The Boruto Movie is no longer canon.
Says who? YOU?
The Databooks aren't canon and are often inaccurate, and there was no reason to explain Kaguya's origins or her clan's in a Naruto Databook when it serves as one of the building blocks of the sequel. That would be like telling you the ending of the story before it has even started.
What I see here is an excuses from Lukecetion because he's unable to counter address my point.
"The Databooks are not canon and oftenly acurate"
But I think peasant in NB/Animebase love to create something out of thin air to fit with their own personal belief then they use it as their point in every argument. Above is one example.
Dude we're not asking for a complete detailed backstory of Kaguya or Otsutsuki clan in the Databook but just a little important details. It will not cost Kodachi lots of story materials.
Besides that we have manga(Naruto manga) as a medium to spread information.
The last line is completely BS. You lack of imagination is apparent.
I hate to tell you this, but what you think subjectively in regards to what is "good" writing doesn't even come close to being as accurate as what people have studied and used for decades. Not to mention that Boruto has given us more than plenty of glimpses and story hints on its own. Heck the first few pages of the manga is just that. Then again, the point of Boruto is to tell Boruto's story as it happens, not to tell you the end. Which as I stated earlier would be horrid writing.
I never talked about good writing but just the continuation story that makes sense and really well connected.
Spared me your vague statement about people have studied this or that for a decades. One of clever tactic used by people like you so people will think you are very knowledgeable. So what kind of thing they have been studied for a decades??
Boy I'm talking about Naruto manga here. A glimpse or a foreshadowing or a little advanced story should being Shown in the Naruto manga first. So why you still bring Boruto in this argument?
Boy what is the ending you're talking about here? Boy this thread is about "what if the Karma seal was meant for Zetsu"
Let say this theory/prediction comes true in Boruto manga so how would you connect the plot brilliantly and logically to Kaguya/BZ story in the Naruto manga?
BZ is Kaguya's Will which mean Kaguya. So Kaguya/BZ should have mentioned about this seal long time ago. They should know it and not stayed clueless about it
One, he doesn't follow the theme. That was the point of what I said. Boruto and Naruto doesn't follow the same overarching theme. The story is also not the same. They are contained within the same universe, but are not the same story. Same as (because you used Marvel Comics as an example for some reason) the fact that X-Men and Avengers take place in the same universe, but aren't specifically part of the same narrative.
What can I understand after reading your statement.
Ok..
So both of the story is completely unrelated and not connected at all.
Kaguya and Otsutsuki in Naruto manga is not related to the one we saw in Boruto manga.
Ok I understand.
Yes, and Kaguya herself isn't remotely important to the story. Her clan is important, specifically those that came before her. Which is what the Boruto story has focused on heavily up until this point. Even connecting Karma and Kara to them through Jigen.
Kaguya may not be a focus point in Boruto but her story in Naruto manga is important for the connection of both manga story. So If Kodachi failed to tie Kaguya/BZ story in Naruto manga to the one in Boruto properly I consider both manga are not connected.
And that is because there isn't a clear indication as to who Jigen really is.
OK
They are not less connected just because you want the story to 6 one chapter long.
I couldn't understand this point.
What. Kishimoto is relevant to use, and he wasn't the only example I used.
And the examples you used to back up your point doesnt meet the objective of this debate. You still unable to understand my focus point in this debate.
Kishi received many ideas from his helpers but that doesn't mean they set the story/rule in NM. It's all from Kishi with helped from his editor.
And he has given Kodachi the right to continue his story in his place. Naruto is Kishimoto's story. Boruto is Kodachi's. The Narutoverse is a shared universe between two stories that are interlinked.
But That's doesn't mean all Bull Shit coming from Kodachi in Boruto can be acceptable just because they shared same universe. The contradictions become legal and its automatically is accepted as one uncontradicted story line and be a part of very long story just bcuz Boruto manga shared the same universe as Naruto manga.
Kishimoto severely disagrees, as does pretty much everyone who's ever studied writing along with Shonen Jump and the wast majority of the community.
Evidence please.
No. Not really. Considering that manga refers to cartooning and comics. Beyond that we have the common trope of "writing" which is shared across all forms of fictional media, be that comic, manga, anime, movies or anything else.
I THINK YOU'RE TOO WESTERN(NORWAY)TO KNOW OR UNDERSTAND THIS.
Manga clearly have a big difference to Comic or Cartoon in the concept and principle.
Show me one Japanese manga that is using American mainstream comic as its format, style and how the story is written.
Look at one piece manga, what have you found in it to be similar to DC comic besides Drawing and dialogue??
You can in the glorious way of time-travel or reality shifts that Marvel is quite fond of. Out of those you can probably explain it some other way, and if you can't then they aren't directly connected as they contradict each other. That is not the case with Boruto though.
The contradiction will appear if Kodachi neglecting Naruto story line and 700 chapters worth of information.
Such as? You pointed out the Otsutsuki earlier, to which I commented as an attempt to prove you wrong. Your response was that "it isn't part of the overall story" and then you went back on that. Hence at this point you are arguing for the sake of having an opinion, regardless of how wrong or inaccurate it is to objective matters such as writing tropes and quality.
I think you have mixed thing up.
Yes I'm talking about the whole story. Otsutsuki story+information combine with large part of the story made it a whole story. If Kodachi's Otsutsuki story/information starting to have a contradiction it will spoil Otsutsuki story in Naruto Manga and also overall Naruto story in the process.
You have told me about someone giving Kishimoto an idea, example is Sasuke. But this is not the subject of this debate so its irrelevant.
And Kodachi's Otsutsuki story has started to Show some contradiction. I have addressed some of it in the previous comment.
Yet you did say that this conversation is about the story as a whole and not the Otsutsuki Clan specifically. Make up your mind.
If One part of the story is "rotten" it will effect the entire story including the previous work(Naruto story)