You forgot mention that Sasuke already fought multiple samurai, Ay, Ay's group, Gaara, and Gaara's group before being confronted by Mei.
Anyway, Tsunade definitely deserves the kage title. Not only is she the perfect supportive ninja, but she can instaheal and take out somebody with a single landed strike. Mei's kg put her at kage rank. Lava and boil releases are very powerful and tactically formidable.
Hiruzen would lose to Tsunade quite easily. They both are strong. Tsunade is the second strongest kage of the current kages. Tsunade is even one of the better hokages, you can deny it all you want but it's true. Hiruzen was quite pathetic and Tobirama lacks feats. Minato vs Tsunade is debatable.
Answer is Tsunade. She has ruined kage title lolI've seen people compare Lee, Chouji, Hidan, Zabuza, and even Part 1 CM Sasuke as being Kage level. Seriously? Whatever happened to the title of Kage, and why is it so easily acheived?
Assuming they could actually kill her before her seal healed her.lol no, Hiruzen would mop the floor with Tsunade.
Minato and Tobirama are not debatable, they would kill Tsunade with close to no effort. You are ridiculous for thinking Tsunade is that powerful.
I've seen people compare Lee, Chouji, Hidan, Zabuza, and even Part 1 CM Sasuke as being Kage level. Seriously? Whatever happened to the title of Kage, and why is it so easily acheived?
Well, I think there are a couple things.
First of all, it doesn't help having people like Tsunade and Mei as Kages. Before, Kages were these legendary shinobi that were often shrouded in mystery and power. Then after seeing Tsunade (but mostly Mei) Kage level seemed to be something that could be acheived easier. As much as you argue, Tsunade and Mei can't compare to any other Kage.
Another thing is the power scaling. It's gotten to the point where even Kage level shinobi are being sh*t on by these OP shinobi from day's past. I think it's ridiculous how far the power scaling has gone, Sage Mode should have been the strongest powerup Naruto got.
That being said, bring back the Kage days!
I wouldn't call any of those unqualified: Gaara fought toe to toe with the second Mizukage, Mei has used devastatingly powerful techniques and Tsunade is considered the greatest medical ninja alive. Kakashi was able to hold his own against fully transformed Jinchuriki.
Also neither Gaara nor Tsunade were chosen in a haste, when the third died the most powerful ninja available for the position of Hokage was Jiraiya (IMO at least) and he himself suggested her. If Gaara was named Kazekage at fifteen it clearly means that the Sand village took around two years to decide who to choose, it's telling that they chose him.
As much as you argue, Tsunade and Mei can't compare to any other Kage.
This is just your speculation and doesn't come from anything that was said in canon and if it were the truth then he would have been named Kazekage right after the body of his father was discovered and the village wouldn't have taken two years (or more) just to decide that.Garra was too young and didn't have the right experience to be kage. Only got the position because it was vacant and it helped keep a better eye on the 1tail( and he still lost it)
Kabuto took advantage of her hemophobia; and, as soon as she overcame it, she easily bested armless Orochimaru.Tsunade was in a piss poor condition when she got the job having trouble fighting a mid level jonin.
...I didn't comment anything on her because that'd be speculation.Mei only got the job after the rein of yagura.(i think)
I never denied that his nomination was in a haste, I agree with you that it was. Yet Kakashi has also showed Kage level strength in the battle with Obito and his six paths and then the ten tails.Kakashi was offered the job in haste since tsunade left the spot vacant.
My point is only when others were also vying for the title did a truly strong leader show up. When the title is offered to you, you didn't deserve it and are most likely unqualified.
Examples: Hashirama(Madara), Hiruzen(Danzo),Minato(Orochimaru)
This is just your speculation and doesn't come from anything that was said in canon and if it were the truth then he would have been named Kazekage right after the body of his father was discovered and the village wouldn't have taken two years (or more) just to decide that.
And I see you don't comment anything about him fighting on nearly equal ground with one of the resurrected Kage and eventually sealing him. Maybe not enough experience but definitely enough strength.
Kabuto took advantage of her hemophobia; and, as soon as she overcame it, she easily bested armless Orochimaru.
...I didn't comment anything on her because that'd be speculation.
I never denied that his nomination was in a haste, I agree with you that it was. Yet Kakashi has also showed Kage level strength in the battle with Obito and his six paths and then the ten tails.
That is, again, just your opinion and there is no way to confirm or refute since nothing in the manga either confirms or refutes so I abstain to comment on it as well.
... Tsunade is the greatest medical ninja alive and one of the Sannin, if that is not Kage material then every Kage should just be at the level of Hashirama and Madara.I am not talking about their current standing with the jobs im talking about when they first got the job.
When tsunade first got the job its only cuz leaf had nobody else to choose. She didn't want it and wasn't fit for it.
Agreed, Gaara is sixteen, that's not experience, yet he showed a strong will to protect the Sand Village and enough strength to do so. If that doesn't make him worthy of the Kage title then we should remember how Minato died.Garra wasn't experienced for the position when he first got it. FACT.
Kakashi would fall under this as well. When he was offered the job he wasn't ready for the position.