The parts that are not contradicted can be. I don't care about your opinion as many members consider it to be valid.
I'm not saying it's more valid, but without significant proof against a topic, there's no reason to cast it out just because it's been presented in the databook. It's foolish to discredit an entire work based on a few inconsistencies especially when you don't apply the same logic to that which you declare is more credible.
This is what I'm talking about.
Who said anything about opinion? I don't debate with opinions alone, I use logic and explanations, evidences and facts. Most members that still believe in it just use it to keep a stupid hype. You're using these members to back you up?
The reason to cas it out is exaclty because it made a "few" mistakes. Actually, last time I checked, there's a thread with countless miskates the databook had made. Once a source of information starts to give this quantityu of misconceptions, it loses it's credibility. It's common logic.
Another reason to cast it out is because kishi changes his mind usually, as we've seen before. However, when he makes the change, he adds it to the manga, and as I said, sometimes he doesn't bother fixing the databook.
The reason which i don't apply the same for the manga is simple: the manga is different, too diferent to fit the same rule. As I explained before, the stories, the plot, the chars, everything is first and mainly presented in the manga itself, not in the databook. The manga is where the events happens, is where the logic of that universe is created. The manga is the narutoverse, not the databook. That's why it has more credibility, and it will always have. It will present mistakes and incosistences, of course. But due to the above, it holds more importance than the databook.
