Why Sasuke's Eye Is Not A Rinnegan?

[NaruSasuRival]

First thing first:

If Sasuke shows a proper Rinnegan, I will admit it is a Rinnegan. However, until we see the actual confirmation, I will treat the translation as a mistake.

Second, here is why I think Sasuke does not have the Rinnegan, but a leveled Sharingan.


Rikudo mentioned that his Mother posed the Sharingan, the same Sasuke has!

You must be registered for see images

Sasuke's eyes showing two different Sharingns

You must be registered for see images

Before we argue, know that I like to follow logic because it is the only reason we discuss here. If you check Sasuke's left eye, he has the regular Uchiha Sharingan. That Sharingan has only there tomoe (base). If you look at that eyes, the three tomoes are designed on a circle giving a regular Uchiha Sharingan two circle.

Now, if you look at the right eyes, it has 9 tomoes just like Kaguya. Each triple of tomoe is also inscribed on a circle. This gives the look of Rinnegan, but still it is a requirement for the number of Tomoes needed by the Sharingan.

In addition, Sasuke's right eye is the same as Kaguya's Sharingan. Thus, for now, I think there was a translation error, unless what Hagoromo, Nagato and Madara had before was not a Rinnegan.

My take is that Rikudo gave his power half-half to Sasuke and Naruto. They only got perfection from Rikudo, not brand new power. Naruto perfected the Senjutsus he had before, and Sasuke got the final Sharingan.

PS: I may be wrong, but from a logical view, this is not Rinnegan from a logical view based on what we know.

 

[Klue]

For the 1,000th time, Hagoromo only stated that she possess Sharingan'S POWER. He did not call that eye the Sharingan.

**** are you guys reading?

 

[KINGXEagle]

I totally agree, kaguya never had the rinnegan, the rinnegan is the controlled form of sharingan or more like the evolved version of it.

 

[Erebus]

My thought are something along the lines of Corrupted Sharingan(right) and True Sharingan(left) idk just throwing stuff out there right now

 

[bluvkilla]

Its em rinnegan

 

[DaVe14]

I actually agree with you cause Hagoromo would of stated if she had the Rinnegan but he clearly says sharingan. I think really think he has an upgraded sharigan its not quite the Rinnegan but stronger than EMS though. Almost like a transition stage between the EMS and Rinnegan.

 

[a banned cartoon]

They have been translating the word rinnegan chapter after chapter. I don't think it's a translation mistake. It's not like it's a new word to them.

 

[Mr Hiru]

...there you go.

You must be registered for see links

It seems you also noticed.

 

[Klue]

I actually agree with you cause Hagoromo would of stated if she had the Rinnegan but he clearly says sharingan. I think really think he has an upgraded sharigan its not quite the Rinnegan but stronger than EMS though. Almost like a transition stage between the EMS and Rinnegan.

He says Sharingan's POWER along with Byakugan's power, because those powers were used for her gruesome-world-controlling jutsu. Ocular genjutsu is a power we associate with the Sharingan.

 

[Luesias]

I think that's 3 tomoe not 2.
Its just covered by his eyelid.

 

[DaVe14]

He says Sharingan's POWER along with Byakugan's power, because those powers were used for her gruesome-world-controlling jutsu. Ocular genjutsu is a power we associate with the Sharingan.

Ok but how you gonna have the sharingan's power without the eye though???

 

[warlee]

It's your opinion and interpretation vs kishi's words. This is not even debatable.

 

[HENI]

It's definitely Sharingan according to Hagoromo.

 

[Klue]

Ok but how you gonna have the sharingan's power without the eye though???

Are you asking me how a Rinnegan can have the same power as the Sharingan?

Seriously?

Reread 560 if you're having trouble. Sharingan's natural evolution (final stop / terminal) is the Rinnegan. Sharingan becomes Rinnegan.

 

[NeutralChaos]

In addition, Sasuke's right eye is the same as Kaguya's Sharingan. Thus, for now, I think there was a translation error, unless what Hagoromo, Nagato and Madara had before was not a Rinnegan.

My take is that Rikudo gave his power half-half to Sasuke and Naruto. They only got perfection from Rikudo, not brand new power. Naruto perfected the Senjutsus he had before, and Sasuke got the final Sharingan.

PS: I may be wrong, but from a logical view, this is not Rinnegan from a logical view based on what we know.

What type of logic is this? Sasuke's right eye is attainable by any Uchiha clan member. His left eye is a rinnegan that can also produce Sasuke's mangekyou abilities.

 

[a banned cartoon]

I'm just spit balling here but maybe theirs yin version, and a yang version of that eye. The 9 tomoe Kaguya and the Juubi possessing being red, and the one sasuke posses being blue. Madara's no idiot he would notice the 9 tomoe's on Sasuke's eye before anyone else. He would notice a differance. One made to start infinite Tsukiyomi, and another to stop it. This goes with the whole yin-yang concept. A balance of powers basically.

 

[a banned cartoon]

It could just be a hybrid of the two. A sharinnegan if you will. I'm coining that word by the way.

 

[NeutralChaos]

It could just be a hybrid of the two. A sharinnegan if you will. I'm coining that word by the way.

Too late, it's already been used plenty of times.

 

[NaruSasuRival]

I'm just spit balling here but maybe theirs yin version, and a yang version of that eye. The 9 tomoe Kaguya and the Juubi possessing being red, and the one sasuke posses being blue. Madara's no idiot he would notice the 9 tomoe's on Sasuke's eye before anyone else. He would notice a differance. One made to start infinite Tsukiyomi, and another to stop it. This goes with the whole yin-yang concept. A balance of powers basically.

Well, I will respond to you for everyone. The eye Sasuke has is the same as the eye Kaguya has as far as the manga goes. Concerning Madara, don't forget he is giving his own opinion, and interpreting the opinion of a character has Kishi's is why many people cry plothole later in the manga.

Now, take Naruto for example and what Madara said about him. He said Naruto obtained Rikudo's Senjutsu. Obviously, Madara is wrong because Naruto has always had the same Senjutsus. The only thing that change is the level of the Senjutsu. However, fact is that Madara ignore that Naruto has 9 bijus inside him, and if he knew that, he would not speculate.

Besides, it is obvious that Madara's Rinnegan is different from Sasuke's if Sasuke has Rinnegan. 9 Tomoes Sharingan requires at least 4 5 circles to write it down.

Moreover, if you listen to the whole talk with So6P, you can see that to obtain Rinnegan, you need both Yin and Yang of Rikudo - that is both Sasuke and Naruto's power as Madara did. My take is still the same - that is Sasuke has a more powerful Rinnegan - and it sound well with Tsukyomi just as Itachi's MS that he has.

 

[DaVe14]

Are you asking me how a Rinnegan can have the same power as the Sharingan?

Seriously?

Reread 560 if you're having trouble. Sharingan's natural evolution (final stop / terminal) is the Rinnegan. Sharingan becomes Rinnegan.

I know the Rinnegan is the last evolution of the sharingan you must not know how to read cause it never says that in any of my posts that the sharingan and Rinnegan have the same power.