[Discussion] Whitebeard Pirates and Red Hair Pirates vs. Marines(with Shichibukai)

[Olorin]

The Marine side also faced heavy casualties.

I'm beginning to wonder if a single person here actually read MF, or understand why Coby had to yell for them to stop. Marines were dying left and right too. Akainu was badly injured as well. The only notable people who were badly put down were Whitebard, Ace and Jozu, and that only happened because Whitebeard's health was at an all-time low, Ace went against his worst match-up, and Jozu got distracted. Many of the other WB commanders were fine, such as Vista, who Mihawk himself took note of. Two Yonko crews, one of them being in their prime? Please, the marines get anally raped.

yes but all marine fodder could have been dead and all pirate fodder alive against Aokiji, injured Akainu, Kizaru, Garp, Sengoku and Mihawk and they would have 0% to win

MF was decided by a handful of names and not the fodder, yes there were heavy casualties on both sides but the important characters, the ones that decide wars were almost unfazed on the Marine side while the big names of the pirates were either dead or running away

 

[Punk Hazard]

yes but all marine fodder could have been dead and all pirate fodder alive against Aokiji, injured Akainu, Kizaru, Garp, Sengoku and Mihawk and they would have 0% to win

MF was decided by a handful of names and not the fodder, yes there were heavy casualties on both sides but the important characters, the ones that decide wars were almost unfazed on the Marine side while the big names of the pirates were either dead or running away

The WB pirates were retreating because they failed to save Ace, and Whitebeard died, they no longer had a reason to be there. Notable names such as Marco and Vista had no serious injuries, and were still capable of fighting, but decided to retreat upon Shanks' arrival. One Yonko crew+allies caused heavy casualties. Another Yonko crew+allies would have been overbearing, then it would have been Sengoku, Garp, Akainu, Aokiji and Kizaru, Mihawk, Doflamingo, and Kuma as the only real notable names versus the 12 commanders, 2 Yonkos(one was enough to terrorize the Marines), and their entire ally-crew force.

The Marines narrowly managed to avoid being overwhelmed by one Yonko crew. If it wasn't for the luck that WB's health ailed badly that day, they would have been overwhelmed, as that would have taken out the distractions that led to Marco and Jozu getting injured in the first place, and hindered Whitebeard's performance.

 

[Red Swag]

Honestly, id go with the marines.

Dont forget about bb hed side with the marines.

Garp vs shanks
Sengoku vs wb
The admirals vs top commanders
Then u still have mihawk mingo kuma bb damn

Id go with marines.

 

[Red Swag]

Honestly, id go with the marines.

Dont forget about bb hed side with the marines.

Garp vs shanks
Sengoku vs wb
The admirals vs top commanders
Then u still have mihawk mingo kuma bb damn

Id go with marines.

 

[Killua Zoldyck]

I don't think this is as big of a rape as people making it out to be:

Basically, everything happens as it did in manga. Marco is the only significant character left standing on the WB side while moderately injured Akainu and mint clean Aokiji/Kizaru (With DD) take on the Red Heads and win. Garp and SenGoku take out the remaining WB Pirates.