Who did you prefer as the villain/antagonist: Madara or Obito?

[The Work]

Obito was doing so good until the mask came off.

 

[HiddenSound]

Madara is better for me because he has more "solid reasons" than Obito. He actually experienced wars himself since he was a kid and it was that experience that shaped him to who he is.

While Obito, just because his loved one died, just one, he lost hope of the entire world, which is very lame. He was very naive kid at that point in time and got manipulated very easily by Madara.

Nevertheless, both of them are tyrannical and arrogant in that they believe that only their opinions are correct. Both wanted to force the MT on the people event though the people resisted it. They never actually care to explain the full reasoning of their plans to every people, yet wanted to obliterate anybody who opposed.

Obito also experienced war :|
Also, Obito is an orphan. The only person he ever loved was Rin, and she died. So it's odd that you put it that way, "just one." She's all he had.

 

[mohdzarif]

Obito also experienced war :|
Also, Obito is an orphan. The only person he ever loved was Rin, and she died. So it's odd that you put it that way, "just one." She's all he had.

Yeah right Obito also experienced war but it was just for a moment. Madara was living his life in periods of war from his childhood till his adulthood. Obito never needed to actually went on the front line fighting the enemies directly while Madara experienced that from his childhood. He lost many brothers but still he endured it, while Obito just lost Rin.

In Madara's era as kid, I supposed there was more sense of danger going on as at that time, the system of "hidden villages" wasn't created yet. Everybody including small kids were in constant fear of being attacked by enemies. While in Obito's era, everybody in the villages are generally safe almost all the time. Wars happened outside the villages.

Okay I get that he's an orphan. But the sole reason for him turning evil was because of Rin only, not because of his parents. We never knew anything about his parents, probably he never knew parental love just like Naruto and actually never really felt bad about not having parents because he was used to it, just like Naruto.

 

[HiddenSound]

Yeah right Obito also experienced war but it was just for a moment. Madara was living his life in periods of war from his childhood till his adulthood. Obito never needed to actually went on the front line fighting the enemies directly while Madara experienced that from his childhood. He lost many brothers but still he endured it, while Obito just lost Rin.

Okay I get that he's an orphan. But the sole reason for him turning evil was because of Rin only, not because of his parents. We never knew anything about his parents, probably he never knew parental love just like Naruto and actually never really felt bad about not having parents because he was used to it, just like Naruto.

Yes. Madara was on the battlefield longer and he did lose more family.
But the thing is, it didn't hit him as hard as it hit Obito because he actually had a father. And another brother. And more family that he obviously trusted and vice versa seeing how he became head of the Uchiha.

Obito never had such bonds. Sure he was an Uchiha, but he obviously never felt loved. The only person he loved was Rin, and she died. In that moment Obito snapped because he, unlike Madara in his childhood, had nothing left. He did mostly everything for Rin.

I'm not saying one's tragedy is greater than the other, they both suffered in similar and dissimilar ways. It's not so easy to just say "yup ___'s pain > ___'s pain".

 

[mohdzarif]

Yes. Madara was on the battlefield longer and he did lose more family.
But the thing is, it didn't hit him as hard as it hit Obito because he actually had a father. And another brother. And more family that he obviously trusted and vice versa seeing how he became head of the Uchiha.

Obito never had such bonds. Sure he was an Uchiha, but he obviously never felt loved. The only person he loved was Rin, and she died. In that moment Obito snapped because he, unlike Madara in his childhood, had nothing left. He did mostly everything for Rin.

I'm not saying one's tragedy is greater than the other, they both suffered in similar and dissimilar ways. It's not so easy to just say "yup ___'s pain > ___'s pain".

I agree on Obito's pain. But he still had Minato and Kakashi although they might not felt very close to him in terms of bonds compared to Rin.

But still, it was unreasonable that just because his loved one died, he wanted to change the entire world. He "said" and "promised" it to Rin just after he slaughtered all the Kirigakure shinobis. If it's all because he was sad about Rin, then no need to think about changing the entire world forcing other people to live in a fake world. Just put himself in the genjutsu world to live with Rin, no need to force others to follow you. He was just being fooled by Madara's words at that time.

 

[lelerskates]

Except, she didn't give a hand, unless you can show me where. Like I said, the only thing Kaguya influenced Madara one, was her power inspiration. Didn't do anything with the plan.​

Where does it say that Kaguya started manipulating Black Zetsu, the moment he was created? Rest is a fan-fictional nonsense you made up.​

He didn't even have a character. He was all bland.​

You are trying so hard to defend Madara; But you and I both know that the story is only going to continue and show that Kaguya was the main villain all along. Did you ever think that maybe when Madara had both Indra's and Ashura's transmigrated chakras that maybe Kaguya's chakra also transmigrated into him, thus causing the start of the plan? You are basing your argument on what you want rather than what make sense.

 

[RasenUchihaChaos]

Weak guy upgraded by another is like kid naruto


Or man born in a age of war bro dies foresees the decline of his clan wishes for peace is a ba is a good fighter trained to be a skilled shinobi Trashed several other ninjas

Captured all nine bijuu while akatsuki led by obito failed to cap them all after several years

I choose madara

 

[awesomeseimei]

I liked Obito when he was mysterious but Madara is more epic.

 

[Angelic.]

i would say madara if he himself wasnt being used... ppffftttt
obito saw and did alot more than just what bashers say about only doing it for rin. he gave up on his dream because madara brainwashd him and turned obito into a madara jr. obito is also more relevant to the plot. madaras ideology might be behind tobi but obito still cooler :] the end.

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

Madara never really felt threatening after obito has been Juubi jin. He's got rinnegan? We just took down a juubi jin. He's juubi jin now? Oh if only we had any experience fighting those!

 

[Angelic.]

he was more threatening without eyes..... now hes kaguyas shiny new body with pretty hair.

 

[Vapid]

Did I mention that they both are godawful villains?

 

[Kakashi Hatakeo]

I did not like obito but compared to madara I like him better

 

[Ldude]

I wanted both of them to work together. They had the same goal, anyways.

 

[Telekinesis]

In the end we've been following Uchiha Obito's story

You must be registered for see images

 

[naruttebayo]

obito all the way

madara is a loser

lost to hashi countless times
became gai's punching bag
became narto / sauce's b!tchh

 

[Lord Orochimaru]

Forget Madara or Obito. You want antagonist I give you Orochimaru.
And I am not Bashing. If I had to choose. I would take obito

 

[Zol]

Jutsu =/= Plan.

Madara's plan didn't simply revolve around the Jutsu. It revolved around long-term thinking, using pawns, and gathering the components back together. ''Its time to become one'' - Madara's line. Kaguya never had influence on the plan. She used the Jutsu. Madara was the one who came up with the plan of how to get things back and achieve it.​

Eh, yes. I guess that's why Kaguya said "It's finally time to become one" after Madara absorbed the Shinju...

Madara is a good character, as is Obito, but please, accept that he was a puppet all along...

 

[UnknownJin]

Kaguya, because she is the Goddess of us all *bows*

do u see Kaguya's name anywhere? .... tttt this ppl , btw cool sig

 

[EliteShinobi]

For me, I prefer Obito over Madara.
But I like Madara too.