Why making Naruto/Sasuke transmigrants of Ashura/Indra instead of Hagoromo/Hamura?

[DarkStar1]

I'd imagine there more to this family story than what we've been shown so far, but it feels almost redundant.

All the signs were pointing to Naruto being Hagoromo from chapters like the Kurama's comparison of them, Juubi seeing his eyes behind Naruto, symbols on his cloak, etc. And Hamura had a Byakugan, which will end up confirming Kakashi's monologue about how the Sharingan hails from the Byakugan, so Sasuke could fit in there as well.

So, why force Ashura and Indra roles upon them when they'll most likely have to take the Hagoromo/Hamura route for this fight a la Kaguya noticing Sun Mark on Naruto that Hagoromo also had?

 

[Xlad]

Seems that Hamura's chakra was passed down to Indra.

 

[ObitoRolent]

Your title just brought me to a theory.

 

[Made in Heaven]

Kishi is a moron, that's why.

 

[Sound]

Because Asura and Indra were unsettled between each other and their ways of peace. Hago and Hamura probably were certain of their way of peace

 

[Tobi98]

Because Hagoromo is both Yin and Yang

Ashura and Naruto are Yang

Indra and Sasuke are Yin

 

[wanderingcactus]

Thats what happens when you dont know your endgame and youre writting it as you go along. You tend to not stick to it and change some stuff and having to explain how it got to that part by using a fodder explaining potholes in the most inconvenient time.

 

[Bulch]

Get it
Hagomoro=Ashura=Naruto the same thing.
Same goes for Sasuke

 

[KidGamer65]

Naruto and Sasuke's whole conflict and their power is based off of Ashura and Indra, same as the people before them. Them taking the roles of Hagoromo and Hamura for one fight doesn't mean that Naruto and Sasuke should have been their reincarnations.

The only way they resemble Hagoromo and Hamura is that they are the ones who will seal Kaguya away this time around. That is it..and:

Kishi is a moron, that's why.

Thats what happens when you dont know your endgame and youre writting it as you go along. You tend to not stick to it and change some stuff and having to explain how it got to that part by using a fodder explaining potholes in the most inconvenient time.

Posts like these, clearly don't understand this. At all.

Also, Hagoromo is the original owner of both the Sun mark and the Moon mark. Those were described as Rikudo's Yin and Yang, not to mention Hagoromo can't give them something he doesn't own.