Why are some filler being considered canon while some filler non canon?

[super michael]

I mean in the anime Kishimoto involvement doesn't change no matter what episode the filler is, the only official anime that Kishimoto is involved is Naruto the Last movie and maybe Boruto the movie.

If we include this latest filler doesn't that mean we have to accept all filler like:

Kakashi Ice style and Fire style
Hinata part 1 doing 64 trigram jutsu
Naruto and Gamabunta doing colaboration jutsu
Guren and Shino bugs evolving

Basically any feat done in filler.

 

[Char Aznable]

I mean in the anime Kishimoto involvement doesn't change no matter what episode the filler is, the only official anime that Kishimoto is involved is Naruto the Last movie and maybe Boruto the movie.

If we include this latest filler doesn't that mean we have to accept all filler like:

Kakashi Ice style and Fire style
Hinata part 1 doing 64 trigram jutsu
Naruto and Gamabunta doing colaboration jutsu
Guren and Shino bugs evolving

Basically any feat done in filler.

None of those have been made canon.

 

[super michael]

Hagoromo never had Sharingan in manga, yet member believe it to be canon due to anime.

I see no different having Anime have Hagomoro with Sharingan and Kakashi having Ice style and fire style.

Both are anime filler and not manga.

 

[I Am Richard]

The only Filler that is canon is Raiga.

 

[Marin]

Officially, no filler material is considered canon. Let's get that out of the way right now.

Still, assuming the filler covers parts that are canon and doesn't contradict the manga by doing so, it's not at odds with the canon so, even tho it's still technically filler, there is no harm it treating it as canon. The recent fillers are treated as canon by many because they simply portray the events that have been mentioned in the manga but never fully shown. While doing so they don't make any plot holes so in a sense, they're comparable to the fight extensions we see in the canon fights presented in the anime (like Madara vs Alliance, Obito vs Kakashi etc).

 

[123fire]

Not all filler are canon there are exceptions , when a filler is talking about relevant Characters like Kaguya Hagoromo Hamura Indra and ashura , then we can consider some canon in them!

We should take them as part of the naruto universe not say its fillers who cares

Till now everything happened in the latest Kaguya filler are naruto facts to me

 

[XxTayxX]

Filler is filler.

 

[ANiMUS]

Officially, no filler material is considered canon. Let's get that out of the way right now.

Still, assuming the filler covers parts that are canon and doesn't contradict the manga by doing so, it's not at odds with the canon so, even tho it's still technically filler, there is no harm it treating it as canon. The recent fillers are treated as canon by many because they simply portray the events that have been mentioned in the manga but never fully shown. While doing so they don't make any plot holes so in a sense, they're comparable to the fight extensions we see in the canon fights presented in the anime (like Madara vs Alliance, Obito vs Kakashi etc).

Thats OK if we were just talking about personal interpretation, but considering stuff like the current arc canon and using it in discussions, for things like feats causes problems.

An example could be Hinata's fight against Pein. The anime woukd have you think that Hinata was actually doing something, while in the manga she got solo'd quick.

That's why even ppl choose to stick to manga as the canon source to avoid confusion and retcons

 

[BlacLord™]

The only one considering them canon is 123fire.

But it is just another filler, like the rest. Well worse, because of the contradictions.

 

[Marin]

Thats OK if we were just talking about personal interpretation, but considering stuff like the current arc canon and using it in discussions, for things like feats causes problems.

An example could be Hinata's fight against Pein. The anime woukd have you think that Hinata was actually doing something, while in the manga she got solo'd quick.

That's why even ppl choose to stick to manga as the canon source to avoid confusion and retcons

In versus discussions one should always, ofcourse, use the manga as it is direct word from the author. However, in terms of general presentation there is really nothing wrong with accepting a few details that were added in like Hinata doing something in the fight as it's overall a better presentation out of two and they don't really contradict. Hinata still couldn't do a thing to Pain, but atleast she went down with style.

I'm talking that kind of thing.

 

[Yatori]

The only one considering them canon is 123fire.

But it is just another filler, like the rest. Well worse, because of the contradictions.

This ^^. It's filler but some wants to believe it's canon.

 

[ANiMUS]

In versus discussions one should always, ofcourse, use the manga as it is direct word from the author. However, in terms of general presentation there is really nothing wrong with accepting a few details that were added in like Hinata doing something in the fight as it's overall a better presentation out of two and they don't really contradict. Hinata still couldn't do a thing to Pain, but atleast she went down with style.

I'm talking that kind of thing.

That can lead to some problems. Like I think I heard Obito once beat up Itachi and Itachi somewhat feared him, but the manga said that Obito held back on his plans in fear of Itachi

 

[Ricardo]

123filler strikes again

You must be registered for see images

 

[Yatori]

123filler strikes again

You must be registered for see images

Yato-sama? :WAT:

 

[Ricardo]

Yato-sama? :WAT:

Yeah, you can be the god of calamity now :bdpf:

 

[Marin]

That can lead to some problems. Like I think I heard Obito once beat up Itachi and Itachi somewhat feared him, but the manga said that Obito held back on his plans in fear of Itachi

I don't remember it ever being stated like that. Even so, mutual fear would be nothing unusual for the two.

 

[Yatori]

Yeah, you can be the god of calamity now :bdpf:

Strike!!!

 

[ANiMUS]

I don't remember it ever being stated like that. Even so, mutual fear would be nothing unusual for the two.

For them no, but to NB fanbases it's a big deal.

 

[Marin]

For them no, but to NB fanbases it's a big deal.

lol well the fanbases need to chill and just watch it for fun. It's funny how seriously some people take the manga when not even Kishi gives it that much thought. xd

 

[Vulpini]

If The Last can be considered canon, anything can be considered canon too.