Why didn't Madara give Nagato 1 Rinnegan as opposed to both?

[Floydical]

A necroed thread inspired me...

Its a manga fact that having only 1 Rinnegan grants you access to all 6 paths. Nagato never surpassed that level of jutsu so he didn't need the pair. We saw 3 cases of a person with only 1 Rinnegan, Obito, Sasuke and one-eye Madara. I don't think Nagato would have questioned his eye's origin if he had only one versus two.

Madara could have passed the Rinnegan while keeping one for himself for safe keeping. Madara knew about the ability to use just one, as he showed with such great expertise in the war. Surely he would have thought to only give Nagato one as opposed to both?

 

[Demonic.]

Manga fact that Obito could use all six paths? Who said this nonsense.

 

[Floydical]

Manga fact that Obito could use all six paths? Who said this nonsense.

He directly stated he could use Human realm. He was being forced by Zetsu to revive Madara with Hell realm. Kakashi and company believed he was not using the other techs during their fight because he either didn't have enough chakra or knew the abilities could be properly countered. That's enough evidence if you ask me.

 

[Angelic.]

why wouldnt he? its best to have more power when doing a plan

edot: actually if konan had just destroyed nagatos body, thered be no rinnegan lol

Manga fact that Obito could use all six paths? Who said this nonsense.

he can do anything! u mad?

 

[Sir Blades]

I'm still wondering how Madara new Nagato and when/how did he give him the Rinnegan.

 

[Ansatsuken]

I'm still wondering how Madara new Nagato and when/how did he give him the Rinnegan.

I think Kishi just created that plot on the spot without any planning before same like Kaguya and BZ

 

[Urda]

Manga fact that Obito could use all six paths? Who said this nonsense.

Do people not read the Manga?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

I assume Nagato was entrusted with both of Madara's Rinnegan eyes. However, I never suspected Nagato other eye to carry Rinnegan because it was always covered by his hair. And when Obito took the eye of Rinnegan and transplant it in himself, I concluded it to be true, until later the other pair was stated by Zetsu that Obito hidden it away.

I believe Kishi was foreshadowing the connection of Rinnegan to Madara.

Oh. To your question. I think Madara wanted to awaken the full powers of Rinnegan and utilize the Rinne Birth Technique. He couldn't do that with one Rinnegan. He choice Nagato as a container because Uzumaki has the vitality and large chakra reserves to do so.

 

[Draphsin]

Madara was dying, it was literally pointless to keep an eye. He gave them to nagato as a "storage" of sorts because if somebody found his body [like kabuto did] then they'd have access to a real rinnegan. He passed his eyes on while planning to have the user revive him when the time was right since his body was already old, frail, & would've died w/o the GM.

& He wasn't expecting to be revived at a younger age, he was expecting to be revived still as an old man, BZ was going to take nagato's eyes, & madara was going to become the JJ. That was his plan but it didn't work out that way [got revived as a young edo, got revived via RT by obito, had to get his eyes back separately, had to put the bijuu back into the GM].

 

[Demonic.]

Do people not read the Manga?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

I assume Nagato was entrusted with both of Madara's Rinnegan eyes. However, I never suspected Nagato other eye to carry Rinnegan because it was always covered by his hair. And when Obito took the eye of Rinnegan and transplant it in himself, I concluded it to be true, until later the other pair was stated by Zetsu that Obito hidden it away.

I believe Kishi was foreshadowing the connection of Rinnegan to Madara.

Oh. To your question. I think Madara wanted to awaken the full powers of Rinnegan. HE couldn't do that with one Rinnegan.

Unless I see some feats I'm not taking that as evidence that Obito can use Deva Path. I am aware of the paths he can use.

 

[Urda]

Unless I see some feats I'm not taking that as evidence that Obito can use Deva Path. I am aware of the paths he can use.

We provide you with Manga facts yet you want feats. :| GTFOH

 

[Demonic.]

We provide you with Manga facts yet you want feats. :| GTFOH

I'll give you some facts retard

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

So why should I believe he can use Deva?

 

[Angelic.]

Madara was dying, it was literally pointless to keep an eye. He gave them to nagato as a "storage" of sorts because if somebody found his body [like kabuto did] then they'd have access to a real rinnegan. He passed his eyes on while planning to have the user revive him when the time was right since his body was already old, frail, & would've died w/o the GM.

& He wasn't expecting to be revived at a younger age, he was expecting to be revived still as an old man, BZ was going to take nagato's eyes, & madara was going to become the JJ. That was his plan but it didn't work out that way [got revived as a young edo, got revived via RT by obito, had to get his eyes back separately, had to put the bijuu back into the GM].

his plan was half baked lol

I'm still wondering how Madara new Nagato and when/how did he give him the Rinnegan.

the specific details arent important enough lol. he was also watching obito and chose him. i assume its zetsus role except they made it sound like madara gave the eyes away before the zetsus woke up.

maybe he was in a susanoo wheelchair at one point before needing life support and roamed the world looking for fresh young red haired boys he liked. p:

 

[Urda]

I'll give you some facts retard

You must be registered for see images

So why should I believe he can use Deva?

TF that scans has to do with anything. :|

Edited/ Never-mind. You just prove my point. He didn't have the chakra. Manga facts.

And here is the Viz version:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[Kage BoOmBa No Jutsu]

Madara had discovered the creation of the rinnegan when taking in Hashirama cells (senju+uchiha chakra) but was running out of chakra feeding the gedo. I agree with ANUBIS. Nagato was just madaras hoe in the end.

Response to thread: the concept of having both eyes means complete use and jutsu (for example: kakashi and obito eyes put together creates ultimate kamui and Susanoo)

 

[Demonic.]

TF that scans has to do with anything. :|

Lol This illiterate clown, I don't even know why I waste my time.

If you could read Obito is saying he could not use the Rinnegan to its full extent because the chakra from it was so overwhelming he could barely handle it.

In the Viz he states, "

You must be registered for see links

" implying he was at his limit, yet we never saw him use Deva Path.

If you want to go ahead and give him fanfic abilities like Shinra Tensei and Chibaku Tensei, go ahead, it doesn't mean I (and a group of others much more credible than you) will be inclined to do so.

 

[Ansatsuken]

TF that scans has to do with anything. :|

Different people have different understanding about same thing. That is what I saw here.

No one can said Im right and you are wrong vice versa. Because that I saw never ending arguments/debate in this NB for same matters over and over again

Plus Kishi never gave as full detail about every thing.

 

[Urda]

Lol This illiterate clown, I don't even know why I waste my time.

If you could read Obito is saying he could not use the Rinnegan to its full extent because the chakra from it was so overwhelming he could barely handle it.

In the Viz he states, "

You must be registered for see links

" implying he was at his limit, yet we never saw him use Deva Path.

If you want to go ahead and give him fanfic abilities like Shinra Tensei and Chibaku Tensei, go ahead, it doesn't mean I (and a group of others much more credible than you) will be inclined to do so.

Its not about him using the Deva Path or any of the Paths. It is the fact we know he can use them. Tard.

 

[Angelic.]

Its not about him using the Deva Path or any of the Paths. It is the fact we know he can use them. Tard.

yeah! who said he was going all out?

 

[Demonic.]

Its not about him using the Deva Path or any of the Paths. It is the fact we know he can use them. Tard.

Yet the DB lists Nagato as the sole user of Shinra Tensei. So are you trying to tell me you know more than the person who wrote the manga?

Lol I think I'll stick to giving him the paths that he showed than make speculations, thanks.

 

[SharinganisOP]

Being a non-Uchiha, perhaps Nagato wouldn't be able to use all the powers with only one eye (specifically probably rinne tensei and jutsu related to the gedo statue). An Uchiha could use all the abilities with one eye, excluding the ones unique to the original owner. And then the original owner only needs one eye.