who is the smarter shinobi?

Westernaut

Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2012
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Though one.
But I'm gonna have too say Minato.
like SasoriOfTheRedSaand already said: Minato uses self made techniques, with thats skill and intelligence.
Besides that: Minato was Hokage: It was his job to be smart
 

shelke

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
22,716
Reaction score
2,495
I don't care about most fanboy wars, but one important factor you people have missed here. Most of Minato's feats we have seen - all of them - were well into his prime. He was around 25-26 in the episodes with his team, and just touching 30 when he died. How can you say that Itachi has lesser intelligence, when will less experience he has shown more impressive feats? Itachi clearly takes this, due to being extremely mature and level-headed for someone so young.
 

Lucidus

Legendary
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
11,733
Reaction score
1,291
minato takes this one but itachi is definetly a close second
 

cmilius

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jan 4, 2012
Messages
983
Reaction score
31
Minato is smarter than itachi. minato has proven that no one can touch him and showed what it is to find weaknesses like tobi's s/t which took gai, kakashi and yellow flash naruto to even break his mask when minato on the other hand, did more than beat him.

Itachi as well is a genius who had proven to find weaknesses in short times but minato is faster in that category and more dangerous than even madara himself.

Credibility plan of the two: Itachi plan failed
Minato plan works this is what gave him the total 5 points up for the smartest.
 

Barac Obama

Banned
Joined
Oct 14, 2012
Messages
28
Reaction score
2
any one who is smart enough or not a uchihaa d**k rider knows the fact that Minato is wayyyy smarter than itachi.

just look at minato's feats.

1.rescued kushina , just by figuring out the path made by her hairs
2.youngest hokage of all times
3.developed many complex jutsu like FTG,rashingan, death reaper seal and the list goes on
4.has a keen sense of analyzing objects and events like the way he analyzed TBB and chidori just by looking at it and finding out its shortcoming and weakness.
5.fought A and B and he also found out B was a jinchuriki at the spot and adviced A about future of killer B
6.He fought OP Tobi , found out his weakness in few minutes later and defeated him and was able to save his family, Konoha Village from 9 Tail fox.
7. Minato was extremely foresighted and he knew it was Madara or his henchman who caused the attack on konoha so he sealed half of kyubi chakra to naruto so that he would be able to fight the masked man.Similarly he also put his own chakra and kushina's chakra in naruto anticipating the seal will grow weak and reinforce it in future.

8. Minato was always a winner and he never did any thing wrong. even after his death he guided Naruto to right path and always did his best for betterment of konoha.
9.And the best part about minato is that he dont have Op sharingan ,which can read,predict,do many Op jutsu nor he had senju strenght or Uzumake life force. Minato was a normal ninja who came out best among the rest. and its all beacuse of his will power and intelligence.


Now lets talk about Itachi

yup itachi is a great intelligent ninja too but all i can see is failure and backfired plan and strategies only

1.Ist of all itachi has a huge advange , i.e sharingan which makes even a simple ninja Op. The main reason itachi pawned all of the other ninjas are sharingan. Look itachi himself admitted that the moment his M.S activated at that fruitful day he obtained tsukuyomi and Amatersu. these tech are obtained by lineage not earned by hard training or intelligence.So they are virtually gifts. same goes for his susanoo which was also free gifts from god .Hence itachi's intelligence is limited to how well his eyes are developed. I am preety sure itachi would be no better than a simple anbu fodder captain without his M.s and sharingan.

2.peoples talk about itachi's feats well to me all i see is failures in Itachi's corner.
a.Itachi let his friend shi sui die and couldnt save him from Danzou. itachi only reached shi sui's final death bed to awaken his M.S and take SHI SUI's eyes
b.Itachi even coulnt convince his villager to stop Coup D feat and made the worst possible choice of killing all his clan members.Well what the fking use of being intelligent if its used against your own family and kill you own family. Fk that intelligence
c.Itachi was only a pawn in the great lie of history by Tobi, Tobi manipulated and used itachi for his grandscheme and itachi didnt knew even after his death who exactly tobi was !!!!!!!!!!! what a waste of great intelligence.
d.Itachi made an ass out of his intelligence when he got surprised and ambushed by Jiraiya and nearly got his ass digested in frog's stomach. and both itachi and kishame had to run for their lives.
e.Itachi spared life of his brother sasuke , only for him to be a vigilante and destroy the same konoha that itachi vowed to protect hence this is another grand failure.
f. Even during his whole lifetime itachi never won a single major fight ,except for trolling kakashi and Orochimaru . and non of these battle showed any of his intelligence prowess but only OP genjutsu rendered by sharingan hence i havent seen any intellegence at all
g. Now about edo itachi , well he was just a tool of kabuto and luckily shi sui eyes gave his awarness back so itachi beacame super powerful due to edo body and with help of naruto and killer B he was able to seal nagato. but u guys should know since itachi spend years with nagato so obviously he knows nagato has rinnegan. and his abilities bcoz unlike jiraiya , Itachi was quite friendly and familiar with pain's ability and plans.


hence all of above points proves that minato is way above itachi's league. In one place Minato is always a winner and who always plans right while itachi is the biggest failure in entire nartuoverse
 

shelke

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
22,716
Reaction score
2,495
c.Itachi was only a pawn in the great lie of history by Tobi, Tobi manipulated and used itachi for his grandscheme and itachi didnt knew even after his death who exactly tobi was !!!!!!!!!!! what a waste of great intelligence.
d.Itachi made an ass out of his intelligence when he got surprised and ambushed by Jiraiya and nearly got his ass digested in frog's stomach. and both itachi and kishame had to run for their lives.
e.Itachi spared life of his brother sasuke , only for him to be a vigilante and destroy the same konoha that itachi vowed to protect hence this is another grand failure.
f. Even during his whole lifetime itachi never won a single major fight ,except for trolling kakashi and Orochimaru . and non of these battle showed any of his intelligence prowess but only OP genjutsu rendered by sharingan hence i havent seen any intellegence at all
g. Now about edo itachi , well he was just a tool of kabuto and luckily shi sui eyes gave his awarness back so itachi beacame super powerful due to edo body and with help of naruto and killer B he was able to seal nagato. but u guys should know since itachi spend years with nagato so obviously he knows nagato has rinnegan. and his abilities bcoz unlike jiraiya , Itachi was quite friendly and familiar with pain's ability and plans.


hence all of above points proves that minato is way above itachi's league. In one place Minato is always a winner and who always plans right while itachi is the biggest failure in entire nartuoverse

Itachi never vowed to protect konoha. He only slaughtered the clan to Save Sasuke. And I wouldn't call sparing his brother a failure. It's called love and compassion for a family member. Aside of that, carry on.
 

Flawž

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
12,247
Reaction score
1,407
My father..Minato is smarter. itachi is also smart!
 

Barac Obama

Banned
Joined
Oct 14, 2012
Messages
28
Reaction score
2
Itachi never vowed to protect konoha. He only slaughtered the clan to Save Sasuke. And I wouldn't call sparing his brother a failure. It's called love and compassion for a family member. Aside of that, carry on.

dude u need to read the manga once again. He didnt did the massacre to save sasuke . he did it to save the village
 

shelke

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
22,716
Reaction score
2,495
dude u need to read the manga once again. He didnt did the massacre to save sasuke . he did it to save the village

Dude, he slaughtered the clan to save Sasuke. Read the chapter with Iatchi's past and his final conversation with Sasuke in Edo form. It will make everything clear to you. And if Itachi is a patriot as yo make him sound like, then he would have stopped Sasuke when he told him he was going to destroy the village, instead this is what he said: "I don't care if you forgive me. But no matter what you do from now on; I'll love you forever". Which means, even if Sasuke destroyed the village, Itachi wouldn't care.
 

Omnislash X SageMode

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Mar 21, 2012
Messages
984
Reaction score
72
minato...
itachi is close but minato planned forth narutos future (either on the fly or in a state of crisis i forget), defended the leaf village, redirected the TBB on the fly, hid some of his chakra to be able to meet his son in the event the 9tails is about to be unleashed and last but not least he fought against obito and won in a matter of minutes..
 

Bijuu Master

Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
233
Reaction score
7
minato...
itachi is close but minato planned forth narutos future (either on the fly or in a state of crisis i forget), defended the leaf village, redirected the TBB on the fly, hid some of his chakra to be able to meet his son in the event the 9tails is about to be unleashed and last but not least he fought against obito and won in a matter of minutes..
I agree with you.
 

Cassosphere

Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2012
Messages
208
Reaction score
9
dude its not itachi ..he would be 2nd or so ...minato will always be first no matter how you look at it ..you could say itachi because he was older and had more expirience and more time to learn things.. but minato was younger- he made rasengan from watching the kyubi use tbb ..for the first time ...he firgured out tobi's s/t faster than people who have seen it more than twice..he out smartest alot of people ...and he always was at his best since he was a kid.. ( at the part where he rescues kushina) - if minato lived to itachi's age he would have been smarter from the expirience though i understand people saying itachi is first though... i just dont believe he is

1.minato
2.itachi

Minato is about the same age as the Raikage. in his later 20's or 30's

Itachi was in his younger 20's
 

Cassosphere

Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2012
Messages
208
Reaction score
9
Minato created rasengan which was based on tbb that means he has experienced a fighting with a biju before since he had rasengan that means it wasn't the first time he faced a tbb and a bijuu he had intel it was itachi s first time facing a ct and he imediatly found out the weakness so itachi has the edge here :) itachi also knew about rinnegan s shared vision which shows his Knoledge :)

Actually, before minato faced the kyuubi he already had the rasengan! How do you think Kakashi did the chidori at 13? (the chidori comes from the rasengan)
 

naruTOBoI007

Member
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
59
Reaction score
2
Minato just because he found out how to beat Tobi in moment's time and stopped 9-tails from destroying the village. Plus there is a reason he is the 4th hokage.
 
Top