[Discussion] when did madara die and when did tobi takeover?

[ZeroBeloved]

title explains it all.

facts: madara knew about nagato so he was alive then. no other information on time line.

1a. died shortly after nagato given rinnegan
1b. died after jiraiya training of nagato
2. died after fight with minato
3. died after uchiha masacre

 

[Hipster Madara]

I think
1a

 

[captain pop]

Probably 1a

 

[Illyasviel]

1a

 

[zombiejesus]

i think maybe madara knocked up some random uzimaki and nagato was born and i also think tobi may be the elder son of madara but i have no proof lol its just what i think


thats why madara said or tobi said that he gave nagato the rinnegan meaning by birth but like i said i have no proof and people usually either laugh or flame me when i say this

 

[ZeroBeloved]

I think
1a

thats what i think aswell... the problem i have is MINATO AND ITACHI both geniuses said that this was madara they met. i think they are too smart to be fooled

 

[ZeroBeloved]

i think maybe madara knocked up some random uzimaki and nagato was born and i also think tobi may be the elder son of madara but i have no proof lol its just what i think


thats why madara said or tobi said that he gave nagato the rinnegan meaning by birth but like i said i have no proof and people usually either laugh or flame me when i say this

very random, but quick question. madara was born with sharingan not rinnegan. y would nagato then be born with rinnegan

 

[Hyperion]

69 - Search Tool

 

[Kerrah]

Well, judging from the shape he was in when he was brought back. I'd say he doesn't look so old. He did also say he unlocked the Rinnegan shortly before his death. Which could mean Nagato could have been with him when he was on his deathbed...???

It's extremely confusing !!

 

[cryhwks]

I think 1a but u have to compare that time line with when Kisame saw him for the 1st time. It is interesting & I hope that Kishi will give us a flashback of what happened but it probably won't happen until Tobi losses the mask.

 

[Rem]

I think it happened a little like 1a.