[Discussion] WhiteBeard vs Garp
- Thread starter MickNerks
- Start date
YellowFang
Active member
WB!!!
Due to insufficient hype and featlessness of Roger and Garp, I've made my opinion thus far; WB[prime]>=Roger[prime]>=Garp[prime]
Due to insufficient hype and featlessness of Roger and Garp, I've made my opinion thus far; WB[prime]>=Roger[prime]>=Garp[prime]
Punk Hazard
Active member
Awards
Not really. Shanks isn't stronger than Mihawk just because he's a Yonko. Mihawk is stronger because his title is based solely on strength, while Shanks' titles comes with a set of politics.
Okay :/
Bold: It's Buggy who made the statement. Buggy only came in the crew during Roger's last journey to become Pirate King, which means Whitebeard and Roger fought at that moment. It's also noteworthy that he said WB was the only one(so no Garp, no Shiki, etc) who could fight equally with the late Pirate King(Roger). It's exactly what he said. He was clearly talking about a Roger as a pirate king
Shanks has feats unlike Garp U_U.Yes and Garp is neither the Hero of the Marines nor a Haki beast
Either way, enjoy your day arguing the usual
1. Clashed with Whitebeard while only using one hand whilst whitebeard was using two.
2. His conqueror haki is so strong that it Damages material thing not just people.
3. Stopped marineford war
the only feat Garp has shown are lifting up a giant iron ball and supposedly crushing 8 mountains for training which is technically hype cuz we didnt see it. and punching Marco. Admit it Garp is strong yes but he doensnt have enough feats to put him above whitebeard.
Honestly, I dont know who would win, but I know who ever did win it would take the Extremely High Diff, and they themselves would be in critical condition after the fight.
Im pretty sure that Garp can tank a direct tremor punch, and Im sure WhiteBeard can tank a Haki enhanced Garp Punch. Im also confident that what WhiteBeard did to Akainu would NOT happend to Garp. There power is closer to each others then Akainu's was to whitebeard.
Im pretty sure that Garp can tank a direct tremor punch, and Im sure WhiteBeard can tank a Haki enhanced Garp Punch. Im also confident that what WhiteBeard did to Akainu would NOT happend to Garp. There power is closer to each others then Akainu's was to whitebeard.
WB high diff.
It was stated that garp and roger nearly killed each other but when was that, in what period of time was that, it could very well be when roger and garp were almost equals and roger later on advanced and became stronger, this is what mere fodders knew about garp and roger:
It tells that he cornered Roger, but it was never stated that he cornered him when both were at the peak of their power, in the other side we have plenty hype and feats that put WB above anyone on the manga except Roger, look what a crew member of the PK ship said about WB:
WB as the "only man" who tied with WB, buggy knew better than mere fodders that WB was the only guy to ever fight Roger on par, it means they were equals in power and standing.
Not only that we had the manga itself who proved that WB>anyone:
Even though sengoku knew the power of garp he always said that WB is the WSM, and nothing changes that, even garp itself puts WB on a pedestal:
His hype and feats are better, why someone claims that Garp>WB I dont get it.
It was stated that garp and roger nearly killed each other but when was that, in what period of time was that, it could very well be when roger and garp were almost equals and roger later on advanced and became stronger, this is what mere fodders knew about garp and roger:
You must be registered for see links
It tells that he cornered Roger, but it was never stated that he cornered him when both were at the peak of their power, in the other side we have plenty hype and feats that put WB above anyone on the manga except Roger, look what a crew member of the PK ship said about WB:
You must be registered for see links
WB as the "only man" who tied with WB, buggy knew better than mere fodders that WB was the only guy to ever fight Roger on par, it means they were equals in power and standing.
Not only that we had the manga itself who proved that WB>anyone:
You must be registered for see links
You must be registered for see links
Even though sengoku knew the power of garp he always said that WB is the WSM, and nothing changes that, even garp itself puts WB on a pedestal:
You must be registered for see links
His hype and feats are better, why someone claims that Garp>WB I dont get it.
Uzumaki Macho
Active member
Mihawk doesn't have a crew or territory, so he can't be a Yonko. It has nothing to do with his strength.
Buggy was also fodder when he made the comment so your point is void.
Gol Roger himself stated that they nearly killed each other as well. Are you saying that his words dont matter:
You must be registered for see images
Last edited:
but it was stated by roger, he had fought garp so many times he considered him a friend and trusted him enough to tell him about his son.
and how do we know that when they fought roger was in his prime and garp wasn't?
"we nearly killed each other countless times"(from roger himself to garp)
we can easily conclude that they might have been almost, if not equal.
now answer this, is that statement in the manga for a FACT or are we speculating like you are?
Didn't you read one piece marineford arc properly????WB was not healthy and he is near to death.He was stabbed by squalo and 3 admirals landed serious blows and he was still standing.He got hit with bullets and 267 sword slashes,gun wounds of 152,shot by canon 46 times he received and he died standing so u think akainu can take all these and survive??????
garp takes this high-diff in my op.
Hinata Loves Naruto
Member
are you on drugs? Garp would absolutely STOMP Sakazuki...
On topic, Whitebeard very high Diff
Punk Hazard
Active member
Awards
Forbidden Tale
Active member
Hm, how do you know who is strongest Pirate?
on topic:
Both in prime:
WB win. WB was said to be only man to rival Roger's strength, but for Garp it was said that he only give good fights to Roger, which is not same.
Both old:
WB still wins, he is still holder of "Strongest man", but match would be closer here.
