don't you mean "assisted in defending the village"? Look above for answer ^
> He wanted to take Deidara for questioning for his own selfish reasons, he probably wouldn't have killed him either cause he had no intent of doing so
> Danzo was still a Vice-Hokage, killing him without a trial is a crime in itself
> Itachi was on spying mission, an agent of Konoha, that's a crimeception
> It was Itachi's idea and he did all of the work by himself (mostly)
> It took 4 greatest undead shinobi to convince Sasuke to march against Madara, and all of them are under Orochimaru's control fyi, whom he had also ressurected

All of that is coincidental and he actually didn't care about releasing edo tensei, it was all Itachi's doing, he killed an hokage candidate regarless of if said candidate was an *******, and about the Hokage, he originally just wanted them to answer his questions anyways.

And even if he has done some good, it doesn't negate all the crimes he has comitted, he's guilty of them and should face the consecuences.

If what Danzo did occur when pain invaded was exposed, people will praise sasuke. Candidate or not he was the head of security and he abandoned the village when it needed him the most.

Going by that logic.. Kakashi should face punishments for killing Rin and not considered a hero at all.

Sasuke didn't have the best intentions however looking at his ACTIONS from when he left the village... you would think he was a double agent for the village.

 

[Wind Squid]

If what Danzo did occur when pain invaded was exposed, people will praise sasuke. Candidate or not he was the head of security and he abandoned the village when it needed him the most.

Going by that logic.. Kakashi should face punishments for killing Rin and not considered a hero at all.

Sasuke didn't have the best intentions however looking at his ACTIONS from when he left the village... you would think he was a double agent for the village.

Except that...no one knows that he abandonded the village, who's going to charge him for that? And while that action was a crime, Danzou still had to be trialed and he probably would have been sentenced to jail.

Uh, Kakashi killed Rin cause enemies tried to take hold of her, thus taking hold of Konoha secrets and it's not something that we haven't seen before. Kisame actually took out his entire squad for the same purpose and everyone was kay with that.

and you just took that last one out of your ass

 

[Sot viing hun]

If what Danzo did occur when pain invaded was exposed, people will praise sasuke. Candidate or not he was the head of security and he abandoned the village when it needed him the most.

Going by that logic.. Kakashi should face punishments for killing Rin and not considered a hero at all.

Sasuke didn't have the best intentions however looking at his ACTIONS from when he left the village... you would think he was a double agent for the village.

I understand what you mean, but it doesn't justify all of his crimes, betraying the village with Orochimaru, joining Akatsuki, attacking Bee so Akatsuki could extract him, breaking through the Kage summit, killing a Hokage candidate, all the killings and the fact that he's considered a S rank criminal.

Just now he's been reasonable, and that doesn't negate any crime he has comitted, he really should face the consecuences, a punishment.

 

[Orochimaruofthesound]

Yes, yes he does.​

Here's the list of crimes he had commited:

- Boycotting his village.
- Orochimaru's conspirator and a long-time follower
- Battery and Assault (Kage summit, Team 7)
- Violently attempted robbery (Hachibi)
- Mass manslaughter (Dozens of noble Samurais during Kage summit, all of which had families and friends)
- Aiding criminals in escape from their confinement (Okay, this is a bit of a stretch but Juugo is a total antisocial psycho)
- Assassination of a prominent political figure (Danzou)

Correct me if i missed anything

He wpnt get punished because saving them from certain defeat will clear him. plus whos going to punish him the 5 kages got there asses handed to them by an uchiha

 

[RasenUchihaChaos]

To be or not to be it appears that is the Question!

 

[Wind Squid]

To be or not to be it appears that is the Question!

No it's not the question

He wpnt get punished because saving them from certain defeat will clear him. plus whos going to punish him the 5 kages got there asses handed to them by an uchiha

thats npt the question

 

[-Phoënix Flower-]

Naruto wouldn't let anybody touch Sasuke.

Exactly this U_U

 

[Wind Squid]

Exactly I should probably read the ****ing thread first before drowing retarded conclusions out of my arse this U_U

Fix'd :scorps:

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

I understand what you mean, but it doesn't justify all of his crimes, betraying the village with Orochimaru, joining Akatsuki, attacking Bee so Akatsuki could extract him, breaking through the Kage summit, killing a Hokage candidate, all the killings and the fact that he's considered a S rank criminal.

Just now he's been reasonable, and that doesn't negate any crime he has comitted, he really should face the consecuences, a punishment.

wow,you are such a hater

 

[6thpathsage]

Except that...no one knows that he abandonded the village, who's going to charge him for that? And while that action was a crime, Danzou still had to be trialed and he probably would have been sentenced to jail.

Uh, Kakashi killed Rin cause enemies tried to take hold of her, thus taking hold of Konoha secrets and it's not something that we haven't seen before. Kisame actually took out his entire squad for the same purpose and everyone was kay with that.

and you just took that last one out of your ass

NInja world dont work like that br000.. village betrayers die, look at Hashi and Madara, Jiraya's words to Tsunade, Kakashi's words to kabuto.

I understand what you mean, but it doesn't justify all of his crimes, betraying the village with Orochimaru, joining Akatsuki, attacking Bee so Akatsuki could extract him, breaking through the Kage summit, killing a Hokage candidate, all the killings and the fact that he's considered a S rank criminal.

Just now he's been reasonable, and that doesn't negate any crime he has comitted, he really should face the consecuences, a punishment.

The joining Akatsuki and attacking Bee and kage summits are pretty big ones. but there are two ways Sasuke makes it out of this.

Become a war hero (guaranteed at this point)
OR get Naruto the war hero already to let him of *_*

Id like to see him not accepted into the village, so he can roam the world like jiraiya or start his own village like oro

 

[Wind Squid]

NInja world dont work like that br000.. village betrayers die, look at Hashi and Madara, Jiraya's words to Tsunade, Kakashi's words to kabuto.



The joining Akatsuki and attacking Bee and kage summits are pretty big ones. but there are two ways Sasuke makes it out of this.

Become a war hero (guaranteed at this point)
OR get Naruto the war hero already to let him of *_*

Id like to see him not accepted into the village, so he can roam the world like jiraiya or start his own village like oro

He killed innocent people, remember

 

[Sot viing hun]

wow,you are such a hater

If for wanting Sasuke to receive the punishment he deserves for all his crimes I get labeled as a hater, then okay, I'm a hater

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

You should probably share your opinion with all the judicial court systems in our world.

You seem like an expert on the subject of law, Mark
[video=youtube;9wNGm6dFISQ]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9wNGm6dFISQ[/video]

You should be put to court based on your bad humor only. The point is everyone in Naruto except the main character killed someone. It's a fiction ninja world,deal with it. He won't get any punishment, that is pretty obvious,so deal with it too.

 

[6thpathsage]

He killed innocent people, remember

SO... did Danzo = uchiha massacre, abandoning the village when pain invaded, who knows how many people would have survived if all of root and anbu got involved. Those fodder samurai were collateral damage, they were protecting a murderer.

 

[Hebi Sasuke]

If for wanting Sasuke to receive the punishment he deserves for all his crimes I get labeled as a hater, then okay, I'm a hater

You are so persistent in your "wish",it just seems like hate. Gaara killed so many innocent people and he got his punishment. Oh,wait,no he is a hokage.

 

[Wind Squid]

You should be put to court based on your bad humor only. The point is everyone in Naruto except the main character killed someone. It's a fiction ninja world,deal with it. He won't get any punishment, that is pretty obvious,so deal with it too.

The point is, they kill people that they were only ordered to kill and Sasuke went apeshit and boycotted the village, durr

SO... did Danzo = uchiha massacre, abandoning the village when pain invaded, who knows how many people would have survived if all of root and anbu got involved. Those fodder samurai were collateral damage, they were protecting a murderer.

Ucihas were planning a revolt, and it was the decision of Village elders, the only real crime Danzou did was not helping the village and even that would probably just get him mild jail sentence. Fodder samurai were people, not bugs, and they were protecting the kage summit wich was off limits

You are so persistent in your "wish",it just seems like hate. Gaara killed so many innocent people and he got his punishment. Oh,wait,no he is a hokage.

Gaara was the victim in that situation. And his father was at fault for making him a heartless monster

 

[Sot viing hun]

You are so persistent in your "wish",it just seems like hate. Gaara killed so many innocent people and he got his punishment. Oh,wait,no he is a hokage.

Sure, but did he betray his village? did he kill a candidate to hokage like Sasuke did?, did he join a criminal organisation like Sasuke? was he considered a S rank criminal?, no because he opened his eyes before it was too late, unlike Sasuke, that has only opened his eyes recently, after all he's done, and some people try to just ignore that and claim that he'll be forgiven and freed of sins because of that, I really hate that idea, but it's probably going to happen as I said in my previous comments.

 

[6thpathsage]

Ucihas were planning a revolt, and it was the decision of Village elders, the only real crime Danzou did was not helping the village and even that would probably just get him mild jail sentence. Fodder samurai were people, not bugs, and they were protecting the kage summit wich was off limits



Gaara was the victim in that situation. And his father was at fault for making him a heartless monster

1St : Imagine north korea attacks US and the defence secretary tells the army to stand down, will that get him a mild jail sentence... or a beheading in the city centre?

Sasuke was made like that because of Itachi killing his whole family and friends and showing it to him in a genjustu twice! and you want to blame Sasuke but not Gaara. Just admit Sasuke will not be punished because he wasn't all that bad.