Who's the Better SHINOBI

[jimbobbity]

Sorry, but age and experience don't fly here. These are ninjas with main and branch families, clan massacres, tailed beasts, and unconditional, everlasting love that's supposedly so strong it hurts....Itachi killed his family at 13 and had a damn lover....these characters should be judged on the maturity required to function in this harsh world of theirs....they are shinobi....you don't get to pull the Sakura is only 16 card...nope...sorry.....btw- her and Hinata are basically the same age so there's another feather in Hinata's hat for being able to make the tough decisions she did and I guess having "grown" at a faster rate according to you guys.

Thats almost like saying a 12 year old Naruto would make the same judgements as a 16 year old one (which is obviously not true).

 

[Demonic.]

Hinata neg diff. All sakura cared about was Sasuke's D.

 

[CJ Mac]

This isn't even a debate.

Hinata has demonstrated throughout the series that she has a stronger resolve than Sakura.

During the Chunin Exams, Hinata was introduced as weak, but she was still willing to stand toe to toe with Neji, who, at the time, was considered unbeatable. During the same exams, Sakura had to be saved by Sasuke, Naruto, Lee, Ino-Shika-Cho, and Sasuke (again).

During the Pain Invasion Arc, both Sakura and Hinata survived the destruction of the village pretty much unscathed. Sakura immediately fell to her knees and cried out for Naruto. After realizing what was going on and seeing Naruto in trouble, Hinata was willing to die against Pain. This is yet another case of Hinata standing up against an opponent that she knew outclassed her in every way.

There is no doubt that Sakura is an excellent support shinobi, able to provide medical assistance usually from a distance. However, whenever she has faced adversity or hardship, she has always relied on somebody else to save her and those around her.

 

[RustledJimmies]

That's nice and all, now put Hinata in a position where she has to kill Naruto and see what happens.

 

[Made in Heaven]

Also, notice in the panel I provided that Sakura admits her will is weak, and this is shown when she gave up on saving Sasuke, when she gets sad at Sasuke insulting her and when Sasuke ignores her...

Compare to Hinata who pulled through, continuing her hardest to train despite her father's harsh words, who continued to fight Neji despite knowing she couldn't win, who was willing to risk her life to save Naruto from death, who pulled through after Neji's death, making sure to honor his sacrifice as opposed to letting it go in vain, who was willing to put her love for Naruto aside in order to save her sister and the world

it's very clear which of the two has a stronger will.

 

[FemmeFatale]

Also, HInata was given proper training, and teachings from the main branch on her jutsu and what not, and struggled severely. Even letting a self taught branch memebers surpass her in things she should have mastered.

In a short time, sakura replicated tsunade and Shizune skills and abilities effortlessly,

 

[Mikasa Hagaromo]

Thats almost like saying a 12 year old Naruto would make the same judgements as a 16 year old one (which is obviously not true).

Shiiit...Naruto's a bad ninja too....though his resolve is as strong as they come.....unlike Sakura's....anyway....off I go to watch the Real Housewives...thanks for the feedback....though we disagree, I appreciate your POV and you made some great points.

 

[Shanks]

Sorry, but age and experience don't fly here. These are ninjas with main and branch families, clan massacres, tailed beasts, and unconditional, everlasting love that's supposedly so strong it hurts....Itachi killed his family at 13 and had a damn lover....these characters should be judged on the maturity required to function in this harsh world of theirs....they are shinobi....you don't get to pull the Sakura is only 16 card...nope...sorry.....btw- her and Hinata are basically the same age so there's another feather in Hinata's hat for being able to make the tough decisions she did and I guess having "grown" at a faster rate according to you guys.

That's why i said Sakura was not matured as a ninja untill the war Arc .. I don't see why you compare her to Itachi and Hinata who were all already way more mature enough as a Ninja ..

I probably add her she was insecure and Confused and deep down she was still a fangirl . The moment she was given herself to kill Sasuke she grew up loving him even Karin Noticed it ..

 

[jimbobbity]

This isn't even a debate.

Hinata has demonstrated throughout the series that she has a stronger resolve than Sakura.

During the Chunin Exams, Hinata was introduced as weak, but she was still willing to stand toe to toe with Neji, who, at the time, was considered unbeatable. During the same exams, Sakura had to be saved by Sasuke, Naruto, Lee, Ino-Shika-Cho, and Sasuke (again).

During the Pain Invasion Arc, both Sakura and Hinata survived the destruction of the village pretty much unscathed. Sakura immediately fell to her knees and cried out for Naruto. After realizing what was going on and seeing Naruto in trouble, Hinata was willing to die against Pain. This is yet another case of Hinata standing up against an opponent that she knew outclassed her in every way.

There is no doubt that Sakura is an excellent support shinobi, able to provide medical assistance usually from a distance. However, whenever she has faced adversity or hardship, she has always relied on somebody else to save her and those around her.

I actually agree with this (though its an intentional key part of her character).

 

[Mikasa Hagaromo]

Also, HInata was given proper training, and teachings from the main branch on her jutsu and what not, and struggled severely. Even letting a self taught branch memebers surpass her in things she should have mastered.

In a short time, sakura replicated tsunade and Shizune skills and abilities effortlessly,

Please refer to the first sentence of my original post. This comment brings nothing to the topic at hand.

 

[Silverforsakenhamster]

Not same thing .. You are a female you must know how complex Women's love is . No matter what it takes whether the person is good or bad she loved him ..

When has it ever been stated that a women's love is complex? What's complex is the person, not love.

She would probably sacrifice her own life instead....but I have reason to believe she would as she wept bitterly while doing it bc she seems to get what being a shinobi is all about.

Yeah right she probably would kill herself.

Actually, I'm about to go to bed....but to clarify my point is giving up being with the person she loves for the sake of the world....saving Sasuke is not giving him up.....Hinata gave up on her own happiness of being with Naruto for the sake of the world...Sakura faltered.

But isn't it time you go through with it. You agree with all these peoples point but you refuse that the two girls are similar. Here everyones defending Sakura, only a few times do you see this happen, and it's not clear enough that your comparisons are completely wrong? You've been defending Hinata throughout this whole thread, and yet you agree with other users' points. Your main aim is to prove how you justify their actions, when you obviously haven't even seen the real source of what your comparing to. This argument and this thread is a fail and misconcepted.

 

[jimbobbity]

Shiiit...Naruto's a bad ninja too....though his resolve is as strong as they come.....unlike Sakura's....anyway....off I go to watch the Real Housewives...thanks for the feedback....though we disagree, I appreciate your POV and you made some great points.

No, i actually agree with you. I was just sayig that imo your examples were a bad choice. Anyway peace out.

Real Housewives is a horrible show btw. Lol

 

[Shanks]

Please give me a popcorn i want to see femme vs Lady Byakugan .. This will be interesting to watch ..

 

[Mikasa Hagaromo]

That's why i said Sakura was not matured as a ninja untill the war Arc .. I don't see why you compare her to Itachi and Hinata who were all already way more mature enough as a Ninja ..

I probably add her she was insecure and Confused and deep down she was still a fangirl . The moment she was given herself to kill Sasuke she grew up loving him even Karin Noticed it ..

Oh ok then. So you agree Hinata's maturity and resolve by extension is greater than Sakura's. Got ya.

 

[Shanks]

When has it ever been stated that a women's love is complex? What's complex is the person, not the love.

.

My Girlfriend .. She say Women's love is complex sometime men don't understand it ..

 

[Shanks]

Oh ok then. So you agree Hinata's maturity and resolve by extension is greater than Sakura's. Got ya.

Hinata was already a mature character since Chunnin arc ..

 

[Made in Heaven]

Also, HInata was given proper training, and teachings from the main branch on her jutsu and what not, and struggled severely. Even letting a self taught branch memebers surpass her in things she should have mastered.

In a short time, sakura replicated tsunade and Shizune skills and abilities effortlessly,

Proper training ? Did you miss the whole backstory of Hinata and Neji's relationship? She only ever learned the very basics of the Gentle Fist before her father stopped training her, afterwards she trained on her own for a long time until Neji seemingly began traiing her.

 

[FemmeFatale]

Please refer to the first sentence of my original post. This comment brings nothing to the topic at hand.

No because being a shinobi , you have to factor in that stuff.
Sakura, being emotional able sasuke was still able to push through and become her best,

Hinata always spoke about her nindo and all this stuff but never really pushed her self, you guys are making Hinata somethings she isn't, she was no back bone, she only show off when naruto is around,
Sure sakura wanted to impress sasuke a lot, but he is the same all around.
Sakura was emotional, yes, but only with sasuke ....and you have to realize, sakura didn't comsoder that fight to be seriously to the death. To her sasuke will always be that boy,math at team mate, she once fought aside.

Thought Hinata does have the cold factor down pack,when NEji died she was pressed for naruto. So happy he held he hand, NEji head at her fight and everything.

 

[Tantalus Thief]

This thread certainly is interesting.

 

[~Ethereal~]

Congrats on making a hot thread...I still don't know the answer.