Who do you think should’ve been the final villain?

[Pappasaur]

Kaguya, Orochimaru would have been sad, and seeing Madara defeated would have been sad too.
That he was kinda left like a loose end was ok for me.
He was so powerful nobody really defeated him, he was backstabbed by plot.
It makes sense they just fight some mysterious character at the end for me.
Only thing I would have wanted was that she would have been mentioned like earler, instead of like being name dropped near the end and all of a sudden she is there.

It’s hard to decide how orochimaru would fit in at the end honestly, I feel like the plot would’ve had to change a lot for that to happen. And I agree completely about kaguya; great concept and horrible execution lol.

As far as madara goes, I actually feel the opposite about him ending as a loose end. He was hinted at and built up for a lot of part 2 and didn’t even get a solid ending. I thought it felt lame and anticlimactic

 

[Pappasaur]

Orochimaru.

This! u_u

Edit: Itachi? Lol

Oro is always gonna have a special place in my heart as a top tier villain honestly, and so will Itachi. But the more I think about it the more they feel like specificly sasuke related villains, and not so much someone to close the story with

 

[Pappasaur]

Obito. it started with him and should have ended with him

I get what you mean. Idk if I agree, but he had a unique presence in the manga and his kamui was nearly impossible to deal with. He would’ve been better dying as a villain imo than having a redemption at the end, it would’ve felt a lot heavier to see someone so pure as a child die as a cold hearted villain

 

[Animegoin]

All good points. Madara was a big let down due to poor writing, and even more so for kaguya. Madaras “defeat” at the hands of black zetsu still hasn’t been explained, what technique did BZ use that had more effect than RSM naruto, Rinnegan Sasuke, and 8th gate Gai? It was a lame cop-out for a powerful villain and kaguya had literally zero development besides Hagoromo saying he had a mom once. If madara had a more consistent personality and a fitting defeat and if kaguya had actually been built up to, they could’ve both been viable end game villains

The technique was the infamous plot-no-jutsu, which I’m not mad that it happened but I’m disappointed at how it was executed.

 

[Pappasaur]

The technique was the infamous plot-no-jutsu, which I’m not mad that it happened but I’m disappointed at how it was executed.

I just wish the ending hadn’t been rushed. And I think I heard it before, but didn’t kishi lose his editor after a while?

 

[Light up the Darkness]

Tobi was the best
once that mask broke and we saw obito's motivation for being a villain

it goes downhill from that point

so my answer is Uchiha Madara ​

 

[Animegoin]

I just wish the ending hadn’t been rushed. And I think I heard it before, but didn’t kishi lose his editor after a while?

Same here and I’m not entirely sure, I didn’t keep up with things like that lol.

 

[Uverdore9]

Itachi/Nagato.

It's disturbing that these many like and voted for Madara. The Edo Tensei was quite unappealing & lost the "sense" of shinobi in all definitions of it. He was the center of it. Yet some how many like him for some weird reason.

 

[Klubargutan]

Obito. it started with him and should have ended with him

Actually you're right...Until he got the rinnegan, I totally enjoyed his appearance...but then it started going sour, even worse when Madara appeared, and after Obito being unmasked by rasengan, things turned into a poop.

 

[Peculiar Chester]

Why would anyone vote for Itachi? He wasn't the main villain at any point in the series.

Anyways, my answer is Obito.