what if sasuke killed naruto as itachi tol him??

lndra

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 1, 2014
Messages
31,928
Reaction score
2,237
First they had to capture each Biju in order, and the fact that they were just catching the Ichibi at the beginning of Shippuden means that Sasuke would have at least that much time before Akatsuki makes their move
They would be finished by the time the Pain Arc took place, given that Sasuke failed at taking the Gyuki, and the Akatsuki members who Naruto help bring down would most likely still be alive meaning they wouldn't be as weak as they were when Nagato died.

It wouldn't be a good scenario at all. Since Sasuke wanted to destroy Konohagakure, but at the same time he betrayed their group.

It would be an inevitable showdown.
 

minamoto

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
23,996
Reaction score
5,084
Status
Itachi's earlier interaction with Sasuke seems like major "plot" that got heavily retcon'd once Kishi decided to make Itachi into less of a villain. Itachi's character isn't very consistent between Part1 and Part2.

this is the kind of commnts i wanted to read... thx
 

The Demon Hawk

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
4,546
Reaction score
212
i----------->.

considering itachi the wisest guy.....why did itachi tell sasuke to kill his best friend (who is supposed to be naruto)..

what if sasuke killed naruto as itachi tol him??..

Maybe, Itachi knew that Sasuke would never kill Naruto (Itachi's forecast is unparalleled) because Sasuke would never do what Itachi did i.e. follow his footsteps, because of the hate against him. That's why he confidently told Sasuke to kill Naruto for the sole purpose of acquainting him about the MS activation process.

He woud have probabky awakened the mangekyo sharingan sooner than he did

True. But what then?

Then everyone would be zetsu right now.

I agree. Sasuke wouldn't be a Zetsu because he can resist IT, but he most probably wouldn't be alive by then.

He wanted him to get strong, and with MS he would be strong enough to survive

Sure. But he probably knew that Sasuke wouldn't kill Naruto. He planned about his death from Sasuke's hand long ago which also contained Sasuke's MS activation plan (by Itachi's own death).

Pain would of killed him

Not necessarily. The plot has no interest in Sasuke vs Pain fight. But Sasuke would definitely get killed sooner or later, maybe in the war against JJ Obito or JJ Madara (2 Rinnegan).

Im pretty sure MS Sasuke can handle Pain

If plot supports him i.e. progresses in a way favorable for Sasuke, then yes, because Sasuke has counters to most of Pain's powers. But if it is a pure power match up, then Sasuke loses, because a CT will end Sasuke's life.

Unless Sasuke took Itachi's eyes, Pain would have killed him, if not Sasuke would have gone blind and died sooner, anyways.

Also, Madara would have won in the end and might have still turned into Kaguya.

Why would Pain even fight Sasuke? What interest will he have in that? None. There is no way Sasuke is dying prior to the war because he won't be a target of any powerful opponent.

BTW, EMS Sasuke can defeat Pain. But yeah, Sasuke would die sooner or later, against JJ Obito, if lucky then against Madara, or if very lucky, then against Kaguya definitely.

It took the 9 tails and a whole lot of plot to beat Pain. MS Sasuke would never be able to do so.

It took plot only for SM Naruto to fight/keep up with Pain, the 9 Tails didn't need plot support. MS Sasuke with plot can defeat Pain.
 

lndra

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 1, 2014
Messages
31,928
Reaction score
2,237
Maybe, Itachi knew that Sasuke would never kill Naruto (Itachi's forecast is unpa
It wasn't that Sasuke and Pain wanted to fight each other, but they had to.

They are both extremists in a sense, and Sasuke left the Akatsuki (meaning he would be a rogue shinobi from a rogue group). Do you think Pain would just let him live, though?

They would eventually cross paths.
 

The Demon Hawk

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
4,546
Reaction score
212
It wasn't that Sasuke and Pain wanted to fight each other, but they had to.

They are both extremists in a sense, and Sasuke left the Akatsuki (meaning he would be a rogue shinobi from a rogue group). Do you think Pain would just let him live, though?

They would eventually cross paths.

You're right. Leaving Akatsuki during Pain's life would eventually turn them up against one another. But there is a lot to it.

Obito probably wouldn't allow their fight because he supports Sasuke (he even agreed to implant Itachi's eyes in Sasuke even after Sasuke openly averted his role as an Akatsuki member after the Danzo fight). He would convince Nagato not to kill Sasuke, Nagato still considered Obito his boss then.

Plus, Sasuke could gain EMS and then fight Pain. EMS Sasuke w/ PS would probably defeat Pain.

And if Nagato decided to use the Bijuus powers for himself (which he won't but let's assume he will), then Obito wouldn't be very happy and he'll side with Sasuke (EMS).
 
Last edited:

Aznkidd

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Sep 7, 2014
Messages
7,437
Reaction score
401
That is like asking Sasuke to go die.
First if Naruto has intention to kill Sasuke, then Sasuke will get no chance to kill Naruto before Naruto kill him... if scenario both has intention to kill.
Second Sasuke didnt have any answer for Kurama pre ems...
 

Dark Sonic

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jul 21, 2015
Messages
3,207
Reaction score
287
I doubt Naruto would die since Kishi wouldn't allow it but Obito would manipulate him. XD
 

lndra

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 1, 2014
Messages
31,928
Reaction score
2,237
You're right. Leaving Akatsuki during Pain's life would eventually turn them up against one another. But there is a lot to it. Obito probably wouldn't allow their fight because he supports Sasuke (he even agreed to implant Itachi's eyes in Sasuke even after Sasuke openly averted his role as an Akatsuki member after the Danzo fight). Plus, he wouldn't be very happy if Nagato takes all the Bijuus powers for himself so he'll side with Sasuke and even give him Itachi's eyes. Plus, Sasuke could gain EMS and then fight Pain. EMS Sasuke w/ PS would probably defeat Pain, and EMS Sasuke and Obito tag team would definitely defeat Nagato.
When Sasuke left the Akatsuki he basically became a "one man army" in the sense of becoming a man who was thinking outside of the box (as we see in the Revolution Chapters). I can't really deny that these two fighting together would be an interesting arc considering what Sasuke could learn from Pain since he was going through so much with Itachi but back to the topic at hand...

The biggest thing here though is that when Naruto died, it depends on the hypothetical host for Kurama. Since there is no one else in Konoha like Naruto who could take in Kurama, I would just go in favor of the Akatsuki taking a rampant Kurama back in Part 1 rather than Konoha having any spare human host lying somewhere in the gutter.

Well Obito can take down Nagato by himself thanks to Kamui, and as long as Nagato has a cool-down usage between ST. He wouldn't need Sasuke to win but Sasuke would need him to win. I would think they would fight before the War Arc because by that time Sasuke would already have had a matured EMS and Obito and Madara would be controlling the scenes with Kabuto working the Edo-Tensei's, meaning that Nagato would already have been disposed of since they needed his Rinnegan.

The biggest contributing factor here you like you pointed out is MS Obito, but we also have to factor in the other Akatsuki members that would still be alive bar Itachi, thanks to Naruto's death. I can't really imagine Nagato not surviving a match-up against Obito if both teams had enough support (as in the Akatsuki backing up Nagato) and MS Sasuke (with probably Taka at his side).

Though most likely this would be 6POP fighting, not Nagato.
 

Nick01

Legendary
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
12,556
Reaction score
796
Impossible, he just can't kill Naruto even if he wanted. :hint:
 

XxTayxX

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Apr 28, 2014
Messages
3,699
Reaction score
250
Maybe, Itachi knew that Sasuke would never kill Naruto (Itachi's forecast is unparalleled) because Sasuke would never do what Itachi did i.e. follow his footsteps, because of the hate against him. That's why he confidently told Sasuke to kill Naruto for the sole purpose of acquainting him about the MS activation process.



True. But what then?



I agree. Sasuke wouldn't be a Zetsu because he can resist IT, but he most probably wouldn't be alive by then.



Sure. But he probably knew that Sasuke wouldn't kill Naruto. He planned about his death from Sasuke's hand long ago which also contained Sasuke's MS activation plan (by Itachi's own death).



Not necessarily. The plot has no interest in Sasuke vs Pain fight. But Sasuke would definitely get killed sooner or later, maybe in the war against JJ Obito or JJ Madara (2 Rinnegan).



If plot supports him i.e. progresses in a way favorable for Sasuke, then yes, because Sasuke has counters to most of Pain's powers. But if it is a pure power match up, then Sasuke loses, because a CT will end Sasuke's life.



Why would Pain even fight Sasuke? What interest will he have in that? None. There is no way Sasuke is dying prior to the war because he won't be a target of any powerful opponent.

BTW, EMS Sasuke can defeat Pain. But yeah, Sasuke would die sooner or later, against JJ Obito, if lucky then against Madara, or if very lucky, then against Kaguya definitely.



It took plot only for SM Naruto to fight/keep up with Pain, the 9 Tails didn't need plot support. MS Sasuke with plot can defeat Pain.

He would went itachi even sooner since he would have possesed the same level of eyes
 

SatanicGod

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Mar 30, 2015
Messages
3,687
Reaction score
138
They would be finished by the time the Pain Arc took place, given that Sasuke failed at taking the Gyuki, and the Akatsuki members who Naruto help bring down would most likely still be alive meaning they wouldn't be as weak as they were when Nagato died.

It wouldn't be a good scenario at all. Since Sasuke wanted to destroy Konohagakure, but at the same time he betrayed their group.

It would be an inevitable showdown.

He was never a part of Akatsuki though, they were using him and he was just using them. Tobi made them wear those cloaks in order to differentiate between ally and enemy
 

NineSNS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Dec 6, 2012
Messages
6,848
Reaction score
791
If Sasuke did kill Naruto as Itachi suggested, then no Part 2, some of which I really enjoyed.
 

minamoto

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
23,996
Reaction score
5,084
Status
He was never a part of Akatsuki though, they were using him and he was just using them. Tobi made them wear those cloaks in order to differentiate between ally and enemy

in your sig : why is sasuke sitting on naruto's D***??
 

Skull Knight

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jun 6, 2013
Messages
4,442
Reaction score
272
If Sasuke killed Naruto, that mean that Kurama would be free. If Konoha manage to capture Kurama, I believe Jiraiya would be the Jinchuuriki since he is one of the strongest in the village and level headed.

the strongest guy donot become Kurama jin.
thats why Hashi made his wife jubi jin. Minato did the same.
So Jiraya got no chance to become Kurama jin.
And i agree if Naruto was killed by Sasuke then Pain would be inplace of Madara as final villain. Kaguya would have never come in first place.
 
Top