[Discussion] Who is narrating one piece

[Tomato God]

You must be registered for see images

It says I which in story telling Is an indicator of First person... So who ever is narrating one piece is one of the straw hats...

 

[Artesia]

Wasnt it a decendent of that guy who travelled alot Norland who told the story

 

[Flakez]

You know who is narrating?

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

The Narrator.

 

[Olorin]

Oda

 

[silmarill]

should be Montblanc Norland no?

 

[Tomato God]

Oda

Thats what I thought but oda would use third person pronoun Everytime "they" look at the sky not every time "I".. Unless oda is a character on the ship which only raises more questions.

 

[Yusuke Urameshi]

It makes sense for it to be Montblanc Noland.

 

[silmarill]

It makes sense for it to be Montblanc Noland.

Actually I was wrong . It does not make sense since Norland had no idea Skypea was up in the sky

 

[Tomato God]

Actually I was wrong . It does not make sense since Norland had no idea Skypea was up in the sky

Oh dammit now I have more questions...

 

[silmarill]

Oh dammit now I have more questions...

lol u are on to something

Op is actually being told by granpa Usopp

 

[Tomato God]

lol u are on to something

Op is actually being told by granpa Usopp

OR its luffy's captain log being read to his babies by their mommy Hancock.

 

[Manicherryblossom33]

should be Montblanc Norland no?

I don't really care whose narrating. More importantly, that sigXD

 

[Derek1st]

I thought it was chopper

 

[silmarill]

OR its luffy's captain log being read to his babies by their mommy Hancock.

More logical would be that it's Cricket Montblanck saying that. This is actually his story to a bit + he says 'fairy land' ...
A Strawhat would not say that. They would say Skypea
Unless old and senile ofcourse

 

[Tomato God]

More logical would be that it's Cricket Montblanck saying that. This is actually his story to a bit + he says 'fairy land'
A strawhat would not say that, they would say Skypea
Unless old and senile ofcourse

Luffy Is Young and senile. Luffy calling it a fairy land because he doesn't understand it makes perfect sense.

 

[silmarill]

Luffy Is Young and senile. Luffy calling it a fairy land because he doesn't understand it makes perfect sense.

Luffy is not the story telling type. He can't even listen to a story for 5 minutes without falling asleep..let alone actually telling it

Nope this is Montbland Cricket. It makes perfect sense

 

[Tomato God]

Luffy is not the story telling type. He can't even listen to a story for 5 minutes without falling asleep..let alone actually telling it

Nope this is Montbland Cricket. It makes perfect sense

I'll accept it because I doubt luffy can read.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Either Bartolomeo, Cricket or Sabo or maybe Ace talking with Roger and Whitebeard in the afterlife, though the narrator sometimes sounds scholarly.

Edit: It could also be Dadan or Mariko telling her kid the story of Luffy

Edit 2: Final answer is the spirit of the Going Merry.

 

[Tomato God]

Edit 2: Final answer is the spirit of the Going Merry.

Seeing as we have seen the merry communicate through boxed speech like that already it makes sense. And the Mini merry could just hold the Spirit of the old merry making it so it can still tell the story.

 

[Hexuze]

That seems pretty cliche.